27,826 karma · joined December 17, 2009
2) He seems to be ok with some level of immigration: "Copenhagen, by comparison, was about eighty-five percent native Danes in 2000, and is still three-quarters today. Enough of a foreign presence to feel cosmopolitan, but still distinctly Danish in all of its ways. [...] So I get the frustration that many Brits have with the way mass immigration has changed the culture and makeup of not just London, but their whole country."
Nothing extreme about this. I have British friends of Indian descent who have expressed similar sentiments to me.
Do you boycott Japanese and Chinese companies as well? Because I guarantee their views on immigration are far more extreme. China, for all practical purposes, has essentially no immigration.
And finally, none of this has anything remotely to do with his operating system.
Climate science is pretty close to a "pure" hard science. What's not pure are the sloppy geopolitical and socio-economic predictions built on top of it.
The first ~1.4C of warming coincided with the greatest surge in human development, poverty reduction, and technological progress in history. For most of it, we didn't even realize the climate was warming... To me, this suggests that economic development massively outweighed any negative impact that warming might have caused.
I don't object to climate change. I object to the idea that the current moderate warming is catastrophic. It's not an ideological position, other than placing a high value on human progress.
I'm also not saying we shouldn't do anything about it. I just don't think we should do anything about it that would significantly hamper economic development. Fossil fuels are on their way out anyways, in large part due to economic development and economic forces.
I doubt so. Let's say Harry Potter is in the training set and you ask the LLM to generate a quick sort function in C, is that quick sort function a derivative of Harry Potter? What if you ask the LLM to output some known public domain work? That leads to a contradiction where according to one definition, the work is public domain and according to the other, it is a derivative of Harry Potter. It seems to me that there's no other option but to consider each output on its own merit.
你不去,我也不去
You no go, I also no go
今天这里人很多
Today here person very many
下雨就不去
Fall rain then no go
Also, it's worth noting that the USCO does not actually have the final say here. It's possible to register works that don't hold up in court or to fail to register works that do hold up. It's the courts that ultimately decide what the law is.
"To summarize the analysis that now follows, the use of the books at issue to train Claude and its precursors was exceedingly transformative and was a fair use under Section 107 of the Copyright Act. And, the digitization of the books purchased in print form by Anthropic was also a fair use but not for the same reason as applies to the training copies. Instead, it was a fair use because all Anthropic did was replace the print copies it had purchased for its central library with more convenient space-saving and searchable digital copies for its central library — without adding new copies, creating new works, or redistributing existing copies."
https://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/legaldocs/jnvwbgqlzpw/...
IANAL and don't know how significant this decision is, but it is, at the very least, how one judge views it.
Personally, I don't think judges will rule a certain way because of the money involved but because it seems clear that training a ML model is highly transformative.
> Specifically, if a third party sues a commercial customer for copyright infringement for using Microsoft’s Copilots or the output they generate, we will defend the customer and pay the amount of any adverse judgments or settlements that result from the lawsuit, as long as the customer used the guardrails and content filters we have built into our products.
https://blogs.microsoft.com/on-the-issues/2023/09/07/copilot...
> Under the updated terms, we will defend our customers from any copyright infringement claim made against them for their authorized use of our services or their outputs, and we will pay for any approved settlements or judgments that result.
https://www.anthropic.com/news/expanded-legal-protections-ap...
> Output indemnity. OpenAI’s indemnification obligations to Enterprise customers under the Agreement include claims that Customer’s use or distribution of Output infringes a third party’s intellectual property right.