HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

omarhegazy

36 karma · joined April 12, 2014

Prism Boy
submissionscomments
omarhegazy··on The Government is Silencing Twitter and Yahoo, and It Won't Tell Us Why
I'm reading through these comments and really laughing my ass off at the bold, crazy rhetoric being used here.

Orwellian governments! Everyone is just a complacent cog! America is it's own worst enemy! No more freedom!

I mean, I admit, this specific act seems pretty dumb on the government's part. I have no idea why the government would silence Twitter or Yahoo. And given that they didn't care enough to explain, seems like it was probably a legal bug. Maybe some 60 year-old anti-Internet Congress member that thought SOPA was genius got cranky one day and sent some phone calls. I don't know; doesn't seem like anyone that truly has power in government cares, or else they'd succeed in silencing. This doesn't seem like "an extraordinary effort by the government"; this is the same government that dropped two nukes in order to end a worldwide war, so if they really cared about what your favorite anti-government Reddit liberal had to say in in a 140-character long witticism, they'd be able to really shut it down.

But I have a feeling that these alarmist and dramatic comments regarding FASCIST AUTHORITARIAN GOVERNMENTS HOLDING THE TRUE ARTISTS DOWN! have much more to do with the general reddit.com/r/technology culture of shitting on everything the government has been doing since last June. And that culture is much more retarded and out-of-hand than anything PRISM could possibly be.

It seems like what the government is doing with user data since PRISM is very similar to what advertisers have been doing with user data since Fucking Forever, the government doing it for it's ideals regarding terrorism and advertisers doing it for the moolah. But the point is the same -- massive data collection and other forms statistical analysis that you dramatic fucks label "spying" in order to seem passionate and cool has been going on for a while. Just that the government is a much bigger and more complex system than your average advertiser, so you seem like a hip and happening individual by attacking it.

Most people really don't give a shit about massive data collection. I mean, sure, everyone's a Reddit slacktivist nowadays, throwing around words like "spying!" and "privacy!" but no one really cares, or else we'd all be using rsync + ftp and BitMessage and all that idealistic free software stuff that RMS peddles. People just want to seem special and cool and smart and advanced when they post about how EVIL the government is for spying on all of us. But no one honestly cares, or else no one would use Facebook and Google and Apple products.

And should you care?

Is it really that significant, your tiny, indistinguishable contribution to our advertising overlords that isn't even tied to your personal identity? Is it really that creepy or a violation of privacy? It's not like the government knows that specifically Omar Hegazy and E1ven, they don't care about everyone's specific identities (but that would be truly creepy). I mean, even if they have your specific data tied to your real name, it's not like the NSA has people actually listening and looking at your conversation and spying on who you are and what you do. That would be statistically impossible. There are 316 million American citizens, 204 million e-mails sent per minute, and 1.26 billion Facebook users, and only 75 thousand NSA employees.

Could they really be reading all your e-mails tied to you the person, are they even capable of that? They wouldn't be able to spy on each and every one of you even if they tried, and that wouldn't make sense, either. So I'm pretty sure the only thing that knows about you you is the program transferring stuff from Google's servers to NSA servers, and you can trust that one to not be sentient enough to care.

So. They're not spying on individual people, cause they physically can't - but that would really be creepy. They're checking on aggregate statistics. And when you're just another brick in the wall of statistical analysis, is it really all that creepy? Do they really know all that much specifically about you?

But why are they looking at aggregate statistics, you ask?

Good question. Don't laugh -- I think it's terrorism ? I mean sure, that seems like such a cop-out answer from our perspective. But how do we know that the only reason that terrorism isn't a threat anymore isn't because of the American government putting it's foot down? Couldn't it be that the government's seemingly creepy obsession with fighting against terrorism is the reason Al-Qaeda and such have failed so hard that we just laugh at the possibility of them being a threat? If terrorism isn't a threat anymore, couldn't it be that shows that the government's way is working? I mean, this bin Laden guy. His family was filthy fucking rich, man. They were connected to Saudi royalty. These Al-Qaeda guys had fucking planes, man. And they reaaaaalllllly didn't like us. So obviously, if we just did nothing about it, they probably would've struck again ...

But I don't know. I haven't done enough research on this topic myself. Maybe the government's obsession with terrorism is a bit too much and while we should be worrying about this issue in order to keep it from happening, maybe 20x the military budget of the next 10 countries on the list combined is a bit too far. Or maybe it's just the right amount. I don't know, I read programming books in my free time, not political discourse.

But it's just so obvious from their alarmist bullshit that these Reddit libertarians haven't done their research either. They just want to seem like they have.

omarhegazy··on Dropbox acquires Hackpad (YC W12)
Eh. If price declines become a problem, Dropbox will be just like every other seemingly free consumer-facing service.

Sell data to advertisers.

It's making Facebook $6 per user per year, and as company databases get more and more massive (Did you know Facebook has 300 fucking petabytes of user data? And 5 years ago, Google was processing 24 petabytes per day.) and machine learning / data statistical analysis gets more and more advanced and software companies have more and more cultural capital and industry reliance (Software is eating the world, etc. etc.) that number can only go up higher. Mix $6 per user per year revenue with the massive increase in users you'd get from consumer-facing vs enterprise (everyone vs. a single business vertical) and you got yourself a consumer-facing company that makes so much more moolah than the equivalent enterprise company.

But I agree there's more pressure. There are much fewer winners in consumer-facing than enterprise. But Dropbox is just betting they'll be one of those winners.

omarhegazy··on Dropbox acquires Hackpad (YC W12)
They wouldn't lose too much of their existing customers. Are you implying that massive data collection and advertiser interest are bad?

Most people really don't give a shit about massive data collection. I mean, sure, everyone's a Reddit slacktivist nowadays, throwing around words like "spying!" and "privacy!" but no one really cares, or else we'd all be using rsync + ftp and BitMessage and all that idealistic free software stuff that RMS peddles. People just want to seem special and cool and smart and advanced when they post about how EVIL the government is for spying on all of us. The art of saying "I don't use Facebook; they sell my info to advertisers", then turning around to use Google products (which are fucking unavoidable on the Internet, by the way, did you know fucking ReCaptcha is owned by Google? You'd have to completely avoid the Internet to avoid Google at this point) , is the 2014 spin on the 1990s art of saying "I don't own a television".

We use Chrome and Gmail and Facebook and OS X and Amazon and what-not, because the net benefit of having really convenient software developed by teams of hundreds (thousands, even, in huge cases like Google/FB) talented professionals that are putting in $120K / year's worth of effort beats the net cost of having to pay for that $120K by letting Facebook give advertisers all your user data to make up for the costs of developing and operating such convenient software (and whatever profit FB is hoping to make -- people don't start businesses out of the goodness in their hearts). I mean, what's the alternative? Paying for the $6 per user per year that Facebook makes? Would you really rather pay for these services than just aid in letting the advertisers know that 67% of young (18-34) males in New York City prefer Macy's over JC Penney? Is it really that significant, your tiny, indistinguishable contribution to our advertising overlords that isn't even tied to your personal identity? It's not like they know that specifically Omar Hegazy and Xerophyte clicked on this ad over that ad in A/B tests; they don't give a shit about the specific identities and that would be truly creepy. No, they obviously care more about aggregate statistics, like overall click through rate and what-not. And when you're just another brick in the wall of statistical analysis, is it really all that creepy? Do they really know all that much specifically about you?)?

So, people don't really care about privacy, and Dropbox wouldn't lose a huge chunk of their customers. Or else, Facebook and Google and Apple and what-not would've lost a huge chunk of their customers.

I agree, though, about the enterprise market. Enterprise is smaller than consumer-facing, because the set of all professionals in a certain vertical is much smaller the set of everyone. That means that spying on the enterprise market is much more personal and tied to identity than spying on everyone as a whole. So it really does lose you customers in enterprise. Also it's much easier just to charge people directly for money in enterprise; usually verticals have a greater demand for a proper solution than horizontals, cause they're a much more specific market to target and so their biggest pain points are easier to solve. People really would pay $6 a year, and even more, for a product that truly understands what their specific problem is.

But I disagree that enterprise is where all the moolah is. I just think that it's much, much harder to make moolah in consumer-facing software, and all the moolah in consumer-facing software goes to a select few very well-known winners. But if you become one of those winners, then you have much more money and historical recognition than any boring old enterprise company will get you.

It's really very hard to nail down "What's a problem that everyone is having but no one has solved?" -- but when you do nail it down, oh boy, you just solved everybody's problem, and it gets you the quickest company to reach $150bn valuation in ever and the founder becomes the youngest billionaire in the world. I think, if Drew Houston and Co. went down the consumer-facing route, they'd be playing their chips on the assumption that they really struck gold with answering that seemingly unanswerable question. And given how far Dropbox has gone in the consumer market, I wouldn't hold it against them for taking that risk.

That being said, they do seem like they're saving some of their chips for the enterprise route. So if they really were worried about ruining enterprise trust by being yet another consumer-facing company that gobbles all your data and feeds it back to advertisers, they'd just do the other thing I suggested - sell hard drive space. But something tells me Dropbox is trying to be more.

omarhegazy··on Dropbox acquires Hackpad (YC W12)
How is Dropbox's core business unsustainable?

The way I see it, Dropbox wants to be the filesystem and personal hard drive of the Internet. Easy enough business, just sell hard drive space. And as always with any software business, with users, you have data, and with data, you have potential advertiser money and a lot of investor interest.

Why can't they rival Google/Apple? Yes, bigger companies have a lot more resources. But that doesn't mean that only big companies can succeed. If small companies have nailed a service that big companies can't wrap their heads around/move quick enough to take over, then they'll outperform big companies in that market. Once upon a time, Apple was a small company, too. But they did personal computer and personal computer software better than competitors long enough to become a large company. Not too long ago, Google was a small company too, competing with large companies. The reason they succeeded to go on to become a big company is their superior product. Yahoo and other search engine competitors just couldn't tap into what Google had, whether it be because they didn't possess the genius/talent/skill/anything-other-than-resources Google employees had that made their product better, or because Yahoo was too large to move strategies fast enough to beat Google to market. Even more recent than Google being a small company, Dropbox was just another Y Combinator application that was shat on by oblivious HNers who thought "Don't people just use rsync and ftp?". But because they could provide a product that people wanted before big companies could catch on in time, they grew in size. Small companies have a chance against big companies. If they didn't, it'd be a pretty fascist society where everyone'd be forced to use the same products and services for all of forever.

How is this "flailing"? Google integrates cloud editing (Docs) with cloud storage (Drive) pretty well and that great integration is what's allowing Google to enroach on Dropbox's vision of being "the file system and hard drive of the Internet." Google has just shown us that integrating content creation tools with content storage tools isn't "flailing" or feature creep or anything; it's a valid strategy to boost content storage. And Dropbox is catching the hints. That's why this acquisition exists. So they can integrate content creation (HackSpace) with content storage (Dropbox). Now claiming HackSpace is going to put up a good fight against Google Docs is pretty absurd, but 1. now they're being backed by Dropbox, which should aid in the fight, and 2. remember what I said about small companies having a good chance if their product is good enough? With proper leadership (Drew Houston and Condoleezza Rice [moral issues aside, she has business and leadership skills that are completely separate from her political views which wouldn't affect anything about her position at Dropbox] -- check), resources (Dropbox -- check), and product design and development (this is the risk Dropbox is taking by purchasing HackSpace -- will DB be able to produce a better product than Docs?), yes HackSpace can beat Docs.

"Acquisitions like this never go to plan, and they are almost always a waste of money."

Why does HN do this? Toss around bold and interesting rhetoric that is completely baseless and has no substance or logic. Like the Michael Bay of writing.

This is so absurd, I don't even feel like I need to argue against it; it's like saying "The idea of companies never go to plan and are almost always a waste of money." It's just so ridiculous and against the way the real world works that it's more on you to prove your radical theories than it's on me to prove them wrong.

If acquisitions didn't work to produce a net benefit, then successful companies wouldn't do them, period.

omarhegazy··on Ask HN: Idea Sunday
I wish I knew. This site seems more interested in telling me about it's wondrous history than giving me a forum of discussion.

Can I get a frontpage? Links to different subforums? A design that isnt from the late 90s?

omarhegazy··on Ask HN: Idea Sunday
Exciting rhetoric.

How do you expect people to discern between Reddit reputation and TheWebsAlzheimersCure.com's (drop the "the" -- just WebsAlzheimersCure. Cleaner.) reputation?

omarhegazy··on Ask HN: Idea Sunday
The astroturfing would have to be so well concealing that it'd be content users would actually like. So, it's still corporate-supported advertising, but it's smart corporate-supported advertising.

Reminds me of this : https://xkcd.com/810/.

omarhegazy··on Ask HN: Idea Sunday
That's the thing. If this service is implemented properly, you want users to game the system for profit. It'd have to be so airtight that the only way to "game" the system would be to go out and try to think of something intelligent to contribute. Another commenter discussed the possibility of astroturfing -- The astroturfing would have to be so well concealed that it'd be content users would actually like. So, it's still corporate-supported advertising, but it's smart corporate-supported advertising. Which is still awesome. Reminds me of this : https://xkcd.com/810/.

What you said about a system of experts and trained users determining whether your comment is worth exposing to the public ... eh. It sounds like it'd take a shit-ton of time and debating, especially as the service expands to handle a lot of content.

Also, isn't that just modern journalism? As a journalist, you apply to write an article for, or get a job at writing articles for, a well-established high-quality media company like the NY times or the New Yorker. A system of trained experts review your application and approve or deny it accordingly. Then you write articles and they get shown to the public after you've been approved.

I'm not saying it's a bad process, I'm saying it already exists. The problem is, it's slow and it takes a shit ton of time to determine who's a great writer and who gets limited participation and who doesn't. And when you allow the process to get faster, you have to give up the expert-authority, and well, you get something like Reddit.

This service would have to find a way to keep submissions and distribution extremely fast, like Reddit, but also keep the quality of discourse high, like NY Times.

The proposed solution is : money. People who submit stupid cat pictures to Reddit aren't dumb themselves, they've just been exposed to a forum for discourse that allows dumb content. Meaning, if you asked them : "Do you really think that cat picture is going to allow for quality discourse?", they'd definitely say "No."

So I'm willing to trust ilovekatpictures1998 on his judgment of discourse, if not his ability to create such discourse. So if we can trust the users to have good judgment, all we have to do is create a system that forces them to use their judgment, which Reddit doesn't do. And telling them to put their money where their mouth is by making them pay is the best way to force them to use their judgment.

The only reason it wouldn't get as big as Reddit is, people don't want to put their money where their mouth is. Well, most people. But then again, there are a lot of niches ...

omarhegazy··on Ask HN: Idea Sunday
A pay-to-post/view social discussion site.

Reddit starts out cool, then slowly becomes 'dumber' (discussion-focused articles turn into quick reaction images) as it becomes more and more popular.

Hacker News avoids this by purposefully not trying to be as popular as Reddit -- UI remains minimal, tries to stay out of search engines' ways, etc.

But, in this way, HN is discussion focused through obscurity. What if you filtered out dumb crap by making it a cost to the user for posting? In that way, the user would have to really care about what h/she's posting about before h/she posts it. I.E.: thought-provoking discussion and not cheap images.

That way, you can mass market and accept huge gains in popularity while being sure that the people who are posting/voting on the stuff care enough to pay for it. Want cheap (often not even funny) images? Go to Reddit.

The best posters get compensated with the money that the voters paid. This creates a network of "I pay to post and I pay to vote but I get money from posting which incentivizes me to post but I only get paid if I get voted on a lot which means I'll want to encourage voting which means I'll have to vote a lot myself" : the voters and content contributors conflate in one genius network of money movement.

It still wouldn't ever get as big as Reddit, simply because people don't like direct payment for services on the Internet. But it'd be an effective way to get a bunch of smart, dedicated people who would kill for thought-provoking discussion on the Internet, and also pay them for just that.

omarhegazy··on PC gaming has 24 billion dollars estimated yearly revenue
I have a feeling, that in the future, gaming is going to either see a complete revolution or another crash (and then a renaissance).

Traditional consoles will go out of fashion, and console manufacturers will either 1. fall under, or 2. continue generating a lot of money, but fall out of relevancy in the public eye (much like IBM, Oracle, some would say Microsoft, etc.). People are starting to see consoles for what they are : overpriced PCs with really shitty OSes and very limited software opportunities. Why spend $300 on a gadget that can play games when I have already spent $300 on a different, more powerful and capable gadget that can also play games, but also a lot of other stuff? Why lug around another portable when my smartphone already has a bunch of awesome games/spend my money on a device sitting on a shelf that basically can only do a fraction of what my PC already does, in a shitty way, too (poorer graphics,more expensive games, no mods, not upgradeable, etc.)?

Before it used to be that consoles had the best library of games, but as the indie scene explodes, we're seeing the best games coming from developers who simply can't afford the inefficient and restrictive console publishing system when they can reach a much larger/much more devoted market by just putting their work on the App Store/Greenlight -> Steam, and then giving Apple/Valve 30% of their sales. Why get in a whole fuss with publishers and console manufacturers and retailers and what-not? Sony and Microsoft are trying to retaliate by being relatively more open about indie/digital publishing, but it's too little, too late.

Gaming will then split into 2 main platforms : Mobile for 'casual', and PC for 'hardcore'. Hardcore gaming isn't going to go out of fashion, no, it's just going to move to a different platform : instead of consoles, the desktop -- fully equipped with keyboard, mouse, and Oculus Rift (that's another thing I see will happen - VR is going to replace the TV for gaming). As PC gaming gets more and more popular and PC-building gets more and more widespread and Valve gets more and more accessible/approachable in terms of the Steambox, Big Picture, etc., people will go to PC whenever they want multiple hours-long sessions of gaming instead of the quick, easy, addictive, instant gratification of the Flappy Birds they play on the subway. And the VR will just enhance their experience 100-fold.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2