HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

omonra

1,010 karma · joined May 9, 2011

submissionscomments
omonra··on ‘The Market Is Saturated’: Brooklyn’s Rental Boom May Turn into a Glut
Why? Increase in supply will affect the entire curve, thus making housing cheaper for everybody.

Ie that's like making one part of the room warmer.

omonra··on Commission says Ireland granted undue tax benefits of up to €13B to Apple
The word scapegoat implies being blamed for something they are innocent of.

Here Ireland is clearly complicit with Apple in the tax evasion scheme and thus isn't a "scapegoat".

omonra··on Millennial men with different incomes
First thing that jumped at me.

He also says "I wish I could pay off the mortgage". From what he described, he should be able to pay it off in a year or two.

Doesn't add up.

omonra··on New research shows Europe leads the world in inherited wealth
No, I don't think that.

But I'm enough of a realist to see first generation asians / indians operating laundromats or chinese restaurants and their children becoming doctors or lawyers. So to my mind US is the land of high social mobility - for people who are intelligent and are willing to work.

omonra··on New research shows Europe leads the world in inherited wealth
Because they won't be admitted to the SWPL heaven?

Your ideas actually remind me of the barely literate from the middle ages who believed that the world was sitting on 3 whales or something like that.

Preponderance of evidence to the contrary was dismissed with 'That's not what it says in the Bible!'.

You've got same religion ("all people are equal") that goes against ALL real-world observations. But just like they waved everything off with 'Because G-d wills it', you've got 'Because racism!'.

omonra··on New research shows Europe leads the world in inherited wealth
1. The 10% of Danes that are migrants are all recent arrivals and hence I doubt there are generations to study inter-generational mobility on. When they will have been in the country for generations, I would be extremely surprised to find them having higher social mobility than in the US.

2. Re racism - I'm sorry but that's typical liberal nonsense. Discounting all differences between groups of people, assuming equal distribution of intelligence & culture and then ascribing resulting group differences to 'racism'.

What's rather interesting is that educational results among various US sub-groups map rather closely to their old-world kin. Ie US whites/blacks/asians correlate fairly well to the countries where they originally came from (hispanics obviously not having an old world mapping). Hence the hang-wringing "Our kids are failing vs X" is actually misplaced as they're comparing apples and multi-fruit juice.

omonra··on New research shows Europe leads the world in inherited wealth
It's a silly conclusion. If you are born in the bottom 20% of household income you in the US you are probably from a different ethnicity than the top 20%. Meanwhile in Denmark they're all ... Danish!

So essentially that study discovers that if you are born into ethnicity X you will unlikely end up as ethnicity Y.

omonra··on Should We Be Having Kids in the Age of Climate Change?
According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_di... US and EU make up 22% of world's carbon emissions.

So if we (ie the people addressed by the article) stop to exist, the population will continue to grow in size (4bn in Africa by the end of the century) and carbon emissions will probably catch up to where they are now in a decade or so.

omonra··on The meaning of trust in the age of Airbnb
I imagine the store keeper had enough experience with arab kids breaking stuff that wasn't paid for by their parents. So it's not a call on clumsiness of one set of kids vs another but personal experience on whether their parents can be trusted.

Which seems to be the point of the article.

omonra··on 3-word code is address of 57M 3-square-meter patches on earth's surface
Mongolia is one of the 22 countries in the world that Britain did not invade, so unfortunately they don't have the benefit of the British post code system :)

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/history/9653497/British-have-inva...

omonra··on How millions of trees brought a broken landscape back to life
I guess the point is that some benchmark should be used to determine whether a country is rich enough to take care of it s citizens. You and the commenter above disagree whether space program can be considered such metric.
omonra··on How millions of trees brought a broken landscape back to life
His point is that if India can afford their space program, UK should not be sending them aid.

Ie just like if your cousin decides to buy a Ferrari, you probably should not have to to support him financially.

omonra··on A molecule called ‘Sandman’ could help solve the ‘mystery of sleep’
I think the purpose of this device is to provide context to the problem. If you are about to provide the scientific explanation for something all of us experience every day "Why do things fall down" / "Why is sugar sweet" it helps to take a step back and remind the reader that there is a scientific explanation for the phenomenon they are so familiar with (so much so that it feels unnatural to even question it in the first place).
omonra··on Navy to Name Ship After Gay Rights Activist Harvey Milk
This report provides relevant background on US navy ship naming: https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/weapons/RS22478.pdf

For ship types now being procured for the Navy, or recently procured for the Navy, naming rules can be summarized as follows:  Aircraft carriers are generally named for past U.S. Presidents. Of the last 14, 10 were named for past U.S. Presidents, and 2 for Members of Congress.  Virginia (SSN-774) class attack submarines are being named for states.  Destroyers are named for deceased members of the Navy, Marine Corps, and Coast Guard, including Secretaries of the Navy.  Littoral Combat Ships (LCSs) are being named for regionally important U.S. cities and communities.  Amphibious assault ships are being named for important battles in which U.S. Marines played a prominent part, and for famous earlier U.S. Navy ships that were not named for battles.  San Antonio (LPD-17) class amphibious ships are being named for major U.S. cities and communities, and cities and communities attacked on September 11, 2001.  John Lewis (TAO-205) class oilers, previously known as TAO(X)s, are being named for people who fought for civil rights and human rights.  Lewis and Clark (TAKE-1) class cargo and ammunition ships were named for famous American explorers, trailblazers, and pioneers.  Expeditionary Fast Transports (EPFs), previously called Joint High Speed Vessels (JHSVs), are being named for small U.S. cities.  Expeditionary Transport Docks (ESDs) and Expeditionary Sea Bases (ESBs), which were previously called Mobile Landing Platform (MLP) ships and Afloat Forward Staging Bases (AFSBs), respectively, are being named for famous names or places of historical significance to U.S. Marines.

So basically there has been reserved a class of ships (oilers) that are all going to be named after Civil Rights activists.

omonra··on What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speech at RNC
Those figures are not for tech roles but company-wide. Apple does not provide figures for % of engineers who are black.

If you want to prove that companies discriminate, look up percent of engineering PhDs (like CS) who are black that graduate per year. If that number is above what companies hire - you will have a reasonable claim.

Otherwise it's nothing.

omonra··on The Strange Politics of Peter Thiel, Trump’s Most Unlikely Supporter
The only other clear thing is that Trump would be President.
omonra··on The Strange Politics of Peter Thiel, Trump’s Most Unlikely Supporter
Sorry - that's an overview of how ONE company find value in diversity.

We are asking for research that shows that companies like Etsy outperform (on any metric) companies that don't really care about diversity (judged by their actual hiring practices, not paying lip service to it).

Because the availability heuristic points to the other 99% of Silicon Valley that's doing quite well without caring about diversity.

omonra··on Come Back, Colonialism, All Is Forgiven (2008)
Ok sure - then go ahead and do that. Say 'Have a look at X or Y'.

By saying 'That's racist' you come out meaning to stop the conversation because you have nothing more substantial to say.

omonra··on Come Back, Colonialism, All Is Forgiven (2008)
You're absolutely right about Egypt - but when people talk about Africa they usually imply sub-Saharan part of the continent (not the mediterranean civilizations).
omonra··on Come Back, Colonialism, All Is Forgiven (2008)
What I meant was not a civilization in the abstract sense of the word but rather what we consider modernity (as brought to us by Europe).

My understanding is that Asia is widely expected to get there without Europe - but it's not clear for Africa.

In the case of America there actually were quite a few civilizations on the upswing when Europeans arrived (and killed everybody off with their diseases). I am yet to see the same said about Africa.

omonra··on Come Back, Colonialism, All Is Forgiven (2008)
I find it rather hilarious that all you can muster is 'that's racist'. It pretty much means 'I can't produce a coherent argument that counters what you said but I don't like it, so I'll call it x-ist'.

Your second point might make sense if Africa had middle class before Europeans arrived. The fact that there is civilization there after colonization doesn't in any way refute the original point.

I personally don't know whether Africa was on track to have civilization without colonialism (other people commenting that 'people around the world got there' is nonsense as most societies throughout history didn't get civilization on their own). But I detest trying to shut someone up merely because you don't find their thinking agreeable.

omonra··on Silicon Valley-Driven Hype for Self-Driving Cars
Volvo XC90 has this feature. It's basically lane keeping with automatic cruise control that works between 0 mph and 30. It also requires you to keep hands on the wheel (that's not a problem, imho).

The only drawback to me is that if the car stops completely, the autopilot shuts down and has to be manually restarted (click button) to resume.

omonra··on Bayesian Analysis of Racial Bias in Police Shootings in the United States
Who decides who was 'wrongfully' killed? For example to me (as well as grand jury) MBrown was rightfully killed. To the BLM he was not - so we're stuck.

Even if that can somehow be quantified, do we have statistics for the number of white people who are wrongfully killed by the police? One metric I saw (unfortunately don't have a source) is that this year 3% of whites AND 3% of blacks were killed while unarmed.

omonra··on Bayesian Analysis of Racial Bias in Police Shootings in the United States
I actually did a similar kind of back of the napkin + Google exercise the other night, here is what I wrote down:

---

Recent MN incident is definitely horrible and seems unequivocally wrong, no questions about it. It's very sad. It's worse than Garner and totally different scale than other high-profile cases of late. It's the sort of incident that definitely supports claims made by BLM (as previous ones have not, at least to me).

The clear racial implications prompted me to look at the overall country-wide figures to see if the actual stats for last few years reflect the narrative promulgated in the news (black people are disproportionately killed by the police).

1. "... roughly 49 percent of those killed by officers from May 2013 to April 2015 were white, while 30 percent were black. He also found that 19 percent were Hispanic." (http://www.washingtontimes.com/…/police-kill-more-whites-t…/)

2. "There were 511 officers killed in felonious incidents and 540 offenders from 2004 to 2013, according to FBI reports. Among the total offenders, 52 percent were white, and 43 percent were black."

The ratio of african-americans among cop killers (43% of all incidents) to those who are killed by cops (30% of all incidents) is 1.43 - which does not bear out the claim that they are unfairly targeted as a group (of course this doesn't absolve the individual cops who wrongfully kill innocent people).

The one obvious problem with this analysis is that the set of people who kill cops vs are killed by them are non-overlapping - but when country-wide stats over a few years are considered the numbers would sort themselves out (ie random white guy killed by mistake simply doesn't make the national news).

I'm sorry if this analysis is unpleasant and welcome criticism of why it could be wrong.

omonra··on Violence Against Women in Papua New Guinea
I was talking about homicide rate rather - ie if poor whites commit serious crime at the same rate as poor blacks.
omonra··on Violence Against Women in Papua New Guinea
Do you happen to have (or ever looked at) the statistics for criminality of low-income whites? I'd be curious for that comparison - let's say murder rate (as these things are less likely to be covered up) across bottom 10% of income by race.
omonra··on African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard English with Mistakes (1999) [pdf]
Good point - but people explain that it is due to political reasons [1].

Ie same way that people in Luxemburg want to point out that they have their own language different from German, rulers of Morocco (who are Arabs - majority of Morocco's population native language is Berber) want to stress that they share same language & culture with rest of the Arab world.

In other words - if you are a country, you have the option to have your own language (even if it's mutually intelligible with a major other language). If you are just a part of a country, that option seems off the table (ie you need a non-mutually intelligible language to make that claim).

[1] http://matadornetwork.com/abroad/why-hindi-urdu-is-one-langu...

omonra··on African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard English with Mistakes (1999) [pdf]
My understanding is that if you have a country, you get to have a language (such as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luxembourgish_language)

Therefore the argument 'How come X is a language while Y is not' doesn't make sense if X has their own country and Y does not.

omonra··on Windows 10: Microsoft launches intrusive full-screen upgrade reminder
Exactly this for me.

I simply don't want to deal with new interfaces. I feel that Windows has reached its interface peak around Win7 and Office around version 2003. Everything since has been driven by the need to justify having a team which develops new interfaces for each platform.

Incidentally I feel the same way about OSX - I stopped upgrading my machine with 10.9.5. Don't like the new look and feel that there isn't anything worth upgrading to in the new version that will make me look at that candy-store like design all day long.

Will hold out as long as I can - probably until I get a new machine.

omonra··on America's top earners are Asian men
It's the modern version of 'mongoloid' which has gone out of fashion.

Interestly enough, in the UK 'asian' refers strictly to people from India/Pakistan.

← PreviousPage 2 of 23Next →