710 karma · joined August 15, 2015
Die Open Office Die...
The worst solution is to panic and attempt to ban technology like this insuring that only the bad actors will use it.
I want everyone down to kids to be able to make fake videos to their little heart's content so we can all internalize this inevitable Black Mirrorization of reality.
And your proposed solution is fantastic BTW. Unfortunately, there are more than enough bad actors among us to social engineer those signatures out of otherwise trustworthy agencies and a general lack of intellectual curiosity on the part of most people to even bother to check for such things. Imagine the day we have a video where HRC confesses to the pedophile colony on Mars and coming up next, Trump tells everyone where he buried the bodies, and if people look, there will be bodies there (never mind that they're stolen cadavers). How will people cope with a world like this?
It is almost like we need pop art and pop culture to drive this point home before political mass media does it in the worst possible way.
https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/trump-made-in-america_u...
So the solution now is even more battery-killing HTML + Javascript + Secret Sauce? Hell no...
PS Just say no to push like the Hulk says no to Banner.
All IMO of course but these days, I use my phone for Yelp, Google Maps, weather, GMail, stock prices, and little more. The improvement in battery life from 6-8 hours to 2+ days has been astounding and what it's drove me to the viewpoint I just espoused. Am I missing something here?
IMO they deserve an entire fulfillment center of ice cream for that alone.
Now when a Tesla GPU costs $9-10K instead of <$1000, that's a somewhat different story, but even then, NVDA tapes out a brand new architecture almost annually. Good luck keeping up with that pace ASIC startups. And that's exactly what happened to Nervana. Their ASIC was better than a Pascal GP100, but it's clobbered by Volta V100. So at best you get a 6-12 month lead on them.
In contrast, if you can right-size the transistor count for expensive and very specific workloads across 100K+ machines like companies with big datacenters and big data sets can do, I see an opportunity for all of the BigCos to build custom ASICs for their siloed data sets and graphs. That's what GOOG is doing and it seems to be working for them so far. FB is now hiring to do the same thing I suspect.
So unless they cripple CUDA altogether, there will always be efficient workarounds (arguably DirectX or OpenGL programmable shaders in the very worst-case scenario). They even gave up on doing so for GTX Titan Black and then resumed with Maxwell. Currently, I would not be surprised that the lack of a true consumer Volta GPU is their only play at crippling consumer Volta by making it effectively nonexistent or $3000 for the GTX Titan V.
What they could do across the board is hamfistedly disable the deep learning frameworks on GeForce. That would probably stop 90% of amateur hour data science on GeForce. But the remaining 10% would just recompile them without the cripple code in violation of some sort of scary EULA clause against doing so and requiring such cripple code in all HPC/AI applications. I would love to see them try this - they'll pry my FP32 MADs (which is the core operation of AI/ML as well as vertex and pixel shaders) from my cold dead consumer GPU desktop.
I don't think they'll do that though. They know the low-end is the entry point to their ecosystem. They just want to force people to graduate into the high-end after hooking them. Not that you have to: multiplication and addition want to be free.
OpenCL could have been killer on mobile, and it could have delivered low-power machine learning and computation there all the way back in 2012, but both AAPL and GOOG went out of their way to cripple its use despite many of the mobile GPUs having hardware support for it. We all lost there IMO.
All that said, Bill Daly rocks, and NVDA is a hardened target. But the DL frameworks have enormous performance holes once one stops running Resnet-152 and other popular benchmark graphs in the same way that 3DMark performance is not necessarily representative of actual gaming performance unless NVDA took it upon themselves to make it so.
And since DL is such a dynamic field (just like game engines), I expect this situation to persist for a very, very long time.
Or you can be like BIDU, buy 100K consumer GPUs, and put them in your datacenter. In response, Jensen altered the CUDA 9.1 licensing agreement and the EULA for Titan V such that going forward, you cannot deploy Titan V in a datacenter for anything but mining cryptocurrency, and his company reserves the right going forward to audit your use of their SW and HW at any time to force compliance with whatever rules Jensen pulled out of his butt that day after his morning weed. And that's a shame. Because there's no way any of these companies can beat the !/$ of consumer GPUs and NVDA is lying out of its a$$ to say you can't do HPC on them.
But beyond NVDA shenanigans, I think it's incredibly risky to second guess those siloed computation graphs from the outside in the hopes of anything but an acqui-hire for an internal effort. Things ended well for Nervana even if their HW didn't ship in time, but when I see a 2018 company (http://nearist.ai/k-nn-benchmarks-part-wikipedia) comparing their unavailable powerpoint processor to GPUs from 2013, and then doubling down on doing so when someone rightly points out how stupid that is, I see a beached fail whale in the making, not a threat to NVDA's Deepopoly.
https://www.thestranger.com/news/2018/03/24/25953235/king-co...
Backpage was pretty sleazy. I don't think anyone's going to miss them, but are you not at all alarmed that there's a sudden onslaught of legislation that is claimed to target "sex trafficking", but which also apparently requires the deletion of the personals section from Craigslist, censoring of pornographic Google drive content, and even dirty words from Word documents?
https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/03/28/microsoft_services_...
Where is this heading? And do you trust the motives of the people behind it?
Doesn't that mean you are now on the hook for enabling sex trafficking with SESTA if a gmail account was used? Or is there a loophole wherein if you promise extra double hard not to look at said content, you're not liable? But in that case, why are you guys deleting teh p0rnz?
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-watch/wp/2014/03/27/...
TLDR: the criminal lifestyle one must pursue to obtain illegal supercharged versions of the drugs is vastly more harmful than the drugs themselves when legalized. I see a lot of parallels here in equating all sex work to sex trafficking. Both sides have their points, but what is the most effective strategy to minimize sex trafficking?
Not to mention that there are acceptable places to do (small counties in Nevada) and unacceptable places to do so (everywhere else in the US). I won't even get into the number of countries that have either legalized or decriminalized this practice.
Finally, the best way to find sex trafficking victims seems to be decriminalization which removes the stigma of speaking out. What's really broken here is that the foot soldiers of sex trafficking seem to be against all this pending legislation, fearing it will drive the practice further underground, rather than assist with battling it.
http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml...
http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml...