HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ongy

336 karma · joined October 8, 2021

submissionscomments
ongy··on Playing with more user-friendly methods for multi-factor authentication
At best WPA2. WEP is broken in ways that don't need human fault.

The only downside of TOTP to FIDO and friends (from a security perspective) is phishing resistance

ongy··on Dwl: Dwm for Wayland
The core devs were all paid to work on it when I was still active.

Not sure how many of the gnome (mutter) people are paid. Last I checked, the nvidia support was donated by nvidia (paid) for both KDE and Gnome.

I think KDE got some work sponsored by valve (before gamescope), though I'm not quite sure on that.

Overall, outside the sway/wlroots group I was a part of at the time, people generally worked adjacent or directly on wayland for day jobs.

ongy··on How Cloudflare blocked a monumental 7.3 Tbps DDoS attack
My homenet is 1GBit, so is my Internet

I.e. no traffic beyond my legitimate saturation can reach the ISP

I have saturated my link with quic or wireguard (logical or) plenty of times.

The lack of any response on high data rates would be an indicator I've only tried that once and it failed gloriously due to congestion. I don't think there's many real protocols that are unidirectional without even ACKs

ongy··on Containerization is a Swift package for running Linux containers on macOS
I think that's the point. You don't have to run the full kernel to run some linux tools.

Though I don't think it ever supported docker. And wasn't really expected to, since the entire namespaces+cgroup stuff is way deeper than just some surface level syscall shims.

ongy··on Replacing Kubernetes with systemd (2024)
The default hook systemd uses to wait for network is documented in https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/latest/syst...

It has the slightly odd behavior with trying to get all configured links up. This can lead to some unexpected behavior when there's more than one.

But yea, the upstream stance is essentially "don't rely on network to be up before you start. That's bad software. You have to deal with network going down and back up in practice either way." Which is often not super useful.

ongy··on War story: the hardest bug I ever debugged
This is after the jit.

I.e. don't think fancy language shenanigans that do negative indexing. But negative offset from the beginning of the array memory access.

When there's some inlining, there will be no function call into some index operator function

ongy··on Europe's Largest Makerspace
> Europe’s largest makerspace for founders, startups, SMEs and many other creators

This feels like it'll have none of the community character that makes maker's spaces what they are

And more of a rental machines co-working space sort of character

ongy··on Google’s OAuth login doesn’t protect against purchasing a failed startup domain
Yea. The leet amount of payout seems like this was someone saying that the classification was technically correct, but it's worth fixing either way and it'd be nice to pay an amount.
ongy··on Ending our third party fact-checking program and moving to Community Notes model
> > Whether and under what circumstances trans women have no advantage over cos women is a highly complex question.

> Again, not really, except for all the misinformation online. If trans woman have such an high advantage, why haven't they dominated the Olympics for the last 20 years?

Not really sure why you specify 20 years, but I'm too lazy to go through the history of IOC positions to figure out the one 20 years ago.

Because looking at the current one already provides the answer. The IOC doesn't take the position that it is a simple topic.

The wording in https://olympics.com/ioc/human-rights/fairness-inclusion-non... (and click through) is quite clear that they see a tension between inclusion along the axis of sexual identity and a continuation (or successor) or male/female category split.

ongy··on When should we require that firmware be free?
While this looks hard, the FSF has long ago provided us with a solution.

The preferred form to make modifications on.

ongy··on When should we require that firmware be free?
Yes.
ongy··on Where Is HTTP/3? (2021)
That's how I use it

Envoy as TLS terminating reverse proxy, and then locally it does http2.

ongy··on My PhD advisor rewrote himself in bash (2010)
The value in the stock market is an increasing function, but neither nondecreasing, nor constant. And most of all, not monotonically increasing.

The monotonically is important because it says that at every zoom level the function is increasing, while it being increasing just says it about the function shape in general.

ongy··on RISC-V HiFive Premier P550 Development Boards with Ubuntu Now Available
I'm with the middle commenter

Use proper title case in titles.

ongy··on My second year without a job
Kinda useless to reply to a throwaway after 5h but let's see

1. Minor mistake. 42% marginal is at 60k~ish, the 278k number is 45% 2. The effective income tax rate around 100k is in the area of 25%. When there's numbers thrown around above 40% they usually include the 19% sales tax, CO2 tax etc. it's a slightly odd number including government induced cost.

ongy··on Go-Safeweb
This might be me being daft, but I never quite understood the appeal of doing this with istio. OR also partially just due to the timing of when I started to care about things in k8s world. (Rather recently)

My understanding of that model is that the services themselves still just do unauthenticated HTTP, this gets picked up on the client side by a sidecar, packed into mTLS/HTTPS, authed+unpacked on the server sidecar, then passed as plain HTTP to the server itself.

This is great when we have intra-host vulnerabilities I guess. But doesn't allow to e.g. have code sanitizers that are strict on using TLS properly (google does this).

And while it is a real gain over simple unauthed with untrusted network between nodes, with cilium taking care of the intra-node networking being secure, I don't quite see how the added layer is more useful than using network policies strictly.

(besides some edge cases where it's used to further apply internal authorization based on the identity. Though that trusts the "network" (istio) again.)

ongy··on Go-Safeweb
My reading is that it's supposed to provide an API that's safe to use, but might not allow to do everything technically possible within the HTTP spec.
ongy··on Go-Safeweb
I suspect this is partially from google's internal 0 trust cluster networking.

I.e. even if the communication is entirely between components inside a k8s (or borg) cluster, it should be authenticated and encrypted.

In this model, there may be a reverse proxy at the edge of the cluster, but the communication between this service and the internal services wouls still be https. With systems like cert-manager it's also incredibly easy to supply every in-cluster process with a certificate form the cluster-internal CA.

-- Googler, not related to this project

ongy··on Why Docker Compose Falls Short as Self-Hosting Scales
They don't mention it in the article, but by default ports 80 and 443 require elevated privileges.

There's some (namespaces) knob to avoid that, but the lack of nod to it makes me worried.

OTOH containers as security boundary is iffy. But I still like them to not be root in case of compromise

ongy··on Authenticated Boot and Disk Encryption on Linux (2021)
I wanted to avoid making this a "it's Lennart" point.

Even then, IME he's building software for 99% of users, which this covers. It can be quite annoying when he makes life hard for the remaining 1% (or fraction thereof), but I'm not as antagonistic to him as others.

Also, he kinda mentions it in the "Anything Else?" section. Not the firmware that doesn't ship with the MS keys at all, but the ability to insert your own keys and distrust the MS ones.

ongy··on Authenticated Boot and Disk Encryption on Linux (2021)
He's generally (I suspect p>99, probably a 9 more by volume) correct with his statement.
ongy··on Ask HN: How to store and share passwords in a company?
While the single point of failure (especially for browser cookies) can be an issue, handing authentication and associated bookkeeping to an entity that does that, instead of plugging your own essentially least viable product level auth on top of every service is a win.

If everyone did authentication well, then centralized IDPs might be questionable from a computer security perspective. But most aren't doing it well.

On top of that, humans generally work best if they don't have to remember lots of truly random passwords. I.e. in realistic settings, there's a maximum of expected passwords either way. And the true gain of having dedicated auth everywhere is minor.

There's some consideration for things like FIDO/WebAuthn/PassKeys, but they mostly just shift the issue from a single provider in cloud, to a single (hardware) token. Harder to copy than browser cookies, but still a single point unless it's combined with MFA.

ongy··on Client-side filtering of private data is a bad idea
For something like input field validation, a request per keystroke might be a bit much, but the update rate of feedback users expect.

In systems with frontend UX validation and backend functional validation, errors from the backend tend to be aimed at devs. I.e. might expose the reflex that's known good over having nice words for the approximate test done in the frontend.

ongy··on Go Donut: Convert Live Streaming to WebRTC
If the server is not behind NAT, the only reason you might require TURN is a restrictive egress firewall blocking UDP to arbitrary ports.

It'll be a host<>prflx connection pair. Though if the host can be reached that way, I'm unsure what the benefit of WebRTC is.

ongy··on Go Donut: Convert Live Streaming to WebRTC
What's the purpose of this?

Mostly a tech-demo, or primarily to plug a p2p layer onto existing servers?

ongy··on Peerfetch – Peer-to-Peer HTTP over WebRTC
Provide a server on-prem at the customer, but allow them a hybrid access to the system.

Via cloud when necessary, "local" (by WebRTC) when possible. While we could just open a local port, using the cloud to arbitrate gives us a common product vision, and proper authN/authZ.

Also allows us to pull the latency down to single digit milliseconds. The regional relays are double digit. When we use relays that aren't regional it's a couple hundred.

ongy··on CrowdStrike will be liable for damages in France, based on the OVH precedent
You can use SEccomp for some of it as well. But for SEccomp something in the hierarchy needs to do this actively

While SELinux can be set up somewhat orthogonal to the running system. OTOH systemd should make it easy to confirm every service process

ongy··on CrowdStrike will be liable for damages in France, based on the OVH precedent
> Only authorized images will boo

How do you do this on modern commodity hardware without secure boot?

Or do you assume something in the category of embedded systems that allow to blow some efuses to get similar trusted boot?

ongy··on The six dumbest ideas in computer security (2005)
It's not controversial to write secure software.

Saying that it's what should be fine is useless. Since it's not instructive.

Don't fix implementation issues because that just papers over design issues? Great. Now we just need a team that never makes mistakes in design. And then a language that doesn't allow security issues outside business logic.

ongy··on Apple won't roll out AI tech in EU market over regulatory concerns
Then people gain options.

Some of them might be worse for privacy, but if they offer better (or cheaper, which can be a quality) features, that's up to people.

If this was "the olden days", it would be a legitimate concern. But mobile OSs have long forced Apps to request permission to use various features explicitely and fall back graciously when some aren't provided. So outside security concerns that exist either way, they really can only claim to care about misinformed users.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →