HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ordinaryperson

2,156 karma · joined December 13, 2016

submissionscomments
ordinaryperson··on Ubuntu 20.04 LTS’ snap obsession has snapped me off of it
Auto updates have existed long before Windows 10.

It's great that you are diligent about updating your software regularly. But how many people do? If you agree that it's a low percentage, then why is not better for the ecosystem as a whole to improve security and compatibility?

ordinaryperson··on Ubuntu 20.04 LTS’ snap obsession has snapped me off of it
OK, but why is the problem FRR not addressing bugs it may be auto releasing and instead the entire principle of auto-updates in general?

If we agree that auto-updates on the whole improve security for the platform, why is that not a goal worth pursuing? Why are application devs totally blameless in releasing buggy software?

ordinaryperson··on Ubuntu 20.04 LTS’ snap obsession has snapped me off of it
My position is not that certain users would prefer to update on their own schedule. Of course there are.

Or that new updates sometimes break things and that's a hassle. Of course they do and it is.

The problem is if you want to distribute an important security update, what do you do? Ask everyone nicely to upgrade? How? Again, what % of users will manually update their software? Not a lot.

For #2, that seems like a resolvable problem that can be brought to Canonical. I'd prefer to see auto-updates fine-tuned rather than have super users immediately dismiss the idea in general.

It's just my opinion but I think the greater good of the Linux community is served by auto updates, even if occasionally it means an update to an individual application has a bug here or there.

Maybe this doesn't apply to you but I wonder how much of the Linux community just doesn't like change. Sometimes Canonical stuff does crazy stuff (Mir?) but auto-updates seem like a noble principle worth attempting to adopt.

ordinaryperson··on Ubuntu 20.04 LTS’ snap obsession has snapped me off of it
> Updating everything has always been one click in Ubuntu (and I'm sure there's an option to have it go automatically).

And what percentage of users do that? From your experience in software in general how much of the general population manually updates their software? It's almost always a low number and that creates problems. A different set of problems than new updates that cause bugs, but IMHO worse ones.

> Maybe the benefits justify it, but what are those benefits supposed to be?

Security, compatibility, uniformity. Not having to support 18 different versions.

> I hate systemd because it breaks a bunch of stuff but I'm still forced to use it.

Exactly what stuff does it break? And are those things more important than the benefits of systemd?

ordinaryperson··on Ubuntu 20.04 LTS’ snap obsession has snapped me off of it
OK, so there was an image orientation bug in that specific release of Chrome.

But it's estimated there are 1 billion users of Chrome. One billion! How wide of an attack surface does that present? Or how much of a nightmare would it be if they were all on wildly different versions?

I get that this specific bug may have caused problems for you. But if I had to choose between security and compatibility for 1 billion software users vs an occasional image orientation bug, I'll choose the former, personally.

ordinaryperson··on Ubuntu 20.04 LTS’ snap obsession has snapped me off of it
> I don't want Google's (or anyone else's) code running in the background doing whatever it wants.

Is it really "doing whatever it wants" or just updating itself? Doing whatever it wants seems like a much broader range of activities.

Crashing or freezing is a problem, but isn't all software susceptible to those bugs? What if Chrome was crashing or freezing on other people's computers and the latest update fixed it for them?

The problem with your preferred methodology of opting in to updates is that 90% of users won't do it, which leads to security and compatibility nightmares.

I get that an update can cause problems. But to say that all auto-updating is terrible and it just breaks things and software is doing "whatever it wants" in the background seems like an exaggeration and misses the larger benefits.

ordinaryperson··on Ubuntu 20.04 LTS’ snap obsession has snapped me off of it
OK, what issues does it cause? And are those issues outweighed by the security and standardization issues raised by non-updating software?

I don't know who all remembers having to develop websites compatible with outdated versions of Internet Explorer but I do and still have nightmares about it.

ordinaryperson··on Ubuntu 20.04 LTS’ snap obsession has snapped me off of it
Maybe I'm in the minority but I like Snaps. I wish all software would auto-update silently in the background -- when's the last time you even thought about upgrading Chrome?

The author of this article claims it's too difficult to find Flatpak apps and that the Ubuntu software center prioritizes Snaps over .deb. Are platforms never allowed to migrate to a new standard? Why is it Canonical's fault that authors of individual applications have yet to migrate Snaps?

If we all agree that on the whole auto-updating software is generally better and more secure than manually updated software, why not single out the applications that haven't migrated instead of blaming the whole standard?

Maybe I'm just naive and not doing advanced super user stuff these Snap haters are doing but from a distance to me this resembles the systemd vs init controversy. One which, IMHO, Linux super users seemed unusually attached to an older standard for not always clear reasons. Snaps offer real benefits: maybe instead of complaining that 'this sucks' users could offer constructive criticism about how to improve the new standard.

Just my opinion tho.

ordinaryperson··on Bloomberg bankrolls a social-media army
George Washington lost his first campaign to the Virginia House of Burgess in 1755, 271-40.

When he ran again 3 years later he gave away 28 gallons of rum, 50 gallons of rum punch, 34 gallons of wine, 46 gallons of beer, and two gallons of cider royal — "nearly enough for a half-gallon per voter." And guess what, he won.

Considering we wouldn't even declare independence until 18 years later, it's safe to say that buying influence in an election has been American since the beginning, and even before.

[1] https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/12384/swilling-planters-...

ordinaryperson··on Judge rules that student loan debt is dischargeable in bankruptcy
Sure, there's some leeway in how these vague tests are applied. But just because one judge gave a generous interpretation it doesn't mean the law has somehow changed significantly.

If judges just abandoned it they'd probably be overturned by appellate courts.

I'm not arguing the injustice of it, just reinforcing the OP commenter's point: the law has not changed, and this ruling does not materially affect that.

ordinaryperson··on Judge rules that student loan debt is dischargeable in bankruptcy
That's not how the law works.

The "Brunner test" that the OP commenter mentioned looks at 3 things:

1) Based upon your current income and expenses, you cannot maintain a minimal standard of living for yourself and your dependents if you are forced to repay your loans.

2) Your current financial situation is likely to continue for a big part of the repayment period.

3) You have made a good faith effort to repay your student loans

In this specific instance the judge ruled the litigant had passed the Brunner test. It may have been a lenient application of the test, but the law remains the same.

Other judges cannot look at this case and abandon the Brunner test, which is what you seem to be implying should/will happen here.

If you want the system changed you'll need Congress to pass a law.

ordinaryperson··on Ask HN: How was your first performance review?
Ideally a good performance review helps the employee become better, and they can use that feedback to grow in their carer.

E.g. have someone on your team who writes long e-mails? Or insta-replies to things without taking time to think? Helping those people grow is the point.

Compensation is a universe unto itself. Ideally we'd all be paid according to merit but merit is hard to measure. A (well-executed) performance review should have value in helping people grow and not just be a vector for more $$.

Realistically speaking if you want to significantly increase your compensation these days you have to get a new job.

ordinaryperson··on Ask HN: How was your first performance review?
Odd that many in this thread blame performance reviews themselves ("complete and utter waste of time", "waste of time and simply busy work", etc) and not the manager giving them.

For your manager to do it right requires some courage (to give negative feedback), maturity (to do it professionally), training (e.g. never deliver feedback in 'the compliment sandwich') and empathy (to relate to the employee's POV). Obviously most managers lack these.

E.g. Some employees are over-eager and blitz colleagues: "Hey did you get the email I just sent 30 seconds ago?" Others like to have Jira ticket comment wars. A good manager would give direct feedback routinely throughout the year.

"Hey Bob, blowing up my inbox with dozens of IMs and emails in a single day is counter-productive."

"Hey Suzy, that 750-word Jira comment about why your dispatch function to the React store is a better approach then Duane's could have been better handled face-to-face."

Then the performance review is hopefully a boring, pedestrian summary of stuff talked about all year.

Instead managers are afraid to give feedback and wait until January to tell you all the things they hate about you. Plus your review is likely tied to your compensation/promotion, often making it unnecessarily a high-stress, do-or-die bombshell.

What's really important these days (IMHO) is not the review itself since nowadays everyone changes jobs like they change pants, what matters is your ability to receive negative feedback like an adult and adapt. It means having a manager who can give negative feedback like an adult (a big if) but that will likely help you more in your career than generic pats on the back.

Happy review season everyone.

ordinaryperson··on JobFunnel, a job website search aggregator
Conservative HR/Legal departments will often post jobs publicly to avoid a discrimination lawsuit from the EEOC.

The federal government can (and routinely does) ask mid-sized to large companies for records of their job applicants to "prove" they are not discriminating against protected categories (women, minorities, the disabled, etc).

So if the CEO/hiring exec wants to hire his good old boy friend to a position no matter what the job will still be posted and applicants will be collected even if they have no chance of being hired.

Obviously I have no data on how prevalent this practice is but I've witnessed it firsthand, so it happens.

ordinaryperson··on Carlos Ghosn Flees to Lebanon to Escape Japan Legal System
> Both articles describe the transfers as misappropriations of funds

"Describing as" != prove. And when it comes to throwing people in jail we should strive for prove.

> Broadly speaking, if management finds their operational budget in their personal account without the Board's knowledge, that's fraud.

First, no Nissan funds were in Ghosn's "personal account." Not sure where you're getting that. The articles clearly describe GFI as an arm of Nissan directly controlled by Ghosn but that is not a personal account -- it was still a Nissan account.

Second, Ghosn's defense has been all along that others in the firm approved the transactions. Someone somewhere was clearly signing the checks -- I don't know how true this is but it is a legitimate defense.

Allegations are not proof. I can accuse you of anything -- doesn't make it true.

Ghosn may indeed have engaged in criminal activity but nothing you describe proves it, or even seriously indicates it.

ordinaryperson··on Carlos Ghosn Flees to Lebanon to Escape Japan Legal System
What proof is there these services were never rendered? Neither article you cited claims that.
ordinaryperson··on Carlos Ghosn Flees to Lebanon to Escape Japan Legal System
I agree, it was odd the way they immediately threw the book at him.

Look at the Takata airbag executives. Their decisions resulted in the actual deaths of human beings and they were not treated as harshly.

ordinaryperson··on Carlos Ghosn Flees to Lebanon to Escape Japan Legal System
How are the GFI payments to SBA the "elephant in the room"?

GFI (controlled by Ghosn) paid SBA (an Omani businessman, Suhail Bahwan) for "marketing incentives." At some point later, SBA paid GFI. The Japanese suggest this was a kickback scheme but 1) the fact that one firm paid another and vice versa is not ipso facto evidence of financial wrongdoing 2) if this really is a kickback scheme, why such low sums of money relative to his net worth?

The other accusation in the articles you reference is that GFI made payments to a company named "Shogun Investments", of which Ghosn's son was involved, and that he directed those funds to his own financial startup, "Shogun Enterprises", which then possibly used the funds to buy a yacht.

The first charge has no clear basis for impropriety, and the second is against Ghosn's son, not Ghosn (and btw, even if Ghosn's son did misuse investor funds -- and he denies doing so -- it wouldn't be the first startup in the world to do so).

Unless you can explain to me something I'm missing these accusations do not strike me as "the elephant in the room."

ordinaryperson··on Carlos Ghosn Flees to Lebanon to Escape Japan Legal System
I'm no fan of fatcat CEOs but by most accounts the charges against Ghosn are weak at best. See: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-01-31/inside-th...

Specifically he's accused of:

1) Concealing the true scale of his retirement package, none of which had been paid

2) During the '08 crisis he had Nissan temporarily take on hedging contracts (used to blunt the impact of currency fluctuations of the yen) since his bank was demanding collateral he didn't have; then later securing a line of credit from a Saudi businessman who was paid $14 million by Nissan (ostensibly for regional distribution)

I'm no forensic accountant but that's not a lot of smoke, much less fire. The retirement package was still theoretical and it's hard to believe a man being paid $20 million a year was really engaging in financial skullduggery for what amounted to peanuts of his net worth.

As others in this thread have pointed out, this seems to be a case of the Japanese looking down on greed, whereas it's the norm in America and some parts of Europe.

Also the Japanese were possibly reluctant to see a big Japanese company (Nissan) subsumed into a large international behemoth (Ghosn was trying to formally merge Renault and Nissan at the time of his arrest).

Ghosn is probably right that he can't get a fair trial in Japan's notoriously prosecutor-friendly justice system. Even the Businessweek article notes the conviction rate is at or near 100%.

Ghosn may have been arrogant and greedy but unless new details are presented the publicly available evidence suggests these charges are extremely flimsy.

ordinaryperson··on Windows 95 UI Design
Compounding this frustration (on iOS at least) is stuff like "force touch" and hidden toolbars. Depending on how hard you press a button you might get a totally different UI interaction.

Are others good at knowing exactly how many newtons of force it takes to follow a hyperlink instead of triggering this horrid mini-preview window? Maybe that's why Jonny Ive made millions of dollars while I work like a stiff for a living.

Want to open a new tab in mobile Safari while on a webpage? Oh I must tap the invisible button bar at the bottom. So obvious.

I just wish Apple et al. didn't force these choices on us, that we could disable silliness like force touch and hidden toolbars. But alas one cannot.

ordinaryperson··on Today’s Top Tech Skills
Exactly.

"I use [x] all the time and know it well, so [x] will be a good filter for evaluating someone's technical skills."

No. People do different work tasks depending on the project or company.

Sometimes I'm knee-deep in SQL. Others in React. I'm often forced to do PHP. My familiarity with specific SQL syntax ebbs & flows with what I'm doing.

There's no point in keeping something in your brain if you're not going to use it every day. Just remember the general concept and Google the specifics when you need it.

Just one example why interviewing is terrible and interviewers really should be trained on what not to do.

ordinaryperson··on After Spike in Deaths, New York to Get 250 Miles of Protected Bike Lanes
A history = means a history, not a low probability history, not a high probability history, just a history. You seem to be creating requirements for a "a history" to "needs to happen with a certain frequency." Even 1 time would be a history, altho cyclists kill more people than that.

It's not something "only I am saying." Cyclists have a history of endangering pedestrians...it's a low probability event but by any rational definition of "history" it's a track record aka history.

Not sure why people are so eager to defend cyclists they're willing to overlook the fact that they can and do endanger pedestrians and now -- in your case -- pretend they have no "history" of doing so because it's not happening often enough for your satisfaction.

And it looks like this parent comment was deleted and this thread is now detached -- I'm assuming the moderators also had a problem with that original statement.

ordinaryperson··on After Spike in Deaths, New York to Get 250 Miles of Protected Bike Lanes
No.

Again, his exact statement was: "Cyclists in NYC (and I imagine most cities) do not, and have never had, a history of 'endangering the lives of others.'"

He's stating unequivocally that cyclists do not have -- and have never had -- a history of endangering the lives of others.

They kill people. I certainly call that endangering the lives of others.

They don't kill a lot of people. Neither do sharks -- in the US they only kill about 1 person a year. That doesn't mean sharks are not dangerous or don't have a history of endangering people.

If you or he want to make a statement about the low probability of such an event -- fine. Or compare cyclists to far more dangerous motor vehicles, also fine. But to say that cyclists don't and have never endangered pedestrians is not factually accurate.

ordinaryperson··on After Spike in Deaths, New York to Get 250 Miles of Protected Bike Lanes
Cyclists do kill pedestrians in NYC. E.g.: https://gothamist.com/news/cyclist-who-killed-woman-in-centr...

Not saying it's a high probability, especially as compared to motor vehicles, but to state the opposite -- cyclists don't have a history of endangering the lives of others -- is also false. They can and do kill pedestrians.

ordinaryperson··on My Time at Snap
> We have all worked for a "John" in the industry.

Agreed. But since so many middle managers are twits isn't it incumbent on the employee to learn a set of skills to deal with Johns?

Managing people is hard. Being a good manager is really hard, which is why there are so few of them.

Rather than rail against how terrible Person X is as a manager I feel like it's more productive to say, "Unless I start my own company there's always going to be some clueless middle manager above me. How do I deal with him/her effectively?"

ordinaryperson··on Serverless: slower and more expensive
Exactly. Like anything, right tool for the right job.

I was hosting my personal website on EC2 with an RDS instance and it cost around $20/month. But since the site gets little-to-no traffic and I got sick of EC2 upkeep, I switched S3 & Cloudfront: now my bill is $0.80/month.

Another example: at work we inherited an old EC2 instance that was set up solely to run cron jobs on other servers. Occasionally it would lock up or go down, for whatever reason, creating chaos for the servers that needed specific jobs run frequently.

We switched to AWS Lambda functions for those cron jobs and they've never failed once.

If you're running a games website that gets pinged 24/7, don't use Serverless. But the notion that it's slow and overpriced is misguided if you're applying the wrong use case.

ordinaryperson··on College, Calculus, and the Problem with the SAT
> "The most selective institutions, she found, spend a lot more on each undergraduate than other colleges do, and they give a significant boost in lifetime earnings, on average, to the students they enroll."

OR rich kids tend to go to rich colleges (Harvard, Yale, Stanford) and were predisposed to high incomes anyway -- one study showed that rich kids WITHOUT college degrees earn more than poor kids WITH them [1].

> "It has more or less always been true that the SAT, on balance, benefits college applicants who already enjoy lots of financial and social advantages."

Here's the problem with this analysis: what's the alternative? 50 years of education research no one's come up with a more meritocratic method than GPA + test scores. What, you going to rely on personal essays? And you think that's a fair, objective standard??

If not that, then what? Mandatory racial quotas like Carranza is trying to implement in NYC high schools?

> "Their high school grades had turned out to be much better predictors of their academic ability and college potential than their SAT scores."

What was the sample size he interviewed? A cohort of ~3.3 mil students graduate high school every year and ~66% apply to college, so it's a total population of around 2.2 million students going to college every year. Did he get a representative sample size? I doubt it.

Research has consistently shown the data with the highest correlation coefficient of first-year GPA (FGPA) in college are standardized test scores + GPA [2]. This should be common sense, there's obviously wildly different standards in high schools across America, GPA by itself is a noisy signal.

> "If they lived in Michigan or Virginia or North Carolina, they would be unlikely to be admitted to their state’s flagship university. But in Texas, their hard work in high school earns them admission to the finest university in the state."

Yes, but how many qualified out-of-state students were excluded from admission because of this system? If the goal was to admit a cohort of the most academically qualified student body then this system is, by definition, unfair and not meritocratic.

Let me say I am very much pro-diversity. But a lot of what Paul Tough is selling here is wishful thinking -- essentially throwing out standardized testing in favor of high school curricula, which the research shows is uneven and not a meritocratic standard.

[1] https://www.brookings.edu/blog/social-mobility-memos/2016/02...

[2] https://facultysenate.umich.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/22/...

ordinaryperson··on Edward Snowden: Permanent Record
Unpopular opinion destined to attract downvotes but: IMHO the NSA spying program was outrageous...for the colossal waste of money and time it was.

First, if you're really worried about privacy, why is it not a DEFCON 1 outrage that state DMVs are selling your info to private investigators? [1] Or if you're really worried about your personal liberty, isn't your local police force a greater threat then NSA eavesdroppers?

Back in 2013 the NSA claimed it was spying on 29 petabytes of internet data (out of 1826) a day [2], or 1.6%. That's both a trivial amount of overall traffic and an insanely large dataset at the same time (since it accumulates every day).

Isn't a big chunk of that traffic encrypted? Even if it's not, how do you find terrorists in that data? Do they self-identify? Even if they use a trivial substitution cipher ('cupcakes' instead of 'bombs') it would evade these billion-dollar supercomputers.

To me the NSA's spying program was security theater akin to airport security: expensive machines that don't even catch terrorists. They fail their own internal tests 95% of the time! [3]. I personally would like to know what algorithms the NSA was using to successfully identify terrorist data in exobytes of (possibly encrypted) datasets. Sounds like billions spent on airport scanners to me.

Finally, on a political level, Snowden seems like a massive hypocrite to me for hiding in China, which harvests the organs of political prisoners [4] and Russia, which routinely assassinates political opponents and journalists [5]. But he's mad that what, the US was reading his Gmail?

I realize he's super popular among the HN crowd and the libertarians for whom all gov't surveillance is evil but I, for one, am not a Snowden admirer. Downvote away.

[1] https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/43kxzq/dmvs-selling-data-...

[2] https://www.zdnet.com/article/nsa-hunger-demands-29-petabyte...

[3] https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/investigation-breaches-...

[4] https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/china-forcefully-harvests...

[5] https://www.thedailybeast.com/russia-shows-us-what-happens-t...

ordinaryperson··on Effects of short-term fasting on cancer treatment
Who's equating caloric intake with nutrition and satiety?

My point is people who have successfully adopted a particular technique for reducing their caloric intake (fasting, kale, smoothies, veganism, omega 3 acids, etc) are disguising the underlying process that's conferring most of the health benefits they're seeing: which is weight loss.

How many stories have you read out there about Secret Diet X that does all sorts of allegedly amazing things for you? Paleo diet. Veganism. Atkins diet. The Zone diet. The Dukan diet. And on and on.

There are many strategies for reducing caloric intake and if 16:8 fasting works for you: fantastic. But at the end of the day most people will improve their health through weight loss, not some special ritual or ingredient, and I think we should be cautious before crowning specific calorie reduction techniques as having special or more beneficial properties unless there is clear scientific evidence for them.

ordinaryperson··on Effects of short-term fasting on cancer treatment
"Burst of fresh nutrients" -- there are fresh foods but just nutrients. Not super nutrients, not fresh nutrients, just nutrients.

Hey it's a good strategy. Works for you, can work for others. But the magic is not in breaking your fast with a "burst of fresh nutrients" -- it's in reducing your overall caloric intake, as well as eating a balanced diet.

Good luck and congrats again.

← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →