HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ordinaryperson

2,156 karma · joined December 13, 2016

submissionscomments
ordinaryperson··on What do Stanford CS PhD students think of their PhD program? [pdf]
This doesn't answer the question I fundamentally want to know: do they think it was worth it?

In my CS master's programs profs often warned against the PhD, said companies wouldn't hire you, that they'd view you as "too smart" and potentially be bored by everyday work.

Not true for certain disciplines (AI, e.g.) but I don't think every CS PhD is walking out the door with 300K/year offers hitting them in the face.

ordinaryperson··on AT&T’s Troubling Plan to Change HBO
Developing hit shows like "Game of Thrones" is extremely hard, and the competition for streaming content is cuthroat.

Meanwhile AT&T essentially only competes with Verizon, and does that primarily by offering the exact same services -- not exactly revolutionary, Harvard Business School Case Study stuff.

What has AT&T done in the last 20 years that was original? Mainly its operating business strategy is to raise prices as a regional, quasi-monopoly.

But sure, it's the (not highly paid) HBO employees that have to work harder, emulate those brilliant AT&T execs and their super original business growth strategies.

ordinaryperson··on How much does a tech bro cost?
It also conflates "tax breaks" with "subsidies".

Not charging you a fee is not the same thing as handing over cash.

Tax breaks are valuable, for sure, but I can't buy a bunch of F-35s with tax breaks.

ordinaryperson··on Convergence to Kubernetes
Dumb question from someone who doesn't use Kubernetes (or Docker) in production: don't routine security updates mean you're constantly rebuilding and redeploying these images? And if so, how is that more efficient than just using Puppet / Chef / Ansible and a 'real' server?
ordinaryperson··on Why Do We Care So Much About Privacy?
"People are inconsistent about the kind of exposure they’ll tolerate. We don’t like to be fingerprinted by government agencies, a practice we associate with mug shots and state surveillance, but we happily hand our thumbprints over to Apple, which does God knows what with them."

Great point. People say they care about privacy but willingly Instagram and Snapchat and YouTube every minor detail about their lives.

Not everyone of course, but a lot. Facebook has what, 2.1 billion users?

There's a vast asymmetry between the privacy people say they want and in reality how quickly they'll give it up in exchange for free services.

But this article is a good legal history of American law.

ordinaryperson··on Performance Reviews Are a Waste of Time
Defending performance reviews is like cheerleading taxes -- automatic way to accrue downvotes here, but bear with me.

I've lived through unfair, biased and unhelpful perf reviews, I know what it's like to have this sky beam open up out of nowhere and vaporize you over absurd nonsense, but in a company of > 100 people you need a paper record of performance.

If you're a VP and suddenly someone asks, "Hey, can you promote or fire Person X?" What are you to go off of? Just a manager's recommendation? And you think perf reviews are biased?

Unfair performance reviews are usually a byproduct of bad managers. For ex: I knew fellow managers who never told reports what they were doing wrong, they'd wait til the end-of-the-year review and write vicious stuff. Why? It was hard to say face-to-face.

That's cowardly and not good mgt: you meet weekly or biweekly to discuss all issues, a well-run perf review is a boring rubber stamp on the 25 things you've been discussing all year.

This author suggests that employees present managers "handwritten notes" of their performance "in a notebook every 6-12 months." Guess what-- that's a performance review! As if the problem w/perf reviews was the formality of the process and not the human judgment being applied.

Again, I get it: performance reviews suck. But I think it's not the paperwork or the process, it's that management can be very inept at evaluating talent periodically, regardless of how that process is run.

Unfortunately, it's hard to run a company of > 100 people without written records of performance (especially if someone sues).

ordinaryperson··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (June 2018)
Dan, I appreciate the thoughtful and measured response. But let me offer a counterpoint: you could apply the same logic to any comment anywhere.

Take yesterday's topic on Microsoft potentially acquiring GitHub. How many anonymous comments are there slagging Microsoft (or GitHub)? No one has any way to verify the credibility of comments there, either.

The question is: do complaining about a negative experience (real or imagined) present any long-term benefit to the community and to the original poster?

If the comment is junk or fake then the poster has the ability to respond as such (or profess ignorance). But the community gains by either being warned about a potential job opportunity or seeing how the hirer responds.

I understand not turning this into Glassdoor/Yelp bottom-feeding but I was specifically referencing the recent hiring practices of this particular company, not reviewing them as a whole or judging their leadership or corporate direction or promotion systems etc.

I think if you really want no replies it should be hardcoded into the HN architecture, but the antiseptic posting of job listing, without any potential input from people who've recently gone through the process, is IMHO a loss for the HN community -- if I just want unadorned job listings, I can get that many other places than HN, and with much better filtering technology.

I recognize this is a gray area but I really think commenters should be allowed to share interviewing experiences with companies who post here -- keeping HN from becoming a complaining ground is more complex than just banning comments, IMHO.

Thanks for listening.

ordinaryperson··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (June 2018)
Recently I interviewed with Discovery, although not for any of these exact 3 positions.

Had an HR screen, timed online programming test, then a phone call with the hiring manager -- who then ghosted me. He seemed obsessed with MongoDB migrations and upset I hadn't done any.

I realize it prob wasn't you and it's up the hiring manager but ghosting is unprofessional, IMHO. If I'm going to take time to pass a technical test and have 2 hour-long phone call interviews, at least e-mail me later to say no thanks.

ordinaryperson··on I Write Letters to CEOs
Agreed. That was my perception of the offer.
ordinaryperson··on I Write Letters to CEOs
Yes. This, exactly.
ordinaryperson··on I Write Letters to CEOs
To elaborate on why I declined:

The District Manager left a voicemail for me asking when he could schedule a tour with me. He was 100% polite, but it sounded like he was gritting his teeth.

Maybe I was reading too much into it, but I interpreted it as, "My boss's boss is forcing me to give an idiot like you, someone probably with no experience in retail economics, a tour while I patiently pretend to listen to how you tell me to do my job better than me, a person with decades of experience in selling video games."

If the situation were reversed I wouldn't want some rando customer coming into my job and telling me everything he thinks I'm doing wrong.

Plus, I got the feeling (again, just my perception) that it would just be "here's what's wrong with this store" instead of "here's what's wrong with all of your stores."

Maybe it was all in my head and they would have taken me seriously, I don't know. But that was the impression I got.

And I was legitimately busy. Writing a letter takes 10 minutes, a tour and presentation of my ideas would obviously take a lot longer.

ordinaryperson··on I Write Letters to CEOs
Years ago I wrote a letter to Paul Raines, then the CEO of Gamestop.

Mainly I complained how terrible the store experience was. Whereas Apple stores feel like an avant-garde museum Gamestops feel like the inside of a Chuck E. Cheese circa 1987 -- games everywhere, no real organization, no marketing of individual titles or genres, it's just grabbag nonsense of plastic container after plastic container.

Days after I sent the letter, his secretary called me and scheduled a phone call for the next day.

Paul could not have been nicer. He said he appreciated the criticism and offered to have his district manager tour a location with me so I could share in greater depth my concerns.

I declined (too busy) but was obviously taken aback with his generosity and patience.

Sadly, he passed away in March of this year from brain cancer at the very young age of 53.

He had no real incentive to respond to an angry letter from a random customer, but he went way out of his way to at least listen to me (even if the stores haven't improved much).

R.I.P. Paul.

ordinaryperson··on Scrum disempowers developers
What’s that quote from Elon Musk - process is an excuse for large companies to keep mediocre talent?

Put enough smart people in a room and they’ll figure it out. Scrum isn’t any worse than Kanban or ‘pure’ Agile or Waterfall or Lean — every system has tradeoffs and smart people learn to adjust.

No company is perfect. Tell management how the process can be improved. If they ignore you, consider moving on.

ordinaryperson··on Perceived Physical Activity and Mortality: Study
Yes, the article seems to take liberties from the two studies it quotes.

But I also am skeptical of the underlying studies. So many factors in mortality rate I'm having a hard time believing they were able to control for all of those (weight, age, diet, exercise, family history, etc) and isolate "positive thinking."

ordinaryperson··on Perceived Physical Activity and Mortality: Study
Yes, you're right. The study is different than what the article says. The article is taking a leap of faith from that study to generalize, so, fair point.

But even for that study, I'm a little skeptical of their results. There are so many factors that figure into mortality, it's hard to believe a positive attitude can really be singled out as significant.

Diet? Age? Exercise level? Family history? Weight? Where does positive thinking sit on this list?

Whether you're using it as a proxy for fitness or mortality I think it's a questionable correlation, IMHO.

ordinaryperson··on Perceived Physical Activity and Mortality: Study
BMI is only useful for large populations but terrible as a metric for individuals.

For starters, it can't distinguish between muscle and fat. So anyone muscular is obese per BMI.

More: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/bmi-is-a-terrible-measu...

ordinaryperson··on Perceived Physical Activity and Mortality: Study
Agreed. It has an impact. And it helps you break through walls in training.

But I think the authors of this article, who cite a previous study got a little carried away. They cite a paper where researchers measured cleaning ladies after 4 weeks? You're not going from zero to hero in 4 weeks.

How they ate over that period probably had a far larger effect on their overall health than mental positivity.

ordinaryperson··on Perceived Physical Activity and Mortality: Study
What about powerlifters or weightlifters? Super strong. Get winded walking up a flight of stairs.

My point is, there is no one universal definition of fitness.

The most reliable measure I've heard of is belly fat, which you can measure with a calipers. But you can't wish away belly fat with positive thinking, so I think the writers of this article are taking this study a little too far, IMO.

ordinaryperson··on Perceived Physical Activity and Mortality: Study
Yes mindset is important. But having run 8 marathons I can tell you wishful thinking is not a substitute for training.

You can’t really quantify fitness, there are too many subtypes (running? swimming? weightlifting?) This study used blood pressure and weight (among others) but those can vary wildly based on genetics and diet, I’m not sure they’re reliable indicators.

The point of the article (as I understand it) is that positive thinking can influence your health. Fine. But let’s not get carried away: you’re not going to roll out of bed and complete an Ironman without training just because you think you can.

EDIT: Mods have updated the title to better reflect the first underlying study (which focuses on mortality, not fitness).

But 1) even with the focus on mortality, it's still hard to correlate PMA and mortality and not control for diet, exercise, history, genetics, etc. and 2) if PMA doesn't correlate w/fitness, it's hard to see how it can make you live longer (i.e., can you be morbidly obese and positive and live longer than an athlete with a bad mental attitude?)

PMA is good. But I'm having a hard time believing you're going to live longer -- seems like there are 50 other factors that are more important.

ordinaryperson··on Both in rich and poor countries, universal health care brings huge benefits
> So the US healthcare model as it stands is a euphemism for the wealthy and healthy subsidizing the poor and sick in an insanely inefficient way.

Don't really understand this line. The US model itself is a euphemism? What?

I have no doubt that indigent patients get a break from a lot of facilities, but my question would be: why are those services so expensive in the first place? Why is it totally impossible for a person making a reasonable income to pay for a service like healthcare by themselves? You seem to be assuming the costs for your lab are totally normal and legit and wow, isn't it amazing the breaks we give people, but maybe your lab could be charging a lot less than it is for its services?

I don't know obviously, you work there, I don't, I'm just pointing out the underlying issue.

ordinaryperson··on Both in rich and poor countries, universal health care brings huge benefits
Exactly. It's also not a tax mandated by the state, which is the key difference between insurance and universal health care.

If America wants to introduce UHC, great, but let's be honest about what it is, and let's understand it's going to be prohibitively expensive unless we bring costs down first.

ordinaryperson··on Both in rich and poor countries, universal health care brings huge benefits
You're assuming they have much lower costs because of socialized medicine -- that's not necessarily the case.

But my broader point is just that universal health care is not an honest description of what it is, and our costs are so great we're unlikely to ever implement such a wealth transfer.

It's a lot less pie-in-the-sky IMHO to focus on bringing costs down. UHC could help in some ways but it's a broad assumption to make that if say Medicare paid for everything prices would just automatically start to drop.

ordinaryperson··on Both in rich and poor countries, universal health care brings huge benefits
UHC does provide more levers to control costs, sure. But it's not some huge fix to the underlying problem. One example: https://www.cnn.com/2018/02/10/health/uk-nhs-universal-healt...
ordinaryperson··on Both in rich and poor countries, universal health care brings huge benefits
> Given dozens of such comparisons, all coming out to the same result, your case becomes anti-empirical.

As others in this thread have pointed out, Finland vs. US is not a good comparison, Europe vs the US would be. We can socialize medicine in individual states with good results (see: MA) but US-wide? With 332+ million people? With all the differences in costs of living in different parts of the country?

When the EU rolls out a single-payer system for the entire Eurozone then we'll have something to compare against but the entire nation of Finland has less people (5.7 million) than New York City (8 million) and is a monoculture, to boot.

ordinaryperson··on Both in rich and poor countries, universal health care brings huge benefits
Uh, what?

Where in my comment did I write the government should provide no financial benefits for its citizens?

No idea where you're coming from with that.

The question is: should the government pay for everyone's healthcare? Universal health care sounds amazing except no one has a plan to pay for it, at least in the U.S. where our system is outrageously expensive.

If your plan is just to tax a small group of earners to pay these astronomical fees, good luck with that.

More realistically we have to bring the costs of healthcare down, but that seems to get little to no attention.

ordinaryperson··on Both in rich and poor countries, universal health care brings huge benefits
Obviously, I'd like everyone to be healthy and with an affordable education. But our universe is finite and someone has to pay for these services. Just blindly assuming we can tax all wealthy people into total equality seems like a pipe dream to me.

Hence, I'm arguing that instead of just blind wealth transfers from one group to the collective we should focus a lot more energy on bringing the cost of care down.

Just like we should be focusing a lot more energy on bringing the cost of college down.

ordinaryperson··on Both in rich and poor countries, universal health care brings huge benefits
Yes, the problem is American universities, like hospitals, are severely overpriced.

There are many reasons for this, but it's easier for Finland to pay collectively for higher education when the tuition is reasonable.

Just like my healthcare argument -- if we could bring down the cost of higher education then subsidizing it for everyone would be less controversial.

ordinaryperson··on Both in rich and poor countries, universal health care brings huge benefits
Sure. But what if the costs keep skyrocketing? Say you pay 50% in taxes now -- you cool with 70%? 80%?

Presumably there's a limit to what you're willing to pay.

I am in favor of higher taxes but it's impractical to assume just paying for universal health care at all costs is a viable strategy.

ordinaryperson··on Both in rich and poor countries, universal health care brings huge benefits
Yes, and I'd love to see them do more. Like a lot of preventative care.

Or obesity -- so many health problems stem from being obese. Surely nurses could help patients develop strategies to eat better and exercise.

ordinaryperson··on Both in rich and poor countries, universal health care brings huge benefits
It wouldn't. Those are 3 examples, just to prove my point about how we seem to focus exclusively on how paying for the cost of care but seemingly don't bat an eye on bringing down the costs, where there seems to be a lot of room for improvement.

If the costs were not so high, paying for it for everyone would not be as difficult to implement.

← PreviousPage 7 of 11Next →