HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

orijing

1,359 karma · joined January 26, 2011

BS/BS/BA from UC Berkeley for EECS, business administration and economics. Software engineer at Facebook.
submissionscomments
orijing··on Google’s Jaw-Dropping Sponsored Post Campaign For Chrome
So the concern is that this impacts the ranking of Google Chrome in Google Search, and that the FTC is investigating Google for favoring its own content unfairly?

It makes sense in the context of travel websites (Expedia complaining about Google, for example), but I'm not sure about Google Chrome. It's been promoted on the front page of Google many times--so does Google really need the extra boost in its search results?

orijing··on Rare earth crisis: Innovate, or be crushed by China
It's just a statement that we aren't at equilibrium... i.e. that prices would have to go higher to reach equilibrium.
orijing··on Seagate now offer only one year warranties on some HDD's
That's interesting. Do you have a reference?
orijing··on LCD makers in $553 million U.S. price-fixing accord
Without specific evidence like phone records, how could they prove illegal collusion?
orijing··on End artificial scarcities to increase productivity
When I read the heading, I expected this to be a rant about patents and the imposition of artificial scarcities to various industries like music, software and pharmaceuticals, where the marginal cost of production is negligible compared to how much they cost customers.

The article was a pleasant surprise; instead of arguing the trite, it made a point that was rarely made. For me though, I just write off these "wasted" minutes of walking up the stairs to get the scissors as "exercise."

orijing··on How Facebook Is Selling Your Timeline to Advertisers
If that were true, the sponsored content would be labeled. See http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3388106
orijing··on How Facebook Is Selling Your Timeline to Advertisers
> Optimizing for user engagement, when you make money off of ads, is optimizing for the bottom line by definition. To claim otherwise is disingenuous at best.

Well, optimizing for f(x) (revenue) is different than optimizing for g(x) (engagement), which is related to f(x), and claiming that we are objectively optimizing for f(x). Not sure if that makes sense, but you are right that it is to our long term interest to optimize for user engagement, not because it necessarily optimizes our revenue, but it optimizes our value for users.

That's not the same as optimizing for revenue directly, though, so calling that "disingenuous at best" is a little misguided.

orijing··on How Facebook Is Selling Your Timeline to Advertisers
Hi, I'm an engineer from Facebook's ads team. I worked on ads for Timeline.

The article's unsubstantiated premise is that Facebook releases products solely with its bottom line in mind. Based on my experience working on ads for Timeline, I'd say that this is antithetical to our nature. We optimized timeline for user experience (engagement) and released it not because of its impact to our bottom line but DESPITE that.

If you aren't convinced, look at the ads on Timeline, and compare to Profile. There were on average four ads per Profile page. Now there's two. People also click away a lot faster on Profile (because there's less content), but people now scroll around and navigate within Timeline. Photos are bigger, we show a lot more content. The resources to support these new products are expensive. If this doesn't illustrate our focus on engagement over our bottom line, color me surprised.

Just another point I wanted to clarify: Whenever money changed hands, even for organic content like sponsored stories, they are clearly labeled "Sponsored." If you don't see Sponsored, there was no optimization for revenue, because no money changed hands.

Ultimately, I think the author is exploiting a confusion between news feed and timeline. Sure, we will experiment with sponsoring organic content in news feed (max one), but they will be clearly labeled and things you can already see.

I just wanted to clarify a few issues that the author is either truly confused about, or is aware of but intentionally exploiting. I hope this helped.

If you have any questions I can answer, I'll be happy to clarify.

orijing··on Discovery of the Higgs Boson rumoured to be at 3.5 sigma.
Thanks for the correction. That link worked when I checked...

Well, Chebyshev inequality always applies. It just might not be the tightest bound possible. Unless we know the distribution better, this is the best estimate (tightest bound that's provably correct given the single assumption about standard deviation)

orijing··on Discovery of the Higgs Boson rumoured to be at 3.5 sigma.
I wonder if they can combine the experimental results from the 2.5 sigma and the 3.5 sigma experiments. If two independent experiments confirmed some hypothesis at 2.5 and 3.5 sigma, the combined evidence is surely much larger than 3.5. Does anyone know what the right way of combining experimental results is, to yield a more accurate answer?
orijing··on Discovery of the Higgs Boson rumoured to be at 3.5 sigma.
Well, if we take the 3.5 sigma at face value and bound it using Chebychev's inequality [1], it seems that the discovery of the Higgs Boson is bounded by 1/3.5^2, which is 8%. In fact, the standard inequality is two-tailed. If we're measuring just from one tail, we can use the single-sided inequality to yield 7.5%. Remember, we can't always assume a distribution is normal, a mistake that even respected researchers often make.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chebyshevs_inequality

orijing··on Remind HN: There's a lunar eclipse right now
Yes, during the Lunar eclipse, the sun is on the other side of the planet. It's like [sun] [earth]* [moon] in a straight line. (The * is where the photographer who sees the moon is)
orijing··on The Unintended Effects of Driverless Cars
Guys, some of you who are criticizing the precise "assumptions" are missing the point! He's not saying that utilization will go up to 96% precisely, or that there will be 20x fewer cars. He is challenging us to imagine the possibilities ourselves, seeding it with some immediate (potential) implications. On first sight his assumptions seem reasonable, and it's up to us individually to determine what the ramifications are.

Indeed the potential is enormous for freeing up a lot of human time/etc. We will need less parking certainly, cars will be running newer models (since they're used more, they'll likely last less time) with better technologies, and potentially there will be more efficient routing algorithms to save energy, time, etc.

I like how HN is often first to criticize, but sometimes you're just missing the point. The point is to imagine for yourself the possibilities. For me, it's enormous.

orijing··on World's First 128 Gb NAND Device
This is enormously impressive. But what cost? The press release claims "low cost", but fails to specify a concrete number.

If this can be produced cheaply, I can imagine newer laptops, especially those with constricting form factors like the Air or other ultrabooks, using just this and skip the entire SATA interface altogether. Perhaps even bundle the storage with the motherboard for better throughput.

orijing··on Don't Be A Free User
The author didn't bring up the point that many of those services became successful (not yet profitable) because they were free. The years when they had no ads and charged nothing are considered loss-leaders in order to build a large network, because their services typically benefit strongly from first order network effects.

Google didn't always have such an indisputable business model. Who knew search was so profitable? Would it have been as successful if it started charging users right off the bat, or covering the results pages with (irrelevant) ads before contextual ads were developed?

orijing··on CNet's Download.com now bundling Nmap with malware
I'm confused. Did Microsoft make a deal with Cnet to include this on every download, or did a third party do this? StartNow (startnow.com) is run by an independent company:

"The StartNow Start page is owned and operated by Zugo Ltd, a start page platform company. Our start pages are usually official operated on behalf of one of our clients or partners. Some pages may be "unofficial" and in support of/dedicated to improving the user experience for an existing product or extending a product's existing functionality."

This sounds like really bad PR for Microsoft. I wonder what they will do.

orijing··on How about some Android graphics true facts?
I think he means the number of apps running in the background. For example, if you have the Groupon app making constant push notifications to you, that's expensive.
orijing··on Why are you using Google Plus for Blogging?
Thanks for the explanation. I think your distinction makes sense. Facebook mimics my physical social circle very well--people I know in real life like classmates, friends, coworkers. I don't accept friend requests by people who I don't already know.

Thankfully my friends and I share many common interests, but that's a very limited audience. So I run my own blog where I post things that my friends might not be interested in, but someone will hopefully be interested in.

orijing··on Why are you using Google Plus for Blogging?
The same can be said about Facebook, so what makes Google+ unique in that regard?
orijing··on Suddenly, Hacker News is not the first result for 'Hacker News'
Of course that's the point. Again, I was responding to the parent ("Google should simply deliver the best results, no matter what algorithm they use to do so"), which I understood to be what results Google should choose to show. Perhaps I misunderstood his meaning for "best", but "best" in this context to me means the result that's most likely to satisfy the user.

I'm not disagreeing with the fact that ads are subject to a whole different objective function. I'm saying that if the best results were already in the organic, then the ads would either be redundant (for the user) or otherwise less useful than the organic (by definition, really).

orijing··on Suddenly, Hacker News is not the first result for 'Hacker News'
That's exactly my point. I was responding to the parent's suggestion that "Google should simply deliver the best results, no matter what algorithm they use to do so." In the scenario you describe, the best results would be the stores (for example) where you would buy those shoes.

Remember, organic doesn't have to mean non-commercial. In fact, if I search for best buy, the first organic result is bestbuy.com

orijing··on Suddenly, Hacker News is not the first result for 'Hacker News'
If that were truly their goal, their ads would never be the useful, because if they were the best results, they would be duplicates of the organic search results (hence useless). Or, if they weren't the best results, then the best results are in the organic search.

Clearly that's not the case, as advertising makes 99% of their revenues.

orijing··on Joel Spolsky On Tech Hiring: Beware the Exploding Offer
Yes. Google starts around this time, and Facebook starts even earlier. When I was in my Junior year I interviewed and got my offer from Facebook when it was still September. In contrast, Google didn't get back to me until November or so.

If you want them to hurry it up, you just need to mention your existing offers. In my Senior year, I was able to get Google to complete the entire interview-interview-offer process within a week and half, before the first week of October, because I had a Facebook deadline.

So the best bet is to interview early so you can use that as a negotiating stick for getting other companies.

orijing··on Joel Spolsky On Tech Hiring: Beware the Exploding Offer
I understand that we (on Hacker News) tend to come from a startup perspective, so it makes sense where you're coming from. But in the context that Joel was describing, that's not a valid comparison. Surely Joel isn't recommending dropping a startup of one founder using this tactic (it would be better to say no early). He specifically mentioned Microsoft as an example.

If you as an individual got your offer rescinded at the last minute, that's a detriment to your career because you don't have time to make it up. If on the other hand you had 1/1000th of your offer rescinded at the last minute because you didn't give the other party a chance to consider other candidates ("give me an offer now" after the interview), well, sucks to be you but it's not so bad.

Similarly, if a startup that NEEDED one extra employee to fill a critical role suddenly lost that employee, that's an unfortunate tragedy. If on the other hand, Microsoft lost one college grad, that's just a rounding error.

I hope my explanation makes sense for why context is extremely important.

orijing··on Groupon falls below $20/share
I was surprised to find out that the cost to borrow shares (to short) was still so high. Doesn't that pretty much guarantee that the share price is somewhat above the "fair price"? The cost to borrow is like a tax. The price consumers pay is always above the equilibrium price, which is above the price the sellers get (30% below the buyer price).

What about derivatives? Are there calls and puts on Groupon?

orijing··on Show HN: tool for commodity traders, brokers and analysts.
Great tool! I know you probably won't do this, but I think it's important to be clear. How can you convince potential users that you won't front-run them? For example, before displaying the sentiments you run your own trades in anticipation of your customer's trades. Perhaps it'll be right 51% of the time, but that's enough of an edge with enough volume to make some serious money.
orijing··on Show HN: tool for commodity traders, brokers and analysts.
Thank you for only requiring the minimum set of permissions from my Facebook account. I hate it when I go to a website that uses Facebook Connect login button, but requires every single permission possible, when I just need an authentication system.
orijing··on How Facebook is ruining sharing
That's because it considers your account low-security until you enable two-factor authentication, which having a phone with SMS allows. The number isn't to fill out your profile, and has nothing to do with privacy settings. Facebook takes security very seriously, and it would be better for everyone's safety if everyone set up two-factor, just like having everyone around you vaccinated is better for you.
orijing··on Facebook Privacy: Site Confirms It Tracks You After You Leave
> Bejar acknowledged that Facebook could learn where specific members go on the Web when they are logged off by matching the unique PC and browser characteristics logged by both the session cookie and the browser cookie.

> He emphasized that Facebook makes it a point not to do this. " We've said that we don't do it, and we couldn't do it without some form of consent and disclosure," Bejar says.

A better title would be "Facebook /could/ track users via the Like widgets, but doesn't do it yet"

orijing··on Google is mapping your wi-fi access point and the opt-out options stinks
Coming up next: Hyper-local ad targeting that knows to-the-block your position. Current IP-address based targeting is not very accurate, but knowing where you are exactly by your router opens up another frontier of monetization potential.
← PreviousPage 3 of 15Next →