HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

osdiab

690 karma · joined December 27, 2012

submissionscomments
osdiab··on If San Francisco Is So Great, Why Is Everyone I Love Leaving?
To color it in with an anecdote as a 27 year old who grew up in the suburbs and spent the last 7-ish years of my life in city centers: my personal preference is just that I like the presence of other people.

I don’t feel bothered by lots of people walking around the streets, hearing their conversations, living in proximity to others; and I only feel marginally bothered by crowds and packed trains, definitely less than I enjoy the bustle.

In fact even if I don’t talk to a single person or enter a single establishment it just makes me feel energized to be around it. Bars are antisocial and I don’t go often, but even when I’m just walking past one on the way home, the atmosphere around them makes me feel happy (and you can be social at a reasonable volume with all the smokers and loiterers outside if that’s what you like).

There’s something deeply depressing to me about the American suburban life I grew up in: always deserted, copy-pasted strip malls; giant, humanless roads clogged with hurtling metal death traps; cul-de-sacs of strangers spending large fractions of their lives solitary in cars.

(I do acknowledge it can be different to some extent—the ethnic suburbs in LA are vibrant in pockets, for example—but even in the best cases they’re still pretty desolate to me.)

Where I came from in the Midwest, my life involved never talking to anybody within a 20 mile radius of my house except in business transactions, and only rarely even seeing my neighbors. As a child I didn’t mind, but after having lived differently there’s no way I’d choose to go back unless it’s prohibitively expensive to choose otherwise (which is, to my knowledge, a major driver of people moving out of cities into suburbs).

Separately, I personally dislike driving and greatly prefer public transportation. It’s far more comfortable (not much acceleration and far more space than a tiny car unless it’s rush hour), I don’t have to pay attention to anything except where I’m getting off, it’s super cheap, no risk of accidents or headaches from other drivers incompetence, I don’t have to ever find nor pay for parking, I don’t have to worry about the safety of my personal property, I don’t have to worry about my car breaking down out of nowhere, I can drink and not personally endanger myself, the list or positives is basically endless to me but I’ll stop there.

But that all said San Francisco isn’t that dense (in my opinion), has such glaring social issues, is ludicrously expensive and doesn’t have particularly good infrastructure/transit. Given that I can get all of those things automatically by living in pretty much any major east Asian or European city, that’s my preference, but the one and only thing drawing me back is the concentration of jobs and money.

I weaned myself off San Francisco and lived in east Asia for a couple years, but I found myself back now for a job. Hopefully not too long from now I’ll be able to head back over, or at least work remote for a significant part of my time.

osdiab··on Ask HN: What’s your plan in 2019?
I think it’s not necessarily in contrast - what works for you may vary but I think that’s only the case when the time and energy it takes to make a decision isn’t part of your calculus. It’s good to be conscientious when you’re making decisions, especially weighty ones, so long as you don’t get stuck in a loop making that decision, which itself has a cost in your quality of life.
osdiab··on K-Cup creator John Sylvan regrets inventing Keurig coffee pod system
Although they're not easily repairable, they remain usable so much longer than competition. Not sure if this source is accurate, but I've heard the statistic that 63% of iPhones ever made are still being used [1], which I'm pretty sure you can't say about Android phones.

Also, my personal experience with Apple stuff is that it lasts quite long; for example, I used my last Macbook Pro for around 6 years, and even then it was still working just fine, I just wanted TouchID when I upgraded it. On the other hand, my dad, on Asus/Lenovo/Dell machines, has replaced his laptop 3 times in the same period.

Not to mention all the other people talking about just how small a slice of consumers actually do properly salvage and repair their stuff. I'd assume a tiny, tiny percent of sophisticated consumers actually do, while the vast majority don't go to much lengths to repair or properly dispose of their electronics.

I like repairability for myself because I am capable of DIY fixing things. But I don't assume that companies that do it do so because they're somehow more environmentally conscious, when probably plenty of other practices they do are extremely environmentally destructive.

[1] https://newzoo.com/insights/articles/63-percent-of-all-iphon...

osdiab··on Jack Ma: US wasted trillions on warfare instead of investing in infrastructure
Curious—have you ever actually been to China? Those exist, but a lot of the infrastructure is used a hell of a lot more than most American infrastructure, where passenger trains are so crappy nobody rides them except in a handful of cities, and vast, usually empty roads are covered in potholes.
osdiab··on Why Are We Still So Fat?
Totally anecdotal, and I wasn't obese but only marginally overweight; but when I was in the USA, I couldn't seem to get any lighter than 165-170 pounds even when trying to diet and exercise heavily (like 3-4 times a week of strenuous exercise for 1-2 hours minimum, and keeping track of all the food I was eating); but then when I lived in Japan for a few months (probably one of the skinniest countries in the world), I didn't even try to diet and I lost 15 pounds (now I'm at 150 lbs).

Lifestyle is clearly a big influence here. My understanding is that generally speaking foods are not sweetened as much there, portions are smaller, and people walk a hell of a lot more. I've also heard that the quality of ingredients in general tends to be higher across the board.

The cheap food, which I ate a whole lot of, aren't even something I could consider "healthy"—lots of fried food like tempura and kara-age, along with lots of noodles—but even without restraint eating those, I still ended up losing weight without trying. Interestingly I think my diet got a lot higher in carbohydrate intake and my protein intake shrank. Probably some amount of my weight loss involved muscle loss, but my belly shrank considerably as well, so I don't think it was exclusively that.

I think I just gradually got used to eating less, stimulating myself with sugar less frequently and intensely (omg, even diet soft drinks and gum are so powerfully sweet), and being more active, and now that I'm back I realize just how much of a premium I have to pay to not get huge portions of food completely saturated with fat and sugar.

osdiab··on Yelp craters 30% as advertisers abandon the site
I wonder if there’s a way to get the quality of reviews and rankings from Tabelog in the USA - for those who don’t know its the Japanese equivalent service and diners are so critical that most restaurants have 3 stars, 3.5 is an exceptionally good one and 4 and up generally have Michelin stars; I’ve never been disappointed by a decently rated restaurant on it.

The magic sauce for them might be cultural; though there’s definitely room for a better (probably nonlinear) type of reviewing system in the market given how bad quality Yelp reviews are in comparison.

osdiab··on Spectre.css – A Lightweight, Responsive and Modern CSS Framework
I don’t really think of preprocessors the same way as something like this library or bootstrap, that provide specific prebaked components and layouts
osdiab··on Spectre.css – A Lightweight, Responsive and Modern CSS Framework
The more web development I’ve done the more I’ve swung back to just writing CSS myself rather than depending on CSS frameworks; I’ve ended up seeing these less as ways to accelerate development for a team that is skilled at frontend, but instead as a way for people who don’t like styling or have little experience in frontend development/low design sense to style things reasonably.

But I keep seeing frontend frameworks on HN - am I/teams like mine that include at least one person fluent enough in CSS to write reasonable style sheets/styled components, just not the target audience? Or do other experienced frontend devs swear by UI frameworks like these for reasons I haven’t grasped yet? If so, why?

osdiab··on We Regulate the Wrong Things
Cities don't have to be loud. My neighborhood in Tokyo is the one of the quietest I've ever lived in but minutes from places that are denser than literally anywhere in the United States. Not having giant streets, as well as nuisance zoning [1] pretty much solves that problem.

[1] http://urbankchoze.blogspot.com/2014/04/japanese-zoning.html

osdiab··on Problems with infinite scroll
The thing I dislike about infinite scroll is that almost everything that has it is intended to make you addicted and compulsively scroll more, to the point where I pretty much have sworn off any app that makes it a central part of the experience.
osdiab··on Ask HN: Best Self Hosted Comment System?
It looks like the comments aren’t showing up properly when I’m on Safari on iOS in the blog post :P

http://imgur.com/kFPTMaC

osdiab··on Ask HN: Best Self Hosted Comment System?
Yes! If it’s something that I can host as cloud functions or something that would be even cooler :) I’d contribute.
osdiab··on Why Public Transportation Works Better Outside the U.S
Except it's on fire really frequently—track fires caused by garbage are a fairly common cause of NYC subway delays.

NYC is also riddled with inefficiency and corruption that bloats the price of everything they build, which create and exacerbate those budget constraints. Costs per mile of new track and maintenance are consistently an order of magnitude or more higher in NYC than in other parts of the world, with higher rates of encountering problems; this may be partially due to the complexity of building there, but given that fantastically busy and complex cities throughout the world don't have these same problems, I'm much quicker to blame it on the political and economic system (which, tangentially, is why I think stuff like Musk's Boring Company are targeting the wrong issue when it comes to urban development, unless he's just trying to use that as a trojan horse for municipal influence).

It's odd to see that such an extravagantly lucrative city can't seem to put together the money to maintain a core part of its infrastructure, that much much much poorer cities are able to achieve in other parts of the world.

osdiab··on Why Public Transportation Works Better Outside the U.S
An addendum: crime isn't just a law enforcement problem, it's reflective of broader societal ills like wealth inequality, poor education, and lack of access to opportunity. In my opinion, law enforcement is a bandaid for those symptoms, but does not strike at the underlying issues, and defining crime and poverty as that domain is also probably counterproductive to reducing them long term.

My experience in most of East Asia is that the police are extremely unintimidating [1] when you see them but generally invisible otherwise, perhaps indicating that strong law enforcement is not a requirement for managing crime rates.

[1] Tokyo: https://imgur.com/a/FGstZJ3

osdiab··on Why Public Transportation Works Better Outside the U.S
^^ key point, I'm glad to see it came from you actually! I'd add that it's rare to see well-used transit systems where stations end up being hotbeds of crime; it's mostly the poorly designed and barely utilized ones where that becomes the case.

For example, where I grew up, Cleveland, the stations definitely have a pretty grungy vibe, but I'd attribute that largely to the fact that RTA is super slow and infrequent, there are so few lines for such a large geographical mass that you can't do most trips with RTA, and many of the stations dump you in pretty unwalkable, economically dead neighborhoods. Even if you rode it somewhere, there's a very high probability you'd continue a journey on a bus for a crazy long amount of time or need a car to get you to your destination somehow. Even in the well-positioned spots like Ohio City, the station design dumps you next to a bridge on the opposite side of a crazy intersection with no crosswalk that takes like 5 minutes of walking through parking lots and past the garbage-smelling loading dock of the West Side Market to get to any of the businesses there. What a joke lol.

osdiab··on Why Public Transportation Works Better Outside the U.S
I think treating it as vital infrastructure is one way to get it to work properly (assuming federal, state, and local gov't can get their act together enough to do a good job of it), I don't know much about the historical precedent but I would imagine a lot of public systems in Europe work that way.

But private companies seem to have done a good job of making Tokyo's system work well (see my comments above about how since they own the land on stations, they have a huge incentive to make it painless to get to them and derive profit from that); I wonder if given the general ineffectiveness of American bureaucracy right now, if a private approach with the right incentives would be more politically feasible.

That all said, I think the article brings up plenty of good points about how transit has been hobbled in the USA, that aren't entirely attributable to the business vs infrastructure mindset.

osdiab··on Why Public Transportation Works Better Outside the U.S
I'm not knowledgable about this, but does New York MTA own/commercialize the land above their stations or just the tracks/right of way? I always felt like in NYC it was really odd how the stations are usually really tiny and don't really have any stores or vendors except those tiny convenience stores on the platforms, and a few really crappy looking shops sprinkled in big stations like Times Square. Stands in stark contrast to the ones in Tokyo where I'm living now, where the station malls are amongst the nicest and the vendors within the fare gates are plentiful, name-brand businesses (think stuff like Muji and Kinokuniya) and quality restaurants.

Is the Port Authority owned Oculus at WTC an exception to the rule, or am I misinterpreting how the MTA works?

If my understanding is correct that MTA doesn't own that land, then imagine how fast and efficiently they would have built the 2nd Av subway if they also knew they could funnel millions of people to whatever revenue machines they built on every station along the way.

osdiab··on Why Public Transportation Works Better Outside the U.S
The value of transit isn't the fact you rode on it, but the fact you get somewhere you want to go. Tokyo rail companies, and those of many other countries as well (Hong Kong comes to mind), also hold the ability to build shopping and apartments on the stations they build (if you've been, you've probably been to Atré, Lumine, Kirarina, Tokyu etc. station malls, and you've probably spent money in them), which more than reimburses the cost of the rail itself, because ultimately the point of riding a train is to get somewhere—and if the transit companies get the ability to own that "somewhere" themselves, it becomes immediately obvious how valuable transit is.

In the case of San Francisco, hopefully the State of California Bill AB 2923 [1] passes—that's one step in realizing this model of integrated transit, housing, and commercial development, that just makes sense.

[1] https://sf.curbed.com/2018/8/24/17778648/ab-2923-bart-housin...

osdiab··on Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers
I actually find Axios to be a pretty great news source. Lots of solid, insightful analysis on categorized topics delivered as regular newsletters that don’t take up all your time.
osdiab··on Slack Is Buying HipChat from Atlassian
I tried out Twist with my team and I loved it. Much easier to keep up with corporate communications—people tag you on the threads you absolutely should care about, for the rest you can skip entire conversations if they aren't relevant to you instead of sifting through a giant unorganized Slack channel. Searching works well. Idk how scripting bots for it goes but I never really cared for 99% of the bots people write for Slack so I never minded. Highly recommend.

In my current team that uses Slack, I just made it a policy that all conversations have to be in threads. If they're not I just flip a shit until people give up and make threads again lol. Most people don't care enough to retaliate, so that happened a few times and then everybody got used to the system; this is basically an approximation of Twist now (where the destructive behavior is super easy to commit... sigh)

osdiab··on Show HN: My personal website
pure art, this website lit AF
osdiab··on North American vs. Japanese zoning
In The SF Bay Area Sonja Trauss, SFYIMBY and friends actually did bring a lawsuit against the suburb of Lafayette for housing development. https://youtu.be/91g6N_JNnQE

They also established a legal agency for doing exactly that: https://www.carlaef.org/

I wonder if this kind of thing will happen more often for other urban policy related things!

osdiab··on Comparing City Street Orientations
While navigability of grids is nice, I kinda like it when cities have haphazard street layouts—older cities with chaotic street grids tend to be easier to walk around in (assuming you know where you're going) with slower traffic and smaller streets, not as loud since sound doesn't carry through all the buildings that block streets off (New York is loud almost everywhere, Tokyo has countless quiet neighborhoods seconds from even Shibuya Scramble), and as the author mentioned, instill a sense of adventure.

But maybe there's ways of getting these things while still maintaining street navigability—narrow streets with not necessarily rail straight, but still well-structured grids for the major streets, and maybe non-uniform/unstructred alleys could work to get both in one system.

osdiab··on Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buildings
I've always been surprised by how expensive Princeton is even though short drives in any direction can be much cheaper. Students seem to be mostly in student housing anyway, and anybody who lives there in any other capacity probably has a car, is it just prestige of being there that pumps up the rent?
osdiab··on Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buildings
China, HK, Singapore have a lot of copy paste buildings lined up next to each other, which I find pretty odd to look at and dehumanizing/alienating to be surrounded by (though probably very efficient to build, and it seems like Chinese people don't mind too much). You'd see them as soon as you left the airport if you visit there sometime.

I found many cities in China in particular look very similar to one another in a not great way because of similar architectural choices including copy paste buildings, which apparently the government has noticed—I can't find the article about it but the central government is making moves to get Chinese cities to stop being built in exactly the same way/destroy and replace too much of their historic buildings with culturally diverse architecture.

Not to say we shouldn't do what you're saying, but if we do it we should probably do it in a way that doesn't make all our cities too generic.

osdiab··on The Overprotected American Child
I wonder how much the built environment impacts the independence we can give our children. For instance, regarding the milestone of safely crossing the road that this article mentions, does the common milestone age decrease in more pedestrian-friendly places? It's one thing to cross a one-lane, slow-traffic narrow street in Europe versus a wide, high-speed one characteristic of most American suburbs.
osdiab··on Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook
Agreed, I've seen Scuttlebutt around but I can't help but feel that it will ever be mass market with that name.
osdiab··on Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook
Agreed, I've seen Scuttlebutt around but I can't help but feel that it will ever be mass market with that name.
osdiab··on Bike Share Oversupply in China
Really? I was using Mobike as a foreigner in China for a while and I don't recall them asking for a 身份证 or anything (did they ask for my passport number? I don't think they did), plus they have a pretty well-translated app and already operate in other English speaking markets including the USA and Singapore. For Mobike and Ofo they should be flush with enough money that the likelihood of them shutting down all of a sudden is relatively unlikely, but just in case when I left China I did get my deposit refunded fine.
osdiab··on Bike Share Oversupply in China
As well as having proper roads to bike them on, most of America has pretty lame bike infrastructure generally.

Separately, your 22-year-old probably steel-frame bike is probably built a lot better than the average cheap aluminum ones these days, and you've probably taken good enough care of it that it doesn't have a broken or badly bent frame. We're a wasteful people.

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →