HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

otikik

7,135 karma · joined March 19, 2013

submissionscomments
otikik··on A Eureka machine that thinks like nature and explores what AI cannot
Yeah, I was reminded of the Rockwell Retro Encabulator a little bit.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RXJKdh1KZ0w

otikik··on Earth is now heating up twice as fast as in previous decades
The comment added more probably
otikik··on The Companies Cutting Headcount for AI Will Lose to the Ones Who Didn't
That is a very convenient message for marketing and sales people. The fact that their whole job is crafting messages shouldn’t raise any eyebrows.
otikik··on Earth is now heating up twice as fast as in previous decades
> your burrito taxi

Which you are financing through a BNPL platform.

otikik··on Google officially announces that ads will be included in AI Mode search results
“Helpful to our short-term bottom line”
otikik··on Your Most Improbable Life
The Universe Doesn't Care.

Which might sound nihilistic / defeating.

It is not. In fact, it is great.

Imagine the pressure if there was actually a predefined path and you deviated from it. You would have disappointed the whole Cosmos!

Go an live the life that you can according to your desires and circumstances. You will not always succeed. Learn from your mistakes, move forward. Because one day, it will end. And the Universe will still not care.

otikik··on GitHub confirms breach of 3,800 repos via malicious VSCode extension
So I have been thinking about this for a while - if your product has "plugins" there's only two ways forward:

* There's a line of "blessed plugins" that your own company supports, maintains and guarantees, and everything else is considered "not trusted" or

* Plugins have explicit permissions - like phone apps do. "This plugin can make external calls/write to the filesystem inside a dedicated folder/read and set cookies". And then you are in charge of enforcing that with the strongest sandbox you can make.

Plugin ecosystems without these rules are just the wild west.

otikik··on It is time to give up the dualism introduced by the debate on consciousness
You are omitting the second part:

"but it would react exactly the way any conscious human would"

So the pain would be registered, and reacted to.

The only difference is in how the world "feel" is interpreted.

For Chalmers, the difference between a "zombie" and a "regular human", according to Chalmers, is that for the "zombie" is just "meat reacting to things". The "human" on the other hand is "meat somehow connected to something outside of the meat called consciousness that is the only thing that really feels".

I (and the author of the article) disagree. Consciousness can be "just meat". No need to add an "external thing".

otikik··on Gemini CLI will stop working from June 18, 2026
> It's great that gemini-cli is open-source, but that also comes with a bunch of ai-generated issues and pull-requests, which is sure to impede development

In a way, it is exciting to me that people exist that think like this. It is so different than how I think, we could be from different planets.

otikik··on Photo GIMP – A Patch for GIMP 3 for Photoshop Users
Why is this not called Pimp?
otikik··on It is time to give up the dualism introduced by the debate on consciousness
I am not denying the fact that you feel pain.

What I am denying is that there's anything metaphysical about the whole process.

The opponents of physicalism like Chalmers start from the axiom that consciousness is, in fact, separated from the physical world. Then they use the zombie to "demonstrate" (using circular logic, in my opinion) that physicalism is not possible.

I do believe that your (our) feelings, emotions, and our sense of self all emanate from the physical world. So in that sense "we are all the zombies that Chalmers talks about".

otikik··on It is time to give up the dualism introduced by the debate on consciousness
Serves me well for answering a comment before reading the article. This is basically what the author says, even pointing to the Philosophical zombie and all. Shame on me.
otikik··on It is time to give up the dualism introduced by the debate on consciousness
A philosophical zombie [1] is essentially a mobile, autonomous human body devoid of consciousness. Critically, still giving all of the external cues that it has in fact consciousness. It is supposed to prove that physicalism doesn't work. "The sense of consciousness" is used like a "soul, with extra steps".

In my humble opinion, which I have no way to prove or disprove, consciousness ("as a soul with extra steps") does not exist, and we are all philosophical zombies. Consciousness "as an amalgamation of complex biological signals and neural interactions that has evolved through millions of years as a successful survival strategy" does exist, and that is all that is needed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_zombie

otikik··on Xs of Y – roguelike that names itself every run. Written in 4kLoC
Found it a bit annoying having to press 'i' at the start in order to equip the dagger and armor that were on my backpack, but well done.
otikik··on The AI Backlash Could Get Ugly
My main problem is this:

- If (big If) AI actually replaces workers, then we have a problem, because lots of folk lost their jobs

- If AI doesn't replace workers, then we have a recession, because a lot of the US economy now sits on top of corporations betting on it. And this will tank the economy and lots of folk will lose their jobs

It feels that the only path forward is a narrow one where AI removes some jobs, but not too many, but still enough so that the (immense, disproportionate) hype that was put on it does not come with a vengeance and the house of cards falls.

otikik··on Bambu Lab is abusing the open source social contract
Yeah, I was considering getting into 3D printing and Bambu was one of the finalists. It's good to have one less brand to think about, makes it a bit easier to decide.
otikik··on The greatest shot in television: James burke had one chance to nail this scene (2024)
What do you do if you want to combine several sources with different aspect ratios? Surely black bars are acceptable in that case?
otikik··on Canadian fiddler sues Google after AI Overview claimed he was a sex offender
Well "to control" means two different things: "having the ability to modify or interrupt something" and "having the willingness to exert that ability".

OP says Google has the first. You are saying Google doesn't have the second. Both of you are right in that sense. You are wrong in the sense that the second doesn't matter much here.

If I remove my hands from the wheel of my car, while it would be technically true that I was not "driving" it from that point, if I run over some pedestrian they will counter, rightfully, that the vehicle was under my control the whole time.

otikik··on Cloudflare to cut about 20% of its workforce
Well that is not my experience. My first task as an intern, decades ago, was performing a useful task for the company that hired me. I did a mediocre job at it and it took me way longer than it would take one of the experienced engineers there, who would have done it better. That was expected because I was an intern.

With the tools available now, I would have been able to produce things of higher quality and faster, I don't deny that. But putting that code in production without an experienced developer reviewing it thoroughly would have been reckless. And they would have been the owners of that code, not me.

otikik··on Cloudflare to cut about 20% of its workforce
I was disagreeing with "they shouldn't be".

I think we should care that our engineers have put the effort to understand the code they are responsible to produce. I don't care specifically about how they get that knowledge (I am using AI to learn myself, for example). But I disagree with the implicit assumption on the statement, which is, in my view, "humans don't need to understand the code any more" (because some fresh out of university might think they understand, but they really don't).

otikik··on Cloudflare to cut about 20% of its workforce
> it produces absolutely stellar world-class code

I am using Claude Code with Opus 4.5 and I have to correct it every day. It produces working code but it makes mistakes. The code is more verbose than it should be, misunderstands/ignores edge cases, etc. Daily.

And I am not a stellar world-class programmer. I am pretty average. I just read what it produces.

otikik··on Cloudflare to cut about 20% of its workforce
Freshers certainly can give the appearance of taking ownership and shipping full stack features in a few weeks.

The problem is that "I copied the issue on claude code and then committed the code it produced" is not actually taking ownership.

> noone appreciates the years spent "googling and looking at stackoverflow" anymore, and frankly, they shouldn't be.

Well, I do, and I hard disagree with you there. If the human does not understand what the machine is producing, then I need a different human.

otikik··on Agents need control flow, not more prompts
I never tell claude to "go over this bunch of files and do this".

I tell it "write a program that goes over this bunch of files and do this".

Sometimes "do this" can be invoking another claude instance.

otikik··on Welcome to Hell Developer
Love the punchline
otikik··on Belgium stops decommissioning nuclear power plants
I was arguing about the fact that the number of deaths on the tsunami was relevant. I think you must have answered to the wrong thread.
otikik··on Belgium stops decommissioning nuclear power plants
> ~20,000 people died due to the Earthquake

> Irrelevant.

Well, that needs more nuance.

You have to understand that Japan is unusually well prepared for natural disasters. From earthquake resistant building codes, to alarm systems, education, to building, to earthquake refuges. I would venture to say that it is the most earhquake-prepared country in the world (although I have no proof of that point and I don't feel like looking for evidence on that it). Earthquakes that would have killed hundreds in other countries are footnotes in the news in Japan.

The earthquake alone was not enough to bring down Fukushima; the reactors shut down, as designed. The earthquake wasn't the direct cause of many deaths. It is difficult to estimate given the circumstances, but tens or maybe hundreds.

So in in that sense, yes, the earthquake is irrelevant.

However, after the earthquake, came the tsunami. That did shut down the Fukushima backup generators. No generators means no cooling, which means meltdown.

The tsunami also killed the most people. Now, why is this relevant?

Because the Japanese have had drills and tsunami education for decades. They have seawalls, strong buildings, and prepared infrastructure. The tsunami hit the least populated areas of the coast. In short, they were aware, trained and prepared, and they were not hit where most people live.

And still, ~15000+ died. That gives an idea of the magnitude of the event.

otikik··on Where the goblins came from
Caveman mode combined with goblin mode sounds like fun
otikik··on The Rich and Powerful Want to Live Forever. What If They Could?
Fair enough. Thank you for your work, I know it can be quite demanding to deal with people like this all the time.
otikik··on The Rich and Powerful Want to Live Forever. What If They Could?
It’s not “generic”. It refers to, like, 100 people or less.

There’s a comment down below that says “most young people would do it”. Why don’t you say anything to that person?

otikik··on The Rich and Powerful Want to Live Forever. What If They Could?
It is the simplest explanation. It is the conjeture that it feels any different that needs a proof.
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →