117 karma · joined March 9, 2016
You're right, but he also has a point in that eventually, if you just don't do things, the cops will drag you away. Eventual violence is a cornerstone of order in our society. I find this unpalatable, but at least another cornerstone of order is motivation to do good things.
Just as short timeouts are not solitary confinement, open-handed slaps on the butt are not gang beatings. It's generally the parent that determines whether the punishment is abusive, not the type of punishment itself.
Shit, maybe I'm an AI.
But generally commit messages, descriptive symbols, simple logic, short functions, and unit tests are better.
goal: "encourage better intellectual works"
means: "granting their creators temporary control of them"
There are other ways to meet that goal.
I think it's unfair to generalize from VLIW to everything published 20+ years ago. Plenty of the things discovered back then, or earlier, are still applicable and in production today. Your compiler picked most of its low hanging fruit ages ago. Lots of PhD theses are rehashing old ideas, often unknowingly. Results are results, what matters more is whether there's a relevant context, as you've highlighted.
This only works if you're facing away from your destination.
But I think Einstein would be a fan of web searches for a lot of memorizable information, as am I.