HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

oxag3n

547 karma · joined August 21, 2023

submissionscomments
oxag3n··on Programming Still Sucks
Great read. Got absorbed into few scenes. The scene with applauds played in my head as a silent movie with Charlie Chaplin presenting his perfect plans and crowd applauding unrealistically fast (due to under-cranking) with piano playing Super Mario theme in background.
oxag3n··on The bottleneck was never the code
It shares some ideas with Peter Naur "Programming as Theory Building".

Quote from the post article: "To quote Michael Polanyi: we know more than we can tell. Some load-bearing context exists precisely because it was never put into words, and writing it down would change what it is."

Imagine how much knowledge exists only in the heads of software engineers, with code being just a functioning footprint of that "Theory". I know SRE in FAANG who told me that multi-billion system is supported by tribal knowledge within their group, and for years, even pre-AI it was a protection against automation.

oxag3n··on Appearing productive in the workplace
If that happens globally where AGI and engineer replacement is "shipped" as a social construct, I'm afraid real software engineers (who can write and understand production ready systems) will be the vocal minority who can't do anything.
oxag3n··on Appearing productive in the workplace
Software Engineering seems to be quite unique to enable this due to few factors:

* Many software engineers didn't do real engineering work during their entire careers. In large companies it's even harder - you arrive as a small gear and are inserted into a large mechanism. You learn some configuration language some smart-ass invented to get a promo, "learn" the product by cleaning tons of those configs, refactoring them, "fixing" results in another bespoke framework by adjusting some knobs in the config language you are now expert in. Five years pass and you are still doing that.

* There are many near-engineering positions in the industry. The guy who always told how he liked to work with people and that's why stopped coding, another lady who always was fascinated by the product and working with users. They all fill in the space in small and large companies as .*M

* The train is slow moving, especially in large companies. Commit to prod can easily span months, with six months being a norm. For some large, critical systems, Agentic code still didn't reach the production as of today.

Considering above, AI is replacing some BS jobs, people who were near-code but above it suddenly enjoy vibe-coding, their shit still didn't hit the fan in slow moving companies. But oh man, it looks like a productivity boom.

oxag3n··on California farmers to destroy 420k peach trees following Del Monte bankruptcy
That's what happens when "family farms" rely on a large industrial complex and grow a mono-culture that doesn't have uses other than canning.

It was an easy, steady cash-positive business until it wasn't. If those farmers thought what is final product and who benefits from it most, they'd grow diversified crops to sell locally, which many California family farms do.

oxag3n··on Async Rust never left the MVP state
If you read documentation around Rust Async and Tokio, you'll find proper explanation why CPU intensive parts should not be part of async stack, how to use primitives efficiently (like std::sync::Mutex in async blocks), how to glue sync and async code.

A lot of code doesn't follow there guidelines because they don't care about efficiency and don't need it. But there are numerous projects who care about performance and efficiency, and realize the pitfalls once code runs in production (ScyllaDB is one example).

LLMs don't help as well, generating everything async up to the main, using wrong primitives and not properly designing the system.

oxag3n··on Agentic Coding Is a Trap
There's a subset of software engineers who understand most of the points from the article, but it looks more and more like this train can accelerate towards the cliff due to steam from burned money.

“The market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent” quote is usually applied to markets, but it can be applied to software engineering as well - all jobs can be gone even if world will be submerged into technological crisis, with single nine availability (and I'm talking about 9% :) ) and all accounts compromised.

oxag3n··on The 'Hidden' Costs of Great Abstractions
"Any problem in computer science can be solved with another layer of indirection, except of course for the problem of too many layers of indirection." Bjarne Stroustrup

That's why you see hundred level call stacks, polymorphism with a single implementation and still errors are hidden or root causes hidden behind "exception caught".

oxag3n··on Mercedes-Benz commits to bringing back physical buttons
More prevalent in luxury cars, although Japanese had their share of bad experiments as well. My 10yo Honda has all climate control buttons, but no volume knob, which is mitigated a bit by having volume button on the steering wheel.

IMO luxury manufacturers like MB and BMW tried to squeeze larger screens, more of them and there was not enough space to put those screens, buttins and vents. Some luxuty brands make vents supper slim.

oxag3n··on Cloudflare Issues for Anyone Else?
Can't login to dash.cloudflare.com as well.
oxag3n··on For the first time in history, more Americans are moving to EU than vice versa
My uncle moved from Germany to Portugal for the same reason. He loves it and the main pain point is healthcare - low-cost, but in his 70s he travels back to Germany for health issues due to quality. It's unpopular opinion in Portugal and everyone will tell you how nice the hospitals are, zero wait times and no hidden expenses. May be my uncle was unlucky, but minor heart issue wasn't properly diagnosed for about a year there, and required a single visit in Germany to get it under control.
oxag3n··on For the first time in history, more Americans are moving to EU than vice versa
Doesn't include another large group - repatriating Europeans.

Our friends went back to Germany last year after 20 years in USA (permanent residents, didn't naturalize).

My family plans similar move as well in a few years, mostly blocked by my postgraduate program and exact location to return to. There are other scenarios where we'd move right away, like if my spouse gets laid off.

oxag3n··on HERMES.md in commit messages causes requests to route to extra usage billing
“It’s not personal, Sonny. It’s strictly business.”
oxag3n··on To my students
Being part of academia while few family members faang-ish, I see comments to this post are amusingly resembling debates we have - I'm in for deep thinking, research and analysis with code being a product of your mental work, while family members with 10+ years in the industry are proud of not writing a single line of code and thinking Opus is just their new tool to be more productive. They can't answer one simple question though - why those corporations need them in this working setup. It's a hard one because my family well-being depends on it and it doesn't look good.
oxag3n··on If more than 50% press blue, everyone survives. Red pressers always survive
Make it more balanced:

Blue: if >= 50% pressed, they survive, othervise die.

Red: random 50% survival chance, independent for every Red.

oxag3n··on An AI agent deleted our production database. The agent's confession is below
I did read it differently:

> The agent ran this command: ...

> No confirmation step. No "type DELETE to confirm."...

I thought the author expected the Agent to ask for confirmation before running this command.

oxag3n··on AI should elevate your thinking, not replace it
> split people into two nebulous groups

shows both groups using AI differently. Hard to continue reading the article that excludes your group entirely.

oxag3n··on An AI agent deleted our production database. The agent's confession is below
Why so many comments blame the author?

If AI is just a tool, just like a database console, would you blame user for entire database loss if he just tried to update a single row in a table?

oxag3n··on The West forgot how to make things, now it’s forgetting how to code
On the other hand articles mistakes (missing the, a or wrong the). So it'z not AI translated, but also not fully AI generated...
oxag3n··on Meta tells staff it will cut 10% of jobs
Well, they could layoff 100% and world would be a better place to live.

It really sucks for software engineers though - first these companies made a hype out of "coding" and hacking to build those monstrosities, now they switched to squeezing the accordion to keep the music going. This is not the first time and I hope not the last one - just need new Yahoos of 20s to pop up.

oxag3n··on I am building a cloud
Comparing laptop SSD to cloud network drive is misleading.

EC2 provides the *d VMs that have SSDs with high IOPS at much lower cost than network SSDs. They are ephemeral, but so is laptop and its SSD - it can loose the data. From AWS docs "If you stop, hibernate, or terminate an instance, data on instance store volumes is lost.".

oxag3n··on Alberta startup sells no-tech tractors for half price
I was stating current state of affairs. I don't think the point is only about avoiding tracking and personal data harvesting. My 10 years old Honda has emergency breaking and lane assist and it's not connected to the internet, nor I'm servicing it at the dealership to be concerned about data harvesting. I still couldn't enable the system after replacing broken windshield - I had to get it to the dealership so they could re-enable the safety system.
oxag3n··on Alberta startup sells no-tech tractors for half price
Modern cars evolved in terms of safety, this includes active safety too. All the safety features require OEM hardware/software that locks you in, for example replacing windshield in many models requires dealership calibration.

And with all the distracted drivers looking into their phones while driving, I want more and more cars to get at least emergency breaking systems.

oxag3n··on A. J. Ayer – ‘What I Saw When I Was Dead’ (1988)
His conclusion is based on anecdotal evidence from his French friend's mother: "This experience could well have been delusive. A slight indication that it might have been veridical [objectively real] has been supplied by my French friend, or rather by her mother, who also underwent a heart arrest many years ago. When her daughter asked her what it had been like, she replied that all that she remembered was that she must stay close to the red light."

A "slight indication", which if I read correctly leads to "slightly weakened my conviction that my genuine death...". Isn't this kind of reasoning common for metaphysics but is met with skepticism by empiricists?

oxag3n··on A. J. Ayer – ‘What I Saw When I Was Dead’ (1988)
Being familiar with Ayer from his Epistemology works, this writeup was unexpected. How could an empiricist write "My recent experiences have slightly weakened my conviction that my genuine death, which is due fairly soon, will be the end of me". It also directly contradicted his stance about metaphycal claims.
oxag3n··on Vercel April 2026 security incident
> incident response provider

So they use third-party for incident management? They are de-risking by spending more, which is a loose-loose for the customers.

oxag3n··on We gave an AI a 3 year retail lease and asked it to make a profit
Did it actually open? A few bloggers came for opening, came back afternoon, even talked to AI over phone and email, and nothing except hallucinated replies. The store exists, but employee didn't show up to open it.
oxag3n··on The future of everything is lies, I guess: Where do we go from here?
The "Stop" part should have been expanded.

AI doesn't get most value from someone just using it, here's my personal take on what should we stop doing starting with the most impactful:

* Cut the low entropy sources, this includes open source, articles (yes, like the one above will feed the machine), thoughtful feedback (the one that generates "you are absolutely right" BS).

* Cheer the slope. After some time fighting slope in my circles, I found it's counter-productive because it wastes my resources while (sometimes) contributes to slope creators. Few months ago it started as a joke, because I thought the problem was too obvious, but instead the sloper launched a CRM-like app for local office with client side authentication, in-memory (with no persistence) backend storage. He was rewarded something at the local meeting. More stories we have like this - the better.

* Use AI to reply, review or interact wit slope in any way. Make it AI-only reply by prompting something without any useful information. One example was an email, pages and pages of generated text, asking me to collect some data and send it back. The prompt was "You are {X} and got this email, write a reply".

oxag3n··on Backpacks got worse on purpose
It is difficult and requires time investment.

I often searched BIFL sub-reddit to find things quality things and it did fail me in the past. After years of broken dishware created a weird collection, I followed the BIFL advice and bought Corelle glass dishes. Only three years later of daily heavy use and dishwasher all the dishes have degraded edge, which looks and feels just like chipped glass.

Looking through specialized forums helps sometimes, but then you are looking at Hermès dishware and doubting what are you paying for - quality or art.

oxag3n··on Claude Code Routines
It's "promptramming".
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →