HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

p-christ

401 karma · joined May 23, 2022

submissionscomments
p-christ··on Learn Exponentially
I find the Anki shared decks are basically not high quality enough. Do you ever use them? Which ones do you use?
p-christ··on Learn Exponentially
Anki public decks are usually too low quality to be useful unfortunately
p-christ··on Learn Exponentially
I completely agree. We’ve started building that on Save All and will be going more in that direction in future.

The Anki public decks are usually too low quality to be useful unfortunately

p-christ··on Learn Exponentially
what did you think of the article?
p-christ··on Learn Exponentially
lol thanks!
p-christ··on Learn Exponentially
We wrote this at Save All (https://saveall.ai/) and want to know what you think - tell us why it's wrong / right
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
It is partly paid already, you can pay for faster life generation in the quiz. We're almost profitable & very well funded so we aren't going to be shutting down. If we ever did shutdown we would automatically export everyone's cards and send them to you, we also will probably be adding in an export feature for you to do that yourself early next year.
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
I’m not sure what you mean. I agree that learning often requires things like applications and exercises, where did I imply otherwise?

I’m saying the reason why applications and exercises are useful are that they lead to a change in your memory. Not that they aren’t useful.

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Why? I almost didn’t include a link so am interested to hear your answer
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
You review the AIs suggestions which itself is a form of encoding (that is arguably more powerful than the encoding you describe)
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Ok but the point stands that there is a limit to your working memory. Your limit sounds a lot higher than most peoples but it is still limited otherwise you’d never get lost even if you could only read things once.
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Ok how about this more difficult experiment to prove the hypothesis:

I'm going to send you a wikipedia page written in chinese. You're going to read it once. For every chinese word you're allowed to look up the meaning on google translate once as you read. You're not allowed to do any other form of learning besides reading.

Do you think in this case you'd also not get "lost"?

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Maybe you already know quite a lot about physics? Or maybe you have an unusually large working memory and didn't go far enough down the wikipedia hole until you got lost?

The working memory limit explained in the article must apply to you unless you have some sort of a very special form of photographic memory

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
> Writing is important because with it we can overcome our natural memory limitations.

Very interesting. Is the theory here that by writing things out on a page we are then able to manipulate the ideas in our head without the usual limits of our working memory? Working memory is still limited but because all the information is so nearby and within view we can quickly put things in and out of our working memory so its limit doesn't impede us as much?

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Spaced repetition is not the topic. The topic is memory and there are many solutions to trying to remember more, spaced repetition is just one of them. There's also things like elaboration, dual coding, mnemonics, memory palaces etc.
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
> There are definitely differences in how various minds work

Yes, but we still all learn in roughly the same way. The differences aren't big enough.

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Not sure about the relative importance, but save all also has active recall & interleaving. The encoding happens when you first learn something & create a card, and the active recall, spaced repetition & interleaving happens later when you review cards.
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
not sure you read the article
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Understanding is just knowledge of how or why something works
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Learning styles are a myth https://www.techlearning.com/news/busting-the-myth-of-learni...
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
> You have a preference of how you learn, no? It's not a myth if there's perennial truth to it.

I might have an emotional preference but there's no good evidence that different people learn better in very different ways

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
I think it feels different because that knowledge is more deeply ingrained with what you already know. That knowledge has many connections and relationships with other knowledge you have. Whereas the name of a function is more like a leaf node, it isn't connected to very much and i think this is the source of the different feelings you describe.

To expand on this a bit - our memories maintain "schemas" of knowledge and whenever we learn something new it gets slotted into our "schema". The better something fits into our schema the easier it is to remember. I think if you googled schemas you'll be able to find more material on this

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
> Have you seen any SaaS or consumer products that focus on "how to learn?" and "digesting information" aspect?

Yes Save All helps with that in a way

https://saveall.ai/

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
yes exactly
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
I didn't mention it in the article because the article is hosted on the same domain (with a link to it at very top of page) so thought it was quite obvious.

Also I wanted it to stand alone as an essay to see what people thought. If i linked to the product within the article it would turn the whole article into an advert rather than an essay

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
why does that make it the worst possible example?
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
i wish school taught me how to learn instead of me having to wait until i was 25 and doing a free coursera course
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
i had not seen this before, thank you very much for sharing!
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
thanks. and yeah the domain didn't change
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Yeah it needs to help you do better "encoding". This is what determines how sticky information is straight after learning it.

One way that Save All (a company i run that's like anki, https://saveall.ai/) helps you with encoding is that it suggests alternative ways that we can quiz you on a card you just made. This helps you engage with the card a bit more as you're making it which makes it more sticky.

Other than that a good way to also improve encoding is to link new knowledge to existing knowledge. Things like Roam help you do this with their backlinks

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →