HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

p-christ

401 karma · joined May 23, 2022

submissionscomments
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Please explain how you can understand something without remembering the information that the understanding is made up out of?
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Our subconcious mind often works on our problems while we aren't thinking about them, i that's more what's going on here than forgetting. your brain figured it out for you while you were doing something else
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Yeah some simplification is required to condense 300(0) years of research into a digestible article but is any of it misleadingly incorrect?
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
> eg. good teaching is not giving the final answers to learner, which should seem faster, but letting the learner arrive at their answers

Why is that "good" teaching? ---> Its because if they arrive at the answer themselves then both the answer & the process for figuring it out will be more ingrained in their long-term memory!

> Instead, learning the content rapidly (meanwhile forgetting a lot of the content), getting a whole picture, and gradually gain more understanding repeating the process using different textbooks/courses, is a much more faster way of learning.

I agree to an extent. It's inefficient to try and remember everything beyond a point. But spaced repetition is very efficient e.g. with Save All it might only take you 5 minutes to remember something for 10 years... so it is much more efficient than you think to try and remember more things.

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
yeah mental arithmetic and running out of swap space is such a relevant / good example of the phenomenon, might add that into the article
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
yep that's the one! good old ebbinghaus
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
> every time you recall something your brain changes in ways that can affect recall later?

Yeah that phenomenon is called "proactive & retroactive interference".

> For me, it seems like there's a sweet spot to remembering enough to know the concept and then relying on the internet to fill in the details as needed.

I think i agree with you to an extent. For example, there is no point memorising all the digits of pie so that you can use it when programming, it's much more efficient to just remember what pie is at a vaguer higher level than to put the energy into memorising all its digits.

But i would say that most people go too far the other way and only remember less than the efficient amount.

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Are you saying we should mention it for our own business benefit? Or that it's bad to not state it in article for some other reason?
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
If you don't understand it then you don't remember the information that compromises an "understanding" of the thing
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Learning styles are basically a myth actually. It's been shown we all learn in roughly the same way. Check out some of the research mentioned here

https://www.techlearning.com/news/busting-the-myth-of-learni...

> People would have written books about learning that glorified this concept.

There are lots of books on it actually. Make It Stick is my favourite book on this, you should try it!

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
yes! i think that's completely right, it takes so much energy & working memory to adapt to feedback that it's really easy to over-instruct people and give them too much feedback to handle.
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Completely agree on Anki requiring too much effort, its the main reason why i'm making Save All (https://saveall.ai/). Save all is a simpler version of anki that use AI to try and make it less effortful
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
lol oh dear, sounds ominous
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
hmmm very interesting, not sure why that could be happening! I can see loads of people are reading it now but i would have thought our server (arranged on vercel) could handle it
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
yes that's me, how comes?
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
that's really interesting, can you explain this bit a bit more? Or let me know what to google to learn more about this?

"The process of simulating actions is the process that changes the structure of your mind"

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
in what way is the definition limited / what should it be?
p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
Even with programming I would argue you'd be a much better programmer if you can remember more. Obviously sometimes you're going to have to look things up but the more you remember the more problems you'll be able to solve.

Specifically you won't be able to solve a programming problem if the answer requires you combining over 4 things you don't have in your long-term memory (even if you can look them up). This is the main reason why Jeff Dean is a better programmer than me even though we both have access to google - he has more knowledge & experience of programming in his memory than me that means that even though we can both look things up he is able to solve way more problems than me.

Co-pilot slightly changes the type of thing that's valuable to remember, but it doesn't change the importance of remembering things. I think, as you implied, co-pilot probably makes remembering some types of syntax or boilerplate less important.

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
how you mean? this link doesn't load for you?

https://saveall.ai/blog/learning-is-remembering

p-christ··on Learning Is Remembering
I wrote this and would love to know what you think about it. Am particularly interested in hearing any reasons why it's wrong
p-christ··on Show HN: Never forget what you've learned
yeah, we thought it was important to let people try it as quick as possible from the landing page
p-christ··on Show HN: Never forget what you've learned
thanks for trying it out! Completely agree that generic content ==> nice flashcards is going to be big, we really think it's possible now with advances in NLP and we are going to do it.

And yeah the green words aren't very good for that Dolly example. It's ML based so its output is somewhat random but usually it produces green words that are much better than that so i think you were a bit unlucky with that example. All the data we collect on the clozes gets fed back into the algorithm so overtime it should become more consistent aswell!

p-christ··on Show HN: Never forget what you've learned
thanks for trying it out!

We use a similar spacing algorithm to Anki at the moment but eventually we will use a custom spacing algorithm per person & per card that uses machine learning to learn the optimum spacing algorithm per person & per card

Multiple choice questions are the least effective for memory but they help to keep people's motivation up and make the quizzing less taxing. We mixup the quizzes with multiple choice vs. type-in-the-answer so people are getting the right balance.

p-christ··on Extend your runway, cheap money is over
how much does this depend on the stage you're at? Pre-seed & seed funding should be pretty unaffected?
← PreviousPage 3 of 3