64 karma · joined May 3, 2024
I have commented further down, and I really think that, from a broader perspective, there is a great chance that there will be strong positive effects for consumers. I agree that there is a threat with attestation being used to lock out certain implementations. On the other hand, the technical details do not allow that because the IDs can be changed easily. Also, there is no attestation enforced for passkeys, and that should stay that way. But I agree with one concern: If Apple or Google wanted to achieve such things, they could, just because of their market dominance in browsers. However, I just do not see how that would make sense for them from an economic perspective.
For passkeys, we truly believe even if those options are weighed against each other, the benefits are weighing more. Big consumer-facing platforms have huge problems securing accounts for users. If you force them to use classic MFA (SMS or TOTP), the usage drops and recovery/fallback processes skyrocket. They don't want MFA. Risk-based MFA can help but is not perfect as attacks get more precise.
So we think the adoption will be faster than browser developers can get around fixing all of the issues, because once a standard is adopted, it gets more and more difficult to streamline things. But we are looking forward to it.
Of course, we see it that way, because we are building a company around it, but I have been battling against account takeover for years and took great pride in trying to protect the data as a developer, our users entrusted us. So I see a real chance here to improve security in the consumer market.
OIDC implementations for consumers are often not good enough; we have seen other companies promote them for Passkeys. We think that can be suitable for B2B-Auth but not for B2C