2,251 karma · joined September 11, 2011
I'm not asking anyone to believe that zero card readers are broken. I'm only saying I never experienced a broken one, and never experiencing a broken one isn't that weird because the failure rate is low.
Someone saying that 80% of the time the reader is broken is making an extremely different type of claim, not really even comparable with my analogous claim of not ever experiencing a broken one. While my experience might also differ from average, it is orders of magnitude closer to average than someone happening to experience a broken one 80% of the time.
I'm not sure what to say about the bags comment. Every time I've ever gotten a cab to or from any airport anywhere, from Boston to Hong Kong, the driver helped me with bags if I had them. And all the other drivers helped all the other people in line too.
Maybe you're referring to the fact that I always experienced them coming early -- yes this could be highly variable. My anecdotes are probably no more valuable than others here on that point, mostly because nobody here extended the outrageously extreme claims they made (80% card reader failure, effectively zero clean taxis ever) into the topic of how late taxis are, though they might have (e.g. someone possibly saying another statistically unbelievable thing like 'taxis are always 30 minutes late' or '90% of the time they don't even show up' or something).
Keep in mind that being early only applied to taxis I scheduled from home to the airport. I never called ahead to arrange a taxi except when going to the airport, so those are the only ones which could have possibly been early or late.
The majority of cabs I ever took were cabs I just hailed on the street or at a taxi stand.
I only mention it because I believe you are replying to comments below, but by making replies to an earlier comment instead of the actual comment you are replying to -- and sometimes this is why.
I've definitely done that before, and thought perhaps it was a reply limit from HN or something (which can happen).
> I don't make it a habit of calling a person a liar with no verifiable proof to the contrary.
This is an unfair mischaracterization of what I've said.
If someone makes an extraordinary claim and has no evidence, you probably shouldn't just believe it. Choosing not to believe it based on a reasonable statistical premise (e.g. the failure rate of card readers is not high enough such that 80% of them are always broken) is perfectly valid, and is not impolite or rude. It's not at all the same thing as "calling them a liar." The burden of proof is on the party making extraordinary claims.
Is it your opinion, or the consensus opinion of your connections, that 80% of the time the card reader is broken, or that the percentage of taxis which are clean is near 0 (or some other claim similar to these)?
If you're not making claims of that extremity, then whatever you are talking about isn't very related to what anyone else here has said, and depending on the specifics, I may even agree with you, but it wouldn't be relevant to a thread where the primary claim that started the disussion is that taxi service is overwhelmingly always unbelievably bad.
If you are making claims of that extremity, then I don't believe them, and feel that disbelieving them is simply a matter of the claims being too much of an outlier to deserve any serious plausibility.
The comment in which it was said is here: < https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12191938 >.
I am comparing whatever anecdotes (yours and others) that are supposedly backed up by lots of people you know, with this.
While the people you know might have had some bad experiences sometimes, I wouldn't believe they were anywhere near the claims going on in this thread.
If your connections reported occasional bad experiences with taxis, who would care? It couldn't possibly be relevant to a thread where the entire context of the thread is that people are saying that all Boston taxis are almost always awful and almost always have broken card readers, etc.
I'm not sure how to explain it. I'm trying to say that the connections whose informal opinions you cite as backup couldn't possibly have said something as extreme as what the other people of this thread are saying -- in which case whatever minor and totally expected occasional complaints your sources have had, they aren't relevant.
The claims made in the thread were that something like 80% of taxis in Boston have defective card readers, and that literally only a single taxi used was clean (the rest were not of acceptable cleanliness).
These are ridiculous, exceptional claims that should be completely disregarded without evidence. When I said so, adding that my experience has been that taxis are just perfectly normal cars with functional parts, everyone tries to take my head off for it.
I even freely admitted many of the benefits to Uber you already pointed out.
Nowhere did I ever claim that taxis are better than Uber, nor that anyone should avoid Uber, nor that they should use taxis. I even stopped to reiterate that several times.
I only said that the outrageous, over-the-top degree to which people were describing the poor condition and service of taxis, in Boston, was flat out wrong and hyperbolic. That's all! Even if taxis are clean and have functioning card readers (they are and they do), someone may still feel Uber, or whatever other service, is a better value. That's 100% consistent with everything I've said in this thread.
Yet your response is basically a straw man setting it up as if I claimed that taxis were superior to other ride sharing services, or that my claims about taxis just being pretty normal cars with working parts is somehow a claim of their superiority over Uber? I really don't know why you're inferring that into what I am saying, but it's not related.
It may indeed be rude for me to directly point it out, but given the way others are treating me in the thread, I won't lose any sleep over it. I don't think I'm making cutting remarks, only remarks that are consistent with basic, universal experiences, not just of me, but everywhere.
Others seem to seek to take these basic, universal experiences and try to claim they aren't universal, and that instead their experiences of crazy statistical outlier events (e.g. zero clean taxis ever) somehow are the common and universal experiences, and that I am being presumptuous or rude for disbelieving that they actually experienced some exceedingly rare event that shouldn't be believed.
It's completely unreasonable to believe that saying 80% of card readers are broken and there are zero clean taxis deserves to be compared in the same breath as a claim like almost every time I rode in a taxi it was just a normal functioning car and nothing stood out as functionally broken or meaningfully substandard in quality.
The two things are not the same kind of claim, even categorically, no matter how much people in the thread don't like it.
When I lived in urban Boston, and I would go for long runs on the street and through parks, or I would use a rental car to go out to the Middlesex Fells for geocaching, it was like a poor bastardization of what I needed. There were always people around. I could not get into a meditative mood and access any of the cognitively rejuvenating effects that the activities were for.
It saddens me very much that human culture is moving to agglomerative cities, because I believe I am personally extremely maladapted to be able to handle that, so I constantly feel like I'm being squeezed and stressed, even just by my ambient environment, even on a pleasant sunny day when I just take a walk to relax.
It's a very maddening way to live, but I have not found any solution that would let me live with a better compromise that allows me to have private access to nature on my own property and still successfully interface with the industries I work in.
Reporting these noise violations never did anything. The police showed up, asked people to stop, they stopped for 30 minutes then just started up again.
After months and months of this at two totally different apartments, I finally just stopped reporting the egregious noise violations, because what's the use? Probably some disruptively loud neighbor started thinking what you thought -- that if no one is actively complaining then it must be OK, when really it was just worse: the mechanism of complaining doesn't actually help solve the problem so it's of no use.
It's especially bad in older buildings that have been converted into apartments -- which represents a lot of the inventory in Cambridge and Somerville.
Edit: Forgot to add -- city construction noise is also a huge problem, and most cities have specific laws about how much noise construction crews can make and at what times. Inside the permitted limits (even if the limits are actually unreasonable from a human health and well-being point of view) you have no recourse of any kind.
For instance, I usually go on very long runs on Friday nights -- it's one of my weekly exercise and meditation habits. So I tend to sleep in on Saturdays to let my body recover. Being woken up by jackhammers at 9 am on every Saturday for an entire summer was a very miserable experience for me.
Dozens of your connections did not say that 80% of the time the card reader is broken, or that they have never traveled in a single clean taxi ever in their lives. These are patently ridiculous ideas being passed off as if they are in some way accurate portrayals of taxi services when they are just cartoonish fictions meant to inflame and cast Uber in an unrealistically positive light.
As I've said repeatedly, none of what I am saying is in any way a criticism of Uber, nor is it a suggestion that anyone should not use Uber if they want to.
All I am saying is that taxi rides are overwhelmingly normal and most everyone already knows this and accepts it and happily uses taxis plenty of the time, even if they also use Uber too.
The people here are trying to make it seem like I'm saying that taxis are made out of gold and you get a free Swedish massage while you ride. Hardly! I'm claiming that most credit card readers are functional and most taxis are fairly modern and clean -- these are not controversial, and to disagree with them is solely a symptom of unrealistic bias, and in this thread anyway seemingly also irrational hatred, towards the taxi business.
> But we're the "social engineering commenters" because we're rolling eyes at the idea that dealing with cabs is pleasant.
Yes! Rolling one's eyes at a plain and simple fact, like the simple fact that most taxi experiences are just normal, uneventful rides inside of cars, is derivative from Uber's attempts to social engineer against the culture of using taxis. I don't see why that would merit such a sardonic and rude reply from you.
It is very telling that when a person describes his taxis experiences in a super boring, uncontroversial and simple manner: i.e. that the taxis are just normal cars with credit card readers and you should expect a perfectly normal experience if you get in one -- then everyone here acts like I'm giving some kind of gushing, outrageous praise to taxis, and acts indignant that I don't describe taxis as basically the car Fred Flintstone drove but with killer bees inside.
It's crazy that people are so adamant to do social engineering for Uber that they won't even agree to entirely uncontroversial claims, like most taxis in Boston are clean or have functioning card readers -- things which are indisputably accurate.
I'm not saying you should dislike Uber. I'm not saying you should ride in a taxi. I'm not saying the taxi services are perfect. I'm not saying there are zero bad taxi experiences.
I'm only saying that most taxi experiences in Boston are perfectly uneventful, normal rides that completely meet the expectation of the riders, and don't suffer from the hyperbolic criticisms here.
Also, there is no singular reputation that represents all taxi services. Your idea that all taxi services have a bad reputation only further makes your argument unbelievable. A mom & pop business operating a few taxis in a small suburb is way different than a highly regulated city taxi service competing for medallions. Taxis in some cities are always good, while in other cities they are always bad. Taxis in some countries aren't regulated well enough, making them unsafe, but then in others they are regulated and safe.
"The taxi industry" is (mostly) just a fiction that Uber enthusiasts make up. It certainly is when it comes to taxi service reputations, which vary locally.
These responses aren't reporting average case experiences with level headed analysis.
They are just one-sidedly saying everything is bad about taxis, including "corruption" even, and how thankful they are Uber "disrupted" them, etc.
It all reads very much like paid social engineering by Uber. I'm sure that's not it, and they are just strong fans defending a company they like.
But the fact that it's all written just like social engineering spam us a good indication that it's not describing realistic, average-case experiences of most taxi users.
The average-case taxi ride in Boston is quite good.
While I'm sorry that you have had such bad experiences, since your experiences differ so much from what is common, I don't feel people should base their expectations on what you say.
Instead, you can be nearly certain that it will be a clean, modern taxi, with a functioning card reader, that arrives on time and doesn't require a long wait.
To be fair to Uber, you still can expect taxis to cost more and you still have to watch out for drivers who spot a sucker and take you the long way for a larger fare.
Taxis aren't perfect. But taxis also are not rusted out death traps of lateness with serial killers for drivers and credit card readers that make you sexually barren, as apparently the army of Uber social engineering commenters wants us to believe.
The anecdote I described also matches the general experiences of all my friends and family as well, with occasional outliers (both good and bad), so I feel very confident in saying that an average case taxi ride anywhere in the Boston area involves a clean, modern taxi, polite driver, properly functioning credit card machine, a short wait (and no wait at all if you call the dispatcher ahead).
Yes, of course there is variance and sometimes people will have a worse experience. Those worse experiences are very rare, and the taxi services overall are very good the vast majority of the time.
I called ahead to have taxis pick me up for early morning rides to the airport, and they were always early and helped me with my bags. I took taxis over to the Boston College area when I was taking music lessons at a studio there. I took taxis home from sports events and concerts near Fenway. Even when coming out of a crowded show at House of Blues, it was a short wait for taxis.
I never once experienced a broken credit card machine. I once did ask a driver if they accepted credit cards, he said no, and I waited about 30 seconds for the next taxi to come by -- on a side street on the Somerville side of Porter Sq, so not even close to usual taxi spots.
Getting taxis in Boston is cheap, safe, and reliable, with pretty short wait times, easy to deal with dispatchers, drivers who show up on time, cars that are clean and 99.999% of the time have functioning credit card machines.
I honestly don't know what on earth you're talking about.
None of this is an argument against Uber anyway, because people use Uber for features that even good taxis don't have, including price reduction, better real-time tracking, an app interface, and other things. And Uber drivers certainly can do things worse than taxis -- such as simply fail to show up, treat you rudely during the ride, or try to make you exit the car in an inconvenient/unsafe spot of the street at your destination. Uber is not intrinsically better about this kind of thing than taxis.
But some things you absolutely cannot say, at least about taxis in the Boston area, are that they are anything but clean, safe, reliable, punctual, and able to take your credit card.
Are there any openings (that would sponsor a visa) in the Ireland office? I'd love to apply and think SIG could be a good fit, but I've just had no luck responding to the Stack Overflow ads from the Philly office.
The problem for me has not so much been any technical aspect of Haskell nor any technical benefits of Python or R. Instead, it has been sociological issues with the Haskell community.
I won't go into it too much, but the biggest one is that there is no cohesive way to understand what kind of progression of Haskell knowledge makes you "a beginner" or "intermediate" or "advanced" -- especially for the purposes of getting a job. You might have mastered all the basics from LYAH, and know monads inside and out, and then someone comes along and says you're totally a Haskell noob because you haven't used Template Haskell for 6 years, or you don't do everything with Monad transformers, or you don't have the API of some tool like Parsec committed to memory, or you don't use language extensions and LiquidHaskell to use the compiler as a proof system of the correctness of your code. In Haskell, you're always made to feel like you're constantly a fuck-up for not knowing the next great wrinkle of abstraction or the next great toolkit up the food chain.
No joke, I've experienced being called a Haskell "beginner" because I was not deeply familiar with LiquidHaskell. That's not a common opinion, but it gives you a sense of the variety. This stresses me out so much that I don't even bother applying to Haskell jobs anymore. I don't want to get an initial phone screen and then just be made to feel like I'm a dunce because I don't know how some category theory principle is embodied by phantom types or something. Yuck.
Getting Haskell jobs that will actually pay you according to your experience and ability to learn is very hard. Most places just don't want to hire people who aren't super experienced in Haskell, and they default to believing everyone is a beginner unless they wrote a math Ph.D. thesis on multiparameter type classes.
On the off chance that someone will talk to you, and they think "OK, this person has a bunch of years of data analysis in Python or R under their belt, and they know enough about Haskell to work pretty quickly with Monads and basic type classes ..." that means you are a junior engineer at best, and will be paid like it, even if your data analysis skill is very high or you're a very fast learner or you have an advanced degree or many years of experience.
I've never been able to figure out the impenetrable bubble around Haskell jobs, but this kind of culture of believing that about 99% of Haskellers are beginners and less than 1% are anything beyond a beginner is the biggest reason why I mostly gave up learning Haskell or searching for Haskell jobs.
It's funny because a lot of people argue functional programming is too much about elegance to be pragmatic, and they can "just get stuff done" with other tools. Then lots of functional programmer enthusiasts jump in and refute that (I believe correctly) but then turn around and only hire people if they jump through all of the unpragmatic too-much-elegance hoops. It's really vexing.
The trouble I find is that a lot of small-to-medium sized asset managers and hedge funds don't have very good technology practices in general, and are pretty far from sophisticated use of low-level Python. There are often a lot of political reasons why they cling to Excel/VBA, R, or MATLAB, and there's almost always some political battle happening between the people that want to rationalize the system to a proper software design, and people who just want to keep cranking on the hodge podge of existing tools.
I'd probably be fine with some trade-off regarding all of that, if the pay was acceptable and there was a strong commitment to a healthy work/life balance. But among finance firms this is extremely hard to find.
So even though I am not at all opposed to doing this work in finance, I still find the volume of acceptable job openings in that field to be too small to make it realistic.
This is not a controversial opinion, nor really even a swipe at anyone. It's just bad, bad, bad code inside of banks.
I remember talking to someone on the Athena team during a job interview there and they told me that they had to fill out paperwork and wait weeks for approval just to pip install a third-party package for a sandboxed and not-production-facing ad hoc data analysis task. I don't care what industry you're in, that's just taking bureaucracy way too far. I've worked in quant finance before in a highly regulated environment, and there was never the slightest worry that you couldn't just grab any third-party tool you needed to do your job. Getting into production would require a big process, sure, but not just grabbing pandas, say, and answering someone's quick ad hoc business question. In fact, this sort of thing also was never a problem in defense research either.
Anyway, I personally view the fact that the team who spun out of I believe Goldman originally to make the Athena/Quartz/etc stuff (I think now they are even infecting smaller banks like PNC with it too?), is easily one of the worst things that has happened to the world financially in the past 15 years. Sadly not hyperbole.
So unfortunately these types of options aren't likely a good match for the sort of work I am looking for.
I found that the particular combination of start-up environment and consulting was not a good fit for me, and I suspect I would feel the same about Enthought or other kinds of analytics consulting companies, so alas this is not an option for me.