HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pa7ch

706 karma · joined May 10, 2013

submissionscomments
pa7ch··on Tesla Cybertruck
I kind of love it. Seems to hit the mark on price, range, capability, size.

Would personally only want a van version, or possibly just the ability to take out the second seats and barrier. Would be great then for urban travel and camping.

Also would love to learn more about the engineering trade-offs in their exoskeleton structure over traditional frame on body designs.

pa7ch··on Grandmaster level in StarCraft II using multi-agent reinforcement learning
Its not clear all the actions they've taken to limit themselves to human input. Some players feel that the EPM (effective actions per minute) of AlphaStar is enormously higher then a human's during a battle. This is likened to a more advanced aimbot where it teaches human's nothing and has an unfair advantage. Alternatively, alpha go has advanced the state of human go playing without feeling like it cheats.

AlphaStar is impressive but I don't think AI has quite dominated the game of starcraft as convincingly as it has go.

pa7ch··on Go is Google's language, not ours
Many like Go because it is an opinionated language. I'm not sure that a 'community' run language will create something like that because there are too many opinions. Many claim to represent the community, but not the community that doesn't share their opinion. Without clear leaders I fear technical direction and taste will be about politics which seems more uncertain/risky.

I like that there is a tight cohesive group in control over Go and that they are largely the original designers. I might be more interested in alternative government structures and Google having too much control only if those original authors all stepped down.

pa7ch··on PureBoot, the High Security Boot Process
Maybe not the answer your looking for but any Chromebook has a fork of coreboot that I think follows upstream closely.

Chromebooks have been far ahead for awhile in boot security and chromeOS is becoming quite usable with its Linux container support.

pa7ch··on The money, job, marriage myth: are you happy yet?
Not everything he says is off base and he does present the basics of clinical psychology well. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy is an interesting field one can gain a lot from studying. However many things he talks or just hints at can be questional and neither his expertise nor fairly presented.

It helps his cause that many criticisms of him are terrible and involve many fabrications.

This youtube channel contra points is a much better criticism then mine: https://youtu.be/4LqZdkkBDas

pa7ch··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
I really like the upspin approach for federated self-hosting of userdata (for lack of a better term) in that it builds a platform for it that apps like nextcloud and others would build on top of.

I'm not saying its the right solution, but I think trying to get the layers right to make self-hosting a wider and more reliable reality is only going to happen by building the right opensource platforms/components first.

pa7ch··on Passwords: Using 3 Random Words Is a Really Bad Idea (2017)
I just remember two strong passwords. My master password for my manager and my gmail password. My gmail can recover pretty much all my other passwords. Also I keep backup secrets for my gmail as well. This feels robust enough, but backing up my password manager might be wise too.
pa7ch··on Fact vs. Fiction: Truths from Inside the Shaolin Temple
Since I didn't exercise as much I focused on physical activities that require less commitment like hiking, rock climbing gyms, and the occasional yoga class.

I just found having a full time job made it hard to get in consistent workouts that weren't just showing up to a gym. I had a work schedule that was shifted late for commute reasons so I found it hard to hit class times consistently. If I didn't eat enough that day I could still go to a gym and do a light workout. If I messed up my eating schedule and had to go to a intense class, that just wouldn't work out since I couldn't eat too soon before class or go when I hadn't eaten enough.

I looked at jiu jitsu gyms since that's a consistent experience I enjoy and there are lots of gyms. Its pricing is kinda steep if your not committed to going a lot. I find that more traditional martial arts gyms really vary for me depending on the culture and instructor and haven't tried to shop around for those as much.

pa7ch··on Fact vs. Fiction: Truths from Inside the Shaolin Temple
Much of martial arts pedagogy is not about fighting ability.

I went to a very strenuous and traditional Tae Kwon Do school as a kid in a diverse semi low-income neighborhood. I had no delusions that it was teaching me how to fight well in MMA or a street fight. Situational awareness, lack of ego, and running are more important for self-defense anyway.

I got into great shape, became flexible, learned body awareness (forms are good at this), breathing, and it really helped me develop a lot as a person and forever recognize the importance of physical health and humbleness. It was a very welcoming family environment with people from all ages and ethnicity and everyone had so much respect for each other. I still visit my master when I see my parents and its such a blessing. I come back nearly 15 years later and it feels frozen in time in the best way. I'm a little sad to see MMA gyms take over, but I think this school was a rarity even when I grew up. My master spent his entire life doing Judo and TKD and had 30+ years of experience in each.

We sometimes practiced Tae Kwon Do the Sport. Its what you see in the Olympics. Its not about real fighting, its just a sport and a very small aspect of the rest of the training. The other bonus is you don't get CTE from practicing unlike MMA. (at more competitive levels knockouts do happen, but there is headgear and no head punching)

Nothing has made me sadder moving to the software industry then how I let it sever my connection to physical arts. I'm not blaming the industry, it was my own time management and habits. Now, I saved enough to take a year off doing cheap travel in the US and I plan to spend a few months going back to my home gym. I feel so grateful.

pa7ch··on Technology preview: Sealed sender for Signal
Generics in Go, even as proposed, would not be without some trade-offs in readability and orthogonality with interfaces. These are things Go currently excels at.

Its easy to imagine that adding an alternative UX in Signal for non-phone based contacts might complicate user flows. Creating a user-flow for alternative contact discovery without hurting the user experience for existing users I think is not simple and easy to underestimate.

Go and Signal both choose a set of trade-offs that consider both technical and human elements. I think this irks people that don't understand these trade-offs since the human side of trade-offs is harder to define or evaluate the importance of. Ergonomics plays a huge role in the ultimate value of Go and Signal to society.

pa7ch··on Ask HN: What open source project, in your opinion, has the highest code quality?
I particularly like reading code from Upspin (upspin.io). Its probably partially because I think the project design is interesting and write go. Regardless, its a great ground up Go project by some of the original Go authors and contributors.

Very well organized code and it feels like they got the project off the ground, fixed bugs for a few months, and now have largely trailed off from maintaining it largely because it just works (I use it) which lends some credibility to their coding style. Of course, I'd like to see the project evolve conceptually, but, right now it does what it says it does reliably for a project that hasn't even cut a single release.

pa7ch··on A response about dep and vgo
As a user of dep, glide, godep and avid reader of vgo technical docs I favor vgo's solution. I've been a professional Go developer a few years now.

The notion that this committee speaks for the community seems a weak one to me and I've seen my view mirrored with many of my peers. Its good they attempted such research but it seems like confirmation bias as dep just seemed like a re-write of glide with similar fundamentals and a improved user experience. This appeal to authority by the committee to represent the Go community seems unproductive and unnecessarily divisive/misleading.

I wasn't thrilled when I saw become Sam elected to lead the implementation of the "official experiment" because I wasn't a fan of Glide at all. There was no community vote to oversee this, just one maintainer of one flavor of go pkg management was declared the expert and just re-wrote the existing Glide solution with some lesson's learned. Many other maintainers (experts) of other go pkg management solutions favor vgo.

I've navigated many thorny dependency problems in Go before and never have I ever been convinced that the solution was NP complete version constraints. MVS, good tooling, and finally SIV is enough to make this miles better then previous attempts in this space. Also hooray for GOPATH elimination and project based workflows I've always loved GB by Dave Cheney.

pa7ch··on The Decline of the MacBook Pro
I feel like its just taking off. Crostini is a game changer.

Super stable and secure base OS with a modern linux kernel but with real vendor hardware support that is auto-updating and mostly immutable.

Then you have, out of the box with a single click, a debian container running inside a VM with full graphics integration and file integration. You can see your container's FS from the file manager and I can run wayland and X apps easily. Its also easy to run more containers via LXC.

more info: https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromiumos/docs/+/8c8ac04a...

pa7ch··on An Analysis of vgo
Minor correction: MVS requires modules to specify the minimum version to use of a module. The algorithm will then select the newest among those based on the idea that semver is forward compatible among minor versions. The name minimal version selection throws people off.

Other algorithms would select the newest release within a major version even if no module has ever tested it and it was released 5 seconds ago.

When authors do make incompatible changes and MVS selects a broken dependency, as expected, there are manual escape hatches. More complicated NP complete algo's would have more of an automated answer here by allowing dependencies to have boolean constraints (greater then X, less then Y, not Z etc.) on version so that there is this collaborative summation of constraints to work around authors violating semver or bugs. To summerize poorly: It seems Sam Boyer regrets that dep didn't do what vgo does by default, but believes that a SAT solver could kinda do MVS for the happy path but still solve against the introduction of boolean constraints.

Personally, I'd like to let vgo play out a bit, I'm not convinced boolean constraints are something I really want imposed on me by my dependencies.

More info for those who are looking for more context: https://research.swtch.com/vgo https://github.com/golang/go/issues/24301

Whether you agree or disagree, its novel research in this field and excellent technical writing worth reading in its entirety over a cup of coffee.

pa7ch··on Unlearning toxic behaviors in a code review culture
I often ask questions like that because I genuinely assume there is a good reason something was done a certain way but its not obvious to me. Maybe they made it over complicated by accident or, more likely, since I didn't spend as much time thinking about this code I just missed something during review. Maybe there is a way that can better convey that sort of genuine curiosity.
pa7ch··on Samsung DeX
You might be interested in upspin.io. It's by some of the people involved in plan9 and/or Go.

It's an ambitious project because ultimately you need to coerce all the apps with valuable data to export to or be compatible with upspin to realize the dream, so to speak.

However right now I've already found it useful for storing my personal files and media and I've enjoyed reading the codebase.

pa7ch··on Google Pixelbook – A High Performance Chromebook
I've been trying to track the termina project (along with the KVM and vm_launcher bits). From what I can glean: termina is a minimal flavor chromeOS designed to be run with the vm_launcher that will support OCI based containers. I have no idea how the UI will look around it or be exposed. The virtio wayland stuff requires support from the guest VM and termina has it. Tatl and tael are just the x64 and arm flavors of termina.

So as a developer you could easily spin up your own VM (I guess without a GUI) to mess around with, but use a single instance of termina to launch a bunch of container based linux apps for yourself so you don't run out of ram launching tons of vms.

This is a bit of speculation on my part mostly from picking through docs and commits messages. I'm not sure how it will all come together. I'd be completely sold on a NVMe pixelbook once I see some announcements or commitment to something like this for developers.

pa7ch··on How the Elderly Lose Their Rights
To add to this, past the initial elder-knapping, it looks like they drugged the elders to keep them from rebelling/attending court dates. From the article:

>During Rennie North’s first year at Lakeview Terrace, she gained sixty pounds. Parks had switched the Norths’ insurance, for reasons she never explained, and Rennie began seeing new doctors, who prescribed Valium, Prozac, the sedative Temazepam, Oxycodone, and Fentanyl. The doses steadily increased.

pa7ch··on Stop Faking Service Dogs
I think we found the landlord.

The homes people live in are more then just an investment to someone else. As a landlord, I "sure as heck" wouldn't begrudge a tenant the joy of finding a pet as a companion in life over few dollars.

pa7ch··on Plan9-9k: 64-bit Plan 9
Since, this system is a layer outside the kernel, just a bunch of normal applications I don't think this would work as smoothly. I think you'd need a custom storage server to serve the audio card from the other machine. It doesn't by default serve the entire host filesystem.

That said, I think the goal of upspin is that you easily can re-use its interfaces to do things like this. There are already some guides about writing custom shim storage servers like that (the main example being a webcam server), but I think this sort of experimentation is still in the early phases.

pa7ch··on Plan9-9k: 64-bit Plan 9
Yes, definitely you can shard your filesystem however you like or mount any remote system locally if thats what your asking.

There is currently a little research into what it looks like to expose something like a webcam as a file and how streaming interfaces look in the system, but, the client to stream the webcam file is a little hacky still.

pa7ch··on Plan9-9k: 64-bit Plan 9
The dream of the plan9 filesystem may be alive in upspin (https://upspin.io/). Its a federated filesystem/protocol with a global namespace. The security story could arguably be described as a layer on top of any application built with it in mind.

I've just begun experimenting with it on my personal server and like it so far. Its still an early project though.

pa7ch··on U.S. Senate staff can now use Signal
While I tend to agree, regardless, auditing should probably accomplished by requiring managed devices that can slurp the signal data on disk.

This might already be the case and is much better then making senate use non-e2e secure communication software.

pa7ch··on WhatsApp's Signal Protocol integration is now complete
Oh thats really interesting. I've never read CONAME before so I'll check it out. It sounds like its definitely worth evaluating more.

I've wonder if things like multi-device support or deriving a private key from a passphrase (mini-lock style) will eventually make user identity far less likely to change. Then it might be safer to complain louder when your in the situation that someone's identity has changed.

pa7ch··on WhatsApp's Signal Protocol integration is now complete
I think he already made a strong point why CONIKS style transparency isn't all that great for end-users. See this mailing list thread that includes the author of CONIKS talking about it with moxie before CONIKS was published:

https://moderncrypto.org/mail-archive/messaging/2014/000226....

https://moderncrypto.org/mail-archive/messaging/2014/000234....

Basically, users change their identity key in practice so often that a 3rd-party can't be the source of truth on whether a MITM has happened. Only the user can audit that and most users are not equipped to do so. So, towards the goal of universal e2e messaging its not clear that key transparency is a real win over the simplicity of trust-on-first-use.

pa7ch··on What life is like after police ransack your house, then the charges are dropped
I'm perfectly OK with a cop neither taking a starving person's bread nor arresting him. I don't think the bread maker wants it back.
pa7ch··on Go 1.6 is Released
Would you, by chance, be able to link or share that error lib? I'd love to see more solutions for error handling to get a better grasp.
pa7ch··on Google Cloud Storage Nearline graduates to general availability
"SSL added and removed here! :¬)"
pa7ch··on Five new undisclosed Xen vulnerabilities
This is why SEL4 is awesome. http://ssrg.nicta.com.au/projects/seL4/

First kernel with certain security guarantees formally proven; now open source. It can be used as a hypervisor which seems like its most obvious first use case. At least until there is enough middle-ware to build full systems directly with it.

pa7ch··on New Snowden Docs Indicate Scope of NSA Preparations for Cyber Battle
In the interest of facilitating a open and fair discussion on the larger issue of state surveillance, I highly recommend checking out the 2014 Munk debates: http://www.munkdebates.com/debates/state-surveillance

General Hayden and Glenn Greenwald are given fair time to discuss the issue and to give rebuttals to each other.

Its much more informative then trying to parse HN comments to form an opinion about state surveillance. It also forces you to consider the views of people who don't agree with you.

← PreviousPage 6 of 7Next →