HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pa7x1

933 karma · joined May 7, 2020

submissionscomments
pa7x1··on Special Relativity and Middle-Earth
The key observation is that there is no simultaneous. As in, an objective, observer independent, notion of simultaneous. Each observer carries its own notion of simultaneous and observers in different reference frames call different things simultaneous.
pa7x1··on ChatGPT, Rot13, and Daniel Kahneman
I just tried out of curiosity. The jumbled words get broken up into different tokens, the unjumbled words do not get split.

https://imgur.com/a/a3zmkIv

pa7x1··on Why I'm less than infinitely hostile to cryptocurrency
Uniswap, Aave, RocketPool, MakerDAO, Curve...

They are all built on top of Ethereum. They operate without human intervention, providing exchange facilities, lending, decentralized staking, stablecoins... The basic primitives of an automated financial system.

pa7x1··on Why I'm less than infinitely hostile to cryptocurrency
Do you think this is an unbiased source? Considering Central Banks have a monopoly on the issuance of currency and cryptocurrencies directly subvert this?

The current head of the ECB, Christine Lagarde, stated this year that "inflation came from nowhere". And this is your source of information on this topic?

It's like referencing a study on climate change by a fossil fuel producer in the 80s.

pa7x1··on ChatGPT, Rot13, and Daniel Kahneman
This is not it or not sufficient explanation. chatGPT is able to read text with letters purposefully scrambled. Like those texts that show how humans have an innate ability to read text with letters misplaced. chatGPT can understand the text, figure out what is going on and produce text of the same type. I tried it, precisely to understand if it was working with words as its token.

Interestingly, it cannot produce text with the order or characters reversed or guess that's what is going on. And if you explain it, it's able to produce code that would reverse the characters but is still not able to apply it for long sentences.

pa7x1··on The game theory of John von Neumann transformed the 20th century
You are falling pray to the tolerance paradox, I'm afraid. Unlimited tolerance against the intolerant leads to the disappearance of the tolerant. Von Neumann understood these subtleties, perhaps too well, seeing where we are at today.
pa7x1··on The Mystery of Spin
Physics uses fields to describe physical quantities that have a value for each point in space. For example; the temperature in a room is given by a field, the breeze in a room is given by a field. These two fields are not of the same kind, though. The temperature assigns a single value to each point. For example, over the radiator the temperature field says 30 C (86 F in freedom units) and next to an open window 8 C. While the breeze field assigns a vector (a little arrow) to every point in space. Over the radiator, a small arrow pointing up indicating air is flowing with a small speed upwards as the hot air raises. Next to the window a bigger arrow pointing inwards into the room, indicating the breeze is stronger and entering the room.

Different kinds of fields do not transform the same as you change your point of view in the room. If you rotate your point of view, the temperature field remains invariant. For the same point in space you assign the same temperature. But the breeze field changes as you change your point of view with a rotation. If you look directly to the window the breeze in the window points against you, if you face in the opposite direction it points in the same direction you are looking. A rotation changes the breeze vector but leaves the temperature vector unchanged.

How these different fields change as you rotate your point of view is what spin describes. It's a property of the field. The temperature field has spin 0, the breeze field has spin 1.

Fundamental particles are defined by fields too. The electron is defined by a field, the photon is a field, the Higgs boson is a field, the graviton is a field... As fields they have this property characterizing their behavior under rotations.

The Higgs boson is given by a spin 0 field (like the temperature example above). Rotations leave the field invariant.

The photon is given by a spin 1 field (like the temperature example). Rotations make the field changes such that a complete 360 rotation leaves the field invariant.

The graviton is given by a spin 2 field. Rotations make the field change such that a half rotation leaves the field invariant.

The electron is given by a spin 1/2 field. Rotations make the field changes such that you need to do 2 full rotations to leave the field invariant.

Spin characterizes their behavior under rotations. As physics is invariant under rotations this property is a conserved quantity.

Of all of this, the only mind-bending stuff is that a spin 1/2 field requires 2 rotations to leave it invariant. So here is a visualization: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a9/Belt_Tri...

pa7x1··on Rebuilding after the replication crisis
We often hear these days from science commentators if Physics should receive or not funding for the next big accelerator, High Energy Particle physics detector or gravitational wave interferometer. Most frequently brought argument is the lack of interesting findings during the last decades, and if that money would be better spent in other fields that have a higher return on investment given they are more prolific in their discoveries.

Guess what, it's very easy to find things when 1 in 20 of your papers can produce them by random chance (95% CI). When not outright participating in scientific fraud and p-hacking.

Perhaps the real lesson to learn from all of this is that we should defund every field that does not adhere to strict replicability controls. When funding follows findings you have set-up the perverse incentive to find something when there is nothing to get funding.

pa7x1··on Proof of solvency and beyond
Perhaps they are not capable of understanding why you cannot simulate a quantum computer with a classical computer.

Sometimes even smart people are wrong about stuff, that doesn't make them necessarily malicious: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isaac_Newton#Alchemy

pa7x1··on Proof of solvency and beyond
Absolutely. Centralized crypto exchanges should have the same regulation and oversight as brokerages/banks/other financial institutions. Because they are that type of institution, just having crypto under custody doesn't make it magically solve any issues.
pa7x1··on Proof of solvency and beyond
It's partly a UX thing, uniswap can be expensive at certain times. This is beind worked on actively with rollups. But there is still more work to do.

It's partly also because you have to bridge from traditional finance to cryptocurrency somehow. Many of these centralized exchanges are allowing that bridging. Usually that would involve meeting strict banking and KYC regulations. FTX decided that was too much of a hassle and incorporated in Bahamas to avoid it.

pa7x1··on Proof of solvency and beyond
https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/index.php?f=2334&p=fin...

> Client money is segregated in special bank or custody accounts, which are designated for the exclusive benefit of clients of IBKR. This protection (the SEC term is "reserve" and the CFTC term is "segregation") is a core principle of securities and commodities brokerage. By properly segregating the client's assets, if no money or stock is borrowed and no futures positions are held by the client, then the client's assets are available to be returned to the client in the event of a default by or bankruptcy of the broker.

Because segregation is a necessary prior to enshrine further protection on customer assets.

pa7x1··on Proof of solvency and beyond
You make good points, this by itself is not sufficient. That doesn't mean it's not useful, though. For Centralized Exchange you need additional regulation to ensure that level of customer protection. And yet, regulation itself is not enough, as you can still defraud in a regulated entity. You need that the weight of criminal punishment is hard enough to disincentivize it. And you possibly need insurance (FDIC and equivalents) too.

Hence why proponents argue to do things on-chain, where we have built-in guarantees and this issue disappears entirely.

pa7x1··on Proof of solvency and beyond
> The 'DeFi' systems you mention are not in control of vast sums of money, like the exchanges are. People want to use the exchanges and solving the problem by telling people to do other things isn't effective.

Uniswap alone has settled over a trillion USD. The current DeFi ecosystem on Ethereum (even now in the current market) has tens of billions of in value locked. I do not know what would be vast sums of money, it's still small in comparison with traditional finance but the technology is a few years old.

> This seems to me to be a problem with society and not with technology, and trying to apply technological solutions to problems that have existed and will exist as long as people exist, seems to be arrogant and ineffective.

Indeed, the fundamental problems are societal and human in nature. The point is minimizing the surface area where that human intervention can cause damage. If your argument held any merit we might as well get rid of double entry accounting. After all, it's just trying to apply a technological solution to human problems. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-entry_bookkeeping

> Since we have been iteratively working on financial systems for a lot longer, it seems practical to work to progress that way instead of wiping everything and starting from scratch, where we are reinventing the wheel and all of the tragic consequences along with that.

It's not reinventing the wheel. It's building a stronger foundation. I'm going to assume your field of expertise is CS, if it's not, hopefully it will be useful for someone else. Imagine the same argument brought to progress in programming language design. What's the point of Rust? We are just reinventing the wheel, considering how much has been built in unsafe languages like C or C++ we might as well keep iteratively building on them. Humans are still making programming mistakes. We don't need no memory safety in programming languages.

pa7x1··on Proof of solvency and beyond
It's not necessarily about covering all liabilities of an enterprise nor all its assets. It's about building a proof that you hold your customer assets and you are not running a fractional reserve. You may still run an unprofitable business and perhaps at some point you go bankrupt. But at least all the customer assets are there and segregated from the business assets and you cannot use them as the piggy bank for your business.
pa7x1··on Proof of solvency and beyond
These failures are in traditional finance, there was nothing related to blockchains or cryptography in the FTX internal operations or accounting books, nor in DCG/Grayscale, nor in BlockFi or Celsius. These are the failings of traditional finance in an unregulated or poorly regulated sector. Traditional finance as is conducted is insanely brittle and prone to manipulation/fraud. To avoid this, it needs to be strongly regulated and supervised.

As the same error seems to be being made in HN again and again, here is an analogy that hopefully will make the point clear. Traditional finance is like a dynamically typed programming language. You can certainly be productive with it, but it's much easier to slip through programming errors. To compensate you need to build a large set of unit tests to re-do much of what a strongly typed language gives you out of the box. A blockchain is the strongly typed version of traditional finance. Harder to use, to a large extent much of the ecosystem is nascent and still being built but it prevents large swaths of fraud and manipulation because it provides the checks built-in. The DeFi ecosystem is coming unscathed from all this fallout; Uniswap, Aave, Curve, MakerDAO, RocketPool, GMX, dYdX...

pa7x1··on World’s largest crypto fund swept into FTX storm
> Just curious how the dominoes will fall but it does seem like the people that invested in cryptocurrencies underestimated the risks of corruption. It looks like programmable money and clever financial engineering makes embezzling money a lot easier.

There is nothing of these failures that involves the programmable money part. DCG and Grayscale live in the traditional finance world, they are asset managers in traditional finance. Their accounting books are not a public, decentralized, cryptographically verifiable ledger . When you buy a stock of their fund, this is not settled on-chain in any way. If they are fraudulent, it's again the traditional finance controls that are failing.

pa7x1··on Is this the end of crypto?
I get the point and I can understand how it can feel like that from the outside. But the same people that are saying that FTX is not crypto now, were saying it before and same applies to Coinbase, Kraken, Binance... Luna and Terra were crypto, though, economically unsound design with Ponzi economics but crypto. And the litmus test is actually super simple and foolproof. Does whatever you are doing settle a transaction in a public, tamper-resistant ledger that is cryptographically verifiable? FTX business and operations does not involve such a thing. It's a traditional corporation, established in the Bahamas, running some SQL/noSQL DB or perhaps more likely paper napkins as a system of record... And as such was vulnerable to the same kind of abuses that have plagued financial fraud forever.

Here is actual projects that are implemented in a blockchain:

- A exchange, e.g. Uniswap: https://uniswap.org/

Here is a smart contract that executes its transactions: https://etherscan.io/address/0x68b3465833fb72a70ecdf485e0e4c...

You can see the transactions live. You can see the code that runs this exchange: https://etherscan.io/address/0x68b3465833fb72a70ecdf485e0e4c...

- Lending and borrowing, e.g. Aave: https://aave.com/

- Decentralized staking, e.g. RocketPool: https://rocketpool.net ...

Nothing of this has failed. It's working 24/7 without maintenance windows. Everything is on-chain, publicly verifiable, automated and involves no humans.

pa7x1··on Genesis' Crypto-Lending Unit Is Suspending Withdrawals in Wake of FTX Collapse
Nothing dumb about what you said, that's a valid argument. A bug, either unintended or intended as a hidden "feature" for the scammer. Is one possible way to execute a rug-pull on DeFi or, in general, result in losses for its users.

But IMHO this is still a better approach. Serious contracts go through multiple audits, deploye hefty bug bounties and if you are very risk averse you can avoid a new deployed contract for certain amount of time until it's not only audited but battle-tested. As a user perhaps you don't know and shouldn't care about the specificities of the contract or its security but you can rely on the thousands of other eyeballs that do.

For instance, a few audits of Uniswap:

- https://github.com/ConsenSys/Uniswap-audit-report-2018-12/bl... - https://rskswap.com/audit.html

Bug bounty program of Uniswap (up to 0.5M USD per critical bug):

https://uniswap.org/bug-bounty

pa7x1··on Genesis' Crypto-Lending Unit Is Suspending Withdrawals in Wake of FTX Collapse
You are absolutely right, but this highlights that what you are seeing these days with the failure of FTX and its associated fall-out is not a failure of cryptocurrencies or blockchain or any statement of its merits or demerits. It's a failure of traditional finance in an unregulated industry. This highlights how traditional finance is incredibly brittle and requires very strict regulation to have any semblance of resilience, when not failing anyway à la 2008.
pa7x1··on Genesis' Crypto-Lending Unit Is Suspending Withdrawals in Wake of FTX Collapse
This list is absolute rubbish.

1. OneCoin: Not even a cryptocurrency, a centralized currency. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OneCoin

2. Thodex: A centralized cryptocurrency exchange. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thodex

Actual DeFi cannot be rug-pulled, by design. Not even the US can taken down something like Tornado Cash. What a smart contract can or cannot do is written in open source code. How are you going to rug-pull it, if it's not coded there?

pa7x1··on Crypto exchanges may be exchanging ETH loans to pass proof-of-reserve audits
> What defi provides is completely useless in 99% of cases.

What DeFi provides are the foundations of a publicly verifiable financial system. So either you ascribe that financial systems are useless or that public verification is useless. For the first case I will refer you to the history of the Amsterdam Stock Exchange and the economic and welfare growth that it spurred, for the second one I will refer you to 2008 and what just happened with FTX.

> You need $4 to get a "loan" of $1 in DeFi. Who in the world needs such a loan?

Someone that needs 5 dollars? The specific numbers are irrelevant, in fact. They are just a consequence of whatever parameters are set to ensure the safety of the loan. If your question is why do we need to constraint in any margin collateral requirements, after everything that has happened during the last 20 years... I don't know what to say to you.

pa7x1··on Crypto exchanges may be exchanging ETH loans to pass proof-of-reserve audits
HN commenters pretty often ask what is a good use case of blockchains or cryptocurrencies.

Well, the failures you are seeing now are not in the blockchain native finance. They are failures of traditional finance in an unregulated industry. Celsius, BlockFi, Crypto.com, FTX... are corporations with opaque balance sheets operating in a poorly regulated sector. While all of that crap built on greed is imploding you have DeFi (short for decentralized finance, i.e. Finance primitives built on-chain) working just as intended and with 0 risk of contagion, by design.

What we are seeing is once again that traditional final is very brittle and requires very strict regulation to hope nothing breaks, when not outright requiring to be saved by socializing the losses (2008).

Blockchains solve this, they do. And we are seeing a magnificent stress test of it.

pa7x1··on It amazes me how many people are blissfully unaware of the rampant tether fraud
Not knowledgeable:

https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=M93Auk4AAAAJ&hl=en

https://people.csail.mit.edu/silvio/

https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Steven-Goldfeder/2642...

3 different founders of startups working in crypto.

pa7x1··on We will not pursue the potential acquisition of FTX
Don't let the schadenfreude and confirmation bias get to you. Centralized exchanges never had anything to do with the value proposition of cryptocurrency. And trading on them is just speculation with no relation to crypto. It's what gets views in the press, though.

Whenever news like these occur there is always a bunch of "I knew it would all fall down" self-validation comments in HN. Yet it really doesn't fall down, after over a decade. Perhaps it's time to consider that you are looking at the wrong thing and barking at the wrong tree.

Of all these collapses there is 0 decentralized exchanges (i.e. on-chain) involved. Pretty much because they can't, by design. That's the value proposition. Unstoppable exchanges, transparent, publicly verifiable, highest availability.

What you have seen all this year is more and more validation that centralized finance is problematic by design (3AC, Celsius, BlockFi, FTX...) while decentralized finance comes unscathed (Uniswap, Aave, Curve, MakerDAO...).

pa7x1··on FTX’s financial black hole leaves Binance balking at rescue plan
https://medium.com/@Ignas_defi_research/2022-state-of-defi-p...

DEX volume seems to be around 10-20% of CEX volume. But CEX is easier to overstate as it's cheap, sometimes commission-less. While DEX volume always carries a cost.

pa7x1··on Monumental (if correct) advance in number theory posted to ArXiv by Yitang Zhang
This effect clearly exists. It suffices to check how physics and math were expressed in the papers that discovered them and how they are currently represented to notice that sometimes organizing knowledge in the right framework and simple notational changes can be sufficient to power up our ability to make new advances.

Question is, are we dedicating enough effort to this endeavors? Is rewriting known math under a different guise sufficient to survive the publish or perish attrition? And will these efforts keep returning results?

I suspect the answer is no to the first two questions, and I don't know the answer to the third.

pa7x1··on Monumental (if correct) advance in number theory posted to ArXiv by Yitang Zhang
Isn't this evidence that this process has started to occur? The difficulty to make progress in certain areas of math pushes mathematicians to the shallower areas where it's easier to make a contribution. Progress in the first ones will stall and at some point the shallower areas will become less shallow and same phenomenon will occur.

Maybe we will keep forever discovering new shallow areas but I suspect this is not the case. In any case this is a phenomenon that I think will play out in the next few hundred years, not sufficiently impactful in the next few decades but more and more noticeable.

pa7x1··on Monumental (if correct) advance in number theory posted to ArXiv by Yitang Zhang
Math used to be a young person game, but it now requires so much knowledge just to get to the frontiers of human knowledge, not to speak of making a dent into uncharted territory, that results are being obtained later and later in life. When mathematicians have had time to accrue sufficient knowledge while still being sharp enough to make the intellectual leap.

The sad part is that as the trend continues we may reach a point where a mathematician's intellectually productive life is not sufficient to contribute anything novel, statistically speaking. And as population seems to be close to peaking, we will also have less chances of exploring the extremes of mathematical dexterity.

Perhaps we could then rely on computer assisted theorem provers. Or life extension, as long as intellectually productive years are also increased. Or we will need to focus and specialize kids earlier on.

pa7x1··on Why is symmetry so important in particle physics?
> Specifically, I'd love the intuition behind why it must be so that if the laws of physics are time/position invariant, it must be impossible to create or destroy energy/momentum.

The geometrical intuition is that the momentum operators are the generator of spatial translations (i.e. acting with the momentum operator P_x on a system is the same as applying an infinitesimal displacement in the direction x). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Translation_operator_(quantum_...

And the Hamiltonian is the generator of time evolution (i.e. acting with the Hamiltonian on a system shifts it in time an infinitesimal amount). This is quite literally what the Schrödinger equation says, btw. H |Psi> ~ d/dt |Psi>

If the physics of a system (which are given by its Hamiltonian) are invariant under translations then it must be the case that a shift in time (Hamiltonian generates shifts in time) of the momentum (generates shifts in space) of a system is 0.

As the Hamiltonian gives us the energy of the system, if the system is invariant under time translations then its energy is conserved. Using the previous argument.

Rinse and repeat for any symmetry of the system. For instance, angular momentum operators are the generators of rotations. If your system is invariant under rotations, then it conserves angular momentum. Invariance under relative movement (relativistic invariance) gives conservation of center of mass. Etc... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symmetry_(physics)#Conservatio...

← PreviousPage 4 of 10Next →