HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

padiyar83

117 karma · joined December 4, 2013

submissionscomments
padiyar83··on Ex-Google exec: Sun may be setting on Silicon Valley
I think any Canadian cities like Toronto or Vancouver or Dublin, Ireland are best contenders for the title and here is my reasoning for it. You need to wait for about a year to get a H1 visa to work in SV or work in the same firm for over a year elsewhere to get an L1 visa. So essentially SV today is a representation of diverse global talent who could get the visas, which is a very limited demographic. Historically SV did have an information advantage but if information were truly open, which I think is what the world is moving towards, I would assume any country with access to true diverse workforce without any limitations on workforce mobility will have an upper hand. And you already see accrual of talent to some extent in these cities. Nowadays whenever top 5 companies hire new talent from countries other than US, they usually bring them directly to one of these cities outside US. Competitors open up shop in the same cities because of easy access to talent.

I can see a world where ideas and startups increasingly coming from these above cities. And for the same reason, I don't think any of the Chinese cities pose a threat to SV. If anything Chinese cities can produce a Chinese version of the product but it will be hard to produce a global firm without access to diverse global talent.

padiyar83··on DevDocs API Documentation
But you pay for Dash subscription, this one seems to be free.
padiyar83··on IBM Now Has More Employees in India Than in the U.S
>> By not paying a competitive salary, those IBM offices in India are lacking the deep experience of western programmers.

1. IBM offices and most multinationals do pay competitive salary in India. We have the same problem with retaining talent in India that we have in US. Its hard to retain good programmers.

2.Thanks to US immigration system, you do find a lot of folks with deep experience working for firms in US for years return back to India. They carry with them the best practices that they learnt in US. Some of these people also attend US universities.

3. At least the big fives (I don't know about IBM) have consistent coding and code review standards across geographies and use similar frameworks, deployment and monitoring tool chains. So there is not as big of an impact as you think on coding standards across geographies, be it Dublin, Sydney or Bangalore. It usually tends to be the same.

padiyar83··on IEEE Spectrum 2017 Top Programming Languages
>> Any jobs list which has Python above Javascript and Java has to be flawed.

What data are you looking at to backup this assertion?

padiyar83··on India plans massive shift to electric cars
>> India barely has power for normal domestic consumption; even in Bangalore, the ostensible "Silicon valley" of India, power cuts for an hour or two is a daily affair. - Thats because India today relies heavily on hydro electric power and does not have as many peaker plants to handle peak capacity loads. One could make an argument that this is a perfect scenario for solar on rooftops (South India is a temperate country and gets lots of sun) generating the needed power locally and feeding the rest back into the grid as a perfect example that would work for India.

>> There is also the question of trade balance (presumably with China/Japan as well as upstream Lithium miners) - Those are today's constraints. I am not so sure, these are the same challenges that we would be worrying about a decade from now. Geopolitics and tech. change all the time.

>> Environmental solutions, incl. solar, are okay for assuaging the guilt about wrecking the environment (and India is totally wrecked) - Thats true, India today is totally wrecked, but so was 18th century London. You can always get better.

padiyar83··on Uber faces criminal probe over software used to evade authorities
But remember, UBER was playing in an unfair world. A world in which the existing Taxi companies had entrenched monopolies and yearly contracts with airports and city councils. And UBER does provide a valuable service to its users. I hate to go back to the days of having to call a yellow taxi cab to take me to the airport and then wonder if they would show up in time or not.

//corrected a typo

padiyar83··on Engineer Converts Van into Laundromat, Offers Free Loads to Homeless
Nice, thats awesome. This is really using his knowledge for the betterment of the society. Too cool !
padiyar83··on If You Can: How Millennials Can Get Rich Slowly [pdf]
Man those links are illegal and can get someone into trouble especially if they download it (unknowingly) from a corporate VPN. Just link the books on Amazon and leave out the dropbox referrals
padiyar83··on Turning CO2 to Stone
Its not either or at this point, you need both (as many as possible) solutions. In some regard CO2 storage solutions are better because you can make use of lower priced real estate like ocean floor vs growing plants and forests which take away real estate that can be used for human habitation and agriculture. Also CO2 storage is more stable in time. Like 100 years from now, people might just choose to cut down the forests and just release all that stored carbon back.
padiyar83··on Ask HN: If you could live and work somewhere, where would it be?
Bangalore. Great startup scene, amazing talent. The IT spirit of the city almost feels like silicon valley in 90's. Also a lot of pubs and bars and thousands of places to eat makes the city just a amazing place to be in.
padiyar83··on Whatsapp: Video Calling
Love it!
padiyar83··on Tech workers at UCSF face layoff, training their low paid replacements
I agree and its wrong. India should have a path to allow for long periods of staying and working in the country and provide for a valid path towards citizenship. Thats the only way India can be a country that can attract and retain smart global talent to enable its companies compete globally.
padiyar83··on Tech workers at UCSF face layoff, training their low paid replacements
> Because those companies are US companies, their very existence is a byproduct of this political community's stability.

Engineering talent (in US and other countries) is also a byproduct of that society's investment into educating its children. Arguably graduate education is also funded by tax payer money in these countries. So when US firms hire an engineer from India or China, they essentially are getting an engineer without funding his education.

> There is a social contract that exists and that holds together the civic tissue of this country. Of course, some companies are going to try cheating it.

Seeking merit (searching for a person who can do the job at a competitive price point) is not cheating. If UCSF does not offer good courses at great prices someone else will. That someone else could very well be a Indian or a Chinese university.

padiyar83··on Tech workers at UCSF face layoff, training their low paid replacements
When US companies (and universities) can operate and profit by operating in other countries, like India. Why should we not allow employees from other countries (like India an China) to seek employment in US, if they can do the job better and at a competitive price point. Why should it be just a one sided gain model that always benefits US employees.
padiyar83··on 90% of software developers in the US work outside Silicon Valley
That was my first thought too !
padiyar83··on Hello from Orkut
.. beautiful words ! I signed up just for that :)
padiyar83··on U.S. Team Wins First Place at International Math Olympiad
And these are the exact kinds of people who have to work the hardest to get a US citizenship. On average it takes an Indian citizen 10 years more than immigrants from other countries to get a US citizenship. Its equally bad for people who are born in China too.
padiyar83··on What if financial systems were hacked
This reminds me of an article on wired[1] where someone hacked into hosts that were hooked into legacy X.25 networks. And just like mainframes and COBOL, there are not very many engineers who understand X.25 networks today, and hence had a very relaxed security posture.

[1] https://www.wired.com/2016/05/maksym-igor-popov-fbi/

padiyar83··on How to Fall 35,000 Feet And Survive (2010)
You would need a parachute for a cabin bag and checkin luggage too in that case! :)
padiyar83··on Lead Water Pipes in 1900 Caused Higher Crime Rates in 1920?
Correlation between two variables, does not imply one causes the other.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_does_not_imply_cau...
padiyar83··on Dropbox Project Infinite
> ..or taking forever sync. This is really amazing.

I don't think this solves the problem of taking forever to sync. Nothing has changed there. You are still bound by the same data retrieval and network latencies to get the file stored in a datacenter somewhere to you. That one is a harder problem to crack because it needs a lot of infra investment in expanding your content delivery footprint and replace SSD's with something much faster, like flash.

padiyar83··on Network Monitoring, Moral Hazards and Crumple Zones
Network monitoring sucks because its usually an afterthought from a protocol design standpoint. This means most of the monitoring tools end up running at a very high abstraction layer like SNMP or PING requests and as a result, deeper level visibility suffers. We need to make network monitoring as a first class citizen and start including them within networking protocol stack. Like say call out a unique TCP packet type for 'monitor' with the sole job of carrying details on how many packets were dropped, who dropped it and when. Do the same with control plane protocols like BGP and OSPF in that any changes like learning a new route or removing a new route should be relayed to a monitoring tool directly from the protocol stack itself.
padiyar83··on What the IBM Layoffs Look Like
There are bad coders everywhere and it takes years of deliberate practice to be good at anything, including programming. Those people who did not put in the work, don't make it through grueling interviews at Microsoft, Amazon, Google and other such companies. People who do make it however are just as good as programmers anywhere else in the world.
padiyar83··on What the IBM Layoffs Look Like
Hey I am sorry if you are impacted by downsizing, but there are better ways of handling this than disparaging the tech community in India. I have worked in both US and India for more than one company and can tell you there is no discernible difference in the quality of the work that gets done between US and India. And even if I take your point that IBM are fools who doesn't know what they are doing, how to you explain Amazon, Microsoft and Google hiring thousands of developers in India. Microsoft's largest developer shop outside US is in India. Your experience can be due to a variety of different things from person at the other end doing exactly what he is supposed to do just to not poke holes in a secure infra to assuming that the firewall access list is state-full and allows return (HTTP response) traffic to pass by default. And there is no guarantee that a person based in US won't do the same thing.
padiyar83··on Cloud Design Patterns
Not quite true, Satya led cloud and enterprise org. before stepping into CEO. Many of the initiatives at Azure started with direct involvement from Satya. He also pushed for open Microsoft long before becoming a CEO, its just that now he is the CEO, he can make it happen.
padiyar83··on Solving the H-1B Visa Problem
This is my own opinion here. I think if you increase the price of H1B significantly then jobs would just move to Bangalore, Dublin or Vancouver. There is a higher limit to how much you can jack up the prices of a H1 visa and that higher limit should be set taking into account what the companies are willing to pay and still keep employing people in the US, assuming they have an option to hire people elsewhere in the world. If its too high, you might just have incentivized a behavior that stops companies from hiring people in US and instead hires them in other countries, these are the reasons why this will happen

- Companies increasingly have a global presence, almost all Tier 1 (AMZN, MSFT, GOOG) and Tier 2 (CSCO, JNPR, HP) firms have an office in Bangalore, Dublin and Vancouver these days. - Work can be done from anywhere really. At least the kind of work that H1B's are hired to do. A majority of these roles are not client facing. And you can always fly in and back on business visas when you need some face time with the team in US. - And you don't have the hassle of dealing with a non working immigration system. I can hire a guy from anywhere in the world and have him working at my Dublin office in a month. It takes a year of planning to get the same person in the US if I am lucky. I won't even consider it if the prices are too high. - As a precedent, Almost all of the Tier 1 companies and most Tier 2 companies, move workers from US to India, Ireland and Canada routinely if they cannot secure a H1B visa in the US. If the prices are dramatically increased this will just become the default behavior.

padiyar83··on Elon Musk Says SpaceX Will Send People to Mars by 2025
>>> .. I don't think anyone seriously believes the manned exploration of Mars will turn any profit.

I think this will be the most profitable enterprise mankind has ever seen. A earth full of mineral wealth untouched, available for whoever can lay their hands on. If spaceX was trading today I would buy its stock in a blink and hold on to it for the next 50 years.

padiyar83··on How Theranos Misled Me
Agreed, they should have been upfront on what technology they developed in house and what it can and cannot do. A simple table outlining that could have cleared up the air.
padiyar83··on How Theranos Misled Me
They never once said they were not using existing machines to do these tests, not once, they only spoke about the quantity of the sample needed. Using the same analogy, saying I have a great story to tell you but then reading Moby Dick isn't necessarily cheating, because Moby Dick is a great story :).
padiyar83··on How Theranos Misled Me
Theranos was very clear on this. They have about 200 tests that are successful in a lab setting with only one in the works to be cleared by FDA. Truth is that simple ! The rest is just sleazy journalism that sells tabloids
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →