HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

padraic7a

1,308 karma · joined January 15, 2014

<font color="#3c963c">astrofrog</font> [ my public key: https://keybase.io/padraic; my proof: https://keybase.io/padraic/sigs/F1W3qxmmrRrV4aYA-fg8t6Pi8PioCgE7uY50TPlBp8M ]
submissionscomments
padraic7a··on Open Access and the Power of Editorial Boards: Why Elsevier Plays Hardball
It's somewhat shortsighted to see this as a situation where the reader pays versus one where the researcher pays.

In both cases it is typically the university which pays. In one model the library pays, in the other it might be an academic department, research office or the library which pays.

Gold open access [the pay to publish model] is distinct from Green open access [where no payment is required].

Many publishers, like Elsevier are adopting a 'hybrid' model where they charge both to publish , and to read.

While there are costs to publishing one they don't justify teh huge fees [and profits] that Elsevier make. One would have to assume that the major, technical infrastructure Elsevier etc implement is to keep their texts inaccessible.

A new OA publisher, the Open Library of Humanities is trying a new model, where neither reader not author pay. Instead the suite of journals is funded by an international consortium of libraries.

padraic7a··on 14,000 Images of the French Revolution Released Online (2014)
The original image might be out of copyright, but someone's photograph of it is not. So, if you can take your own image you can do what you want with it, but you don't have any right to someone else's photograph of it.
padraic7a··on Fwupd: Updating Firmware in Linux
Well gnome-software is obviously restricted to gnome,and it might be the only current gui option but I don't think the system is. The page states that you can interact using the D-bus api and that's not restricted to gnome: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D-Bus
padraic7a··on Fwupd: Updating Firmware in Linux
Interesting development. Is there info anywhere of manufacturers who have undertaken to provide updates through this system?
padraic7a··on Open Whispersystems Flock being shutdown
Explanation here, seems that WebDAV was just too dated / hard to with https://gist.github.com/rhodey/873ae9d527d8d2a38213
padraic7a··on Open Whispersystems Flock being shutdown
https://github.com/WhisperSystems/Flock

Nothing I can see on the github page to explain things either...

padraic7a··on Yanis Varoufakis opens up about his five month battle to save Greece
Deutschland deutschland uber alles, but with banks instead of tanks.

"The European Union as we have known it ended over the weekend. That EU project was all about the gradual convergence of equal nations into an “ever closer union”. That’s finished now."

http://www.irishtimes.com/opinion/tormenting-greece-is-about...

padraic7a··on Ireland same-sex referendum set to approve gay marriage
Well pray harder so!

I'm usually sceptical about patriotism but am very proud of Irish people today.

Tiocfaidh ar grá!

padraic7a··on Anonabox Analysis
Invizbox is an attempt to create a decent tor-on-hardware solution using the same hardware tech Anonabox falsely claimed to have come up with.

While you can argue about the merits of a Tor-on-hardware solution they seem to have done a really good job of implementing things.

Their website: https://invizbox.io News they're planning to release a flashable firmware to plug the holes in Anonabox:https://twitter.com/invizbox/status/585116913321279488

[I've bought an invizbox but have no other affiliation]

padraic7a··on Stretching the “peer reviewed” brand until it snaps
I don't think that's always true however. Check out this example of an economist featured on Retraction Watch: http://retractionwatch.com/2015/01/05/anyone-want-hire-econo...

That said I do think the idea of a paper being produced after it has been toured around is a good idea - I wonder if it is appropriate for all fields though?

padraic7a··on Show HN: Pdftotext.org
I'm not using it on this pc - I get the error after clicking on the link on the bottom left hand side of the page.
padraic7a··on Stretching the “peer reviewed” brand until it snaps
although I think it's fair to say that not all retractions are the result of fraud. I'm not sure about the ins and outs of this case for example http://retractionwatch.com/2014/12/26/nature-cell-biology-in... but I think it looks like a straightforward revision due to more up to date information. This seems to be a good example of how science should work i.e. scientists posit theory, scientists receive new information and update or revise theory in light of this.
padraic7a··on Stretching the “peer reviewed” brand until it snaps
It's interesting that the elite journals are more likely to issue retractions. Though I suppose the increased prestige and job opportunities logically lead to more motive to game the system, create sockpuppets, commit other fraud etc.

Does the high rate of retractions show that the system works to some extent though? I wonder what percentage of fraudulent research or faked peer review is actually exposed? I guess we'll never know - one more argument for open access and access to open research data though!

padraic7a··on Show HN: Pdftotext.org
This does work impressively fast until you realise that it isn't doing any OCR, as parent comment points out.

The site also throws up a certificate error which might make some people nervous; "Technical Details: pdftotext.org uses an invalid security certificate. The certificate is only valid for the following names: www.github.com, .github.com, .github.io, *.githubusercontent.com "

I think if you put a note on the site explaining what you are trying to do [practice running microsites on the cheap etc] that visitors would be reassured.

padraic7a··on Secure Secure Shell
Based on the Snowden documents and the fact[?] that the NSA can decrypt SSH at least some of the time the author advocates disabling some of the weak points of SSH. He also describes how to go about doing so.
padraic7a··on Cathedrals, Bazaars, and in Between
A welll thought out piece rom someone who promotes open source software and is the guy behind 'software carpentry', an initiative to teach researchers [mosly scientists] basic software skills.

I like the way he pointso out problems with both the cathedral and bazaar models but identifies that "actually matters is the people who build them.".

My favouite line: "One king, one law" can sometimes be a great force for good, but what you usually get is collectivized agriculture and UML.

padraic7a··on 2015 is the Year of Bore-Sec
I think this makes an interesting point abut how effective crypto will have to be "easy and seamless".
padraic7a··on Poll: Do you like open-office environment?
No
padraic7a··on Separating Programming Sheep from Non-Programming Goats (2006)
The claim made by the author of 'The camel has two humps' was later retracted http://retractionwatch.com/2014/07/18/the-camel-doesnt-have-...

Fair play to Bornat [the author] for doing so, he also went into some detail on why the paper was flawed, the retractionwatch piece linked here is well worth reading.

padraic7a··on Why I like XSLT
Ah my apologies, I should have done a better search. Thought it would be worth posting since I have seen it discussed a bit in my area of work [libraries / digital humanities].

xslt really seems to get acceptance from non-programmers who want it to perform a specific functions [like convert some hand crafted xml into html] and hatred from programmers who point out lots of problems with it as a language. I guess I would never even have thought of it as a language until I heard these complaints - I saw it more as a toolkit for, well, performing very specific functions.

padraic7a··on Rejected for a Job at the Container Store
yeah, breast cancer will probably do that to a person.
padraic7a··on Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution
I see you've just added changes, are you looking for anyone to proof read at this stage?
padraic7a··on Ask HN: Best HN android client?
Cool, thanks for that. Does anyone else have one to recommend?
padraic7a··on Cider Project: Run iOS apps on Android
So what are the chances that this will get released in some sort of end-user friendly format? If the original developers don't do it will others be able to apply the ideas now that they are proven to work?
padraic7a··on You’re no snowflake
This is very good, on problems with lionising 'treps', expecing people to work for nothing and why all of this makes for bad politics.
← PreviousPage 8 of 8