HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pakitan

904 karma · joined August 9, 2011

submissionscomments
pakitan··on Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if websites aren't accessible
On the contrary, the power dynamics is completely different. It's one thing to come up with a ridiculous policy (which is easy for a politician to do) and put the onus on minority of affected people to fight it, while the majority is neutral. And it's another thing to ask everyone to vote on the policy before it's enacted.

Fighting the status quo is immensely more difficult than keeping it, even if the effect of that status quo is provably harmful.

pakitan··on Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if websites aren't accessible
No, these were obviously examples. Our site sells expensive products that require a certain level of "visual appreciation", just like paintings. No one would buy something like that, without being able to see it.
pakitan··on Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if websites aren't accessible
> but that is the system the people have decided they want

The people haven't decided anything. As usual, someone comes up with an absurd law, or an absurd interpretation of the law and there are not enough people affected to bother challenging it. But that doesn't mean "the people have decided".

pakitan··on Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if websites aren't accessible
Would a blind person be interested in a painting or car insurance? Another reason I'm sure about it is if there was genuine interest, there would be calls from blind people - "Hey, I'm interested in your products but I'm blind, can you help me with figuring out some things on your site?" or "Hey I'm blind and I have problem accessing certain features on your site, can you please fix those issues?". We haven't got one single call like that. Ever. The people who sued us were never customers, neither before nor after the adjustments we made to the site. The fact they went straight to threats and offers of settlement clearly indicates that it's a racket, not someone genuinely interested in the products offered.
pakitan··on Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if websites aren't accessible
Because currently there is no accepted definition of "fixed" (accessible) site and if they caved, people could come after them for various technicalities forever.
pakitan··on Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if websites aren't accessible
> This is no different than outlawing racial discrimination.

Yes, it is. Racial discrimination requires a special effort not to serve specific part of the population. Accessibility regulations ask you for investing time and money, that you may not be able to afford, in order to serve a minority of the population, that might not even be interested in your product.

pakitan··on Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if websites aren't accessible
The racket goes like this - a lawyer firm, specialized in this type of "work", finds a token blind person and sends you a letter to the tune of "On date such and such, our client visited your site and it wasn't accessible. Based on such and such precedent, we're not required to give you advance notice and can to sue you for $100K. However, we're reasonable people and we're willing to settle out of court for $10K, as long as you promise to fix your site under the supervision of an accessibility expert pointed by us".

For small companies, even if you're in the right, the only thing that makes sense is to settle. Going to court is way too risky.

pakitan··on Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if websites aren't accessible
> It's really not hard to make your websites accessible at a basic level. Follow the standards.

Do you follow the standards? If you show me a web site that you've developed I'll show you a site with multiple violations of WCAG 2.0. Hell, JAWS' own site is littered with WCAG violations! Yes, "accessibility at the basic level" is easy but WCAG 2.0 is not "accessibility at the basic level". It's a huge set of rules that are often unclear and ambiguous. And that's fine because WCAG 2.0 is just something that you should aspire to. But if you start defining accessibility by whether a site conforms to WCAG 2.0 or not, then I can guarantee you that every single popular site is non-accessible.

We got sued and believe me it has nothing to do with blind people. Our site is of zero interest to them. Companies are sued by scumbag lawyers, who have made a nice little racket out of this thing. It's really unfortunate that the HN crowd is siding with them, as if they are championing the rights of disabled people. It's all about money.

pakitan··on We must change food production to save the world, says leaked report
> inability to easily digest raw meat

Humans digest raw meat just fine. Cooking does help a bit but not that much as to suggest it's an evidence for us being herbivorous. It's more about taste and safety nowadays.

I'd suggest you try raw meat vs raw beans/grains and tell me which ones you have more problems digesting.

pakitan··on Empress trees absorb about 103 tons of carbon a year per acre
Mass extinction of what? I haven't heard of a tree that's so invasive that it kills everything in its way, animals and plants alike.
pakitan··on YouTube's ban on “hacking techniques” threatens to shut down infosec YouTube
As others mentioned, discoverability is an issue, as well as monetization. I doubt the frozen channel makes a lot of money but even if it's 100 bucks per week or month, it still helps. If he hosted the videos on his own site, he'll most likely make zero.
pakitan··on Rare Earth Elements could be big business for West Virginia
Hmm...let's see. I know absolutely nothing about the quality of US-vs-Chinese steel but, assuming everything you say is true, that means companies buying steel are perfectly fine buying low quality steel. And they will be perfectly fine buying low quality steel, regardless of where the supplier is located. So, what will inevitably follow is that US steel manufacturers will lower the quality of their steel to match Chinese's, while keeping the price high. The result - US consumers paying more for the same shitty quality steel.
pakitan··on Rare Earth Elements could be big business for West Virginia
It will definitely help some US businesses and will definitely hurt others. The same way import tariffs on steel are good for US steel companies, they are hurting the US companies who are using that US steel in their products. And that's without taking retaliation tariffs into account.
pakitan··on Adults learn language to fluency nearly as well as children: study
> Erdős never married and had no children
pakitan··on China says it wants to eliminate Bitcoin mining
Bitcoin trading is already essentially banned in China.
pakitan··on The Heart of a Swimmer vs. the Heart of a Runner
> If you're massively overweight and someone tells you to just go for a run, you're going to get hurt

Massively overweight people can't run, even if they wanted to. Their "run" speed is slower than my "walk" speed.

pakitan··on The Heart of a Swimmer vs. the Heart of a Runner
I'd suggest you read the actual study. It's way more nuanced and detailed than the 2 sentence summary I provided. And no, I don't think it provides a 100% guarantee that running is safe but that's not what I'm expecting from a study. It's just one more data point in the ever growing body of evidence that active lifestyle is better than sedentary lifestyle.

The problem is not that you're being facetious, the problem is that if you insist on a single study proving something with a 100% certainty, we shouldn't be doing any science. For example, I can find numerous holes in your supposedly perfect study design. It turns out that active runners have less joint issues indeed? How can you be sure that it's due to running and not due to increased exposure to sunlight? Why aren't you testing different exercises? What if the benefits of running are solely due to improved cardiovascular performance but running specifically is actually bad on the joints bearing the heaviest load? If you dig deep enough, we can go on and on.

pakitan··on The Heart of a Swimmer vs. the Heart of a Runner
Well, I don't have the time to go through the whole thing but on a first glance:

1. Seems like they identify someone as runner or walker based on a questionnaire filled. After X years those people fill another questionnaire to indicate whether they had OA or hip replacement. I would think that at the time of the second questionnaire a runner will still be assumed a runner, even if he doesn't run anymore.

2. Exercise other than running increased rates of OA and hip replacement.

pakitan··on The Heart of a Swimmer vs. the Heart of a Runner
It says they followed runners and non-runners for 18 years. Presumably, that means they monitored the same bunch of people over the 18 years and the effect you mention would have been noticed, if it existed.
pakitan··on What happens after rich kids bribe their way into college? I teach them
> To deny someone admission due to poor academics is to deprive the university of revenue.

I understand and agree this would be the case for low ranked universities but the article supposedly refers to an Ivy League uni or at least something close. Don't these universities have fixed admission numbers along with the ability to pick from the best and brightest? They don't have to fight for students, students have to fight to get into the uni. In this case it just doesn't make sense to lower the bar.

pakitan··on EU government websites have undisclosed adtech trackers from Google and others
We're sued right now by a troll law firm for breach of ADA. I'm not even sure there is such thing as "compliant". ADA basically says "well, we're not accessibility experts, just follow WCAG 2.0 and you'll probably be fine". The problem is that while WCAG 2.0 is, IMO, a well designed set of guidelines, it's not meant to be used to assess a site as "compliant" or "non-compliant". This situation is beyond ridiculous.
pakitan··on Mark Karpeles Gets Suspended Jail Term
Kim Nilsson's work is as good and unbiased as it comes and it pretty much explains everything you need to know about the missing coins:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l70iRcSxqzo

https://blog.wizsec.jp/2015/04/the-missing-mtgox-bitcoins.ht...

Btw, with your 350 coins, I hope you've already submitted a claim and are planning to vote on the upcoming Civil Rehabilitation plan.

pakitan··on Mark Karpeles Gets Suspended Jail Term
So, if you buy bank shares today and it turns out the bank has been insolvent for 2 years already and management was hiding this from investors, this is totally fine, as long it's not an established bank but a "startup" bank, am I understanding you correctly?

Mark was in way over his head but nobody says he should be jailed for being in way over his head. He should be jailed for defrauding people. He cooked the books and he hid the fact that MtGox was insolvent practically from the moment he bought it.

pakitan··on Listening to music 'significantly impairs' creativity
I'm pretty sure I'm not confusing anything. However you want to define "music" and "radio", both are passive consumption. Sure, there might be some types of music that engage your brain more than others but that would still be nothing, compared to, say, reading a book.
pakitan··on Listening to music 'significantly impairs' creativity
It's funny the result sounds slightly controversial because music doesn't have the bad rep that TV does. If the study's conclusion was "Watching TV significantly impairs creativity", everybody would be like "d'oh!". However, listening to music is also an act of passive consumption, just like watching TV, so the result is not too surprising to me.
pakitan··on Finnish breaks natural language processors
So, does that mean that if OpenAI's text generator turns out to be as "dangerous" as it's being marketed, we can all just switch to Finnish as lingua franca and Skynet won't have a chance? :)
pakitan··on Showing the world how real soy sauce is supposed to taste
The article says Kikkoman has tried to replicate his process but wasn't able to.
pakitan··on Teaching People to Trade Stocks Is Like Starting Them on Heroin – Munger
Yes, I'm talking about speculating though the difference is basically just in the holding duration of your stocks. If you're trading every day, that's speculation. If you buy and hold for 10 years, that's investing.
pakitan··on Teaching People to Trade Stocks Is Like Starting Them on Heroin – Munger
The house is your broker and their commissions plus the spread - the edge. So, the edge is very well known.
pakitan··on Teaching People to Trade Stocks Is Like Starting Them on Heroin – Munger
The more appropriate analogy is that trading stocks is like gambling. And it's not even analogy. Unless you really know what you're doing, trading stocks is gambling, just with less house edge.
← PreviousPage 5 of 11Next →