HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pakitan

904 karma · joined August 9, 2011

submissionscomments
pakitan··on Britain expels Russian diplomats over poisoning of ex-spy
> It's not something you can order from Amazon.

No, but apparently you can order it from a chemist. A russian banker and his secretary were killed in 1995 by the banker's business partner. With that said, blaming Mossad for this makes zero sense.

pakitan··on Coronary heart disease is a chronic inflammatory condition
Well, I didn't say the Inuit live long lives. In fact I haven't been able to find data how long do they live when in their natural environment on traditional diets. But I suspect they don't live that long as it's a harsh environment. It's probably the same effect as animals in the wild vs in the zoo.

I checked all the studies in your link and didn't see anything to contradict the notion that they had healthy enough lives. First study is behind a paywall so it's hard to comment but the most damning thing in the abstract is "The mortality from all cardiovascular diseases combined is not lower among the Inuit than in white comparison populations". Shouldn't it be significantly higher when you consider the copious amounts of "unhealthy" food they consume (allegedly 5-10 pounds of meat per day).

The paleopathology study involves a grand total of 3 mummies, that all died from trauma, 1 of which was 53 year old woman with signs of atherosclerosis but otherwise no evident heart problems, 1 apparently healthy young woman and 1 woman with severe heart and other health issues, some of which the researcher suggests are the result of a bacterial infection.

The Canadian Eskimos study mostly talks about ailments related to their way of life - worn teeth (which were still in excellent condition!!), snow blindness and the like. No mention of degenerative diseases. In fact you'll see a comparison between "traditional" Eskimos and "civilized" ones. If you intended to prove how unhealthy the traditional diet is, this study says just the opposite.

pakitan··on Coronary heart disease is a chronic inflammatory condition
Our small intestine is long, compared to the colon, precisely because we've evolved on meat-based diet. By the time the "meat" reaches the colon, there is barely anything left because the nutrients are absorbed by the small intestine.

As opposed to our cousins the apes, who have larger colon and shorter small intestine because they evolved on a plant-based diet.

pakitan··on Coronary heart disease is a chronic inflammatory condition
> how do you propose to measure long term mortality rates in a direct feeding study?

Simple, lock lots of people in a building, feed them the same thing for 50 years and then measure :) That's impossible, of course, which is why I try to take all these studies, no matter what the type, no matter which side of the argument they are on, with a monstrous grain of salt. When trying to find the perfect diet, I think it's better to look into the diet of our ancestors and to refer to the works of Dr. Weston Price and Vilhjalmur Stefansson. What they did might not be considered technically "science" because it's not peer-reviewed, doesn't have confidence intervals, mortality rates and whatnot but I consider it much more valuable as they spent years on the field studying people's diets and their health, not sitting in a comfy chair measuring blood cholesterol levels.

Inuit lived practically on very fatty meat only. One can only imagine their LDL. Why weren't they dropping dead of cancer, diabetes and heart attacks at 30 years of age? Dr. Price says that in all his travels he didn't come upon a group that thrived on plant food only. If I remember correctly there was a community in the Swiss Alps that lived exclusively on wholegrain rye bread, cheese + some meat once a week and they were very healthy. That's was the diet closest to vegan that he described. Of course, these days with all the nutrition science advancements, with the addition of supplements, it's may be possible to thrive as vegan but I'm not willing to be the guinea pig.

And yes, I'm well aware that feeding everyone animal protein is not sustainable in any way but that doesn't have much to do with the discussion whether animal protein is bad for your health or not. Given the problems with modern agriculture, it's questionable whether the Earth can sustain 9 billion vegans in the long term either.

I try to take into account the cruelty of industrial farming when choosing my food, at least to certain extent. However, you need to note that the very fact of my existence means hundreds/thousands of critters are being killed. From ecological point of view, the best option would be for me to kill myself, not become a vegan. I just have to draw the line somewhere.

pakitan··on Coronary heart disease is a chronic inflammatory condition
> mechanistic studies involving direct feeding & measurement

I believe that's the fancy terminology for "We fed people with substance X and blood marker Y went up", correct me if I'm wrong. How is that in any way reliable unless it's proven that elevated blood marker Y causes CVD? It's only reliable if you want to prove that food X causes elevated Y.

Also, I find it amusing that you're deriding observational studies, yet the study you're quoting is observational. And a big problem with a study like this is that it wouldn't discern between a high-protein diet consisting of bacon/sausages and one consisting of grass-fed beef. Processed meat contains all kind of shit, it's a major staple in people's diets and it's not surprising to me at all if people eating that have more health problems.

pakitan··on What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town
That same site has published a response from Jared Diamond: http://www.marklynas.org/2011/09/the-myths-of-easter-island-...

It seems far from established that the ecocide is a myth.

pakitan··on What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town
Someone said that's the solution to Fermi's paradox - every sufficiently advanced civilization eventually spends all its resources on cryptocurrency mining :)
pakitan··on A pessimistic vision of India’s looming environmental and economic collapse
> Just because growth isn't "infinite" says nothing about how far away we are from reaching the limits of the planet.

And just because Malthusians have been wrong for centuries, doesn't mean they won't turn out to be right in the next 50 years. At some point something will snap. Yeah, we have it pretty good right now. At least those of us in the west. I'm not sure if those people in India who have to endure 51 Celsius heats, don't have access to fresh water and live in areas where it's hard to breathe are in a better positions than their ancestors.

A trillion people on Earth may be possible if there was a God designing the planet from scratch with the specific aim to put a trillion people on it. But moving gradually to such a number, from where we are now, I'd say is absolutely impossible. Countries like India and China that are already bursting at the seams, seem to be proving that.

pakitan··on Kraken Returns with Free Trading
The purpose is not to prevent bank run. People had plenty of time to run if they wanted. The purpose of stopping withdrawals is to make sure people don't take advantage of any bugs that are still present. Like the poster here who reports having $7M in his account, rather than the expected few hundred.
pakitan··on A basic income experiment in Kenya
OK, I can understand how it can be taken the wrong way but for the record it was a nod to the "white savior complex", rather than an attempt to insult Kenyans.
pakitan··on A basic income experiment in Kenya
Whoa, eliminating poverty entirely...that's a leap almost equivalent to a hyperspace jump. I've seen actual economists, proponents of UBI, making much more modest assumptions. At the very least rents and house prices in poor neighborhoods will go up, negating the benefit of UBI.

> In the US, Social Security + Medicare + Medicaid adds up to US$1.97B per year, almost 11% of the US GDP

Yes, and you want to dismantle them and share that sum among everyone in the form of basic income. That would mean you'd be taking money from people who actually need it, to give to people who need it less. To counter that, you'd have to increase everyone's taxes just so the former welfare recipients aren't worse off. Of course, the taxes won't be raised just enough to offset the newly gained income, it will have to be raised more, probably substantially more because there will be people who haven't qualified for welfare before but will receive the UBI.

My post has no racist tone, you're seeing something that isn't there.

pakitan··on A basic income experiment in Kenya
> Very heart warming article, glad to hear about empirical evidence that basic income leads to fruitful, productive lives.

But of course it does because there is a Big White Friendly Brother supplying the money. If it was coming from Kenya's budget, these people would have to be taxed at a higher rate just so there is enough money to distribute as basic income.

pakitan··on Ask HN: Fully online CS degrees?
University of London: https://london.ac.uk/courses/computing-and-information-syste...

It's the cheapest I've seen - less than $10K total for the degree.

pakitan··on Australia's Housing Frenzy
You can easily see how well the reality matches your forecasts by going back to 2007. Did the masses of unemployed people seem happy to be freed from the burden of "overspending"?

> how about a stable money supply with very low (if any) injection of money by the government?

Majority of money supply in existence is some form of debt. I have $1000 cold hard cash, I put it in a bank and the bank then lends it someone else. Now there are $2000 in existence. Central banks don't and can't control this process directly. This is the vast majority of money out there. The amount that CBs prints is really tiny in comparison. In fact they are aiming at exactly what you suggest - some relatively low inflation rate but they tend to overshoot because they can't get the precise inflation rate they want and undershooting makes the process much harder to control. The fact that money is debt is exactly the reason you're now seeing inflation in US, even though the Fed stopped printing money long ago. Now they'll be starting to reduce money supply but you'll continue to see inflation rise until some sort of equilibrium is reached or (more likely) next bust comes. The money printing is supposed to act as a sort of confidence boost in recession/depressions but now that confidence is back, the money supply is growing and growing even though money printing has stopped.

pakitan··on Australia's Housing Frenzy
When someone says "no one buys anything", deflation proponents always twist that as if it's meant literally. The economy doesn't halt when there is a deflation. It just slows down, people buy less, then, because of the low sales, companies lay off employees, so people buy even less...and so on.
pakitan··on Ethereum Now Handles More Transactions Than All Digital Currencies Combined
You may be correct from a strictly technical point of view but then "digital currency" becomes a meaningless term. After all, one could argue that USD is a "digital currency" as well, given that cash transactions are a minuscule part of all transactions. Also, I can easily devise a "digital currency" which handles billions of tx/s...between address A and address B.
pakitan··on Mt. Gox Bankruptcy Wasn't Really a Bust
He was active and quite helpful but after the last creditors' meeting (when it was officially announced that any surplus will go to shareholders) he deleted all his posts in the mtgoxinsolvency reddit. He claimed it was because of abuse and death threats. I don't doubt that the threats played a part in his decision but I also think that the deleting of his reddit history is an attempt to get rid off of anything that might be used against him in future lawsuits.

Also, he never went as far as claiming that he'd distribute anything he gets to creditors. He's always been quite vague about it and never answered directly when asked about it.

pakitan··on A/B test of banner ads vs. traffic
I have a similar experience - after a redesign and significant improvement of page load time, the bounce rate and few other metrics improved but conversion rate stayed almost exactly the same. Kissmetrics are probably measuring this across thousands of sites and averaging the results as opposed to taking a slow site and tracking conversion rate after it gets speedier. So, it could be a correlation kind of thing - better sites, with more resources, simply invest more into every aspect of the business, including site speed.
pakitan··on DOJ: Billionaire pharma owner fueled the opioid epidemic with bribery scheme
Kickbacks/bribes are absolutely despicable, there is no argument about that. I'm just against some elaborate set of rules that is going to regulate what doctors can prescribe or not. These decisions should be left to the doctors' discretion. And bribe cases should absolutely be prosecuted.
pakitan··on DOJ: Billionaire pharma owner fueled the opioid epidemic with bribery scheme
The cigarette warning labels are working just fine. The point is to warn people of the dangers and practically every smoker is already aware of those and yet they choose to smoke anyway. That's perfectly fine in my book - as long as one is making an informed decision, they should be able to pick the poison that kills them.
pakitan··on DOJ: Billionaire pharma owner fueled the opioid epidemic with bribery scheme
Fast forward 10 years. Top story on HN is "I'm in excruciating pain and my doctor is refusing to prescribe me a painkiller because he's afraid of losing his license". Top comment: "This is ridiculous! Why are all these regulations preventing people from getting proper health care instead of actually helping them?"

No, the solution is not putting doctors in jail. No, the solution is not piling regulations on top of more regulations. Only thing that's needed is educating people and providing less addictive alternatives. If the pack of pills has "Warning: this is highly addictive! Use only in emergency!" in big bold letters, then people will think twice about taking them.

pakitan··on Catalan parliament declares independence from Spain
Why does the number matter? Lots of people here (including the person I was replying to) talk about the "right thing" to do, not about military power. If it's the right thing to allow for millions of peoples to secede, why isn't it the right thing for me and few buddies to secede? Are we inferior in some way? Where is the cutoff? Is it ok to secede if we are 1000 people? 10K? 100K?
pakitan··on Catalan parliament declares independence from Spain
That's not how referendums work. Are you saying that if tomorrow you and few buddies decided to set up a new country, on a land you own, via a "referendum", the government should just go with it?
pakitan··on Bomb kills journalist who exposed Malta's ties to tax havens
Europol's function is basically just coordination of the police forces in EU countries. It's not even close to a federal police force.
pakitan··on Stop the Border Surveillance Bills
Can you please read again the wiki article on what the gun's capabilities are and where it's deployed, as I don't think we are talking about the same thing?

First, masses of innocent people don't usually charge at borders of countries with which they are technically at war. Second, this is not a "gun see, gun kill" technology. There are humans involved and I'm pretty sure the level of automation is directly related to the assumed probability of border being attacked. In more peaceful times, it will be almost all manual. In a full fledged war - mostly automated. You can't afford to be sentimental when your country is being invaded.

pakitan··on Stop the Border Surveillance Bills
Looks like an amazing piece of tech, I'd totally work on that if they would let me anywhere near it. Why should I be ashamed of working on something designed to protect a country's border? Yet, I'm probably supposed to feel proud, had I worked for, say, Facebook, whose sole purpose of existing is to waste billions of man-hours a day?
pakitan··on Sleep deprivation is increasing our risk of serious illness
I'm pretty sure the numbers aren't plausible. I feel at my best if I sleep about 8-9 hours. Maybe I can cut half an hour and still do well but sleeping only 6 hours every day guarantees I'll feel like shit all the time and I'd be surprised if it shortens my lifespan by anything less than 30%
pakitan··on Court OKs child porn prosecution of minors distributing pictures of themselves
> If we open the pandora box of consent under 18, we will have to tread very carefully.

In my country age of consent is 14. There is no pandora's box, there is no widespread abuse of teen girls and children being raped. Only ones who routinely have sex and get pregnant at that age are gypsy girls and that's because their "traditions" require them to marry young.

pakitan··on The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant
That 1200kWh figure doesn't make any sense. It says that "edible tissue" excludes water content. Each kg of tomatoes has about 950g of water. That means 60kWh per kg of tomatoes, which will cost about 5 EUR. You won't be able to sell your produce at that price.
pakitan··on The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant
Yeah, I was wondering about that. Some of those farms look like they have million(s) dollars worth of equipment and infrastructure. And farming isn't exactly a high-margin industry so starting a new farm must be quite a risky venture. Are there government programs that help with the financing or it's all private capital?
← PreviousPage 7 of 11Next →