HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

palmotea

5,360 karma · joined April 12, 2023

submissionscomments
palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> This entire comment is a giant strawman that fails to address the point I was making.

Frankly, the point that you were making was dumb. Complaining about the voters will get you nowhere.

> Half the voting population elected a fascist demagogue.

You're high on your own rhetoric. That's not smart.

> The issue is that something like 40-45% of the population will literally vote for anyone in the Republican party, even if they're "America's Hitler". Project 2025 made it blatantly obvious what they were voting for.

So why is that? Try not to reach for some explanation that makes you feel good about yourself or your guys, because that's self-deception.

What do you have to do to change situation? If your answer is something that's comfortable and easy for you to swallow, it probably won't work. You're prioritizing your own comfort over an effective action.

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> There you go again trying to shift the blame from Republicans to Democrats.

The only thing blaming Republicans does is make Democrats feel better about their own incompetence and failure. Do you think the Republicans are going to take any blame you give them? It's psychological comfort for partisans who find adaptation too uncomfortable, nothing else.

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> But I'm not blaming the voter for not supporting me. I'm blaming the voter for supporting the person that they supported.

You're getting hung up. What the fuck good does any of that do? Tell me.

> Sure, I might be selling poop in a bag, and maybe nobody wants that. I can't blame people for not buying things they don't want. But the guy next to me is selling the Handmaid's Tale But In Real Life, and people are queuing up round the block to buy it. Those people looked at all the options -including abstaining and not buying anything at all - and still made a decision.

The point I was making with the poop-selling example is: you need to get outside your own head and your own biases. I don't think you're doing that. You're doubling down, making excuses for your side.

> They have to take ownership of that decision.

Sure, that would make you feel good, but it ain't going to happen. Quit tripping over it and move on.

palmotea··on Pointing AI at archives found a forgotten meteorite, lost rhinos, and more
>> our global material abundance would be truly unprecedented, nigh unlimited.

> There always seems to be this kind of Underpants Gnomes logic about this where 1. We can do things cheaply 2. ??? 3. Material abundance! where step 2 is actually "very rich people give things away for free!". Which requires people like Altman/Thiel/Zuck whoever to have care for other humans and empathy and actual feelings other than a blind Will to Power.

Exactly. The thing keeping us from "global material abundance" isn't really technology, it's ideology. The (by far) dominant global ideology is capitalism, and that simply does not permit "global material abundance" in conditions of extreme automation.

And it's fucking crazy to think the "step 2" is these business-kings will all the suddenly have a change of heart and share their wealth widely and freely, after their entire lives have probably taught them not to do anything of the sort. You can see it with UBI: it's not generosity, its some kind of minimum viable bribe to diffuse the threat of revolt against their wealth.

IMHO, the real "step 2" is some kind of communism. And I'll leave it as an exercise to the reader how likely that is going to happen in our lifetimes [1].

[1] As an aside, I actually see a path to some kind of twisted to communism from highly-automated capitalism over the long term, just not for me or anyone like me. It'll be for the nepo-babies of billionaires, after all the working people have died off or been pushed to the margins. The survivors would be so wealthy that maybe money ceases to have meaning and nepo-baby would own enough "means of production" to support themselves comfortably.

palmotea··on Pointing AI at archives found a forgotten meteorite, lost rhinos, and more
> Why is it always these supremely weak arguments and rationalizations against LLMs that come from people that have been intelligent, at least based on their comment histories, for so many years. It’s radicalizing me. I want a data center everywhere and I want tokens to be so cheap they’re like electricity or water.

What do you think the impact of "tokens to be so cheap they’re like electricity or water" will be? I think people who are intelligent and don't have their heads stuck in the sand see the implications of that. Why should people with money pay people to for intelligence, when they can buy machine intelligence very cheaply?

I guess it will free up smart people to finally take jobs that don't use their intelligence, or sit around scraping by on minimum-wage-like UBI (if we're so lucky).

palmotea··on Pointing AI at archives found a forgotten meteorite, lost rhinos, and more
>> Makes me wonder how much the author himself learned about the Dutch East India Company. I suspect very little, if anything. Something about these exercises reminds me of junk food: empty calories and all that...

> Surely more than if they read nothing at all because most of it would be tedious drudgery of minimal value.

It's an archive. It's all "tedious drudgery" until you figure out the value.

Sometimes figuring out the value means reading things until notice something, which could be a pattern or something dispersed.

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> Your comparison rests on the idea that politics is an elastic marketplace where people are not bringing in priors when deciding on who to vote for.

Not really.

> It completely ignores that at least part of that market is propagandized to the point where no matter how you sell you will not make the sale. Voters overwhelmingly support policies that Democrats support when polled.

If that's actually the case, it just means the Democrats need to work harder, for longer. But this "nothing we can do, country too propagandized, STAY THE COURSE, DON'T CHANGE," idea is just weird. It really sounds like excuses to avoid the psychological discomfort of being wrong or needing to make compromises with people you disagree with to win.

Also, polls are a data-point, but I'd never use them to jump to the conclusion they're an accurate representation of what people really want. For one, they're too easily to get wrong or even manipulate.

> I think your comparison is far too simplistic to be useful.

Sure, my poop-selling business example is pretty simplistic and exaggerated to make a point. But I think it's still useful in illustrating the foolishness and stupidity of blaming the people you need to reach.

> When the history of this time is written I believe it will be exceedingly obvious that the MAGA and the Republican Party were an incurable cancer and there was nothing that the Democratic Party could have done within the context of the existing political structure to stop it from spreading.

I am sure some history will be written that says that. It will be a lie, but of psychological comfort for some.

If there's any truth to "there was nothing that the Democratic Party could have done within the context of the existing political structure to stop it from spreading," it's about the internal dysfunctions of the Democratic party officials and partisans. This idea that "MAGA/Trump is so powerful, nothing could be done about it" is a stupid lie.

> They might have had one opportunity to avoid it by focusing more on supporting individuals and less on supporting financial institutions in 2008, but the political context of that time was entirely different. At some point it is worthless to blame one political party for another driving the country off a cliff.

I'm not blaming the Democrats for that. I'm blaming them for being incompetent (a state which continues). There's a big difference.

> Yes, they should have done things differently in hindsight, but there is little value in holding them accountable for information they did not have at the time.

What specific information did they not have at the time? Because I don't think the problem is a lack of information; it's their attitudes, priorities, and ultimately competence.

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> You sure are letting the U.S. voter off the hook here…

Because blaming the voters for not supporting you is foolish and stupid.

Not only do they have far less room to maneuver to express themselves (essentially through a single, unclear multiple-choice question), but blaming them prevents actual political actors from doing needed self-reflection and adjustments needed to win.

It's like if you had a failing business selling poop-in-a-bag, and focused on blaming your potential customers being too dumb to see how superior and high-quality your poop is. You think it's awesome, so they must be idiots! Stop wasting your time doing that, and re-evaluate the products you're selling. Maybe no one wants to buy poop?

palmotea··on A statement on the Tor Project's relationship with Mullvad
> They explain it in the next sentence: "We strongly oppose rhetoric that threatens other human rights and freedoms."

That's not an explanation. I don't think it's too much of an exaggeration to say everyone supports "human rights and freedoms," they just disagree on what those are.

palmotea··on A statement on the Tor Project's relationship with Mullvad
> Recent concerns about a political donation by a Mullvad co-founder have raised questions about the Tor Project's funding relationship with the company.

It's kind of obnoxious that they assume everyone already knows the details of whatever controversy this is, and don't even provide a link to any explanation.

So what's the controversy?

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> Factually, Harris as a candidate was orders of magnitude better than Trump: a boring, competent, left-leaning centrist.

OK, so now we know how you voted. What fraction of the electorate are you?

> The problem wasn't really Harris, who got very close to half the vote.

Which in this case is called "losing." Trump even won the popular vote that time.

> The problem is that half the voting population does not think that electing a fascist demagogue is that big of a deal, or compares favorably to electing a boring centrist.

IMHO, one of the Democrats' many fuck-ups was they overdid the "fascist demagogue" line of attack, basically neutering it.

It's pretty clear roughly what your political views are, but let me hazard a guess that you're far away from being a swing voter. IMHO, another one of the Democrats' fuck-ups was being unwilling to make their most loyal voters uncomfortable, and instead demanding that persuadable voters tolerate discomfort, which is a tough sell.

> This suggests that our civic culture is fundamentally broken at the moment. You can't run a society like this!

How very convenient! Doesn't that mean you don't have to adapt in any way that's uncomfortable to you?

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
I agree neoliberals are a very big part of the problem (and giving them the finger was one of Trump's trump cards, pardon the pun), but I don't think it stops there.

Another aspect, which applies to neoliberals and many other groups in the Democratic coalition, is the seeming abandonment the idea of representing voters (in a district) in favor of persuading/lecturing them. That really appeals to the true-believer partisans (who are getting represented), but alienates everyone else.

I'm pretty sure the Democrats would have at least 5 more Senate seats if they consistently ran candidates that focused on representing the state they're running in as a whole (and continued to do that after the election was over).

palmotea··on I hired an illustrator to draw my house. Now it's my Home Assistant dashboard
> He said it's sad, and no matter how you want to spin it, it still is incredibly sad and depressing that we're hailing the age of "semantic photocopiers" as some sort of intellectual achievement.

We've been talking about being sad about a lot of different things in this thread.

But here's another thing to be sad about (somewhat related to what I was originally sad about): building "semantic photocopier" is probably quite an intellectual achievement, but so was the atom bomb. intellectual achievements, even impressive ones, can't be assumed to be good.

To hail a "semantic photocopier" requires a pretty myopic and parochial view. Looked at holistically, this stuff amounts to a project to rub out the human and replace it with cheap, inhuman slop. One aspect if that is when I see a picture like this, it's ruined because when I look at it I'm unsure if I'm communing with a human or getting fooled by a simulacrum. Another aspect is how the slop undermines the viability of creative and intellectually engaging professions.

We really ought to look at the kind of world we want to live in (which would probably have maximum satisfying creative work, and a minimum of drudgery), preserve the good parts of what we have, and focus on intellectual achievements to subtract the bad parts. But instead we're just mindlessly building whatever we can manage, damn the consequences or end result (which seems to be: more drudgery, less creative expression).

palmotea··on I hired an illustrator to draw my house. Now it's my Home Assistant dashboard
> are often thinly veiled appeals to emotion.

What's your problem with emotion?

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> That's like blaming a rape victim for being bad at fighting off her rapist.

WTF? The Democrats lost some important elections to a fool, that's nothing like getting raped.

> If you want the answer, look at Republicans. They nominated him twice, and the second time around the Republican base ignored all of the moral issues they knew about and voted for him anyway because they wanted the chaos and anger.

I'm not saying there are no problems with Republicans, but that the bigger, more important, and more tractable issue is that the Democrats could lose to someone like that, twice.

Complain about how bad Trump is all you want, but if you lose to him, it's pretty clear you are in some important sense worse than him. Focus on fixing that, because bitching about the other side is going to do no good.

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> If half the voting population elects a vicious moron completely unsuitable for power, that's not the fault of the opposition.

Don't let the opposition off the hook: as you said they lost to "a vicious moron completely unsuitable for power." How does someone fuck up an election like that so badly? It should have been a slam dunk.

It's the fault of the opposition for not doing a better job (at all manner of political competencies). One thing I've noticed over the last ten or so years, is that Democrats/Liberals/Progressives are very averse to admitting to and learning from their own mistakes. They'd much rather focus on blaming someone else for their own incompetence.

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> How the US president became president is still the question that baffles me the most.

> Twice. You did it twice.

If you want the answer, look at the Democrats. That's why he got elected twice: they were that bad at politics.

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> I'm sure you can see the problem with your own argument.

Which is?

The US doesn't recognize the ICC as legitimate, and has the power to resist.

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> FWIW, that's not how the ICC works, any more than your national legal system is "ten guys working together to beat you up if they don't like you."

The point was the ten guys are self-appointed and have no connection to any legitimate higher authority that you recognize. Which is a akin to the US' relation to the UCC, given it's not ratified the treaty.

My "national legal system" is a higher authority (than me), which I recognize as legitimate, and in any case have no power to resist.

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> International relations is only literally anarchy if you take the realist school of thought as representing IR.

It's literally the state of things: "there is no hierarchically superior, coercive power that can resolve disputes, enforce law, or order the system of international politics. In international relations, anarchy is widely accepted as the starting point for international relations theory." (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarchy_(international_relatio...).

If you know of such an authority, please point it out. The UN is not it.

Anarchy doesn't mean constant conflict or power politics or anything like that.

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> I guess what he is saying is that work of International Criminal Court is a threat to US sovereignty ? Can someone make that make sense?

Why do you need help? It's obvious. The dictionary definition of sovereignty is "supreme power especially over a body politic" and "freedom from external control : autonomy sense 1." If the ICC has power over the US government or can externally control it (for instance by arresting its leaders), it is a straightforwardly impinges on US sovereignty.

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> Which is why the ICC was established by several countries as part of an international agreement. It's literally other countries collaborating to punish bad actor countries.

What would you think of an agreement by ten guys that they'll work together to beat you up if they decide you're a "bad actor"? Is it somehow solemn and respectable merely because they came to an agreement? Even if you don't agree their self-declaration should give them power over you?

I think the way you've presented things is misleading. International relations is literally anarchy, and different groups have different points of view. Mere collaboration is only that.

palmotea··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
>> "President Trump will never allow the International Criminal Court to prosecute Americans," Secretary of State Marco Rubio said in a statement, first published by Reuters.

> Can't think of a more flagrant and succinct declaration that the US believes itself "above the law."

So would you think of yourself "above the law" if you refused to submit to my law?

Apparently the US never ratified the ICC treaty. International relations is literally an anarchy, there's no "higher authority" to impose law. Countries can only voluntarily submit to a treaty, or be violently coerced by another country.

palmotea··on The value of not getting to the point (2015)
> I was contesting the claim that archive.org wants to preserve material. It's hard to trust that an archive will preserve the page you archived if the owner can come along at any time and wipe it. Some people want an immutable copy of a page that they can reference in case it gets changed or taken down in the future.

You're letting the perfect be the enemy of the good.

Sure, archive.org may not meet your perfect definition of an archive, but it does see itself as an archive that's preserving things for the future. My understanding is archive.is explicitly rejects that role (e.g. IIRC, they make silent changes to pages, their ownership is opaque, and they reserve the right to just disappear without a trace tomorrow).

This is how archive.is describes itself: https://www.reddit.com/r/DataHoarder/comments/1i277vt/psa_ar...:

> Yes, the word “archive” in the title is misleading. The main purpose is to hold up ephemeral web pages for latecomers. Shots taken more than a few days ago have almost no visits.

palmotea··on The value of not getting to the point (2015)
You probably want archive.org: https://web.archive.org/web/2/https://ken.arneson.name/2015/....

IIRC, archive.is actually explicitly rejects the idea that they're an actual archive for the preservation of material.

palmotea··on OpenAI annualised revenues $20B less than previously signalled
> Then they'll turn around and say there's a decent chance ASI will kill us all, so better we build it before China does.

So true. I know I'd rather be murdered by an American ASI than a Chinese one.

palmotea··on I hired an illustrator to draw my house. Now it's my Home Assistant dashboard
1. Hiring a human illustrator is the right thing to do, and I applaud this guy.

2. AI kinda ruined this style for me. The first thing I did when I saw it was start searching for AI incongruities which is sad.

palmotea··on US man given prison sentence for bot-farming music streams
I knew it was something dumb, I just had no idea it was dumb at that scale.
palmotea··on US man given prison sentence for bot-farming music streams
> ...which were generally created using super intelligence...

> ... SMITH turned to super intelligence...

Holy shit, we've got ASI?

Where do I go to invest all the money I have in this breakthrough!

palmotea··on Sharing AI progress in mathematics
> I would guess... But your rabid confusion prevents you from understanding that, eternally damning you...

Heh.

You need to stop guessing. Really, stop. You're not any good at it. You don't know anything about me, and appear to respond to that ignorance by filling in your blanks with wrong but (likely) ideologically self-satisfying hallucinations. I kinda feel embarrassed for you, but also amused.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →