HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

parados

276 karma · joined September 9, 2014

submissionscomments
parados··on The Differences Between the Plane Crash in Tapei and the Miracle on Hudson
> The crux is the airlines choose not to go for either option simply to cut costs, accepting lower safety margin.

Actually it is the passengers that want to cut costs. Us in other words.

parados··on The Differences Between the Plane Crash in Tapei and the Miracle on Hudson
Including the Lufthansa A320 in 2001 where the control stick was miss wired so that the ailerons were reversed: http://www.rvs.uni-bielefeld.de/publications/compendium/inci...
parados··on The Differences Between the Plane Crash in Tapei and the Miracle on Hudson
You are only looking at the economics of accidents which are very rare. Economics also exerts a powerful influence on operations and with modern airliners with supercritical wing sections they can really only achieve optimum efficiency for hours on end on autopilot.
parados··on The Differences Between the Plane Crash in Tapei and the Miracle on Hudson
> Can a computer land in the Hudson?

Well it did. One of the (probably lifesaving) actions that Sullenberger did was to deploy the RAT which meant electrical power was maintained. This was not a checklist item, merely something he though useful. This meant the computers were still firmly in control when the aircraft ditched and the stall protection they gave certainly helped the ditching.

Interestingly after the accident the NTSB and Airbus made a number of ditching simulations and it showed just how hard it was for pilots to achieve the correct entry mandated by the ditching certification (minimum speed, -1 degree approach). However one pilot, an Airbus test pilot, managed to do much better than this by levelling out at high speed and very low using the radar altimeter. He the allowed the speed to decay until the aircraft touched the 'water'. This unusual proceedure probably couldn't be done by many pilots but it could be done by a computer.

parados··on The Differences Between the Plane Crash in Tapei and the Miracle on Hudson
Since few accidents happen in the cruise the more useful measure is fatal accidents/1m departures rather than hours or miles. In 2013 it was 0.16/1m departures for jet airliners[1]. If you took two flights a day it would be, on average, 8,200 years before you were involved in a fatal accident and you would have a 80+% chance of surviving that.

[1] http://www.boeing.com/news/techissues/pdf/statsum.pdf

parados··on Hedge fund robots crushed human rivals in 2014
> This is headed for 2008 ... and your trend algorithms are useless.

Wrong. Trend followers did extremely well in 2008-2010. As the article says it was the years 2011-2013 that they struggled with.

parados··on Ask HN: Studying large code bases
Have a look at David Beazley's video for a real life example: http://www.pyvideo.org/video/2645/discovering-python
parados··on The software errors that made NATS close UK airspace 2014-12-12 [pdf]
Exactly my understanding of the report except that the system (actually the workstation) wasn't in an illegal state but it went into a special mode called the "watching" state. This is quite a legal state. However this mode accessed the System Flight Server through a different code path which had a different (hardcoded?) original magic number of 151, not the new capacity 193.
parados··on Some disasters caused by numerical errors
There are other examples provided by the delightfully named European Spreadsheet Risks Interest Group on their "Spreadsheet Horror Stories" page: http://www.eusprig.org/horror-stories.htm
parados··on Will the UK's gas holders be missed?
The coffee smell is because of Heathrow. They do about one roast a week for all the onboard catering.
parados··on Know When to Run: The Story Behind the Xmas Kings Cross Problems
> They even have powers of arrest.

Source?

parados··on A Dangerous and Costly Photo in Japan
I think that it is merely a consequence of when you have a small number of people that get a huge benefit which is paid by the rest of society contributing just a little each. It is greatly in the interest of the smaller group to continue this by whatever means, even criminal ones. It is not really in the interest of the rest of society to end this because, as individuals, they contribute very little and it would take a huge effort to stop paying.

You get the same effect when, for example, governments subsidise an industry such as agriculture. A tiny group benefits (and lobbies for this to continue) but the cost to the rest of society is individually quite small, for example in Europe around EUR 5-10/person/week.

parados··on What do all the controls in an aeroplane cockpit do?
Or free from NASA: http://www.nasa.gov/connect/ebooks/break_mishap_chain_detail...
parados··on Building C Projects
For the preprocessing part of the problem this might be useful: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8356100
parados··on Windscale Piles: Cockcroft's Follies avoided nuclear disaster
My thermodynamics professor was there as a young scientist when this happened. From what he told us (probably in clear breach of the Official Secrets Act) this was a truly terrifying accident. The absence of temperature data meant that it was impossible to know how extensive the fire was or what remedies would work. Eventually, in desperation, water was used despite the clear hazard of creating a catastrophic Hydrogen/Oxygen explosion. My professor recalled being sent up these towers to monitor any radiation release, perhaps an early example of "this is a job for the intern".
parados··on Countries are still paying off debt from World War 1
And WWII aerial photographs are still used to find unexploded weapons: http://ncap.org.uk/case-studies/explosive-ordnance-disposal Quite something to take a photograph 70 years ago that saves a life today.
parados··on Solving the Wrong Problem
I think Paul MacCready really solved a different problem. Earlier man powered aircraft (SUMPAC, Toucan, Puffin etc.) had been based on glider (sailplane) technology that emphasised the highest possible lift/drag ratio achieved by large span high aspect ratio wings and careful control of the aerofoil shape. The span and aspect ratio make the aircraft complex and comparatively heavy. MacCready realised that if the aircraft was made much simpler and lighter it could fly at a lower speed and although the L/D ratio was poorer (all those bracing wires!) the drag would be lower (V2) and the power required (V3) much lower, within human range. The quick to fail, quick to rebuild was a consequence of this simplicity.

Incidentally the photo showing the "speed ring" is nothing of the sort. Speed to fly rings are about 80mm in diameter to fit on an instrument face.

parados··on High Performance Python Extensions: Part 1
Cython is a code generation tool so it is often much harder to understand what the (intermediate) code is doing in more complex cases. This is especially true with numpy specific Cython code. And with Cython your debug story is more problematic. Cython is great but has some interesting performance corner cases, for example see: https://github.com/paulross/NotesOnCython
parados··on Ask HN: Are there any innovative startups in the porn/adult industry?
I'm curious, assuming you are hiring tech staff, do you find any difference in the quantity or quality of applicants compared to other, non adult, tech companies?
parados··on The Search for MH 370 (Inmarsat)
Hopefully this is not too much off-topic but one of my best school friends was murdered on flight UTA772 in 1989 (he wasn't the target of the bomb, just one of the consequences). Seven years later his mother forwarded me his camera that had been discovered in the wreckage. It was pretty beaten up but it seemed to me that there was still a film in it. I managed to ease the film out undamaged but by now it was way past its process by date and had been lying in the desert for a while so I wasn't at all optimistic about the latent image. With technical help from Kodak and a very good lab we eventually managed to get some usable images off the film. To my amazement there was, when greatly enlarged, one picture of him. Grainy and colour distorted but definitely him. This picture was some source of comfort to his family as his body was never discovered which, as is always the way with these things, adds immensely to the distress.

So on MH370 there might be other useful sources of data in the wreckage apart from the FDR.

parados··on The Human Factor – the 2009 crash of Air France Flight 447
I used to be a glider pilot (and an instructor). A disadvantage of a yolk is that when you are flying one handed and apply g (or encounter turbulence) the g forces on your arm induce roll inputs, a stick reduces that. As most powered aircraft are optimised for cruising at 1g this is not so much of a problem but with gliders varying g forces are quite common. The other consideration is that with most light powered aircraft the pilot and passenger get in from the side and a traditional stick sprouting out of the floor gets in the way, a yolk doesn't. With gilders you usually enter from above so the stick is not a problem.
parados··on Slightly Skeptical View on Sorting Algorithms
I think what the author meant was that the elapsed time to sort: t = k * O(f(n)). So given two algorithms that have the same O(f(n)) then the smaller the k, the faster the sort.
parados··on CPIP – A C/C++ preprocessor implemented in Python
OP here. You are right that C++ is moving away from the preprocessor (personally I can't wait for modules to save me from #include hell). CPIP was not intended to advocate advancements in the preprocessor but merely to make preprocessing in either C or C++ more traceable/comprehensible.

'Modern' C++ does not depend so stongly on a preprocessor however C does and most big C projects use all features of the C preprocessor, however opaque. This is why I chose to illustrate CPIP with preprocessing a single file from the linux kernel: http://cpip.sourceforge.net/copy_to_html/cpu/index_cpu.c_942...

parados··on CPIP – A C/C++ preprocessor implemented in Python
I doubt it. Jinja2 is a templating language for generating web pages. CPIP is a means of understanding what the C/C++ preprocessor is up to. These are unrelated.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2