HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pardon_me

88 karma · joined February 20, 2022

submissionscomments
pardon_me··on Supreme Court weighs fight between music industry, ISPs
The open internet is dead.

Everyone seems to be liable for each others' actions and content, yet simultaneously we don't own our own data.

The internet is a tool. Rather than putting ourselves at risk by standing on a street corner shouting our message to the world, or using controlled mass media streams such as TV and newspapers (which themselves are always at risk of being sued), we can "anonymously" communicate to millions, with very little risk to our personal safety or finances. There are few (if any) laws or commercial control worldwide which govern our right to so called "free speech" online, unless it affects profits.

This had led to opposing forces: Web technology companies (ISPs, AI, social media, search engines etc.) want us to share as much as possible, particularly emotionally-driven content. They use tools to deeply inspect data for tracking and profiling, and lobby government for the right to own and retain this data--all for profit purposes. Simultaneously, they wish to take no responsibility for creating and running these tools, nor the data retained, nor the global societal impacts. They refuse to share the data or inferred summaries.

Advertising has led to military grade tracking technology, and the web is practically run by advertising companies, who scrape, process, and retain our data, to create useful tools for us to use in order to encourage us to share more information. A feedback loop.

It's effectively privatizing profits and socializing losses on a data/information level; The commercial success of encouraging us to share our psyche and fostering opinion silos goes to investors. The control of individuals and groups goes to seekers of power. Yet the social impact of a divided society full of disinformation falls on all of us who aren't insulated from the reality of humanity.

Perhaps the general understanding of the value of data will begin to merge as we wake up to understand what this all means.

pardon_me··on Parliament must buy European IT, lawmakers tell Metsola
The article is behind a paywall.

It's probable the EU will develop alternatives to US products as they become less trustworthy. Microsoft seems to be developing Windows into adware and spyware.

The key question will be whether the EU and UK fully ban the use of US communications products in government, such as Whatapp. The idea that Western countries use private messaging apps to conduct government business, with no oversight, traceability or proper records, is absurd.

pardon_me··on We're losing our voice to LLMs
This is the root of the problem with LLMs.

At best, the can attempt to recall sections of scraped information, which may happen to be the answer to a question. No different to searching the web except you instantly know the source and how much to trust it, if you search yourself. I've found LLMs tend to invent sources when queried (although that seems to be getting better), so it's slower than searching for information I already know exists.

If you have to be more of an expert than the LLM to then verify the output, it requires more careful attention than going back to the original source. Useful, but it's always writing in a different way to previous models/conversations and your own writing style.

LLMs can be used to suggest ideas and summarize sources, if you can verify and mediate it. They can be used for a potential sourcing of information (and the more data agreeing, the better). However, they cannot readily be used to accurately infer new information, so the best they can do here is guess. It would be useful if they could provide a confidence indicator for all scenarios.

pardon_me··on Credit report shows Meta keeping $27B off its books through advanced geometry
Along with this, hedge funds got the heads up, and being smart/efficient money, went and bought up a load of power companies. This means higher profits as energy prices increase.

They would be surely rushing to invest in power infrastructure and use the AI scare (military need) to push through legislation. If they aren't doing this, they must be predicting the demand won't follow through...

pardon_me··on Credit report shows Meta keeping $27B off its books through advanced geometry
> more like wash trading

This is it. I can see TSLA and a lot of bitcoin vehicles have done it too. Combined with the extent of tech companies proportion of total S&P500 market cap, along with expected energy price increases due to usage, will lead to a huge drop of worldwide confidence in US stocks once this bubble pops.

Governments who do not take enough action to stop this behavior inevitably lead to this. The US credit rating may be at risk entirely.

pardon_me··on Credit report shows Meta keeping $27B off its books through advanced geometry
Most will be specialist jobs too, with people moving there to fill them and/or working on a rotating basis, requiring traveling. Truly magnificent for the community, and the environment--employees can bring bottled water with them from out of state to solve that issue!
pardon_me··on The realities of being a pop star
They try to sell your body and your soul It's the price you pay for rock 'n roll And no-one understands it how you feel For it's so unreal, oh, it's so unreal

Baby, don't you cry for me It's an illusion, just an illusion

BZN - Just An Illusion https://genius.com/Bzn-just-an-illusion-lyrics

pardon_me··on The realities of being a pop star
I call this "justing".

Justing trivializes life entirely.

pardon_me··on The New AI Consciousness Paper
> I think the only frontier company that gives a measurable amount of fucks about the possibility of AI consciousness and suffering is Anthropic, and they put some basic harm mitigations in place.

It seems more likely this is just their chosen way to market themselves. Their recent exaggerated and unproven press releases confirmed that.

pardon_me··on Boom, bubble, bust, boom. Why should AI be different?
The current LLM models are too fallible and inefficient for everyday use. Energy requirements have become a major concern, bucking the trend of banking exponential computing gains through the efficiency improvements. Until recently, year-on-year global energy demands of data-centers were increasing linearly despite the exponential increase in computing power.

This has changed since the cost of equipment and infrastructure has been close to "free" for the large corporations running a cycle of funny-money investment in a bubble. This has allowed them sell access to the computing and models for just above operational energy costs (to the extent of increasing global energy prices), whilst offering free accounts to harvest data. No small competitor could possibly compete with that model.

The calculation for profitability (useful output for humans in a cost-benefit analysis) of the current setup is broken, and trades on our dreams of the future. Scaling computing forever simply does not work. It will never be profitable without further leaps forward in the technology--either more efficient models or hardware. By this time, the extent to the excessive investment in new data-centers will be clear.

pardon_me··on Personal blogs are back, should niche blogs be next?
Personal blogs are completely different from a web-based business which relies on SEO to be profitable.

The idea of personal blogging is for your own growth and history.

pardon_me··on Original Superman comic becomes the highest-priced comic book ever sold
It's already happened unfortunately. LLMs learned to write correctly from people who write correctly. Those people are now being blamed for sounding like AI, when AI actually sounds like them (and probably learned from their work without permission). To avoid they, they write differently.
pardon_me··on Loose wire leads to blackout, contact with Francis Scott Key bridge
Clear plastic viewing windows on the spring terminals are the way to go. It allows for both instant feedback for the installer, and visual inspection or troubleshooting later by a third party.

The spring terminals should also be designed to have a secondary latch on this type on (what should be) rugged installation.

Finally, critical circuits should be designed to detect open connections, and act accordingly. A single hardware<->software design for this could be a module to apply across all such wiring inputs/outputs. This is simple and cheap enough to do these days.

A manual tug-test on the physical would be advisable when installing, to check the spring terminal has gripped the conductor when latched.

pardon_me··on Criticisms of “The Body Keeps the Score”
Grieving heals trauma. Death of a child is traumatic but we allow room for this in society. We provide instinctive support to others going through this.

Death in general is an inevitable part of life that can be dealt with in a healthy way. It's still individual but generally there are outlets.

Traumatic disorders are specifically where the symptoms caused by trauma interfere with daily life and are measured in severity and longevity.

We should actively grieve traumatic experiences by paying attention to them where necessary.

pardon_me··on Daniel Kahneman opted for assisted suicide in Switzerland
We are human. Unfortunately all of our experiences with others change our perception of them, no matter how much awareness of their motivations and our history with them. We can try to ignore it and have patience. Apologies can help but relationships will constantly change.

It's certainly a failure point within us and something to be aware of to make effort towards understanding our own impact as you suggest. Sadly a problem with no full solution over long enough time periods.

pardon_me··on Ask HN: How many of you are open to Piracy again?
By the time this could be set up, making digital content by recording real-world action will be niche. It will be mostly computer generated.
pardon_me··on Twitter suspends pg's account [fixed]
Is this real life?
pardon_me··on Paul Graham is leaving Twitter for now
Musk is a fraudster. Someone must compile a timeline of his claims. Just the content that pops up from Thunderf00t on Youtube calling it out is enough for investigations. The only way I see investors going along with it is embarassment, riding the tide and not knowing when it will change. SoftBank style. It's changing now, economic corrections, just a time he's leveraged more than a sane person would value his companies at. lol

Then there's China. Tesla's 25% yearly revenue after being the first US company to launch without being 50% hand-in-hand with a local business. He agreed to teach the locals his methods, and they now sell straight-up copies at half the price. lol

I'm sorry but this whole thing is one big joke.

pardon_me··on Paul Graham is leaving Twitter for now
The best choice. Twitter was Twitter before Elon Musk and it could be Twitter again after Elon Tusk - although it is likely to tank unless he has the balls to move on before say 2024.

I wonder what's next...

pardon_me··on EU adopts global minimum 15% tax on big business
IMO when UBI becomes a global standard country by country the tax-free threshold should be the UBI amount.
pardon_me··on Riffusion – Stable Diffusion fine-tuned to generate music
Excellent work! Singing would be amazing - karaoke can finally sound good :p

Have you released a tool for volumetric capture? I'm applying this to LED lighting fixture setup for tv/film/live shows and 3D positioning is the last step to fully automated configuration.

My goal is real-time sync between 3D model and real world.

pardon_me··on Twitter applies 7-day suspension to half a dozen journalists
Charges raised for fraud mid 2024 Arrested before 2026
pardon_me··on Ask HN: A quiet place for a short stay (UK)
This is great, exact what I’m looking for, thank you!
pardon_me··on Ask HN: A quiet place for a short stay (UK)
This is great thank you! I’d never have found this in my search. I will look into it.
pardon_me··on Ask HN: A quiet place for a short stay (UK)
Scotland’s lovely and as you say, not many miles out of Glasgow it becomes another world - meandering around the Lochs until suddenly mountains.

I’ve been to Mull, Islay and Oban scuba diving. Highly recommended and plenty of excuses for whisky.

I’ll likely go again next year.

Thank you!

pardon_me··on Ask HN: A quiet place for a short stay (UK)
Excellent suggestions. Thank you for taking the time.

I’m looking to book somewhere in Pembrokeshire for this break on my own. Rural walks and a log fire in the evening will be nice.

I’ve saved Glastonbury for a future trip with friends. Too true about the seaside towns - holidays and grandparents!

All the best.

pardon_me··on Fosshost Is Shutting Down
Horizontal organisation 001: one member should not hold the ownership and voting rights?

The AWOL director has full control...

"Nature of control Ownership of voting rights - 75% or more Right to appoint and remove directors"

Ownership in open orgs is very difficult but this is set up to fail.

pardon_me··on The impotence of being clever
I (internally reluctantly) agree. A clever idea stretched out and headlined for attention. Structured well as an essay but most often a clever idea doesn’t stretch to 2000 words. This is an example. Such a shame.
pardon_me··on Stable Diffusion 2.0
Exactly. I have a catchphrase for this "AI generate, human mediate".

This revolution is allowing us to conduct the orchestra instead of playing each instrument.

pardon_me··on Amazon Alexa is on pace to lose $10B this year
Trillions involved in Amazon entering markets one by one to dominate, their secret to lower prices being sell at a loss. Running a company for decades on loans without a need for profit is quite a force.

Amazon has fuelled the race to the bottom and it seems the company inevitably destroys its own good creations given just a short time.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →