HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

partomniscient

654 karma · joined November 9, 2012

submissionscomments
partomniscient··on Chromatone – Visual Music Language
I couldn't say. I only know that my personal experience of using Rocksmith to learn guitar meant I couldn't bust out a song perfectly without looking at the screen, even if I could get 100% in expert (no visible notation) mode for some songs.

The 60hz refresh visual input was 'expected' by my brain to be there in order to coordinate my body with correct timing, intonation etc. i.e. it seemed to be mixed in with my so called 'muscle memory'.

One other thing that was most noticeable is the gamification noises (e.g. the noise you get for reaching the 25x multiplier) became part of my mental model, and when I recognised this and turned them off in the options, my inability to play that part of song nearly as well became extremely evident, although persisting with the option set to off allowed me to overcome it.

partomniscient··on Mondragon as the new city-state
I'd imagine the Silly Walks sketch transcends language boundaries.
partomniscient··on Chromatone – Visual Music Language
From personal experience, I think having to unlearn the trigger(s) - in this case a specific colour creates more difficulty than its worth. You're intentionally coupling then de-coupling neuronal networks, and the de-coupling is harder than the coupling.

It also makes me wonder how much cognitive dissonance this may cause for those with synaethesia who already have their own thing going on.

partomniscient··on For those who hear voices, the ‘broken brain’ explanation is harmful
Thanks for that.

Good read, and it also parallels discussions in mental health forums where people with dissociative mental health issues generally recommend against meditation, or at least some types of meditation (e.g. walking meditiation is ok, watching your observer/stillness/awareness types are not).

partomniscient··on For those who hear voices, the ‘broken brain’ explanation is harmful
Hearing voices is an experience. Behaviour is a response to said experience. They are separate parts of a process which may or may not always result in a same or similar outcome.

i.e. Actual behaviour is not the expected behaviour. The experience is the trigger of said behaviour (or even lack thereof such as a lack of empathy or sympathy).

partomniscient··on Just use fucking paper, man
There's a different Andy Bell who fixes everything by adding more guitar pedals.
partomniscient··on Making 'food out of thin air'
>"This means 40% of the planet’s total habitable land is dedicated to animal products, despite the fact that meat, dairy and farmed fish combined provide just 17% of humanity’s calories."

It's complicated. Not all calories are equal, this obviates the fact that those calories may be the main sources of specific proteins, vitamins and minerals etc. that are essential to human health and not easily obtained elsewhere.

I get what they're trying to promote but its not a completely valid standpoint to take, and I say this as a vegan.

Plus its not something easy to transition from for the majority of people because so many complex systems are involved that are resistant to change for a variety of reasons. Including profit motive and general resistance to change. (e.g. Just think about the amount of time it took the wine industry to move away from using cork even though it was proven new bottle sealing methods were superior.)

I still applaud the general idea, and they mention vitamin's, advantages of fermentation etc. later - but this paragraph really irked me.

partomniscient··on Airlines are running out of 4-digit flight numbers
Interesting. I thought he was more of a submarine guy.
partomniscient··on CrowdStrike CEO apologizes for tech outage
Time ends at 3:14:08 UTC on January 19, 2038.

I don't think we can explicitly blame Kurtz for this one though.

partomniscient··on Cities need more trees
Agreed, although I still don't get the fact we continually plant trees that grow taller than the overhead power lines and then the council has to continually prune them into weird shapes to prevent interference.

e.g. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-10-18/pruning-street-trees-...

A lesson on how not to do things. I'm all for appropriate trees though.

partomniscient··on Wikipedia Pain
I'm with jwz on this - I had that exact experience.

Some autistic german guy (self described in his profile) rolled back an edit I'd made related to a local band known for its satirically serious take on things, quoting 'lack of citation'.

I had zero clue as to how some guy in Germany knew, let alone understood the band given their lack of context. It was then I noticed that wikipedia had gamified moderation because part of his profile showed off his 'moderation badges' or whatever they were.

Despite all that I still use it often enough that I overall like it, it just has its flaws like most things do.

I also found it funny that my attempt to be funny/clever on the internet was thwarted by someone who clearly had no idea what they were doing (other than gaming the system as part of their own self-identity), which kind of fits with the bands whole schtick.

partomniscient··on Three Laws of Software Complexity
I think most of us go through a 'software development is like..' metaphor phase.

Back in my day it was via McConnell and the PragProg guys. Jeff Atwood covered it in a blog post from over 15 years ago:

https://blog.codinghorror.com/tending-your-software-garden/

partomniscient··on What the damaged Svalbard cable looked like
Its the groundstation that needs backing up and the location is surrounded by the sea.
partomniscient··on What happens in the brain to cause depression?
Its fundamentally an analog device. The concept of information being a 0 or 1 are simply one voltage level offset from one another. Its how we project the digital 'view' onto the computer and work with it. If the signal is not in the expected range of '0' and not in the expected range of '1' it should throw a hardware error and you'll end up with a BSOD (Blue Screen of Death) or equivalent.

We feed it alternating current to start with. It can partially power up, the only reason it appears to be working or not is because of all the safeguards designed in - don't power up unless voltage is at least blah, and failsafe cutout refuse to power up because voltage is over say blah*1.05. There's a subset of expect Voltage ranges (eg. 3.3V)[1].

It's literally the first thing the computer does. POST - Power On, Self Test.

[1] https://www.lifewire.com/power-supply-voltage-tolerances-262...

partomniscient··on Show HN: I made a books recommendation app based on your mood
Some other not yet mentioned feedback: The 'Show more' button which only revealed the last half of a sentence in both choices I made basically made me ditch the site. There's absolutely no reason to do this if there's no other collapsed content on the page, and also should be avoided if its only collapsing a tiny amount of text. Each book summary has its own distinct page, so its just annoying and to me serves no purpose.
partomniscient··on Jim Ward has died
I thought Drawmij's Instant Death was a parody spell and not actually real. I still remember that being in one of the Outrages from the Mages spells in Dragon magazine. [1]

[1] https://www.greyhawkonline.com/greyhawkwiki/Drawmij#Trivia

partomniscient··on The Hacker News Top books of 2023
It should be titled "How to win friends and influence people by being insincere".
partomniscient··on How a software glitch at the UK Post Office ruined lives
It's kind of similar, but in Robodebt it was more a case of covertly implementing a wrong algorithm for debt calculation (because it inferred good results for the government of the time), placing the responsibility of disproving the debt on the individual with ridiculous requirements and no support or process to easily challenge them.

It was really a result of the Liberal & National Party (LNP) who were in government at the time wanting to:

- look tough on welfare cheats for image/election purposes

- claim a potential massive source of income (that wasn't really there) for the next budget

Most of the wrong calculations were due to a result of income averaging fortnight or multiple fortnights worth of income and extrapolating them to an annual figure, which is the absolute wrong thing to do when a lot of people on welfare worked as casuals and/or had short term jobs and the fortnight(/s) were non-representative of their yearly income.

In some cases the first time the alleged debtee found out about the debt was via a demand from a debt collection agency.

When individual action was taken against them, the government was reducing debts to $0.00 and then claiming there was no longer a reason for a case against them and had it dropped. The only reason the debt recovery program was stopped was because lawyers acting upon someones behalf also claimed interest on a paid false debt, which meant they couldn't succeed using the same tactic at which point they rolled over and admitted the unlawfulness of the scheme, which had been going for many years at this point.

I recommend this youtube 3 part series to get a good understanding of what was involved:

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OfsL9GAbl3M

It starts out mentioning that it resulted in the largest class action lawsuit in Australian history...

partomniscient··on We need technology that is less immersive, not more
I'm kind of with you. In line with the article, its more the application of computers that's the problem - instead of making the world a better place, its a more distracting place.

Is it really worth it shuffling digitized crap around at high speeds if the outcome is a worse human experience because we're only applying it to the low hanging fruit and therefore creating a slippery slope for ourselves...?

The irony is that escaping into a simpler VR world with less distractions can help you deal with this, but I don't think its the right move.

I'm also reminded of Lee Felensteins quote from Steven Levy's Hacker's book. "You're doing all that for the computer!? What are you doing for the people!?"

partomniscient··on Wizards of the Coast admits using AI art after banning AI art
I suspect IAAI (I Accidentally AI) is going to become more and more of a thing...
partomniscient··on Possible Meissner effect near room temperature: copper-substituted lead apatite
On a planet undergoing global warming.
partomniscient··on Notation Must Die: The Battle for How We Read Music [video]
Yeah, but to me it makes as much sense as measuring everything in 3/4 of an apple.

How many per grouping(/bar) is what is important, not conformance to some symoblic notation in which 4/4 is much more popular and recognisable and forcing it into other less easily divisible circumstances.

I agree with those carrying on about rhythmic importance over time signature notational importance. da-da-da-da-da-da. Everything is relative to everything else, and not to some explicit concept of an 'eigth note'.

partomniscient··on Notation Must Die: The Battle for How We Read Music [video]
That always did my head in and still does. Ok, so each bar has 6 notes and they're eighth notes. But there are only 6 of them, so why are they specified as an 8th note? They're sixth notes by definition surely? I'm with the crowd that 3/4 should be correctly written as 3/3 even though we were told that was a misnomer in school.
partomniscient··on Notation Must Die: The Battle for How We Read Music [video]
Tracker notation is even more complicated in that duration is built into the sample, and whether the sample has endless looping repetition built in or not - none of which is possible to discern from looking at the tracker notation itself.

Let alone thoss 'notes'are actually a bunch major and minor synth chords in different keys, or orchestra hits in a 2-unlimited mod.

partomniscient··on Read the Chronicles of Narnia in Publication Order (2018)
>I’m reasonably sure we can rely on the linear nature of time.

I'm not even sure about that, perhaps we can rely on our linear _experience_ of time, but we can't determine which is the correct version of two billiard balls colliding if we're shown the forwards and the backwards versions.

Assuming time is linear is convenient, but I don't think its provable or outright definite.

partomniscient··on From Nand to Tetris (2017)
The Great Tinkertoy Computer [1] is made from raw materials, although its specific rather than a general purpose computer, and had computer aided design although back in the day it was via a PDP-10.

[1] https://www.computerhistory.org/collections/catalog/X39.81

partomniscient··on BSD on Windows: Things I wish I knew existed
But they should all break on MacOS and refuse to be cross-compiled for Windows/Linux?

I agree with your idealism, but I think the best we're going to get is more or less what we have now, otherwise we end up in the space where program x works with o/s y version z subsystem q, but not the other combinations you'd hope for.

I'm still annoyed that we don't design enough for the future that when a new O/S version/architecture gets released there isn't more effort to save the past. We have a perfectly serviceable relatively recent printer (4-5 years old?) that my wife now can't use because her new Mac which replaced her 12 year old mac, now doesn't have a driver for it, because there are no Sonoma versions of it.

I think we err on the wrong side of creating waste at the expense of not doing (admittedly annoying) work.

To get back on topic, this was the point of subsytems - you managed to hold onto and get access to the past you liked from within your walled garden.

partomniscient··on I hacked Magic the Gathering: Arena for a 100% win rate
The thing that weirded me the most in the article out was seeing the 'goto IL_1894' statements in C# code.

It brought back memories of error handling in VB6, and was rather unpleasant. I presume this is being done for performance reasons?

partomniscient··on Accidental database programming
Now I feel old, I remember "Anything but sourcesafe" [0], which was a followup to "Visual Sourcesafe Version Control tunsafe at any speed", and having my trust evapourate when I found out Microsoft didn't dogfood their own version control system.

So long ago I can't remember exactly which but I was running a local cvs and/or subversion repository for my own work just to avoid issues like the above. s [0] https://blog.codinghorror.com/source-control-anything-but-so...

[1] https://developsense.com/visual-sourcesafe-version-control-u...

To get back on topic, the key thing an explicit database gives you is a purpose built-language (and data-integrity enforcement etc. if you do it properly), that everyone knows. (Or used to? SQL is getting more hidden by abstraction layers/eco-systems these days). I'm old, so I reach for my older, well understood tools over new and exciting. Get off my lawn. It may be over-architecting, but I'm also not working in maximising 'performance in milli/micro-seconds is vital' high load environments, or releasing updated software every other day.

The other issue is tool/eco-system fragmentation.

But when you're young and have the energy and mental capacity to abstract out the wahoo for effeciency/performance, you do, because you can, because its better at the time. In our day everyone was writing code to write to code which were effectively the pre-cursors to ORM's. It's just part of being young and committed to your craft, and wanting to get better at it - this is a good thing!

It's only as you get older you start to appreciate the "Less is More" around same time that job ads appear with "Must have 3 years of SQL-Sync experience" (no offence intended here). There are both costs and benefits but which and how much of each you only find out years later.

partomniscient··on Nanoplastics promote conditions for Parkinson's across various lab models
If you wait too long, because the issue is so widespread there can't be any type of genuine control group because everyone is affected at some level.
← PreviousPage 5 of 16Next →