HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pashamur

115 karma · joined April 19, 2012

submissionscomments
pashamur··on An amendment to the Constitution of the USA to abolish the electoral college
Yes, but as a counterpoint that was due to offshoring of the domestic manufacturing base which was due to the setup of the international monetary system in 1971/1974 as well as a whole slew of policy decisions which made labor-intensive manufacturing businesses less profitable as a whole in the U.S. because of the necessity of running fiscal deficits and a strong dollar; so the red states were basically sacrificed in the grand scheme of things, not by their own volition.
pashamur··on The Lies that can Undermine Democracy
> Suppressing their views doesn't change their beliefs either. It only increases their feeling of being oppressed.

Consider why every dictator strives to have complete control over the media, and you'll see that suppressing views does actually work on the majority of the populace unfortunately (not on the politically active, of course, but most people aren't)

pashamur··on Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler
> If it's a marketplace of ideas, the current situation is equivalent to monopolies stamping on startups to prevent them from ever becoming competitors. An actual marketplace of ideas would work without censorship in the first place, like it used to. Note that most minorities right now who obtained civil rights would never have been able to claim them had they be silenced from the get go.

The fundamental problem is that truth and lies don't operate on the same playing field. If we can make an assumption that the game is being played fairly within the marketplace of ideas (people are being reasonable and accepting rational arguments), then the marketplace works as intended. If certain actors are subverting that system by design, then you cannot have an unmoderated idea-sphere, unfortunately. Studying some Nazi and Communist propaganda techniques should certainly convince you of that (and how effective they are when applied against a gullible populace).

There is no good solution to this, unfortunately. Once a radical movement takes over the idea-sphere moderation and certain censorship is sadly inevitable & needed. Something akin to Denazification in post WWII Germany (which specifically and forcefully suppressed any Nazi ideology from the mainstream)

pashamur··on Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler
This is actually demonstrably false - people have successfully been reintegrated into "normal" thinking by removing corrosive media influences.

The key distinction is between people who seek out certain content and people who stumble across it passively (in a morning car commute, say). The latter can actually be de-radicalized and de-programmed much more easily, and it's a worthwhile task to do so. Trumpism is a cult, and so the deprogramming methods have to be similar to recovery from a cult (and not the typical arguments that we see on facebook and such which are completely useless & worse)

pashamur··on Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler
"What I found is that approximately 18 percent of Americans are highly disposed to authoritarianism, according to their answers to four simple survey questions used by social scientists to estimate this disposition. A further 23 percent or so are just one step below them on the authoritarian scale. This roughly 40 percent of Americans tend to favor authority, obedience and uniformity over freedom, independence and diversity."

https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2020/09/23/trump-amer...

That also aligns with around 20% of voters supporting Nixon after Watergate. I think we should do our best to make sure that number stays at around 20% and does not grow; for if it does it imperils the whole democratic system of government that we take for granted.

pashamur··on EFF's response to social media companies' decisions to block Trump’s accounts
You're giving the president here way more leeway than is necessary.

The leave in peace video clearly had a subtext (he mentioned the election being stolen no less than 3 times in the video) and was not aimed at subduing the crowd at all. Furthermore, the later video where he said that the trespassers would be prosecuted is clearly scripted/edited (from the monotone and cuts in the filming), and likely happened because of some strong-arming (how else did he go from "we will never concede" to admitting defeat in a single day?)

My best guess as to what happened there was that Mitch McConnell (or someone else) figured that he could whip enough votes to impeach & convict if need be and Trump, facing potential consequences, reluctantly decided to play ball.

pashamur··on YouTube announcement on content policies
> The big foundational lie is that there are no biological differences. This is demonstrably false, but you will not see it, or any of it's many corollaries censored.

People right of center tend to overestimate how much biological differences matter (versus societal forces), people on the left tend to underestimate it. That's been true for a long time. I don't think either point of view is particularly censored though.

We're talking about censoring outright lies (the kind that the Putin government puts out, say)

pashamur··on Why Markets Boomed in a Year of Human Misery
In theory, yes, but similar amounts of inflows to bitcoin/gold will result in different performances since the market cap of bitcoin is so much smaller (supposedly the circulating supply is ~4 million bitcoin, so functionally ~120 billion USD float currently, versus multi-trillion for gold).
pashamur··on The case for moving to a red state
> There is a cautious tale of moving to a red state: If enough blue state people move to a red state, they may bring the policies that destroyed the previous state with them.

By all accounts blue states are doing just fine: https://thehill.com/opinion/finance/521875-democrat-run-citi...

Red states seem better at addressing homelessness, but that's about it:

https://appliedsentience.com/2020/07/30/economics-are-red-or...

pashamur··on California plan for wealth tax on anyone who spends 60 days a year in the state
No, this is a bullshit argument. It's the same as telling people who want to fight global warming to buy recyclable containers (when we know that most of the damage comes from companies and not individuals) or telling people who are concerned about ocean pollution to use reusable straws or not to use paper bags (when fishing nets are actually responsible for >50% of ocean pollution and straws are less than 1%).

This is actually a tactic that climate change denialists push for (accuse people of not doing enough personally so they don't go after the real source of the problem and blame themselves instead)

It's a milquetoast argument intended to defend the status quo by attacking the people that want to change it.

pashamur··on California plan for wealth tax on anyone who spends 60 days a year in the state
Other countries can have that expectation, but they can't enforce it - that's the main difference. The US can.
pashamur··on California plan for wealth tax on anyone who spends 60 days a year in the state
The U.S. has the world's police force, if they wanted to find you, they could.

And for renunciation of citizenship, there's a one time liquidation tax where you pay taxes on all of your gains (so Bezos would have to pay a flat ~20% on his Amazon holdings to renounce). So the U.S. is the only country in the world that could get away with a global wealth tax on their citizens (they already tax Americans' incomes irrespective of country).

pashamur··on California plan for wealth tax on anyone who spends 60 days a year in the state
The thing about this logic is it breaks down once you replace "workers" with robots (which companies of the future will).
pashamur··on Global chip shortage threatens production of laptops, smartphones and more
Scalping disappears if supply matched demand (with perfect geographic efficiency). Buying from a scalper is strictly riskier than buying from a retailer (might not be able to return faulty equipment, etc). There might be exceptions for rare / limited edition items because then scalpers can potentially control the whole market and extract monopolistic profits (assuming the demand curve allows it).

Scalpers only exist when the true market price of something doesn't match the list price (Demand >> Supply). Graphics cards worldwide, microphones, at-home lifting equipment, USD in Venezuela... it's basically Uber's surge pricing but for products :)

pashamur··on Bill Gates warns Covid lockdowns could drag on into 2022
It was indeed generous if you qualified and were able to access it (a lot of systems were down / not functioning super well early on - especially in states like Florida). That said, it ended in July and there were many people who slipped through the cracks.
pashamur··on FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-19 Vaccine
> From an ethical viewpoint, this is incredibly wrong, as vaccines given to healthy people which cause problems later are very very dangerous.

The first two phases are the safety tests, the third one is efficacy (so we knew the vaccine was "safe" after phase 2, we just didn't know the efficacy - that's what the poster above is alluding to).

pashamur··on Almost one in five Americans may have been infected with Covid-19
> At current rates that would happen 4 months from now; it's hard to see how that's not at least plausible.

* Normalized by population though, you would be looking at today's equivalent of ~2.15 million deaths in the US from the 1918 flu.

pashamur··on Why a land-value tax is inevitable
Yeah, it was an aha moment for me when I understood the reason for the cap gains / normal tax difference.

It makes sense that it's an attempt to index for inflation, although strange that there is only one cutoff (securities held for 1 year taxed the same as the ones held for 10 years); you would imagine some sort of step-down function would make more sense / track inflation more accurately (or indexing directly which is much harder).

So maybe different tax rates for 1/5/10/20 years held?

pashamur··on Excess mortality from March to December of 2020
There's large variance there depending on demographic factors & income quintiles. Life expectancy is going up for some, while down for others:

https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R44846.pdf

"Their most relevant finding for Social Security reform is that life expectancy increased continuously with income and that, according to them, “[t]here was no dividing line above or below which higher income was not associated with higher life expectancy.” At increasingly higher levels of income, they report that an increase in income of a given dollar amount produced positive but smaller gains in life expectancy. "

pashamur··on S&P Dow Jones Indices to launch cryptocurrency indexes in 2021
> Inflation is actually really high, but its mostly hidden in rising prices for stocks and real estate.

Sort of. There's inflationary forces (fiscal / stimulatory policy) battling deflationary forces (mainly technological innovation), mainly netting out to a low inflation rate at the moment, as defined by the CPI.

Assets that are not affected by the deflationary forces (such as land, and some types of housing), do tend to increase in value, though some of that is increase is just due to interest rates being so low (since for most consumers the house payment is more important than the absolute price; when interest goes down, prices normally go up).

It would be interesting to do a graph of interest-normalized house/asset prices over time.

pashamur··on S&P Dow Jones Indices to launch cryptocurrency indexes in 2021
Generally, the only way to make outsized returns in the market is to go against market expectations, otherwise you would just make market returns.

So yes, a bet on crypto is a bet against the market consensus, sort of by definition :)

pashamur··on S&P Dow Jones Indices to launch cryptocurrency indexes in 2021
That depends on how good you are at finding needles :)

The thing not many people seem to talk about is that the 20th century had unprecedented growth in terms of population around the world (which has slowed significantly in the last few decades, although the effects usually lag by quite a bit - when the children enter the workforce and such). We're making up for some of it with technological progress, but ultimately what impact that makes is up to everyone to think about individually (look at Japan as a potential leading indicator of what demographic change can do).

pashamur··on S&P Dow Jones Indices to launch cryptocurrency indexes in 2021
Technically, everyone in the U.S. was an investor in gold up until 1971 since USD was supposedly backed 1-1 by gold :)
pashamur··on S&P Dow Jones Indices to launch cryptocurrency indexes in 2021
*with the caveat that those very few areas also hold a large percentage of the population, since land prices are correlated with population density and zoning regulations (i.e. see Hong Kong for ex.)

One thing to not forget is the amount of leverage provided for you in the housing market is disproportionate compared to the leverage you would get in stocks (20% down is 5x leverage, and there are some options to get in on a house with even less than that).

If you look at the real rate of return on everything (paper from 2017, analyzing the period between 1870 and 2015 in several developed countries), they claim the return on property is around 8% per year, which is comparable to stocks but with a lower variance.

A caveat though is that housing outperformed equity slightly 1870-1950, and equity has outperformed 1950-today. Housing is also a very locale-specific thing, since there is no global private 'housing' market you can invest in.

https://www.frbsf.org/economic-research/files/wp2017-25.pdf

pashamur··on S&P Dow Jones Indices to launch cryptocurrency indexes in 2021
That's also ignoring the cost of capital, as leveraging risk adjusted returns has to take that into account. You don't get the same rate of return if you use margin, say, in order to leverage.

If you use a 3x or other leveraged fund, then you run into tracking issues (look at https://www.etf.com/etfanalytics/etf-comparison/SPXL-vs-SPY) where you see tracking break down), you can lose everything (remember XIV?), and you have other potential issues.

So it's not as simple as leveraging up a low-risk portfolio to assume a given risk/return ratio. There's also diversification to keep in mind.

pashamur··on S&P Dow Jones Indices to launch cryptocurrency indexes in 2021
Even domain names follow the same pattern - in the last decade there has been a huge number of new domain extensions that have been approved for use; if you go to namecheap these days you have hundreds of options for your personal site.

Yet the vast majority will still use .com, .net and .org, and those still remain the most valuable. :)

pashamur··on Bitcoin Price Hits All-Time High of $19,786, Topping 2017 Record
Holding stocks is also a hedge on the USD, not unlike bitcoin.

Perhaps the market is expecting more money printing.

pashamur··on Bitcoin Price Hits All-Time High of $19,786, Topping 2017 Record
Generally house prices are a ~somewhat decent proxy for asset inflation which is driven by monetary policy; I believe the low rates have definitely driven inflation in housing prices (and the gamma squeeze argument above does not apply to the housing market).

Part of the reason we've had an insane housing market valuation growth over the last ~40 years is that cost of capital has gone down from ~15% to 2.5% over that time frame. If rates were near the historical average right now, you would see very different asset prices.

pashamur··on A Worsening Culture War
Well, the other party had four years in power (and previously many years as the opposition) to propose a viable alternative plan; however, that proposal is nowhere to be found.

There were some small things like price transparency and attempts at regulating drug pricing, but nothing on the scale of a large-enough transformation that is necessary.

pashamur··on WTF Happened in 1971? (2019)
Obligatory Paul Graham article about that period, since we are on HN: http://www.paulgraham.com/re.html
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →