HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

paulfurley

272 karma · joined October 18, 2013

Paul Fawkesley (born Furley)

Me:

* https://paul.fawkesley.com * https://mastodon.me.uk/@paul

submissionscomments
paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
Identifiers in DHCP requests is a really good point, thanks for raising this. I'll do some captures and see what my client is revealing.
paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
The capture would occur inside the router. You can just dump its ARP table which translates between MAC and IP address.

"If you're on your home network, this has no impact what so ever." Yes, I'm fairly happy with my own tracking policies :D

paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
Amazing!!
paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
No, because they use the 'locally administered' prefix [1]. This is deliberate in order not to collide with real existing MAC addresses. (The original version of the post used real, Intel MAC prefixes [2] and you can look in the gist revision for that code if you prefer.)

BTW if it's really the feds you're worried about, this article probably isn't for you.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MAC_address#Universal_vs._loca...

[2] https://github.com/paulfurley/www.paulfurley.com/commit/bebc...

paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
If anyone here's involved developing NetworkManager, it would be brilliant to see a 'stable-for-n-days' type setting. This would prevent a WiFi network tracking you over time, as well as between networks.
paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
Unless you're using Ubuntu 16.04 LTS, in which case you're stuck with NetworkManager 1.2.

From the post: "I learned that NetworkManager 1.4.1+ can do MAC address randomization right out the box. If you’re using Ubuntu 17.04 upwards, you can get most of the way with this config file."

paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
There's probably a one-liner in Linux too, but not one which satisfies the three caveats in the post.
paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
I believe iPhones and Android phones only do it while in scanning mode. Once connected, they use the real MAC address.
paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
Or to be more precise, those access points probably need a consistent mac, not your real one. So it would be nice if you could configure those networks to receive their own mac, but that stays the same over time. This is what the NetworkManager 1.4.1+ "stable" setting does.
paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
Good tip, thanks for linking to this.
paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
Yep, feel free to modify to spoof a real hardware MAC address (as the original version of my blog post suggested: https://github.com/paulfurley/www.paulfurley.com/commit/bebc...)

As @_fink on Twitter pointed out, colliding with a real existing MAC address is not ideal.

paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
I also used macchanger in the past but it seems that recent versions of NetworkManager overwrite the changes that macchanger makes.
paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
Yes, in network manager 1.4.1+ (ubuntu 17.04+) you can set each network to `random` or `stable` as well as a global default for new networks. This config file updates the global default (but I can't use it yet!): https://gist.github.com/paulfurley/978d4e2e0cceb41d67d017a66...
paulfurley··on Randomize your WiFi MAC address on Ubuntu
True - I could update the script to allow for whitelisting certain networks so they receive a stable-forever MAC address..?
paulfurley··on Barclays and Halifax are misguided and unethical for disallowing rooted phones
I'd be interested to know what other software professionals think of this.

I believe policies like Halifax's and Barclays' nudge us towards a world of software jaildom - and I don't think this is the direction we should aim for.

Paul

paulfurley··on Ask HN: Critique my startup: ZeroTier One
I find it really useful as a (nearly) zero-config way of accessing devices behind a NAT box.

Even my work internet connection is behind a carrier-grade-NAT box so I can't even port forward. I use it to access our Jenkins server which is physically located inside the building.

It's particularly useful for 2 reasons:

- each machine gets a very stable IP (unlike DHCP-assigned addresses) which simplifies hosts files / dnsmasq etc - it's better than port forwarding as every device can work on port 80

So my use case would be something like "simple LAN setup with no more port forwarding"

paulfurley··on I'm being blocked by BT
Thanks for the tip, and I feel your pain in being blocked. Does the Open Rights Group have any advice on what to do in this case? I wonder if there's a reasonably low cost/effort legal avenue you could pursue against BT?

My feeling is that bad blocking behaviour can be challenged if we make it expensive enough for them to make mistakes like this, so we (and affected organisations with bigger budgets) should do everything we can to make their lives difficult.

Paul

← PreviousPage 2 of 2