HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

paulluuk

930 karma · joined June 13, 2019

submissionscomments
paulluuk··on Xiaomi MiMo Reasoning Model
I assume they mean "Reinforcement Learning", and it's been a decade since I studied AI in university, but isn't it perfectly valid to just say "RL"? What kind of specificity are you looking for, whether they used Q-Learning or some other algorithm?
paulluuk··on Uber raises in-office requirement to 3 days, claws back remote workers
Unless startups with remote talent can't get funding, because investors look at big companies and thinking that if Uber, Apple, Amazon, Meta, Google think having in-office employees is better, there must be a good reason for it.

But I don't know if that's how investors think?

paulluuk··on Reality Check
There's Financial Times, Forbes, tons of reddit posts, youtube videos.. I suppose it's possible that he's the only blogger doing this, but as far as I can see he is not the only one crunching profit numbers on the most "visible" company in the world.
paulluuk··on Reality Check
> I don't know why I'm the one writing what I'm writing, and I frequently feel weird that I, a part-time blogger and podcaster, am writing the things that I'm writing.

I can't tell whether this man actually believes that he is the only one critiquing AI? I mean.. I can barely walk 2 feet without tripping over anti-AI blogs, posts, news articles, youtube videos or comments.

paulluuk··on DeepMind releases Lyria 2 music generation model
It depends; if you do that job or career for fun, then keep doing it! If you do that job because you like contributing to society and not because you like the job itself, then find another way to contribute to society.

Even in a scenario where all jobs are taken by AGI (a utopia if we can get rid of capitalism and wealth, but a dystopia if the billionaire class is the only one that benefits), you could do something as profound as raising children, or something as social as organizing music and art festivals.

paulluuk··on DeepMind releases Lyria 2 music generation model
Thanking of yourself as "redundant" limits your view of a human to that of a machine, and in doing so you are doing humanity a great disservice. I'd recommend reading the Culture series for a vision of a future where AI has essentially taken over and humans can live out their lives as they want instead of as they need to.
paulluuk··on Shortest-possible walking tour to 81,998 bars in South Korea
I think your astronomy skills are correct, but if we have to worry about actual travel then you would also have to consider things like fuel capacity, refuel opportunities, the fact that you probably don't want to actually fly through a star but around it, etc.
paulluuk··on SpacetimeDB
YouTube keeps recommending SpacetimeDB to me even though I have never made a videogame. Now I'm seeing it on HN too.

Are there any game devs here who can comment on how useful this actually is? The pitch seems pretty cool but I can't tell how much of it is just good marketing.

paulluuk··on An image of an archeologist adventurer who wears a hat and uses a bullwhip
I don't think that's true at all. There might be (and probably are) tens of thousands of artists creating masterful artwork at home.

But you're talking about PAID artwork, and yes: when it comes to paid art, money does matter.

You can't expect artists to completely ignore financial incentives, and at the same time expect the creative industry to just throw lots of money at these artists. That's just not how (capitalist) businesses work.

The world absolutely does care for super high quality artwork. But very few people are willing to pay $2000 for a movie ticket when they could also go to 100 $20 movies.

On top of that: who gets to decide what is high quality, anyway? The creative world is fraught with corruption, elitism and "who knows who", making it very unlikely that a highly talented artist is ever even "discovered".

It's a lot more complicated then just "money is all that matters".

And finally: I don't think this "trend" is just in the western world. Show me a place in the world where artists are rewarded based on purely the quality of their work, rather than the profitability of their work.

paulluuk··on An image of an archeologist adventurer who wears a hat and uses a bullwhip
There is a huge middle ground between "static image with another sliding static image" and "1 year of drawing per 4 second Ghibli masterpiece". From your comment is almost looks like you're suggesting that you have to choose either one or the other, but that is of course not true.

I bet that a good animator could make a really impressive 4-second scene if they were given a month, instead of a year. Possibly even if they were given a day.

So if we assume that there is not a binary "cheap animation vs masterpiece" but rather a sort of spectrum between the two, then the question is: at what point do enough people stop seeing the difference, that it makes economic sense to stay at that level, if the goal is to create as much high-quality content as possible?

paulluuk··on The case against conversational interfaces
I'm also curious about this -- I'm pretty sure that I think actual words at about the speed at which I can speak them. I can not speak 3000 words per minute.

I also have my doubts about the numbers put forward on reading, listening and speaking. When reading, again I can read words about as fast as I can speak words. When I'm reading, I am essentially speaking out the words but in my mind. Is that not how other people read?

paulluuk··on LLM providers on the cusp of an 'extinction' phase as capex realities bite
I could be wrong, but I believe Amazon's business model was very simple: do everything as cheaply as possible, run at a loss until all competition is dead, and then raise prices once we dominate the market.

I don't think OpenAI has that option.

paulluuk··on The average college student today
I won't go into whether this is "yet another old person complaining about young people", I do not know whether this is a valid complaint or not. Instead, I just want to comment on some of what is mentioned here.

For context, I want to reveal a little bit of private information. I grew up in a family that was somewhere between lower class and middle class. My parents found out (or perhaps decided?) that I was quite intelligent as a child. And so they really wanted me to go to university, become part of the "educated elite", and make them proud. Whenever I would do anything that was "smart", I could feel their love and appreciation. I internalized this as "smart = loved". So when I started to struggle in school, because it turned out that you need more than just intelligence but also effort, I stopped trying. In hindsight, I realized that I would rather be seen as a lazy genius than as hardworking average student. Could I have been a hardworking genius? No, I'm pretty intelligent compared to most people, but I'm not a Mensa member or anything (despite the lack of trying -- how does geography knowledge end up on an intelligence test, anyway?). I did end up finishing high school at the highest level, and then got a university bachelors, but the whole process took about 1.5x as many years as it's supposed to, because I treated actual exams as practice exams, and I'd sometimes pass them on the "retry" (usually I did not, but I'd pass them the next year). Suffice to say, I am filled with self-shame and anguish whenever anyone even brings up the topic of education.

so, with that out of the way so you can better choose how much to value my opinions, I want to discuss a few points:

> Attendance is a HUGE problem

Is it really a problem, though? God I wish that my classes were recorded, like so many other studies' classes were. I had a pretty bad sleeping disorder, and having to go to class each day at 9 am, expected to be at peak intellectual level, was really hard for me. It's much better now that I'm working, but still I'm at my best around 11 AM. How I envied students who could watch classes at 6 pm, or whenever they felt like it, and even having the option to re-watch classes!

> I’m supposed to believe that they suddenly, urgently need the toilet, but the reality is that they are going to look at their phones. They know I’ll call them out on it in class, so instead they walk out.

Just let them watch their phones in class, then. If you really want them to act as adults, let them choose their own priorities.

> I am frequently asked for my PowerPoint slides, which basically function for me as lecture notes. It is unimaginable to me that I would have ever asked one of my professors for their own lecture notes. No, you can’t have my slides. Get the notes from a classmate.

Why the hell not? What is the point of this? Is this a hierarchy/power thing? Why would notes from a classmate be better than, you know, teachings from their teacher?

> I hate laptops in class, but if I try to ban them the students will just run to Accommodative Services and get them to tell me that the student must use a laptop or they will explode into tiny pieces.

Okay so two things: making notes on a laptop is fine, it's no worse than writing on a notebook. Yes, I know that there are some supposed benefits to the hand-eye coordination from writing, but I can't imagine that that's what you care about. No you're probably annoyed by the fact that they are choosing to do different things on their laptop while in your class. But as I said above, just let them. It's their own responsibility to pay attention, and it's neither your obligation nor your right to treat them as children. Instead, consider why these students might be "checking out". Why are they in this class if they just want to gamble and watch memes? Could it be that they are being pressured into being here and that they are desperately trying to "cheat" the system into expressing themselves? Could it be that this hierarchical system where they are supposedly "adults" they still find themselves being stuck in this boring structure where education staff have become their new parents is not the best way for them to find out what they want to do with their lives? I was a bored, distracted student like this. If I could go to university again (I could, but it's exprensive -- not just because costs are high, but much more so because it means missing years of income) I would probably be an excellent student now -- but it would be because I choose to be a student. I never chose to be a student, except that I "chose" to go along with expectactions, and I know that many fellow students felt the same. These people are adults, yes, but they're also still on the same "school child" mindset that they have been on since they were 4 years old. They can't wait to finally be done and actually, you know, live. Okay that was a long rant.

> No, you can’t make up the midterm because you were hungover and slept through your alarm, but you can if you had Covid. Then they just don’t show up. A missed quiz from a month ago might as well have happened in the Stone Age; students can’t be bothered to make it up or even talk to me about it because they just don’t care.

Okay this opinion is probably way out there, but: why not? If a test is supposed to just be a measure to determine if a student has absorbed the provided information, then why not allow them to take the test because they missed the first one from being hungover? Why have them wait a FULL YEAR to take the class again, if it's entirely possible that they have already absorbed all the information? The article complains about bored students who have "checked out". Gee, with this kind of mindset, I wonder why?

> One thing all faculty have to learn is that the students are not us.

BUT THEY ARE, though! Just younger versions. From their perspective, they are told pretty much "yeah you're adults now, but before you can begin your life, you have to finish this 3-5 year degree, which will be pretty much exactly as the last 15 years of your life have been but now classes are optional and you'll rake up huge debts in the process that you might be able to pay back over the next 15 years". These are not 40 year olds who had a succesful degree and are now, of their own volition, deciding to study something that truely interests them. These are young adults who are not just studying something that they pray will be interesting to them (because how will they know before starting?) and in the meantime are also dealing with finally having some private freedom -- like renting their own apartment, having relationships, finally being able to drink all night and not have to worry about waking up mom, and whatever else comes with that. I know several people like that who ended up becoming professors at a university, so yes they are very much like you. Trying to make them "the others" doesn't do either of you any good.

> Yes, I know some texts, especially in the sciences, are expensive. However, the books I assign are low-priced. All texts combined for one of my courses is between $35-$100 and they still don’t buy them.

why isn't the teacher just providing these books for free in PDF form? Teachers who require students to read the books that they are selling has always felt very bad to me: the teachers have this weird conflict of interest because they can set any price for their books and the students will have to buy it because otherwise they can't complete their degree. I mean, depending on the country (I'm not american), I know some students are already paying over 60k per year - why does that not include the teacher's required textbook? why is it that someone who has no money, who is given a scholarship to attend university, might still fail due to having no money?

Alright, that concludes my rant. Clearly I've been very triggered by this post. As a final note: I want to say that I wish that I had had competent LLMs when I was studying. Textbooks are often written by extremely verbose and long-winded people, which perhaps is not true for the author, but I too really struggled with reading those. And not just because they were long and boring, but also because simple explanations are just much more effective ways to explain complex themes. LLMs are AMAZING at breaking down complicated topics into smaller ones that you can understand, and more importantly, it can tell you in a way that you understand, it "speaks your language" if you will. It's like having a private tutor. Students should be thriving right now because they all got private tutors! Amazing! But instead, the field of education is failing to capitalize on this and is only capable to seeing how it's a problem for the way things have been done in the past. Adapt! Learn! Improve! Don't be complacent, consider that AI might be a tool that can help you teach: encourage students to use it! Find a new way to teach that capitalizes on this amazing new tool in humanity's collective toolbelt.

Alright now my rant really is concluded, haha.

paulluuk··on How Kerala got rich
I think that in almost all western countries, a life spent entirely on hoarding wealth for the sake of wealth, is considered a sad life. Especially if you don't even have any loved ones to share your wealth with.

I think the same it true for most of Latin america, where many of my friends and colleagues are from. And when I was in Nepal they thought that, if anything, western people are way too much focused on gathering wealth.

Islam specifically rejects hoarding wealth, so I think that pretty much takes out most of the middle east and northern africa.

So I'm curious which other cultures you are referring to. Perhaps specifically Indian and Chinese culture?

paulluuk··on How to write blog posts that developers read
Tiny nitpick: instead of using the nested circle diagram, I feel like a venn diagram would be more accurate. I don't think that all developers are blog readers.
paulluuk··on First Known Photographs of Living Specimens
From the page linked:

> First photographic records of already described (but obviously relatively uncommon or cryptic) species

paulluuk··on First Known Photographs of Living Specimens
They're not exactly "relatively uncommon or cryptic"
paulluuk··on Extracting DNA from the air – DNA evidence of human occupancy in indoor premises
> just a contamination during the autopsy.

How does sperm end up on her body during the autopsy? Are we talking necrophilia or are there multiple murdered bodies laying next to each other and the tools are re-used or something?

paulluuk··on East Asian personality may stem from Ice Age Siberia 20000 yrs ago
I don't understand your comment -- are you implying the holocaust didn't happen or wasn't genocide? I want to steelman your argument but it's pretty hard.

Your other point is that you wonder whether a paper review is going to protect against mass killing. I'd say yes, that's quite possible. Anyone can post almost anything they want on any kind of blog or 4chan sub or reddit sub, and that's fine. But scientific papers are what people quote as "truth", and publishers have some responsibility in making sure that what they publish is based in evidence. This is especially true when it concerns topics that have, historically, led to genocide.

paulluuk··on East Asian personality may stem from Ice Age Siberia 20000 yrs ago
I can't judge whether this is a good paper or not, and I think it's really cool that someone with only a bachelors degree (like myself) can get a paper published without first doing a PhD.

However, the anti-"woke" part of this article seems so odd to me. Given all the wacky "science" from Nazi scientists that "research" differences between races leading to genocide, it seems completely logical to me that you jump through several hoops and make sure your research is really sound before you publish a paper that explores exactly that topic.

paulluuk··on 40% of Britons haven't read a single book in the last 12 months
I love reading and other intellectual activities, so I’m by no means anti-intellectual.

But I do abhor elitism - whether cultural or intellectual. I reject the idea that 'high culture' defines intelligence or value, and by extension, I question whether we can truly measure the intellectual level of a society based purely on how many (or which) books they read.

You're right that physical exercise is somewhat tangential to this discussion. My point wasn’t to distract but to challenge the idea that book-reading is the sole meaningful metric for personal or societal development.

paulluuk··on 40% of Britons haven't read a single book in the last 12 months
I know right?! It's so good, but I don't know anyone who has read it, haha. I'll pick up your recommendation for sure.
paulluuk··on 40% of Britons haven't read a single book in the last 12 months
But why does that have to be reading?

Why can't it be meditation, programming, working out, listening to music, fishing, mountain climbing, going for a walk, or something similar?

Why the focus on reading in particular, as if it were some great act? What if someone only reads books written for the MAGA crowd, is that something that many young men are missing in their lives?

paulluuk··on 40% of Britons haven't read a single book in the last 12 months
So, I listen to about 25 audiobooks per year (mostly fantasy and sci-fi, with a few political, popular science or popular economics book sprinkled between). I'm quite happy about that, because it's something that I can do in bed, while travelling to/from work, while doing groceries, etc.

You might say that it's my "escape from reality".

But.. well.. who cares? I don't think that my unending love for Dungeon Crawler Carl is somehow making me a better person.

I think that something much more relevant is how much exercise people get, how many people do weekly sports or exercise for example? And that's something that the Hacker News crowd in particular will likely score worse on then how many books they read per year.

paulluuk··on Age and cognitive skills: Use it or lose it
Though is that causation or correlation? I can imagine that people with all kinds of illnesses would also retire sooner than people who are still in peak health.
paulluuk··on DOGE has 'god mode' access to government data
> they are not linking personal data between agencies

> Trump has prohibited Musk from being involved in with the review in agencies where he was a material conflict

I'm not saying these are or aren't happening, but it seems like a lot of "good faith" assumptions here. If you assume Musk is an unethical actor, these seem mostly meaningless.

paulluuk··on Magma: A foundation model for multimodal AI agents
"Pick Place Hotdog Sausage" is such a bizarre name, though. Is it meant to be human readable? AI-readable? Just a label for the researchers? Same with "Put Mushroom Place Pot". As far as I can see both labels are only used in this Magma paper, nowhere else that Google can find.
paulluuk··on NASA has a list of 10 rules for software development
I'm curious, how does that perspective make the avoidance of recursion more compelling?
paulluuk··on Why young parents should focus on building trust with their kids
I think their point is that you can not just say "children in china like math" or "children in france will drink wine", because those are stereotypes and there are many examples of children within those countries who do not conform.

They say that there are differences between even children living on two different roads in the same town, and these differences matter more than differences between countries, and therefore we should not make any kind of arguments based on nationality at all.

I disagree though, I do think that there are significant statistical differences growing up between, say, Afghanistan or Sweden. That does not mean that you can make claims about specific children in either country, but you can make generalizations about the population as a whole.

paulluuk··on Craftax: (Crafter and NetHack) RL Environment in Jax
Cool project, can we submit models without writing an accompanying paper to go with it?

Though I have to say, using RL to mean "Reinforcement Learning" but also talk about "Roguelike" games (also abbreviated "RL" most of the time) is very confusing.

← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →