HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pavelrub

845 karma · joined September 19, 2013

submissionscomments
pavelrub··on AlphaGo beats Lee Sedol again in match 2 of 5
This doesn't seem to be the main reason why Go is harder than chess for computers. It was noted that even in 9x9 Go, with a comparable branching factor to Chess, traditional Go programs are still no stronger than on big boards. The main difficulty for Go is that it is much harder to evaluate board positions. So in Chess the depth of the search can be significantly reduced by using a reasonable evaluation function, whereas in Go no such function seems to exist.
pavelrub··on AlphaGo beats Lee Sedol again in match 2 of 5
AlphaGo has already played millions of games against AlphaGo during the reinforcement learning stage.
pavelrub··on Unilateral Israeli changes to Stuxnet caused its exposure, angering US
> The almost total control of US Foreign policy ...

Which US foreign policy decisions in the past 10 years were "controlled" by Israel? Sanctions on Russia? Missile defence system in Europe? North Korea? Relations with China? War on Terror? Libya campaign? US non-response to the "Arab spring"? Campaign in Syria? Drone strikes in Pakistan? Relations with Latin America? War on Drugs? Spying on Angela Merkel?

Literally nothing of what the US did in the last decade had anything to do with Israel. Even when it comes to Iran - which Israeli leaders considered to be an existential threat - Israel completely failed to influence the US foreign policy.

pavelrub··on Unilateral Israeli changes to Stuxnet caused its exposure, angering US
> The US gets less than what Israel gets out of the relationship.

That's like saying having a hamster is an unfair relationship because the hamster gets a lot more out of it than you do.

pavelrub··on The NSA’s machine learning algorithm may be killing thousands of innocent people
> The reasonable thing to do with that information, would be to surveil them further, search their house, or arrest them. Not assassinate them without a trial.

Which seems to be exactly the case. Ahmad Zaidan, for example, wasn't assassinated. In fact even if the algorithm was 100% correct - it makes no sense to assassinate people solely based on whether they are terrorists or not. A lot more can be gained from surveilling some of them, etc'.

So there is really nothing at all to suggest that those algorithms alone are used to create kill lists.

pavelrub··on The NSA’s machine learning algorithm may be killing thousands of innocent people
> However we have no assurance that this tool was not used to generate kill targets without any human input.

That's absurd. We also have no assurance that the NSA isn't communicating with aliens to generate kill lists of people who will oppose the alien invasion of 2021, though we do have common sense to filter out such absurd scenarios. "We have no assurance that this isn't so" isn't an argument.

pavelrub··on Ignition: An Informal History of Liquid Rocket Propellants (1972) [pdf]
This is one of the books that Elon Musk recommended (http://www.adweek.com/galleycat/the-science-fiction-books-th...)
pavelrub··on I feel therefore I am
Materialism doesn't explain anything. Materialism isn't science, nor does it provide any scientific theories or models (in fact even Karl Popper was a dualist). Materilism is a metaphysical belief that paints a philosophical veneer on top of the world, and offers no practical applications whatsoever. No scientific theory loses its validity if one suddenly stops believing in materialism. Materalism is also probably either obviously false (eliminative materialism) or a meaningless tautology (Hempel's dilemma), depending on what specific flavour of materialism you prefer. However the same can perhaps be said about dualism and idealism as well (I'm certain that idealism is false, and less certain about dualism because I know much less about it).

The reason why so many westerners believe in materialism today is because scientism has poisoned their minds and they cannot understand the difference between science and philosophy, and they aren't aware of the hidden metaphysical assumptions upon which their worldview rests. However among philosophy departments, there are probably much less materialists today than there were 50 years ago.

Personally I think people should ignore the entire materialist/dualist debate, and go read Wittgenstein instead (or Peter Hacker).

pavelrub··on The Secret Power of ‘Read It Later’ Apps
Many apps do this. Instapaper, Pocket and others. Amazon even have their own "send to kindle" browser extension.
pavelrub··on Magic Leap reveals more details about its technology
If you can project it into an eye, why wouldn't you be able to project it into a camera?
pavelrub··on Inside the Creation of the Microsoft Surface Book
Why can't you use it with the screen reversed like [1]?

[1] - http://www.windowscentral.com/sites/wpcentral.com/files/styl...

pavelrub··on Tesla Model X Launch event, livestream
Who is "they"? You think somebody is forcing Musk to do those presentations? Elon Musk is the CEO. He does the presentations himself because that's his decision and that's what he wants.
pavelrub··on Tesla’s $140,000 Model X SUV Does 0-60 in 3.2 Seconds
Only this wasn't their goal at all. The goal was to enable easy access to the back seats, which is something all modern SUVs lack.
pavelrub··on The Princeton Companion to Applied Mathematics
Nice! This book is modeled after the The Princeton Companion to Mathematics [1] which is simply awesome in every sense of the word, and extremely recommended for any person who is interested in mathematics.

I'm very glad to see more books being modeled after it, and I hope this trend will continue with things beyond math. My only hope is that those new books will match the quality of the original.

[1] - http://www.amazon.com/Princeton-Companion-Mathematics-Timoth...

pavelrub··on Study: Experiencing awe affects the way you treat people
After all the talk about reproducibility problems in psychological studies, and especially after reading examples such as the following from [1]:

> A while ago, Dijksterhuis and van Knippenberg published a famous priming study showing that people who spend a few minutes before an exam thinking about brilliant professors will get better grades; conversely, people who spend a few minutes thinking about moronic soccer hooligans will get worse ones. They did four related experiments, and all strongly confirmed their thesis. A few years later, Shanks et al tried to replicate the effect and couldn’t. They did the same four experiments, and none of them replicated at all.

My natural reaction is to take any such study with a grain of salt.

[1] - http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/09/05/if-you-cant-make-predic...

pavelrub··on SpaceX CRS-5 Webcast
From Musk's AMA on reddit:

Q: Previously, you've stated that you estimate a 50% probability of success with the attempted landing on the automated spaceport drone ship tomorrow. Can you discuss the factors that were considered to make that estimation?

A: I pretty much made that up. I have no idea :)

pavelrub··on SpaceX CRS-5 Webcast
Expected launch timeline:

T-0:00:00: Liftoff

T+0:01:10: Mach 1

T+0:01:23: Max Q (maximum aerodynamic pressure)

T+0:02:37: MECO (main engine cutoff)

T+0:02:41: Stage 1 Separation

T+0:02:49: Stage 2 Ignition

T+0:03:29: Nose Cone Jettison

T+0:09:00: First Stage Landing

T+0:09:27: SECO (second engine cutoff)

T+0:10:02: Dragon Separation

T+0:12:00: Solar Array Deployment

Landing barge location: http://www.vesselfinder.com/?mmsi=367017460

Additional streaming options:

- Youtube official stream: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ohnnl4nOcGU

- NASA stream: http://www.ustream.tv/nasahdtv

- Spaceflightnow stream: http://www.livestream.com/spaceflightnow

pavelrub··on How Possibilities of Life Elsewhere Might Alter Held Notions of Faith
> What's the point on logically arguing from a position of faith anyway? Doesn't that defeat the point?

What point is that? On the contrary - it is necessary for certain "beliefs" be exempt from doubt in order for any logical discourse to be possible in the first place.

When historians are trying to reconcile contradictions in ancient texts in order to better understand history, it makes little sense (for most people) to say "I wonder if any of these historians will ever change the direction of their logic. It's funny that things like this are said 'How to reconcile those contradictions?", and not 'if contradictions exist, is it possible that none of it happened, and the entire universe along with everything in it appeared 5 minutes ago?' ".

It isn't too hard to imagine that some people think of religion and the existence of god in the same way as others do about - for example - philosophical realism. It seems to "defeat the point" only because your "point" is drastically different from that of those people.

I recommend reading Wittgenstein's On Certainty [1] for a much more sophisticated treatment of similar ideas.

[1] - http://www.amazon.com/On-Certainty-English-German-Edition/dp...

pavelrub··on NASA Rover Finds Active and Ancient Organic Chemistry on Mars
> it seems awfully unlikely that none of them have done so yet.

Based on what? How did you estimate the probability of a random intelligent civilization sending detectable (from Earth) Von Nuemann probes into the universe? For a probability of 1/1000 there could be hundreds of intelligent civilizations within our galaxy without any such probes, and the probability can be much lower than that.

pavelrub··on CIA agents who tortured are vulnerable to prosecution in any country
The media uses the word "agent" to refer only to those who work in intelligence and defense agencies, so your explanation doesn't seem sufficient. And even if you are right - the word "agent" has a clear and different meaning in the context of intelligence, so at best this is a really bad choice of words.
pavelrub··on CIA agents who tortured are vulnerable to prosecution in any country
The UN isn't a nation-state. The US obviously acts to promote its own interests, as it should. It doesn't purport to be an objective and an unbiased protector of human rights across the globe. The UNHRC does, and that's the whole point of its existence.
pavelrub··on It's important that cultures disappear
The underlying assumption of this entire post is that "economic, innovation and productivity performance" is the most important thing in the world. Yet this "belief" in itself is nothing but a product of the culture the author lives in. There is nothing universal about it, nor is there any real reason to agree with it. Personally I couldn't care less about "efficiency" if it means things that I consider beautiful - such as the diversity in the world - has to go away.
pavelrub··on What does the NSA think of academic cryptographers?
Differential cryptanalysis was known to the NSA before IBM "discovered" it.
pavelrub··on Caltech professor claims Israeli spy infiltrated JPL
Well in that case I guess it's ok to downvote all those "tiring" comments.
pavelrub··on Caltech professor claims Israeli spy infiltrated JPL
Right. So that's why he was downvoted. And that's why every pro-Israeli comment in this discussion is being downvoted.
pavelrub··on Caltech professor claims Israeli spy infiltrated JPL
Well in that case you shouldn't have any trouble providing written evidence of people who have accused Israel of spying on the US, and as a result had their reputation and careers destroyed, and where labeled as "antisemitic terrorist sympathizers" or as terrorists.

It is you who have claimed that "nobody knows about it", and therefore it's neither obvious nor extensively written about, and it is you who holds the burden of proof.

pavelrub··on Caltech professor claims Israeli spy infiltrated JPL
I don't see anything at all in your comment that doesn't contribute to the discussion. The fact that you are downvoted on HN for just for stating an uncommon opinion is disgusting and extremely disappointing.
pavelrub··on Caltech professor claims Israeli spy infiltrated JPL
Please tell us exactly "how much" does Israel spy on America relative to other countries, based on what information, why is this "amazing", and provide some proof that "if you dare to say it publicly then your reputation and career are destroyed".

It's amazing how HNs usual standards of logical discourse seem to disappear once the argument becomes political.

pavelrub··on Caltech professor claims Israeli spy infiltrated JPL
The only source of your claim that "Israel is the number-one allied country spying in America" is a single Newsweek article from 2014, citing anonymous sources. Yet you treat it as an absolute fact. I don't remember anybody doing the same when Newsweek "exposed" Satoshi Nakamoto.

You claim that "any allegation of spying by whistleblowers is reacted by extreme retaliations", yet none of your source ([3], [4], [5]) support any of that. So what reasonable allegations of spying were in fact reacted by "extreme retaliations", considering that the above allegations were all reported by big and reputable news agencies in the US, gained quite a large exposure, and are remembered by many to this day?

It's quite common among people with anti-Israeli sentiments to make wild accusations and then explain away their unpopularity by appealing to some government pro-Israeli conspiracy. An alternative hypothesis, worth considering, is that the accusations are in fact baseless, and are unpopular exactly because of that.

I seriously doubt that it makes much sense for Israel - a tiny country surrounded by enemies, with a rather limited budget that is never enough for anything - to devote any significant part of its intelligence efforts to developing sources in the US, instead of - say - in Iran, Syria, Lebanon, etc'.

pavelrub··on Calculus with pics and gifs
"Machine" is an abstract term, not limited to Turing machines. Somebody who is just learning about functions has no understanding of what "computable" means, nor why should something be "uncomputable" according to some specific definition of a machine. We can invent in our minds all kinds of machines that don't exist in the real world: Oracle machines have existed in recursion theory since the time of Turing.

If f is a function that tells us if a given Turing machine halts on a given input, there is nothing wrong about imagining this as a machine that receives a string and outputs a True/False answer. That no such machine can exist in the real world under some physical interpretation of the Church-Turing thesis is just a further observation - it has nothing to do with the correctness or usefulness of this formulation.

← PreviousPage 6 of 10Next →