HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pcmoney

1,370 karma · joined April 2, 2018

submissionscomments
pcmoney··on A CS degree is better than teaching yourself how to code?
I am sorry but no.

All of that can be learned during your first internship where you get paid instead of paying.

I would argue college delays maturity and does not foster it. Hanging out with a bunch of people that are the same age, same life stage, etc. doesn't exactly add life experience. Continuing to do "hoop-jumping" work just like we all did in high school also doesn't seem to be novel. Perhaps its the keggers and binge drinking that bring the maturity the author references?

As for prestige, if its a top 10 program sure, otherwise (and often even then) don't waste your money.

Disclosure: Current engineering lead with multiple Degrees (1 Summa Cum Laude) and a bootcamp CS education at one point (which wasn't all that valuable).

pcmoney··on Don't Call Yourself a Programmer, and Other Career Advice (2011)
I would argue that it is the first thing a manager looking for a cost center, cog type engineer looks at. They are not looking for an engineer who actually understands business they are looking for a “ plumbing engineer” that just keeps their head down and grinds out code. There is little upside in this position and this type hiring manager mentality should filter those jobs out for you.

I do agree that most start ups will probably restrict them selves to hiring in the same stack as their tolerance for learning curves will be extremely short.

However, I feel that many employers are used to engineers who don’t “get business” and so they just want somebody to plunk down code. This leads them to “what kind of dumb cog/stack are you?” questions as they are already assuming they won’t be able to hire a truly “full stack” engineer who understands the revenues and costs associated with their work and how they impact corporate strategy etc.

pcmoney··on How to write fast code in Ruby on Rails
Is ruby that slow? I always understood it was comparable to python?

Plus if it is performant enough for Shopify and Github it seems like it would be performant for 90%+ of use cases? The speed of development and the flexibility of development is much greater than most stacks once you add rails.

pcmoney··on US Gen Z and the iMessage Lock-In
I do know that type of person and yes it is not fun. Or they recite all the specs of a new Android vs iPhone and how you are such an "idiot" for being an Apple sheep. When really you don't care that much and the price difference isn't significant. Not to mention side by side your iPhone is noticeably faster in a real world test of launching the same app, browsing etc.

Convincing those people that specs are mere indicators and do not matter in the face of objective UX...impossible.

Really comes down to what you are optimizing for.

pcmoney··on US Gen Z and the iMessage Lock-In
I don't think it is a social cues thing either. I switched back and forth between Droid and Apple for awhile until I read some fairly disturbing predictions on how all these personal data warehouses could be used to digitally enslave us. I am not sure it is a social cues things, although I will concede frothing at the mouth Android and Apple fans are not people I like to be around.

TBH the biggest driver towards Apple for me (aside from privacy) is now that I am older and have kids and more responsibilities at work and don't have time to tinker I don't want to have to figure out what the best messaging app for my phone is. (I gave up using Linux in favor of MacOS as well for similar reasons).

(Cue all the neckbeard Linux/Droid guys without a family or kids saying "its not hard you just need to...<vaporize 30 minutes of your Saturday or evening>")

pcmoney··on US Gen Z and the iMessage Lock-In
Last I checked:

Actual text of convo: not yet but soon. Metadata: yes.

pcmoney··on US Gen Z and the iMessage Lock-In
But the flip side of all those choices are all massive privacy invasions or security risks.

Apple App Store is a walled Garden but the Banking App you get from the Apple Store is guaranteed to be the actual app from the bank it says it is. (https://www.forbes.com/sites/zakdoffman/2019/06/24/google-pl...) Plus the apps on the App Store are often of much higher quality than the Google Play store because of how much more revenue app developers can make on the Apple Store and the better demographics there for most company's targeted audiences.

Apple's voice software is worse because it doesn't do as much machine learning off device and it doesn't try to learn as much about you and communicate it home.

I haven't found any "TV box" to work all that well with a phone. AppleTV does seem to be comparable to others.

These are all trade-offs and subject to the individuals preferences. But saying Non-Apple products don't also "force you" or have trade-offs is misleading.

pcmoney··on US Gen Z and the iMessage Lock-In
I am super excited for the Librem Phone project but still think it is a way off from being a viable phone for most people.
pcmoney··on US Gen Z and the iMessage Lock-In
It does sell your data and is not secure.

What $750 dongle? You can get an iPhone for like $300 these days.

Forces itself into your life? How? Apple's data security is better than literally every other smart phone provider and its OS is fundamentally less intrusive than Android.

pcmoney··on US Gen Z and the iMessage Lock-In
It is 100% a Facebook product. It is FB. I 100% guarantee all data mined from your WhatsApp account is linked either to your FB account or your shadow FB account if you never signed up.

Sure maybe the "experience" hasn't changed from a UI standpoint but FB is weakening WhatsApp's end to end encryption and mining your conversations so under the hood the experience is radically different.

There is a reason the founders of WhatsApp quit FB post acquisition (literally leaving hundreds of millions of dollars behind) in disgust over the privacy abuses Facebook was proposing. https://www.cnbc.com/2018/09/26/whatsapp-co-founder-explains...

pcmoney··on US Gen Z and the iMessage Lock-In
They never had a monetization plan and don't charge for use and their last re-design was in 2012? How do you think they make money? Either they don't and they are going to disappear soon or they do and they are just another data pimp.

They got bought by Skype awhile back which is being shelved in favor of Teams. I bet MSFT shuts it down once it remembers it still exists.

pcmoney··on US Gen Z and the iMessage Lock-In
It is interesting that the comments on the Twitter thread are "Just use WhatsApp". Which is basically iMessage but from Facebook. Comparing two, the vendor lock-in from Apple seems much preferable to the one with Facebook in light of the data scandals Facebook has and their ongoing effort to backdoor WhatsApp and integrate it with FB messenger etc. Also a group message is only as secure as its most weakly encrypted member and sms definitely loses there vs iMessage.

I would rather have Apple win the network effect here vs another data pimp like Google (who, ads aside, can't be trusted to maintain any communication platform).

I would much rather this all be standardized with end to end encryption protocols. (C'mon Signal!)

pcmoney··on Snap CEO Named a Chief Business Officer, Then Changed His Mind
I sort of feel like this is par for the course with SNAP. It seems to me to be a rather scummy company that got lucky despite its original intentions of encouraging people to send nudes (which is pretty sleazy IMO). The CEO as far as I can tell has never said or done anything that I would consider noble or respect worthy. His emails before he was in the public eye really show his true character. Obviously his word is worth less than nothing. Can’t wait for the company to die, just bummed that little snot got rich from it.
pcmoney··on iPhones are hard to use
I wholeheartedly agree that more accessibility focus and ease of adoption for novices is something the industry as a whole should focus on.

Historically large manuals do not help users use the device better. Ex. How well do you know how to use the advanced features of your microwave?

I would say apple is the least bad at this. They offer classes, every release has “What is new” progressions when you launch. Over time this is going to be an increasingly difficult challenge, as tech develops on a platform it builds on its previous patterns. You get to the point where some competence is assumed (correctly or wrongly). When I get into a car there is no display that tells me “this is a steering wheel, it turns the wheels in proportion to how much you twist it”.

pcmoney··on iPhones are hard to use
I disagree unless you are saying: 1. Only iPhones can adjust text size. 2. Only iPhones have mapping functionality 3. Only iPhones have a voice activated digital assistant. 4. Only iPhone have a health app.

These are all common smart phone features. They only pertain to iphones because of the title and the author uses specific examples of otherwise generic problems in the context of iphone use.

I would say only iPhones have apple stores with classes specifically geared towards teaching the novice user how to use their phones.

pcmoney··on iPhones are hard to use
I disagree unless you are saying: 1. Only iPhones can adjust text size. 2. Only iPhones have mapping functionality 3. Only iPhones have a voice activated digital assistant. 4. Only iPhone have a health app.

These are all common smart phone features. They only pertain to iphones because of the title and the author uses specific examples of otherwise generic problems in the context of iphone use.

I would say only iPhones have apple stores with classes specifically geared towards teaching the novice user how to use their phones.

pcmoney··on iPhones are hard to use
Ok, I need to say it. This article just has iPhone in the title to get more views. This is a problem with not just all smartphones but all rapidly evolving technology products. Do you think you could hand an android phone to one of those example cases and have them do any better with it?

Also half of the time I am in an apple store I am helped by someone who needs to use the accessibility features to check me out/in. I think it is awesome that Apple dog foods their products that way.

pcmoney··on As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and blame follow
Ya I think thats a calculation many families have to make. I strongly agree with the other comment in terms of opportunity cost years down the road. I really see this with a lot of our friends. The wife often quits her job and stays home because our society really makes it hard to work as the mom of an infant and biologically that is typically easier (don’t even get me started on the cost of formula vs breastmilk). But they do miss out on those critical career years. Luckily we are both software engineers at well paying jobs and so the daycare isn’t as much as an issue for us. But it is hard to see others have to make these really hard decisions, so I guess I am outraged on their behalf. It is especially brutal because of most of the women leaving their careers haven’t finished paying off student loans. In this era of gender equality we have constructed a financial system where it doesn’t make fiscal sense for many women to get a college degree if they want kids. Anecdotally, teachers can’t afford to work and have a kid and nurses just barely can. These are by no means bad careers and its really just a very tough situation, not all of of us can be software engineers making Facebook/Twitter apps.
pcmoney··on As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and blame follow
$160 a week?! ROFL. Try $450/wk for full time day care. This is in a non-coastal, non-major city for standard licensed day care, not Montessori or high end. Standard rate in the town I live in, could maybe save $50/month if I doubled my commute. Waitlist for daycare? 8months+. We enrolled shortly after we conceived.
pcmoney··on Ask HN: Is Ruby on Rails still worth learning?
Usual personal opinion caveats

Ok, simply rails is a tool. It is a well worn tool. Can do a lot of things and a lot of people know how to use it. Learning how to use it has been done many many times before so the path to competence is really smooth and straight forward.

I think it is worth learning because: 1) the community, you would be hard pressed to find a more diverse, welcoming, non-neck beard programming community. 2) resources, there are a lot of them. You will not encounter a problem that someone hasn’t solved for 3) fun, ruby is really nice and doesn’t fight you. Some features are debatable (meta programming, everything is an object, it’s GIL implementation etc) and I think all dynamic languages downsides are most noticeable in large code bases. But for your stated use case it’s great.

I strongly recommend the hartle rails tutorial. I convinced a friend to drop out of his math PhD and go through it. Do I think he will stay a rails programmer? No, but picking up python is a cinch after rails and there is no equivalently good python tutorial for teaching technical fluency in web dev that I am aware of.

Best of luck!!

pcmoney··on Ask HN: Is now a good time to buy a new MacBook or should I wait?
I would wait, they will announce some level of refresh in September, possibly with new auxiliary Apple designed chips or Face ID etc. and they will have fixed keyboard gate by then.
pcmoney··on Study: Today’s dads are engaging more with their kids
Thanks for the input, I am very thankful we have less pressure in our culture to follow traditional father roles. Not that those fathers were uncaring but they were expected to be a bit more removed and constrained than we are today. One thing is for sure is that time definitely goes by twice as fast!
pcmoney··on Study: Today’s dads are engaging more with their kids
I’m a relatively new dad so maybe the novelty just hasn’t worn off but I can’t understand fathers who don’t interact with their kids. I do it as much as I can, it’s the best. Not always easy but always good.
pcmoney··on Ask HN: Best practices for onboarding new employees?
Oh it was all fine, just the work wasn’t hard or interesting and there wasn’t that much of it (except for crazy spikes for 2-3 weeks sometimes) I dont feel like I passed on anything significant. I was just really under utilized. I got poached by a startup and they offered to match but I declined. If your great goal is leadership at a DoD shop I would recommend a better goal. Even if you make it up the ladder over 15-35 years the top of that ladder just isn’t that great, or at least it wasn’t for me. I keep in touch with some other people from the program, all have since moved on. I would say this indicates the program didn’t know how to utilize and retain the “talent” it selected for. And sure you can argue we all weren’t that talented, I don’t particularly care, I am very happy with that particular career choice.
pcmoney··on Ask HN: Best practices for onboarding new employees?
Out of undergrad I was recruited by a major defense contractor and selected for a leadership development program. Aside from making me fly various places and do nothing they also made me do nothing at my "home" desk in a secure facility (so no cell phone or playful browsing) by myself.

I found a bunch of old math texts and starting reading them and doing practice problems out of sheer boredom. It was then without the stress of juggling other subjects and exams that I realized I actually liked math and just had terrible teachers for most of my education. I went through Calc I,II, III in the first month or two (some was review) and by the time I quit about a year later I had enough momentum and interest to go through differential equations, linear algebra, some analysis, and more advanced matrix methods.

It was one of my favorite jobs.

pcmoney··on Reconsidering the Hardware Kindle Interface
Honestly if it just had a real off switch I would forgive just about anything else.

The number of times my kindle has died because it was displaying an ad forever because it takes 4seconds to turn off... pretty much makes the long battery life feature useless.

pcmoney··on Bulldoze the business school
Fair point, I wonder if union electricians do commit more fraud since they feel more secure/less touchable etc a clearer version of the point I was trying to make is saying a correlation between business school grads and white collar crime does not imply that business school is the cause. Could have many kinds of selection bias there. I shoulda just stuck with the ol correlation doesn’t imply causation bit.
pcmoney··on Bulldoze the business school
1. He makes a good point 2. Its not the point he thinks he makes 3. Full disclosure one of my degrees is a B.S in finance but I work as an engineer.

He makes a point that "At the end of it all, most business-school graduates won’t become high-level managers anyway, just precarious cubicle drones in anonymous office blocks." But isn't that true of most degrees? I would argue even most STEM grads end up in the cubicle farm. I saw plenty there working for a defense contractor. I also think him saying this is objectively bad is a little elitist. Depending on background and family socio-economic status the cubicle farm might be a step up and even a point of pride.

All of his criticism is from the point of view that people in business schools take advantage of others, how about people go to business school to not be taken advantage of? To know how to negotiate a salary, to know the rough rules of the game. If you don't come from a family of means I would argue a decent business school and STEM are about equivalent in terms of increasing your income and providing a long term career. Some don't have the aptitude or inclination to do STEM. Just like many STEM grads couldn't sell someone a $100 bill for $95.

Another claim is that: "Another suggested that the likelihood of committing some form of corporate crime increased if the individual concerned had experience of graduate business education, or military service. (Both careers presumably involve absolving responsibility to an organisation.)" How about people who know a field and are in the field are more likely to commit a crime in it? I am sure the number of blue collar embezzlement is dominated by plumbers/electricians etc. Not even going into criminal medical issues such as corrupt doctors being opioid prescription factories.

I am not saying all business schools are useful, or that they do the job perfectly but his opinion seems shockingly naive. Also business school might not be a good place to be if you don't have some degree of faith in capitalism (the single greatest eradicator of poverty over the past 50 years), it would be like being a flat-earther in an astrophysics department.

Finally, I would much rather be managed or HR-ed by someone with at least some formal training on how to treat people with dignity in difficult complex situations. I have seen conflict/layoffs/firings etc. handled absolutely atrociously by (albeit young) STEM grads. Admittedly having a degree in Management/HR doesn't mean you are automatically good at this, but education helps.

Personal anecdote: My first year in finance taught me a lot about debt, I changed my whole college strategy to graduate debt free. My finance degree also taught me most of the wealth management industry is exploitative of the average investor and have no demonstrable gains over just buying low fee indices. These 2 bits will save me hundreds of thousands of dollars if not over a million dollars throughout my career. Sure they may be obvious but millions of students every year make egregious financial mistakes to get other degrees that may land them in the same cube farm.

pcmoney··on Life is Short (2016)
Only you can answer this for you.

But I would say younger, given you know yourself pretty well and have a good idea what field you want your career to be in.

Yes, kids are limiting. But they also open up the world to you again. You don’t really understand most of art, culture, society until you have kids of your own IMO. It’s not like you can’t continue to have grand experiences, you will just hopefully be having them with someone who you will have a loving relationship with until you die instead of some random person.

Also I didn’t want to be unable to ski/bike/climb etc with my kids when they are young adults because I was too old.

Raising kids is hard. Be prepared to explore how petty and self centered you really are and be prepared to stop being like that.

← PreviousPage 12 of 12