HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pdinny

77 karma · joined May 14, 2020

submissionscomments
pdinny··on The Twitter Ranking Algorithm
The challenge with publishing the algorithm in the hopes of increased transparency and a broader understanding is that it is still impenetrably complicated to the average user.

Even with an open source algorithm the results on the feed for an individual may still seem opaque based on the input data and the metadata for that input data (not all of which would necessarily be visible).

Wouldn't it be better to have some explanation along the lines of "Why am I seeing this ad?" which is presumably more immediately useful to a larger audience.

pdinny··on Against Pair Programming
In general I agree. I've found pair programming to be immensely beneficial and productive for some cases.

I wouldn't go so far as to say recurring sessions are always bad, but I do think that not all tasks benefit from having a pair work on it.

When I have been very attuned with my teammates in terms of the system we were building and how we were building then pairing sessions became much less valuable on work that was very low novelty and was some iteration of a well-established pattern.

pdinny··on Minolta X-700 Aperture Priority Mode
The post title may be a bit misleading here in the sense that the linked article isn't claiming that only the X-700 had aperture priority.

While I can't comment on specifics of the availability of aperture priority in 1980s SLRs, the two models you mention (t90 and n8008) are late 80s models (86 and 88 IIRC) where the X-700 was released in 1981.

The X-700s are terrific cameras, I shot with one for many years.

pdinny··on Ask HN: Software Developer vs. Software Engineer
I see many commenters suggesting that the distinction is a subtle one of ability and scope. This is interesting to observe and definitely not what I had anticipated in the responses.

In my experience the titles are interchangeable in practice. I can see how one might make a spirited argument that there should be a meaningful difference and how that could be useful in hiring.

Taking a look at Google Trends for both terms it is interesting note seeming regional preferences: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=software...

pdinny··on How we broke the supply chain
In South Africa we've seen _some_ disruption too, but the immediate effects have been limited from a consumer perspective.

What I find most impressive is how resilient the overall system is in spite of the many disruptions.

I recently read a book (by Mark O'Connell) about how some groups predicted ever-imminent apocalypse and social collapse. The book was released shortly before the pandemic and tellingly one of the themes presented (not as the author's view, but as a view in some prepper communities) was that a global pandemic would lead a total collapse of the supply chain and then we would become feral and play out Mad Max etc.

While global supply chain issues have led to some shortages (some more serious than others and some more protracted than others) there is so much that is still working. That's something to celebrate IMHO.

pdinny··on There’s No Such Thing as Clean Code
The author isn't arguing against the existence of "good" code or "clean" code but rather advocating for us to try to articulate what is good (or bad) about code because "clean" is vague and encompasses too many things.

In response to: > You definitely know it when you see it. the author suggests: > It’s good to build that intuition, but we can’t just stop there. We need to dig deeper beyond those feelings to understand and articulate why we think the code is good.

pdinny··on Ask HN: Why the obsession with note taking?
Timeline looks really great!

I'm a fan of this approach to users owning their data: it enables things that are interesting and valuable for the user, rather than making it something that necessarily requires an audience.

I hadn't previously considered incorporating notes into a personal archive as I often see them as being of a fundamentally different class to journaling, but I'm starting to reconsider my biases in that regard.

pdinny··on Ask HN: Why the obsession with note taking?
A related question for note-takers: what would you estimate as your rate of reference to prior notes? For my own part that rate is so dismally low that right now I get more value out of making notes than retrieving and reading notes.

I'm reminded of a response to another thread on HN a few weeks back about organizing physical documents. Many commenters had very sophisticated processes with scanning, OCR, indexing etc but there was one commenter who organized their documents as a stack of paper, divided by year. The use case for documents might be a bit different because the number of times you're likely to need a document is probably quite different the number of times you will benefit from reading a note.

A more concise reframing of the above: for those who have adopted a disciplined approach to note taking (geared towards retrieval and linking) do you get enough value from the disciplined approach to encourage us unstructured notes-everywhere to invest the effort of adopting a better process?

pdinny··on Is async for everyone? [slides]
I was also disappointed by this overly simplistic and cheerful view.

Async communication, like most things, isn't equally well-suited to all scenarios (never mind people).

I worked in a primarily async environment and while I, as an individual, like many aspects of this manner of work it is sometimes a terribly inefficient way to get things done. In some instances a meeting with a handful of people can save you weeks of back and forth on Slack, each time with a bunch of context switching.

pdinny··on Write shitty code
This present a false dichotomy of extremes: shitty code and hopelessly overly complicated intended to address all manner of eventualities that never materialize.

Both extremes are awful choices IMO. If the code you are writing is truly unlikely to be extended and adapted then it may be fair to relax your requirements for code quality. As for most things I'd say that applying some discretion to your actual context is more valuable than blanket approaches of embracing bad code.

Code can be good without taking forever and without being over-designed. On the other hand the accumulated effects of shitty code upon more shitty code is unlikely to be a net positive.

Well-designed code can be simple.

pdinny··on Stop Waiting for Godot
I feel clickbaited here. I was fully expecting some weird 'Waiting for Godot'/Beckettverse itch.io game. That said, maybe I'll join the jam!
pdinny··on The Clickbaitification of Netflix
> The employees are incentivized to do so and this is what they measure, so this is what they build

I also work in data teams and this is directly my observation too.

Closely related are Conway's Law (you ship your org chart) and Goodhart's Law (commonly paraphrased as 'When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.')

In Netflix's case I certainly feel the shipped product is too close of a reflection of org structure and incentives and user experience suffers as a result.

This feels particularly evident in the treatment of thumbnails and title descriptions. Often I find myself clicking through on a thumbnail in order to read the description only to find that the I've already read the description and didn't want to watch that title, but the thumbnail has since changed.

I'm sure there is some team in Netflix whose sole purpose is increasing thumbnail clickthrough rates. And they are probably succeeding in that respect by changing the thumbnails. They get to win at their portion of some funnel, even if the net result is a lousy user experience.

pdinny··on Good Riddance, TurboTax. Americans Need a Real ‘Free File’ Program
100% agree. The argument presented in many other threads seems to reason that the easy tax filing systems do not allow for custom deductions or are easy because the tax system is simplistic.

I think that in the South African case the tax system isn't simplistic and I can add all kinds of details that might be specific to my tax requirements.

I'm surprised by how many people seem to be defending the lack of a government provided system on the basis that somehow the citizen will get a worse deal as a result.

pdinny··on The Garden and the Stream: A Technopastoral
While it isn't quite the Federated Wiki that the author describes, I've been enjoying using are.na to curate my readings and areas of interest.

When I post a link to a channel (as they call it), such as this article, it shows me other public channels that contain the same link, which I can then include or explore for related links, or even contribute to.

As an excellent example I've now found many related readings to this article that aren't directly about the same topic but are close enough to have been curated into the same set by some users.

pdinny··on Ask HN: What's your quarantine side project?
A movie recommender (item-item) that recommends movies similar to a proposed movie. The similarity is based on tags, specifically the tag genome created by GroupLens.

This is mostly because I have a personal need for this and I would like alternatives to existing movie recommendation services, but I may make it available online if time permits.

A second step would be to introduce an example critiquing aspect, allowing for interactions like "show me movies similar to 'Crimson Peak' but with less horror".

All of this is based on the MovieLens 25M dataset and an accompanying article (http://files.grouplens.org/papers/tag_genome.pdf) describing a recommender called 'Movie Tuner' that is no longer available.

It will be fun to tune the recommendations based on my own preferences. For example I don't need an algorithm to suggest movies that have the same actor/director.

Initial results are encouraging.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2