HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pdonis

18,510 karma · joined August 9, 2010

Email me at peterdonis {at} alum {dot} mit {dot} edu
submissionscomments
pdonis··on XCancel service is suspended until further notice
> How does one not engage with the corporate product at all?

By not using it. Which is exactly why I don't use X or Facebook, and minimize my use of Google (I use DuckDuckGo for search, and as Maps continues to suck more I use it less).

pdonis··on The Coming War on General Computation (2011)
> That's the same definition as the one where developers have control over their devices, because that's necessary for those apps to exist and be used even if you're not the author of them.

Developers need full control over their own devices to develop apps. But they don't need users to have such control. Indeed, for most users to have such control would be unsafe, since they don't know what to do with it anyway.

> the apps people would actually want are things like "ad blocker that blocks the ads in other apps"

How many people would actually pay for such an app? My guess is, not enough to matter.

For that matter, how many people even understand that it's possible to have such apps on their phone? Again, my guess is, not enough to matter.

In other words, the point is not that Searls' and Doctorow's definitions are "wrong". The point is that ordinary users simply do not understand what the issue is with that framing.

> convincing unsophisticated people that something is in their own interest is hardly the same as that thing actually being in their own interest.

Of course not. But convincing them what actually is in their own interest--and that what the megacorps are trying to sell them is not--requires speaking the users' language. And I don't see that Doctorow's framing of the issue as a "war on general purpose computing" has helped at all with that.

pdonis··on The Coming War on General Computation (2011)
My take on this is the same as when an article by Doc Searls that references this speech by Doctorow came up on HN in 2019:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19862580

pdonis··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
If they're not being held legally liable, then I would not agree that "no one is confused about the liability". Sure, I agree with your analogy with a machine cutting off a finger, but you and I are just two people gabbing on HN. Nothing we say has any effect on OpenAI. And if law enforcement doesn't have an effect on them, then talk about "liability" is just empty words.
pdonis··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
> I'm pretty sure everyone knows that OpenAI is liable for the software they create and run.

Are they? What legal consequences have they suffered?

pdonis··on No constitutional right to clean water, federal court finds
> This is tortured logic that would argue the Fourth Amendment doesn't apply to most police departments in the country

Not at all. The Fourth Amendment does not specify any specific level of government. It gives general requirements that apply to all levels of government.

The Fourteenth Amendment explicitly says "States". That makes a difference--or it should. Someone else upthread pointed out that the Supreme Court in Yick Wo applied it to a city municipal ordinance, so as usual, the explicit language has been ignored and the actual de facto interpretation is indeed broader.

> and that town school boards could violate the First Amendment and have religious instruction.

The First Amendment explicitly says that Congress shall make no law...and the reason for that was that, at the time, most States had established religions and they didn't want the Federal government messing with that. And yes, those States ran religious schools to indoctrinate children in their established religions.

Over time, as all those State established religions went away and as a country we became much more secular, the de facto interpretation of the First Amendment has changed, so that we now expect that local governments can't, for example, run religious schools. But any such claim would have been dismissed as nonsense by the original Framers of the amendment.

> For a concrete example

Yes, I'm aware that the Supreme Court routinely imposes its own interpretation on what the Constitution says, whether it makes sense or is consistent with the actual language or not. The one you cite was fairly mild compared to, say, Hampton Co. v. United States, or Wickard v. Filburn, or Kelo v. New London.

pdonis··on No constitutional right to clean water, federal court finds
> The Supreme Court has applied the Fourteenth Amendment to municipal action since at least Yick Wo

That case was about a city ordinance (true, a city ordinance, not a State law that the city was enforcing, so that much is a fair point) that was inequitably enforced (non-Chinese got permits, Chinese didn't, with no other material facts being different). It was not the city providing a service itself.

> It expressly prohibits states from depriving any person of life, liberty, or property without due process

This refers to civil suits or criminal prosecutions, not the government providing services.

pdonis··on Understanding the recent DDoS attack against Read the Docs
Running a proxy server and running a botnet, at least.
pdonis··on Understanding the recent DDoS attack against Read the Docs
AFAIK most people's contract with their ISP includes fine print that forbids a lot of the nasty things these IoT and "smart" devices do.
pdonis··on Scientists observe Einstein's gravity in the quantum world
All of it. The theoretical work that showed this was done in the 1960s and early 1970s by Feynman, Deser, and others. One of the key insights was figuring out how to reformulate the theory so that it did not require an infinite series of terms, whose sum nobody knew how to calculate, in order to derive the exact field equation correct to all orders. IIRC Deser was the one who figured that out, and he published a paper in the early 1970s that summarized the research.
pdonis··on Scientists observe Einstein's gravity in the quantum world
> One of the key challenges with quantizing gravity is in how the terms in the expressions resulting from analyzing the Feynman diagram interactions behave [4] which prevent them being renormalized.

Not being renormalizable actually isn't a problem in itself if you view the theory as an effective theory, valid only up to some energy scale, not beyond that. You can still use the theory to make some predictions, as long as you're careful. But that does mean that the QFT of a massless spin-2 field can't be a fundamental theory of gravity; it can only be an effective theory, that approximates something deeper.

pdonis··on Scientists observe Einstein's gravity in the quantum world
> SR doesn't consider acceleration

As I said, this is not correct. Early on, in the first years after Einstein published his papers, there were physicists who believed this (and IIRC Einstein was initially one of them), but that was well over a century ago. We've made a lot of progress since then, and part of that progress is understanding that SR can handle acceleration just fine, as long as spacetime is flat.

> when Einstein considered acceleration as well as gravity via the equivalence principle which lead to GR

The equivalence principle as Einstein first came up with it was actually about free fall. What he called "the happiest thought of my life" was "if a person falls freely, they will not feel their own weight". In modern terminology, we would say that, if you are dealing with a small enough piece of spacetime, you can treat it as flat, even if the spacetime globally is curved. And that means you can use all of the physics of SR in that small piece of spacetime. And that turns out to be a key piece of getting to GR, how to handle spacetimes that are globally curved.

> The key insight of the equivalence principle was that the force from gravity (e.g. standing on the Earth) is no different to the observer in their frame of reference to them being in a room in a rocket accelerating at the same rate as gravity

This was a further development of the equivalence principle from the free-fall version I described above. But note what it implies: it implies that, in modern terminology, treating a small enough piece of spacetime as flat works even if we adopt an accelerating reference frame in that small piece. Physics ultimately looks the same whether we adopt the frame of the object freely falling in the elevator/towards the Earth's surface, or the accelerated frame of the elevator/observer standing on the surface of the Earth. SR handles both just fine.

Where SR breaks down is when we need to extend our analysis beyond a small piece of spacetime--when the effects of spacetime curvature start to show up. That's when we need GR.

Again, all these implications were not necessarily clear to physicists a century ago. But they are now, and have been for decades.

pdonis··on Scientists observe Einstein's gravity in the quantum world
> The Dirac equation and Quantum Electro Dynamics (QED) unify quantum mechanics and special relativity

And more generally the Standard Model, which includes the weak and strong interactions. The SM is a quantum field theory, which, as you say, unifies QM and SR.

> (non-accelerating frames of reference).

No, SR and QFT are not limited to non-accelerating frames. They are limited to small enough regions of spacetime that spacetime curvature is negligible. This experiment is an illustration of that: it compares an accelerated atom with a free-falling atom to show the phase shift between them, and the lab frame in which it is done is accelerated--but the SM and SR work just fine. But the experiment does not show any effects of spacetime curvature.

> the remaining piece is either to extend QED/QCD to accelerating frames of reference

No, that's already done. See above.

> or to quantize general relativity.

That's the big missing piece, yes. We know how to write the QFT of a massless spin-2 field (which is our naive expectation of what a QFT for gravity would look like), and we know that the classical limit of that QFT is the classical GR we have now. But we know that QFT has to be just an effective theory, just like the Standard Model; it can't be the final answer.

> That would likely predict the phase shift observed in this experiment.

The theories we already have (Standard Model + the equivalence principle are all we actually need) are sufficient to predict that. Of course any more comprehensive theory will have to reproduce that prediction, yes.

pdonis··on No constitutional right to clean water, federal court finds
The city is not a State. The Fourteenth Amendment says that States shall not abridge the privileges and immunities of citizens.

As the court's opinion points out (and as others have pointed out in this thread), there are plenty of other legal remedies that can be sought against a city government that allegedly poisons its people through its water system, including voting them out of office and bringing tort claims against them.

pdonis··on No constitutional right to clean water, federal court finds
The city is not a State, so that clause would not apply to it. Unless you want to argue that the State of Mississippi was violating the Fourteenth Amendment by not requiring its cities to provide clean water (the article mentions that a few other states have done this). But this suit wasn't against the state.
pdonis··on No constitutional right to clean water, federal court finds
Incorporation of the Bill of Rights doesn't extend any powers granted by the Constitution to the Federal government, to state, county, city, etc. governments. It just says those governments (well, the State governments, since the Amendment only explicitly says "States", but other local governments when they are implementing or enforcing State statutes) also have to respect the Bill of Rights when they exercise the powers they already had. The Constitution did not establish those other governments. They were already there.
pdonis··on No constitutional right to clean water, federal court finds
> The Fourteenth Amendment explicitly constrains states

It says states can't make laws that abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens. It does not say states have to provide whatever services citizens would like to have.

pdonis··on No constitutional right to clean water, federal court finds
> The Preamble explicitly states that the Constitution is for these six things.

The Constitution establishes the Federal government. Not state, county, city, municipal governments. It says what the Federal government is for. Not what those other levels of government are for. The Federal government isn't the government that failed to provide clean water in this case; it's not even responsible for providing city water in the first place, city governments are.

pdonis··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
I assume you're not including Pluto-Charon here (presumably since Pluto is now demoted to "dwarf planet")? Their mass ratio is only about 8:1, which is far smaller than Earth-Moon, 81:1.
pdonis··on Internet centralization and the original sin of NAT
Perhaps a server run by a large corporation could do this. Perhaps.

But an ordinary person? I don't see it. If it's tough for an ordinary person to handle safely opening a port in their firewall for forwarding, it's tough squared (or perhaps cubed or an even higher power) for an ordinary person to handle auto-creating a separate IPV6 address for every other person that wants to communicate over the Internet with them.

Not to mention, how does this work with DNS? If Ordinary Person wants to put an article up for others to read, how do the others find it? Surely not by Ordinary Person sending individually crafted IPV6 addresses to anyone who wants to read their article. (And how do they even find those other people if they are also creating new IPV6 addresses for everyone else?)

pdonis··on Internet centralization and the original sin of NAT
> NAT and a firewall are 2 different things

Exactly. Which is the issue with saying, as the article does, that NAT is the reason most people don't have an Internet visible server, when the real reason is that their computers need to be behind a firewall and once you're behind a firewall, safely opening up just little pieces of it for an Internet visible server is something most people aren't going to want to deal with.

pdonis··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
The Sun's gravitational pull on the Moon is always stronger than the Earth's. (Do the math and see--on average the Sun's pull is more than twice as strong as the Earth's.) So the net acceleration of the Moon is always towards the Sun, never towards the Earth.
pdonis··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
As I understand it, one suggested "double planet" definition was that the barycenter would have to be outside both objects. Earth-Moon doesn't (quite) satisfy that condition, but for example, Pluto-Charon does.
pdonis··on Internet centralization and the original sin of NAT
> most of the time they are unwanted users trying to break in.

Exactly. Of all the reasons why the average person doesn't have an Internet-visible server, NAT, I would say, is pretty far down on the list.

pdonis··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
Since the Moon's orbit is always concave towards the Sun, one could even argue that the Moon is a planet, not a satellite, it just happens to have an orbit that is closely coupled to that of another planet, Earth.

As I understand it, in fact, there was discussion about defining systems like Earth-Moon as double planets, but that didn't make it into the final definition.

pdonis··on The Snow/Leavis ‘two cultures’ clash
I sympathize to an extent with Leavis's anger, but also with Snow's reaction. As you note, Leavis represents bad aspects of the humanities as much as Snow, in Leavis's view, represents bad aspects of science (or perhaps "scientism" would be a better word). Neither of them, to me, comes off looking very good after this exchange.
pdonis··on It takes 5 cloud services to hear my doorbell
We have a Ring doorbell that hooks into the actual chime that the old doorbell used, so it still preserves the old doorbell's functionality[1]. I can understand not wanting to buy into the Ring ecosystem (we started using them before they were bought by Amazon), but maybe there are cheaper doorbells that also do that? All we had to do to make the old chime work with the Ring doorbell was install an extra widget that came with the Ring doorbell inside the chime; the Ring doorbell's instructions explained how to do it. It just needed a screwdriver and a few minutes' work.

[1] More precisely, we did until we moved to a manufactured home that did not even have a doorbell installed, after which I had to do some jiggering (now we have a Ring chime that the doorbell can talk to over the house's LAN). But the setup I describe above worked fine for a number of years in the house we were in before.

pdonis··on European Commission Revives Push for Encryption Backdoors in ProtectEU Strategy
The lawful way for law enforcement to enter a home is to get a search warrant (or whatever the EU equivalent is) and show it to the owner, who then lets them in because that's what the law requires. No need for law enforcement to even worry about the lock. If the owner doesn't let them in when they have a search warrant, they're violating the law, and sure, they can technically keep the doors locked and refuse to open them, but it's only a matter of time before they'll end up giving in one way or another.

But if law enforcement wants to be lazy, they can say, look, this whole search warrant business is so tedious, and even then it might take time before the owner capitulates, so why not just pass a law that requires all locks to have backdoors in them so we can open them? Then we can just let ourselves into someone's home whenever we feel like it^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^Hhave a bona fide need to do so in order to protect the public.

The latter is what the EU Commission is trying to do.

pdonis··on Creepy Crawlies
> I don’t want to stop the bots from updating their knowledge based on all the content.

Why not? At this point, any attempt to try to meet the bots halfway is doomed.

pdonis··on Coordination Headwind: How Organizations Are Like Slime Molds
Is there a version of this that doesn't force me to click through slides with very little content on each one, as if I were in kindergarten? To whoever wrote this: I can read.
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →