HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pdonis

18,510 karma · joined August 9, 2010

Email me at peterdonis {at} alum {dot} mit {dot} edu
submissionscomments
pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
> you are still arguing against things I never said

You said the singularity is a point in space. That's what I'm arguing against.

The rest was an attempt to try to help you understand the correct physics. Evidently it was wasted effort. I won't do it again.

> all you had to do was write down the explicit metric and point out exactly where it disagrees with what I said.

Sure, it's the one in terms of t' and r in the Wikipedia article on Eddington Finkelstein coordinates. [1]

> if you did, you would immediately see that your argumentation falls apart.

No, I see that yours does.

The article is using the timelike signature convention, so positive ds^2 is timelike and negative ds^2 is spacelike. Vertical lines in a spacetime diagram (like the one just a little bit below the metric, on the right, that shows the light cones) are intervals where only dt' is nonzero. It is obvious from the metric that for any r < 2M, i.e., anywhere inside the horizon, such intervals give a negative ds^2, since 1 - 2 GM / r is negative. So vertical lines, of which the singularity is one, are spacelike, and t' is a spacelike coordinate inside the horizon (just as r is). And a spacelike line cannot be a point in space. It can only be a moment of time. The fact that it is vertical on the diagram does not change that.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eddington%E2%80%93Finkelstein_...

pdonis··on Luanti removed from Google Play due to baseless AI copyright notice
The GP is not saying the small entity pays the bond. The GP is saying the big entity that wants the content taken down (in this case Microsoft and TracerAI) pays the bond, and forfeits it if a counter notice is issued.
pdonis··on Bhartrhari's Paradox
If there is any non-empty subset that has no smallest element, then the ordering in question is not a well-ordering. You can of course define some subsets of the reals that do have a smallest element in the standard ordering, for example all of the reals that are greater than or equal to 0. But there are also subsets that do not have a smallest element, and that is enough to show that the standard ordering on the reals cannot be a well-ordering.
pdonis··on Bhartrhari's Paradox
> The reals can be ordered, just use x < y.

That ordering is not a well-ordering, which is what the GP specified. A well ordering requires that every non-empty subset has a smallest element. That's not true for the reals ordered by x < y: for example, the set of all reals > 0 has no smallest element.

No one has explicitly shown that the reals can be well ordered, but it's a consequence of the axiom of choice that every set can be well-ordered. So in ZFC there must be a well ordering of the reals, even though no one has found one. Issues like this are why not all mathematicians accept the axiom of choice.

pdonis··on Aphantasia Beginner's Guide
> Have you actually dedicated significant time to trying to learn how to visualize?

I haven't had to. I don't have aphantasia. Visualizing doesn't feel like a learned skill to me. It feels like something I've always known how to do. Of course if I pay more attention to what I'm doing, I can visualize in more detail than if I just do it casually. But I've never had the feeling that, oh, if I practice this and learn I can get better at it, the way, for example, that I can get better at playing the piano by practicing.

Where I'm stuck is, if someone else who couldn't visualize asked me to teach them how, I wouldn't know what to do. Whereas, if they asked me to teach them how to play the piano, I'd at least have some idea.

pdonis··on Aphantasia Beginner's Guide
Learning to juggle involves easily observed objective activities that other people can check, and which can be learned that way--you can watch someone else juggling, read book that describes the tossing of the balls, etc.

How do you do any of that with visualizing? If I'm trying to learn to juggle, I can watch someone else juggling and say, I want to do that. How do I watch someone else visualizing and see what to do?

pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
Sorry, you're just repeating the same wrong statement. I know you said "space", and I already explained that a spacelike line in spacetime cannot be a point in space. It can only be a moment of time.

You are quite correct that, since the singularity is a line in spacetime, different incoming light rays (or free-falling observers, for that matter) can hit it at different points. Depending on how you choose your coordinates, you can set it up so that those points have different "time" coordinates. But that doesn't make the singularity a point in space. It means you're running up against relativity of simultaneity--whether or not different events on a spacelike line (or more generally a spacelike surface) happen at the same time depends on your choice of coordinates. You can, in fact, choose coordinates in which all events on the singularity happen at the same time (for a "time" coordinate that is genuinely timelike--see below). The standard Penrose chart does that, for example.

You are also correct that a good choice of coordinates can make it easier to see certain properties of a spacetime geometry. But it can also make it harder to see other properties. In this case, your choice of Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates is making it harder for you to see why your claim that the singularity is a point in space is wrong, and why the things I said above are true.

For example, inside the horizon, the Eddington-Finkelstein "time" coordinate that you are using is not timelike. It's spacelike. In other words, it's not actually a "time" coordinate (even though it's labeled as such). It is actually a "space" coordinate! You should be able to see this by observing that the singularity is a spacelike line, and in E-F coordinates it's a vertical line--i.e., the only coordinate that changes along it is the "time" coordinate. That means the "time" coordinate must actually be spacelike there.

And, for extra confusion, the r coordinate in Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates is also spacelike, even inside the horizon (unlike in Schwarzschild coordinates, where it becomes timelike). So in this chart there is no coordinate that is timelike inside the horizon! That means any timelike curve inside the horizon must have more than one coordinate in this chart that changes along it (in the simplest case, a radial timelike curve, both the "time" and r coordinates must change along the curve).

pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
No, everything you wrote is not true, in Eddington Finkelstein or any other coordinates. You wrote that the singularity is a point in space. It's not, no matter what coordinates you choose. It's a line in spacetime, but it's a spacelike line, and a spacelike line cannot describe a point in space. It can only describe a moment of time. No choice of coordinates can change that. (Similar remarks apply to your claim that the singularity always being in your future once you're inside the horizon is an artifact of a coordinate choice. It's not. It's just as true in Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates, or any others.)

That also makes your use of the term "spatial coordinates" questionable, as I already pointed out. The fact that the line r = 0 is vertical in an Eddington-Finkelstein spacetime diagram does not mean it's automatically a "point in space" or that r inside the horizon is automatically a "spatial coordinate". You need to look at the actual physics, not just the surface appearance of the diagram.

pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
Kerr spacetime contains closed timelike curves inside the inner horizon. You can reach them from the outside universe, but you can't escape back out.

Also, the region inside the inner horizon of Kerr spacetime is widely considered to be not physically reasonable, not just because of the closed timelike curves, but because the inner horizon itself is unstable--there is an infinite blueshift there which, it is believed, would cause it to be destroyed by the first tiny bit of incoming matter or radiation.

pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
> it is just a mathematical artefact of weirdly chosen coordinates.

No, that's not correct. The fact that the singularity is always in your future inside the horizon is an invariant, independent of any choice of coordinates.

> the singularity is still just a point in space

No, it's not. A point in space would be a timelike line in spacetime. But the singularity is a spacelike line in spacetime. That's a moment of time, not a place in space.

> There's no need for this whole "space turns into time" notion

That's true; that notion is an artifact of Schwarzschild coordinates. But that does not imply the other claims you are making.

> the spatial coordinates of the singularity

I'm not sure what you mean by this. It's true that, since the singularity is a spacelike line, you can treat a coordinate that varies along it as a "spatial" coordinate marking different spatial points on the singularity. But the singularity itself is a moment of time (as above, a spacelike line), so it is not a "place", and it does not have a particular set of "spatial coordinates". A spatial coordinate marking different points along the singularity is marking different points in space at a moment of time.

pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
> It also is in Schwarzschild coords

True--indeed, the statement that it's a spacelike line is an invariant, independent of any choice of coordinates. But it's a lot harder to see that in Schwarzschild coordinates.

> Kruskal-Szeres really is only useful for demonstrating that the event horizon is not such a weird place, but it does nothing for the singularity at the center.

I disagree, and I think many GR physicists would as well. Indeed, both classic GR textbooks, Misner, Thorne & Wheeler (1973) and Wald (1984) discuss Kruskal coordinates and their associated spacetime diagram (MTW in Box 31.2 and sections 31.5 and 31.5, Wald in section 6.4), and those discussions contain a good deal more than just showing that the horizon is "not such a weird place".

pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
> Susskind's book does also mention that the event-horizon shenanigans are due to coordinates and not a physical thing.

That's good. However:

> Interchange of Space and Time Dimensions at the Horizon

This still seems misleading to me, because "Dimensions" makes it seem like it's not just an artifact of coordinates--but it is.

pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
> the singularity is always in your future

It's not just that it's always in your future in the sense that you can't avoid it. It's that the reason you can't avoid it is that it's a moment of time, not a place in space. You can't avoid it for the same reason you can't avoid tomorrow. And which direction in space you move has no effect on whether or not you reach the singularity for the same reason it has no effect on whether or not you reach tomorrow.

pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
> the singularity is still a point (or rather surface) in the future instead of a point in space.

It's a spacelike line on the Kruskal diagram, yes.

> The issue is that these diagrams are for eternal, static black holes

The full Kruskal diagram is, yes. But the essential features of the black hole portion of that diagram are still there in a black hole that forms by gravitational collapse of a massive body. That includes the singularity being a spacelike line, and there being spacelike curves inside the horizon that are infinitely long.

I agree that Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates can help with intuitions about this spacetime geometry as well.

pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
> if I was walking toward the black hole past the event horizon, and then I turned around

Note that, once you're inside the horizon, you can't "turn around" and go back outside again. You're inside the hole for good.

And once you're inside the hole, yes, no matter which direction in space you move, you're moving "towards" the singularity. But a better way to look at it is that the singularity is a moment of time, not a place in space. You're moving "towards" the singularity in the same sense as you're moving "towards" next Tuesday. You can't stop moving towards next Tuesday by changing which direction in space you move. The same is true for the singularity once you're inside the hole's horizon.

pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
> Really what it means is that past the event horizon you can use the direction in space between you and the singularity as a way to measure time

That's not correct. There is a relationship between the radial coordinate r you are at and the time it will take you, by your clock, to reach the singularity (at least assuming you are freely falling), but that relationship can't be described the way you are describing it.

To put the issue with what you say as starkly as possible: at any event inside the black hole's horizon, there are spacelike curves in every direction from you that will hit the singularity! So "the direction in space between you and the singularity" is not even well-defined.

To be clear, you are right that Susskind's statement is very misleading (I posted my own criticism of it upthread).

pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
This is the opinion of most physicists, yes, but it does not in any way justify the GP's claims or cast doubt on anything that is said in the paper. Note that the paper talks explicitly about the limitations of GR as the singularity is approached and how a quantum gravity theory, if we ever find and confirm one, might fix those issues.
pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
Unfortunately you are wrong. Everything the paper is saying about the singularity and its properties in GR, and more generally about the black hole solutions it describes, is well understood and has been for decades. The definition of "singularity" that the paper is using is perfectly fine, and its topology is perfectly well-defined. A good textbook treatment is that of Wald (1984).

Some of the things the paper points out are not emphasized in other sources, which is probably why the authors chose to write it. But there is nothing in the paper that is in the least questionable or ill-defined; it's all standard General Relativity as applied to the Schwarzschild and Kerr black hole solutions.

pdonis··on Black hole singularity is a surface not a point
> the space and time coordinates switch places as you cross the event horizon

If Susskind's book does in fact say that, it's extremely disappointing to me, because, as a number of other GR textbooks will tell you (e.g., Misner, Thorne & Wheeler and Wald, the two great classic GR textbooks), the "switch places" is an artifact of a particular choice of coordinates (Schwarzschild coordinates), and does not represent anything physical. So it's not something that should be relied on. (Not to mention the confusion it causes when pop science sources repeat the statement and then draw all manner of wrong conclusions from it.)

The part about being "a surface in time" might be all right, assuming that by that he means "a surface representing a moment in time, not a place in space"--in more technical language, a spacelike surface. That is correct, and it's an invariant that does not depend on any choice of coordinates. But that invariant fact can be described without having to talk about the "switch places" thing at all.

pdonis··on Malware infects Android-based automotive head unit firmware
Which doesn't matter to me since the music I'm talking about is music I already have on the USB stick (because it's music I've collected over years and years of buying CDs, mostly before ways of streaming music over the Internet even existed), and I mostly want to listen to that. If I want something else, I can just use XM radio.
pdonis··on Dynamical dark energy and the week that broke cosmology
> Domain expertise.

Sorry, not buying the argument from authority here.

> Fluids always have perturbations

Not sure I agree with this as a sweeping general claim; but in any case, my question was about what in the particular models under discussion you were basing your statement on.

> except in the special case of w = -1 (cosmological constant)

Yes, this part I agree with, a cosmological constant has to be, well, constant.

> otherwise, dropping them violates energy-momentum conservation and gauge invariance

I don't understand the argument here.

> Here are a few excerpts from DESI

Unfortunately these links don't seem to be showing me specific excerpts, just the whole paper. Can you give page/section references or equation numbers?

pdonis··on Dynamical dark energy and the week that broke cosmology
> in the time-evolving model ("model"), dark energy is not uniform across space

What are you basing this on?

pdonis··on Dynamical dark energy and the week that broke cosmology
> it all really looks awfully close to "okay, fine, the dark energy/matter apparently also can do/be this stuff as well, just so we can write in whatever correction factors we need to make the theory fit the observations".

The dark energy density is already a parameter in the model. The simplest case for such a parameter is that it's just a constant, so in the absence of evidence to the contrary, Occam's Razor led cosmologists to adopt it.

But now we have evidence that suggests that it's not a constant, so we're looking at the next simplest case, a function of time (but still constant everywhere in space at each instant of time). The article describes how the DESI data suggest that it's a slowly decreasing function of time.

What has not happened is people making up models and continuing to insist on them even after the data says otherwise. That's what the GP was saying religion does.

pdonis··on Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does it without consequence
> they were able to arrange for their license to allow over 10000 schools, libraries, and other institutions to provide free access to walk-in users.

Sure, but that still only covers a miniscule fraction of US taxpayers. Plus, you have to walk in to the school, library, or other institution, instead of just being able to use your web browser at home.

> A large number of the material on JSTOR wouldn't be online at all if not for JSTOR, because they have put a lot of time and money into digitizing back issues of journals that the publishers probably would have never gotten around to.

This is a genuine value add, but it could have been paid for by the government directly without then having the material behind a paywall.

pdonis··on Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does it without consequence
> You said several times that the public had paid for the papers. Researchers were not paid to create open access papers. You even said it was criminal that they weren't.

I had assumed that readers would be able to exercise intelligence and common sense to see that I was describing how things should be, not how they are. Evidently I assumed too much in your case.

> rude...

It is to laugh: you had no problem describing me as "antisocial" and "delusional", and now you're complaining that I am being rude?

I think I'm done here.

pdonis··on Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does it without consequence
> It seems like you are jumping between the reality you would like and the reality that exists.

No, you did that, by responding to my post where I said "should" as though I were trying to describe how things are instead of how they ought to be.

> I think it is antisocial and delusional to say past papers belong to the public just because that's what you would have wanted.

I didn't say that. You need to work on your reading comprehension.

> The word for this is expostfacto recontracting

No, the word for what you're doing is putting words in my mouth and attacking a straw man.

> there are lots of reasons to pay for research even if it is not made public.

Can you give some?

> Especially so when 99% of researchers whom might make meaningful use of the publication already have access through a journal system.

Which they then have to pay fees to, using more of our tax dollars, because of the sweetheart deals the government has given the journals.

Not only that, but researchers nowadays share copies of papers over the Internet routinely (for example, using sites like arxiv.org), so they don't even need journals to know what other researchers are doing. So even that rationale for paying the journals is now out of date.

> consider private drug patents coming from Public Funding

A patent requires revealing the information that the invention is based on, in exchange for the exclusive right to produce the item for some period of time. So I don't see how this is an argument for keeping publicly funded research behind a paywall.

pdonis··on Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does it without consequence
> I think what Swartz actually did was anger someone at MIT, who called the Secret Service.

MIT was concerned that someone (they didn't know who it was at the time--in fact IIRC they didn't find out until the police told them after they caught Swartz) was using their network in a suspicious way. I don't know that anyone was "angered".

> You can set a surprising amount of government force in action with a concerned phone call, as it turns out.

I don't think the people at MIT who called in the police (and they were, IIRC, fairly low level people) had any idea what a shitstorm they were going to unleash. Nor do I think the (higher-level, but still IIRC not at the level of the top MIT administration) people at MIT who ended up interacting with the Federal prosecutor thought through what was actually going on as they should have, or had the issue considered by the MIT administration as a whole as it should have been.

pdonis··on Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does it without consequence
> Doesn't matter if the public funded it. The public didn't mandate or pay for the publication rights or access.

So when your tax dollars pay for a scientist to do research, you don't think the papers that document that research should be public property? If scientists want to keep their research private, they should find private funding.

Note that, as in my previous post, I said "should". If you mean there isn't explicit language to that effect in the grants, see further comments below.

> The public might donate food to the poor. That doesn't give them the right to go into their house and rummage through their fridge.

Invalid comparison. The scientific papers in question are not the personal property of the scientists.

> Maybe there is a missed opportunity to require open access as a condition of public grant funding.

IMO this should be the case, and it's an outrage that it's not, since it should be an obvious requirement for any research that our tax dollars pay for.

> That doesn't change the fact that it is not a stipulated condition.

Maybe that wasn't written into the grants explicitly, but that just means our government is (once again) failing to act in our best interests.

pdonis··on Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does it without consequence
> I don't like talking about this

I can see why it's difficult, but I think your post provides some much-needed context.

pdonis··on Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for scraping, while Meta does it without consequence
> Aaron Swartz was punished because he disrespected a business model.

Exactly. And what's more, it's a business model, keeping behind paywalls scientific papers that we the public have already paid for once with our tax dollars, that shouldn't even exist in the first place.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →