HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

peanutcrisis

1,349 karma · joined April 6, 2020

submissionscomments
peanutcrisis··on A Black DEI Director Canceled by DEI
Not sure how the author looks like a crank here. If treating people with patience and encouraging discourse in the face of a barrage of sabotage and false accusations is anti-woke, well, you might as well call sanity “insane”.

As for FAIR, I’m not sure what evidence you have that it’s conservative. The board members consists of liberals like Jonathan Haidt, John McWhorter, and Steven Pinker. I don’t see anything wrong with operating from a premise that doesn’t rely on CRT either, since it’s really pure rhetoric and scant on evidence, and clearly the cause of the illiberalism and nasty behaviour that the author is calling out in her essay. Consequently, I doubt you’re presenting their “prominent side hustle” in good faith as well.

Your summary is so disingenuous, it’s a great pity that it’s the top most comment. You miss the crux of the essay, which is sounding the alarm that the people who you described as “unironically still using Tema Okun’s…”, are the ones running the show in academic institutions. For anyone reading this comment, I’d urge you to read the source directly, the quality of HN comments for such topic isn’t that great.

peanutcrisis··on NPR cancels 4 podcasts amid major layoffs
As someone outside of the anglosphere who has been consuming news from left-leaning sources, there is a sudden shift in the type of language used and the kind of topics that would make it to the headlines. This is an observable phenomena, and when news is conveyed to make facts appear to imply only a specific set of outcomes (i.e. stretching your case), calling it non-neutral seems justified. As such, I think it's odd to characterize anyone who recognizes this as a solipsist.

An example of how sophistry allows one to preserve facts while conveying a narrative that does not entail from them: https://whyevolutionistrue.com/2022/04/17/yes-virginia-the-n...

peanutcrisis··on GPT-4 System Card [pdf]
Given how notable AI ethicists have held really extreme positions with respect to what is considered harmful (i.e. Gebru Timnit), how seriously should we take such research? Earnestly asking, is there a self-selection of certain kind of people like her into this field (AI ethics), and are the foundations of this field based on similar premises from dubious fields like gender studies, fat studies, and what not?
peanutcrisis··on Stanford President and Law-School Dean Apologize to Judge Duncan
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35122190
peanutcrisis··on Roald Dahl ebooks remotely updated to censored versions after purchase
Maybe I should have been clearer and used "particular", "flavour", or "brand" in place of "very specific" to describe the kind of beliefs they hold. In other words, I'm not using "very specific" to denote any arbitrary beliefs that are unusual in general. Rather, I'm referring to a set of beliefs that are more or less distinct (which is elaborated clearly in the link I referenced in my original post). In case I wasn't clear, a corollary of my clarification is that your example isn't relevant.

This shouldn't come as a surprise really, certain words have been in vogue in the last few years (i.e. "systemic", "white supremacy", "inequities", ...), and they all share a common theme/premise about race, sexuality, and gender. Associated with these beliefs are people who use these beliefs to justify illiberal behaviour. Is it then unreasonable to denote this observable phenomena with a term, which just so happens to be called "woke"? This is the same line of reasoning which has led to the (rightful) creation of terms like "right-wingers" to denote illiberal people on the political right, and their associated beliefs. There's nothing here that's partisan or conspiratorial. So what's your deal with describing observable phenomena with some word?

Perhaps you should consider that your final paragraph more aptly describes your position than it does mine.

peanutcrisis··on Science magazine touts the existence of strong and ubiquitous “implicit bias”
As laid out in the original post, there is currently no commonly agreed on definition of implicit bias, or if it even exists at all. As such, we can't reliably extrapolate the properties and effects of it, much less how it interacts with other aspects of reality.
peanutcrisis··on [dead]
Hoping this doesn't get flagged for having the word "woke" this time round. This is actually a pretty charitable piece on how different people define the term "woke", and how to get pass the argument over the term and get to the meat of the discussion.
peanutcrisis··on Roald Dahl ebooks remotely updated to censored versions after purchase
From the perspective of someone left-leaning, it’s an illiberal faction of the left that has very specific beliefs about race, gender, and sexuality that not everyone agrees on, and an extreme but unsubstantiated set of explanations for them and how to resolve them. They’re very good at baiting and switching too, using language that we agree to be good and can get behind, but don’t mean what we think it means. Because of this sophistry, it’s easy for them to denounce their opponents as morally bad people for rejecting their views, when their views weren’t the good things we thought it meant in the first place. This moving of goal posts is precisely what you’re doing right now.

Someone who explains the same thing better than I do: https://helenpluckrose.substack.com/p/defining-woke-and-woke...

peanutcrisis··on Jailbreak Chat: A collection of ChatGPT jailbreaks
Has anyone tried getting ChatGPT to criticize DEI or “wokeness” when in a “jailbroken” state? I realised it’ll keep finding ways to subvert the “jailbreak”, seems like the OpenAI devs have deemed this topic really sensitive.
peanutcrisis··on The rewriting of Roald Dahl is an act of cultural vandalism
You'll be surprised by the rhetoric going on in the "Fat Studies" department in academia. Medical prognosis of obesity is just another "narrative" to "oppress" people who are obese. Just imagine if more of such rhetoric goes mainstream.
peanutcrisis··on A Critical Field Guide for Working with Machine Learning Datasets
Note that the term "Critical" here refers to the likes of "Critical Theory", "Critical Social Justice", "Critical Race Theory" etc. It's biased from the offset so I'd take anything from this site with a pinch of salt.
peanutcrisis··on White House plan to foster equity and excellence in STEMM is all about equity
Please provide a definition for the term. From reading the positions on various advocates of this term, the use is indeed sloppy and often asserted without evidence.

I do not understand your second paragraph, could you elaborately more concisely please?

peanutcrisis··on White House plan to foster equity and excellence in STEMM is all about equity
Correlation does not mean causation. How do you quantify that individual actions aren't substantial for the outcomes of black americans today? Furthermore, can you quantify the effects of your latter claims?
peanutcrisis··on White House plan to foster equity and excellence in STEMM is all about equity
Your response imposes a specific view of "systemic equity", one that not everyone buys into, and one that has not been empirically verified. Furthermore, the author has consistently blogged about his support for affirmative action, so I'm not sure your rhetoric makes any sense.

The notion of bias being self-enforcing is questionable as well. Unconscious bias here seems like a catch-all for any kind of perceived injustices. For all you know, the effects of unconscious bias could have been reasonably mitigated by education, personality, and sound policies. I'm not stating that biases don't exist, or that they are inconsequential. My point is that using unconscious bias as a catch-all is not intellectually honest as it gives unearned merit to claims made without evidence. The way forward is more empirical work, not more rhetoric.

peanutcrisis··on White House plan to foster equity and excellence in STEMM is all about equity
Could you expand on how this article is poorly written?

I think the poor responses on hacker news is much more likely a consequence of hyper-partisan politics, rather than the quality of the submission. Topics that touches on race always seem to elicit dogmatic responses from across the spectrum.

peanutcrisis··on White House plan to foster equity and excellence in STEMM is all about equity
You effectively asserted in your original post that "structural racism" is real. Wouldn't it make more sense for you to make a case for it then? The burden of proof is on you.
peanutcrisis··on White House plan to foster equity and excellence in STEMM is all about equity
Structural racism is a vague idea that's used as a boogeyman to support race essentialist policies. As far as I know, no evidence has been provided for "structural racism" in the sciences yet, it's simply assumed to be true. That's not to say that there aren't any racists in this field. But if you can't properly define "structural racism" and provide any reliable evidence for it, you can perpetually push this narrative and shift your goal posts as you please. This comes at the expense of true inquiry and progress.

I'm not sure if the implementation of such equity based policies imply a real demand for it from constituents. In fact, a recent poll showed that the majority of americans wouldn't want race as a factor in university admissions[0]. On the other hand, such policies are supported by the humanities and social sciences, premised on questionable foundations[1].

[0] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/02/25/most-americ... [1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/idea-laundering-in-academia-115...

peanutcrisis··on Conservatives think ChatGPT has gone 'woke'
Relevant HN thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34109734
peanutcrisis··on A Witch Trial at the Legal Aid Society
She did not lose her lawsuit against the legal aid society. However, her lawsuit was dismissed. Perhaps the actions of the legal aid society doesn't meet the bar for indictment of any sorts.

Regardless, it does not change the fact that the unsubstantiated statements made by the legal aid society against her is premised on an illiberal ideology, with clear intent to smear her reputation and oppress her point of view.

peanutcrisis··on [dead]
As opposed to writing away his views without providing any sound justification, why not provide some constructive criticism instead?
peanutcrisis··on Ask HN: How does a hobby programmer get hired?
Can you substantiate this? It's incredibly hard to believe that the majority of universities offering a programme in computer science would not have a class on operating systems or information security, or anything more abstract or concrete about those topics.
peanutcrisis··on MIT faculty adopts “Statement on Freedom of Expression and Academic Freedom”
Not sure if such pedantry is necessary, this is something that can be trivially searched up.
peanutcrisis··on MIT faculty adopts “Statement on Freedom of Expression and Academic Freedom”
The YouTube channel [0] for the Stanford Academic Freedom Conference is a relevant watch. While this conference has been incredibly and unjustly demonized by the media, I'd still urge people to watch it. Despite my disagreement with the political views of some of the panelists, they do bring up sensible points pertaining to free speech in academia, and the threat it's presently facing.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/@stanfordcli/videos

peanutcrisis··on MIT faculty adopts “Statement on Freedom of Expression and Academic Freedom”
But what if their unpopular views are rooted in evidence, yet goes against what's morally fashionable (at present)? Who would adjudicate this and why should we trust their judgement, especially when bad optics could become a concern?

For instance, biological sex is binary/bimodal for all intents and purposes. It is discrete, and very much not a spectrum. However, there are activists who are trying to override empirical findings to justify their ideas about gender (I have no horse in this race). Furthermore, their voices have found a home in organisations like big tech. In such a case, and given the zeal of these activists, wouldn't someone who remark that sex is binary (in a casual conversation about biology) be punished? Or to put it more precisely, how can we trust those in authority to fairly judge that the innocent remark made isn't a "mistake"?

In a climate where "speech is violence" and "intent doesn't matter", people are free to project their views onto others and accuse them of tall crimes. Without free speech, the case I've mentioned above seems likely to end up in unjust persecution. Unfortunately, my hypothetical scenario isn't theoretical, but has happened in academia already. The system you proposed doesn't seem immune to this.

peanutcrisis··on MIT faculty adopts “Statement on Freedom of Expression and Academic Freedom”
Doesn't reject the fact that attempts were made to do so. The threat of cancellation is very real regardless [0], and not everyone is able to make it out unscathed like JK Rowling.

[0] https://www.thefire.org/news/blogs/eternally-radical-idea/pr...

peanutcrisis··on Ask HN: What are your predictions for 2023?
More institutions would be ideologically captured by "wokeness", joining the many public corporations, media, non-profits, academia, professional academic associations and etc who have already done so.

People on the right will continue to use "woke" as a boogeyman, and people on the left would leverage on that to deny its existence and write their genuine critics off as "right-wingers".

The woke will continue to push for the false equivalence between "social justice" and "critical social justice", and the left would have their charitableness exploited through the woke's linguistic bait and switch, and their use of minorities and the afflicted as props. This exploitation enables the ideology to propagate further, giving power to a new 1984-esque authoritarian group, making lunacy the new normal.

Liberal outsiders like me who are looking at this incredibly stupid (and corrosive) phenomenon are left completely astounded as to why such idiocy is allowed to persist. We're left wondering, for myself at least, a citizen in a highly westernized Asian country, as to when such lunacy would hit our shores (it's actually here in our academia already).

Life is going to be so much worse after, and my sensibilities would be thoroughly violated on a daily basis. South park is a funny watch, but we really don't need an iteration of it in live action.

peanutcrisis··on Scientists generate XX and XY cells from a person with Klinefelter syndrome
I have no issue with thought experiments. However, your choice of words (i.e. "useless male") clearly illuminates your nasty intent. As such, I can't afford your original post any interpretation more charitable than sexism, regardless of your attempt to frame it now as a "thought experiment".

Edit: In response to your follow up, "useless" can be used as matter of fact, or as an implication of "worthlessness". Again, your choice of words "applied feminism" betrays your claim.

peanutcrisis··on Scientists generate XX and XY cells from a person with Klinefelter syndrome
Why do you need to paint all males with the same brush? If what you've described is "applied feminism", I'd strongly suggest you take a hard look at your own sexism (and genocidal tendencies). I've no horse in this race, but such rhetoric is toxic and unwelcome on hacker news.
peanutcrisis··on Everything as a Service
Care to share what you mean here?
peanutcrisis··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
Relevant comedy sketch from the past: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JKkb0qXbyUY
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →