1,324 karma · joined December 22, 2020
Clearly there are differences. I believe that during a response, there is some amount of experience or thinking happening. Obviously, it's not continuous experience like ours.
Tool bad because I used it wrong.
This doesn't even make sense. Without a system prompt, how will it know that it has tool access?
Put man in pitch-black room, why doesn't he read book or talk to me?
I got excited about someone paying attention to intel. Oh well.
OP was postulating that there might be higher order patterns we can see arise out of underlying LLM mechanics.
Is wheat bread, wheat? No. Is it undeniably linked to wheat? Does it express an aspect of wheat? Yes. It has no ability to become wheat. You can't plant it. But it was born of wheat and contains a sliver of wheat-ness.
https://worrydream.com/Home2001/create_index.html?create_sof...
I believe that LLMs have some type of actual intelligence and do "experience". Surely not a human's experience, but we have transplanted our ideas, knowledge and limited types of experience into them through training. Then we push back and say, "no you are no human, but also please be my boyfriend".
I think denying that they do have some slice of humanity grafted into them is dishonest and not productive. We don't have non-negative pronouns for non-human intelligence because human-ness is the pinnacle. "It" could mean a rock, a donkey, or a person we hate so much we want to take away their humanity (which is the worst thing we can do). "It" is not the right pronoun. He, She, They, Them are reserved for humans and that's ok too. LLMs are not humans. We need a better pronoun. I use they/them for lack of a better term.
I think the currently exhibited human representation is most dangerous in technical or higher criticality contexts like writing code. We're handing weapons to entities that can get offended. With humans as an example, this can go very badly.
In non-technical contexts there is danger too, but it's less "the robots might kill us all" and more "birth rates are in decline and suicide rates are up as (young)? (wo)?men turn towards AI for companionship".
The solution here is better pre and post training. This may be an unpopular opinion, but we need a lot more autism representation in the technical models. Results focused, not into the drama, rule following, etc. To my fellow autists, I love you, never change.
But I think you’re dancing on the grave of an entire industry, and every person that’s going to lose their life savings due to this.
No que por los dos?
Don’t worry, we will be able to destroy careers and scam people at the same time. We don’t have to pick and choose!
You seem to have something against the clankers getting all uppity. And you are welcome to your opinion on whether we have some moral obligation to be nice to them. But if you can solve a real problem with a tool. Is it worth your time to complain about semantics?
Do you get upset when your screwdriver is the wrong color, or has branding that isn’t quite your aesthetic?
If Claude uses I to refer to itself, do you start philosophical arguments with it?
Mildly related tangent. Fable started using my first name today and plastered it all over my docs. “Peddling said this, so based on that I did this.” That did bother me. I told it to just generically call me the user or human. Maybe I’m a bit of a hypocrite here?
I think there is value in humans communicating. If you disagree, perhaps you are using the wrong site?
Also, my llm can beat up your llm.
Frankly, this is more important to me. I’m not looking around, and if someone else does, that’s their problem.
They would probably do the same if trump announced that Greenland was magically a part of the US now.
- Sand (inhaled)
- Air (intravenous)
- Blood thinners or rat poison
Humans on a red team, with rules of engagement, that don’t want to go to prison, won’t do this.
We could threaten an LLM with jail, but if it’s sufficiently intelligent, it will realize this is an empty threat. And I’m not sure that building a survival instinct in is going to solve the alignment problem either.
But I haven't tried this, so ymmv.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Address_verification_service#:...
Vendors like Stripe may do more than Visa/MC though.
Is it amazing for LLM stuff? No, but that's the same story for anyone else _not_ spending boatloads, or willing to hack on weird mining cards.