HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pedro_hab

307 karma · joined September 30, 2016

submissionscomments
pedro_hab··on Supply and Demand Does a Poor Job of Explaining Depressed Wages
> things are perhaps better now, sure

I really think you are forcing here, I said:

> probably lives better than kings

And I do conceded that I have not studied kings lives to know, so I am guessing, but the poor of the past for sure lived way worse then the current poor. No question. The world is a much better place to live, MUCH.

Now we can argue if should be better, based on distribution (rich are richer, than poor should also be richer) or inflation.

But people used to have dozens of kids and only a couple would live, that alone is enough to justify.

My grandparents had 7 kids in the middle of nowhere and none died.

pedro_hab··on Supply and Demand Does a Poor Job of Explaining Depressed Wages
This is an interesting topic, but it is sad to see how people react to it.

A lot of comments here saying the whole system is broken.

An average poor man in the US probably lives better than kings lived in the past.

Food, water, food, hospitals, AC, heaters and such. These evil employers/entrepreneurs are the one creating it.

Life by every metric is getting better, can it be better? Maybe.

Now we could discuss how to improve the system, and its flaws, but this level of cynicism is hard to handle.

I guess by coming from a really poor reality it skews my view of the world.

pedro_hab··on YouTube’s fake views economy
> google was altering their search results

Hnm, I think google is somewhat biased, but I can agree that this claim is weird, is it that bad though?

> Marxist academics are out to destroy society

History speaks for itself

> Bill C 16 and Free Speech

Kinda ties back to the Marxists, every video I've seen he said he would call trans with whatever pronoun they like, he opposes the government creating speech laws, which I think is a valid argument.

pedro_hab··on YouTube’s fake views economy
I don't get what's going on here, people getting downvoted, what has Peterson said that was that bad?

I heard he telling people to clean their rooms, and people getting offended by it.

I'd like to get enlighten on how is he in the same camp as Alex Jones.

Even then, I would bet Alex Jones and alt-right are not the only ones buying views, that shows the article is biased and HN too for that matter.

pedro_hab··on Operation Serenata de Amor – An AI project to analyze public spending in Brazil
Idk much about corporate taxes in Brazil, but I do know that the poor pay way too much, a minimum wage employee pays taxes and "contributions" and other forms of taxations, such as FGTS and inflation.

And they pay again when buying goods, I was shocked when I read about the welfare state and the welfare cliff in the US, for the propaganda I was subjected in Brazil it was hard to believe.

So Brazil is way worse for the poor than the US, and getting paid in Brazil as remote for me (as a dev) is cheaper, since I work as a contractor and would pay between 4-6% taxes against ~25% in the US.

pedro_hab··on Show HN: Investment Calculator – A simple retirement calculator
I meant to know what percentages he used, conservative/aggressive is relative.

In the US the FED Interest Rate was about ~.25-.55 a couple years ago where the Brazilian was ~14%

pedro_hab··on Operation Serenata de Amor – An AI project to analyze public spending in Brazil
hmn, do you mean corruption is not as bad as income inequality?

Because one can argue that corruption foster inequality, where government workers steal money from the people, they give favor to rich "friends" making them richer.

I can guess your solution is to give more power to the state to solve the inequality issue, which actually worsens the corruption caused inequality.

pedro_hab··on Operation Serenata de Amor – An AI project to analyze public spending in Brazil
Yeah, there is a saying that “Politics is downstream from culture”, the Brazilian culture does not help.

I don't have much hope.

pedro_hab··on Show HN: Investment Calculator – A simple retirement calculator
I have the same issue, if we could change the percentages we could ignore the dollar signs.
pedro_hab··on Show HN: Investment Calculator – A simple retirement calculator
I'd like to know what aggressive/conservative means, and also be able change it, aggressive in the US might be different than in other countries.
pedro_hab··on Why Amazon, Apple, Facebook, and Google Need to Be Disrupted
On the math part, I see a lot of complaints on the rich, in these case the big four are indeed huge, but compared to what?

Last time I check none of these had reach $ 1T value, compared to the US government that expends $ 3T a year.

No one of those same people seem to be concerned with the harms of the a government expending so much money.

pedro_hab··on 'It Was the First Time I Cried in the Operating Room'
Yeah, the doctors I've talked to tend to say the same. A neurosurgeon seeing a MRI or CT scan of my wife's brain said it would be amusing to see her brain's tissues, but fortunately it was not needed.

I had a surgery in my hips which the doctor said the same, he wanted to do the surgery to improve his research and even asked me to use my files, anonymously obviously, in his presentations and research.

I think we all are interested in our work, and he said that every case is different, I'm not sure if experience would help much.

pedro_hab··on Is Legal Pot Crippling Mexican Drug Trafficking Organisations?
Wow, the state deems drugs to be illegal, but anarcho-capitalism is to blame somehow.

A lot of people here are so steadfast to the bigger state idea that they see it everywhere as a solution even when it's the cause.

pedro_hab··on Brazil Unveils Plans to Censor the Internet to Stop “Fake News”
Dilma was caught in a letter trying to buy the Paraguay Congress to add Venezuela to Mercosul.

Although I think this had nothing to do with the impeachment.

> without proof of any crime

Is misleading. She deserved to be impeached, and so does the current president, mostly likely so will the next one.

pedro_hab··on Meltdown Proof-of-Concept
I've seen these in youtube b4, but they were taken down. I'd careful with the title to avoid it.
pedro_hab··on Inequality in nature and society
You are right, sorry for that, but this would really long comment.

We could point out socialist/communist countries, they are/were not better off trying to implant cosmic justice, they ended up worse.

The difference now seems to be that rich countries can afford it, which is weird, since they can afford by using a capitalist system to begin with.

pedro_hab··on Inequality in nature and society
The point was that it's too complicated, trying to fix is pointless, my point is that it is not fixable, if you accept that is a problem, even in a perfect wealth redistribution system, there will be luck involved.

But I also make the point that it is not a problem to begin with, I think inequality makes sense, me having more that my peers when I went where they wouldn't seems fair.

pedro_hab··on Inequality in nature and society
I agree with you that the market allows for it to me somewhat manipulated, one could argue that's how it works.

But that's where I think there may be a better solution, (again a personal option), but I also think it could be a feature, someone with power can control it, but to what extent is the real question.

There is a lot of talk around how the rich are powerful, I have checked, and the richest around don't have that much money.

The US spends trillions a year, that's a lot of money, there isn't a single trillionaire, there isn't a corporation valued at a trillion dollars (yet, almost there though).

If you round up the rich's money, it won't last that long. and now you destroyed the system.

They don't control everything, they may control the market but the market is huge compared to them, and the rich do not have an alliance to control it, making them weaker.

And you just accepted that the state (lawmakers) are corrupt, as people tend to be. So the redistribution of wealth would use these corrupt people to make the world a better place, the idea is flawed in that sense, you would need to speculate on a new righteous system excluding the corrupt, for redistribution of wealth to even have a chance work (people actually getting the money), and then speculate on how this would be beneficial.

pedro_hab··on Inequality in nature and society
I found myself lacking to fully understand this.

I sort of got the idea that you are fond with freedom with the greek story.

But then I sense a little disregard for the free market with the > "commoners chose your app", and how there is a circle trying to be privileged at expense of others.

Do you mean the state (with laws) should fix this circle?

pedro_hab··on Inequality in nature and society
Yes, it's a complex matter, I do not think I know the answers and I'm curious on what the future holds. And I might read more into it.

My gut says we have seen what works, I'd argue that freedom has shown as the best approach to poverty, the only approach I personally have seen so far (keep in mind I am not a researcher in this).

"Socialist" ideas have been tried and even when it "works" it's not clear that it did. Where freedom (read capitalism) is crystal clear (like it or not).

Whatever degree of freedom is given to socialist/communist societies we clearly see improvements. (off tangent much, sry)

But to be concrete, every wealthy country I know of used freedom to get where it is.

I'm from Brazil, I see how these inequality ideas are sold there, how wealth distribution is holding us back.

Enabling people to do what they want is proven to work, allow them to enjoy the spoils of it is proven too, some things will look unfair, that's the way nature is.

Putting our fate in the hands of other is not an idea I see of value, the state is controlled by people, and these people are, like ourselves deeply flawed.

pedro_hab··on Observable Universe contains 10x more galaxies than previously thought (2016)
I wonder if this has some impact in our (mis)understarding of dark-matter/dark-energy, and how the universe expands.
pedro_hab··on Inequality in nature and society
That's what I meant, trying to figure it out what's luck and whats isn't is impossible, as you put it

> all entirely luck to the core

But now how can you, or anyone else have a say in what is equal?

It's all so complicated, trying to do anything about it is pointless, it feels to me as arrogant to think you can find a solution to all this.

I think you are right, we should focus on the problem itself, instead of what's fair.

Everything is luck, you have no control over your starting point. It's all random, to try to say you understand this is the same as saying you understand quantum mechanics:

"If you think you understand quantum mechanics, you don't understand quantum mechanics." -Feynman

Now to say we can fix it with a system of redistribution of wealth is wishful thinking.

I'd argue that this system will be unequal, and worse.

Reminds me of my SO's siblings, they say my SO is successful because she had a father (showed up after she was 10 btw), or her mother liked her more, or some other reason, which sure has an effect.

They had a pretty equal starting point, the are broke because they are losers, to say my wife must share her wealth with them is evil.

I always hear the inequality card as "The losers want to be winners". Of course they want, now the question is it fair?

pedro_hab··on Inequality in nature and society
There is a dilbert strip were the CEO tells the Intern that he got where he is because he was smart not by luck.

The intern then asked how did he choose his IQ pre birth.

pedro_hab··on Inequality in nature and society
So you really believe that even though inequality is a constant, it's everywhere, it's unstoppable. Even then there is still space to try to fix it?

It's not a bug it's a feature. (Software dev here :))

I heard someone calling it cosmic justice, which seems to fit pretty well.

Inequality is a must, this idea that its bad is based solely on a philosophy of evil.

Everyone ended poorer as a consequence of trying to fix this, thinking everyone has a right to have something is evil.

pedro_hab··on Inequality in nature and society
I'd argue that this argument is invalid for practical uses. Saying that luck is unfair is in my opinion a useless and even evil idea, it can be used to justify terrible acts.

Everything is luck, or did you choose what family you'd be born in? Did you choose your physical attributes?

Inequality is inevitable, it is natural, and its fair, everyone got a dice roll, no one had control over it, no one can.

In spite of these starting points, which are not the only luck based you will encounter, people can rise where others won't.

pedro_hab··on Gravitational waves from a binary black hole merger observed by LIGO and Virgo
I know right? There is a video on veritasium on how absurd this is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iphcyNWFD10
pedro_hab··on Insane state of today's advertising part 3
It's the easiest way to serve an dynamic ad, it will require further configuration to get it to go through your own domain, and ad blockers block by element selectors and ad placement, so even those served through your domain will eventually get blocked. To avoid adblocker one would have to actually blend the ad with page moving it in the page to avoid getting detected, which might not be acceptable UX/UI.
pedro_hab··on I’m Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA
That's my second J-1, I actually got the waiver for the first, but we gave up going for the H1-b at the moment.

It was pretty straightforward getting it as a brazilian.

pedro_hab··on Rumours swell over new kind of gravitational-wave sighting
I have the same question, based on the Alcubierre Drive math, (Wrap Drive) which is based on that space can travel at any speed.

But I also know that the Alcubierre Drive have some weird implications, such as the inner of the ship is causally disconnected from the space wrap, basically you can't control it from the inside.

Anyways, I'm curious if the gravitational waves are "space waves", in that case it wouldn't have limit, as space can move at any speed.

pedro_hab··on I’m Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA
I'm going to the US on a J-1 visa, I don't have a Bachelor's degree, though I have 2 years pursuing it.

It seemed unlikely I'd get a H1-b w/o the bachelors, what other options do I have?

I've thought on going back to Brazil for a year, then coming back on a L1 as a last resort.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4