That's what I meant, trying to figure it out what's luck and whats isn't is impossible, as you put it
> all entirely luck to the core
But now how can you, or anyone else have a say in what is equal?
It's all so complicated, trying to do anything about it is pointless, it feels to me as arrogant to think you can find a solution to all this.
I think you are right, we should focus on the problem itself, instead of what's fair.
Everything is luck, you have no control over your starting point. It's all random, to try to say you understand this is the same as saying you understand quantum mechanics:
"If you think you understand quantum mechanics, you don't understand quantum mechanics." -Feynman
Now to say we can fix it with a system of redistribution of wealth is wishful thinking.
I'd argue that this system will be unequal, and worse.
Reminds me of my SO's siblings, they say my SO is successful because she had a father (showed up after she was 10 btw), or her mother liked her more, or some other reason, which sure has an effect.
They had a pretty equal starting point, the are broke because they are losers, to say my wife must share her wealth with them is evil.
I always hear the inequality card as "The losers want to be winners". Of course they want, now the question is it fair?