HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pelzatessa

62 karma · joined October 2, 2025

submissionscomments
pelzatessa··on Signal Protocol and Post-Quantum Ratchets
Yeah, that's true. If they did though, then I think that they'd be more secure than with Signal, at least in this certain aspect of message storage.
pelzatessa··on Signal Protocol and Post-Quantum Ratchets
My point is that to this date everyone was not post-quantum secure, and only the people whom had their messages stored on their servers only can be sure that someone won't read their contents.

Also PGP emails were just an idea that seemed the most basic for me to illustrate an example of selfhosted encrypted messaging. Probably they lack more security features than just post-quantum, compared to the other messengers anyway :)

pelzatessa··on Signal Protocol and Post-Quantum Ratchets
It is possible for them to say that they deleted the messages without actually deleting them though. One has to trust a pretty big company in order to not worry about the messages actually not being stored anywhere.

I'm not aware of all techniques that Signal uses to somehow make the message anonymous even when if the encryption would have been broken, but sealed sender seems to be one of them:

https://signal.org/blog/sealed-sender/

So at least there's that. Unless the encrypted sealed sender messages aren't somehow being fingerprinted by the IP address of client and the timestamps of connections. Signal probably also says that they don't log these, but with self hosted mailserver I wouldn't have to trust them on that too.

pelzatessa··on Signal Protocol and Post-Quantum Ratchets
This is actually disturbing, as the article suggests that all previous messages sent using Signal are decryptable with quantum computers. If there are people with, for example, selfhosted mailservers sending PGP encrypted emails to each other, then, while they have to worry about them not leaking out from the server either by someone hacking to it or someone sniffing the traffic with the encrypted messages beforehand, they know for sure that their messages are safe.

Meanwhile Signal users have been sending messages onto signal servers for years now, as far as I know they aren't sent directly through some p2p protocol. I don't know what their policy is about storing messages, and I believe that they have a lot of other countermeasures, but it still points to the problem with Signals centralized nature.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2