HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pencilguin

396 karma · joined October 16, 2022

submissionscomments
pencilguin··on Red meat is not a health risk. New study slams years of shoddy research
It is unfortunate because we cannot in good conscience ask people to switch from barely-processed meat to ultra-processed meat substitutes, despite the meat industry's heavy contribution to looming climate disaster.

Many of us have switched to things other than meat, but that choice seems beyond most people.

Another alternative is what is called "lab-grown meat", which is not a meat substitute, per se, but is actual meat that might be a lot less harmful to produce. Where it sits on the "processed" spectrum is hard to assess. Obviously it is, in one sense, 100% processed, but details matter.

pencilguin··on Floating solar panels that track the Sun
The operators of the many GW of floating PV in use seem to have solved your string problem, assuming there was any. My guess, not.

Any competent engineer can design a perfectly workable utility-scale energy storage system. All that is uncertain is which designs will be cheapest, or otherwise most practical. (There are many kinds of cost.) Experience will identify the best. We have lots of pumped hydro storage because we have lots of hydro generation easily retrofitted with a pump.

Other utility storage is not being built out much yet because it would be stupid to build storage there is not renewable generation to charge from, and utility operators are not generally stupid. Small battery arrays that shift just a small excess of energy from midday to early evening, and otherwise stabilize grid fluctuations, have been massively successful.

pencilguin··on The surprising afterlife of unwanted atom bombs
Certain politically important contractors' cash flow would be threatened.
pencilguin··on The surprising afterlife of unwanted atom bombs
Literally no one is actively trying to colonize anywhere off Earth. Some people lie about it when not too busy lying about other things.
pencilguin··on Computer proof ‘blows up’ centuries-old fluid equations
... of what people can and also choose to observe about nature.
pencilguin··on Computer proof ‘blows up’ centuries-old fluid equations
If you can't get anybody to read your proof, does it demonstrate anything?

Fred Moxley has (what seems to me like, but what do I know?) a nice proof of the Riemann conjecture that he got by quantizing the problem. But nobody will read it, because mathematicians don't like that method. It might be right or not, but it anyway doesn't tell you anything surprising about prime numbers, so nobody can be bothered.

pencilguin··on Computer proof ‘blows up’ centuries-old fluid equations
I guess this answers why you can't just try it with liquid helium: even that isn't ideal enough.
pencilguin··on The surprising afterlife of unwanted atom bombs
Likewise, for fusion experiments.

I see assertions in planning documents that the supply of tritium on hand is wholly inadequate for planned research operations on ITER, never mind its successor imagined to be built in such a way as to be able to drive a steam turbine, or likewise SPARC or its imagined successor. I.e. there is not enough for either program, never mind both.

And Helion's D-3He reactor would need lots of 3He, and be utterly dependent on making more, itself. It takes 12 years for half of your stock of tritium to spontaneously become the needed 3He, and no possibility of hurrying it along.

pencilguin··on The surprising afterlife of unwanted atom bombs
This seems to make claims of a shortage of plutonium for deep-space RTG power systems into lies. It seems like there is plenty of Pu for all the deep space missions we could otherwise afford.
pencilguin··on Matrix v1.5 Release
That is encouraging. The dodgy code I see in Nheko itself must, then, be mostly UI stuff, probably coded the way dictated by Qt.
pencilguin··on Floating solar panels that track the Sun
So you build out storage facilities. Whatever turns out cheapest for a given site wins. Different sites will favor different winners. We don't know yet which few of myriad choices that all work will turn out cheapest, but probably not batteries beyond a few hours' time-shifting.

There is little value in central storage, except in methods where economy of scale rules. Storage can otherwise be distributed as widely as convenience suggests, and the power moved around on wiring.

Of course you don't build out storage until you have enough spare renewable generating capacity to charge it from. In the meantime you fill shortfalls from peaker plants, the usual way. As synthetic fuels like hydrogen and ammonia become cheaper than NG, peakers will be fired with them, either synthesized locally or imported, when cheaper storage runs low.

pencilguin··on Floating solar panels that track the Sun
Alternatively, floating PV could be a lot cheaper than installing solid mounting hardware to hold panels off the ground and kept from blowing away in wind that gets under them.
pencilguin··on Floating solar panels that track the Sun
No solar installation will block all of the light. Gaps between panels or rows may provide as much light as could be desired.

Note, most aquatic wildlife benefits from shade, even where they depend on an algae-rooted food chain.

pencilguin··on Floating solar panels that track the Sun
It should be obvious that it would be foolish to expect to meet all your power needs, including EV charging, with a small rooftop installation. Rooftop solar is to cut down on your power bill.

"For a society to run on PV on scale" you of course rely on municipal, commercial, and regional "actual tech" solar and wind installations, storage, transmission lines and backup peaker plants to make up the difference. Some storage might involve lithium batteries, or other chemistries, or non-chemical methods such as pumped hydro or other gravitational methods, compressed or liquified air, or synthetic fuels such as hydrogen and ammonia; and commonly a mix of the above.

Floating PV is sited at places where the water is habitually calm; calm water is always flat. Reservoirs and canals are favored sites, as noted in the article. Nobody talks about floating PV on breaking shore waves. It is hard to guess what could be meant by "string output", if anything, unique to floating PV. Solar panel output is the same, terrestrial or floating, and is handled the same way.

We are fortunate that planning for regional renewable power does not depend on people who cannot see how they would deploy it. Others, including other engineers, can and do.

Floating solar will be sited throughout most of the world. Ice on a solar panel does not reduce its output much, but being embedded in ice that, finally, breaks up could be damaging. Engineers are good at designing for local conditions.

The article makes a big deal of imaginary shortfalls of available land for solar, but there is in fact very far from any such shortage. So, solar will always be sited wherever it is cheapest. Some places, it will be floated. Other places, it will share pasturage or crop land. Others, commercial warehouses. In France it will be, by statute, on all big parking lots.

pencilguin··on Floating solar panels that track the Sun
People always seem to jump to the the most complicated and expensive design alternatives. A central pivot and a loop of rope around a motor capstan on-shore to gradually rotate the whole array would be obviously simpler and cheaper.

The extreme for preferring absurd complication seems especially to show up in attempts at extracting wave energy. So, wave energy startups almost always fail; not because the energy is insufficient or hard to extract, but just because they seem compelled to field doomed, overpriced, expensive, and fragile designs.

I sometimes wonder if you need to have foolishly complicated tech to impress investors, who would be disinclined to fund what they feel like they could understand.

Generally, if you are putting stuff out in the water, apparatus that might need servicing should be onshore, with the simplest possible connection out to stuff in the water. For wave energy collection, make your collectors suck air out of a big, shared pipe from shore, with a turbine in the inlet onshore. You don't want your expensive, fragile turbine attacked by salt water and crashing waves, and you don't want lots of little ones where one big, shared one does better.

Apparatus to collect wave energy should be always under the surface, away from crashing surface waves.

pencilguin··on ‘Deep geothermal’ promises to let drillers go deeper, faster and hotter
What they don't tell you is that geothermal is not a growth industry because nobody sees any way to make it, or anything that needs a steam turbine to operate, competitive with wind and solar. If it were made competitive today, it would not be, anymore, tomorrow. Steam turbines are mature tech, so costs are not plummeting.
pencilguin··on Red meat is not a health risk. New study slams years of shoddy research
Unfortunately, "plant-based meat substitute" is, canonically, ultra-processed food.
pencilguin··on Musk’s Twitter Buy Makes No Sense – Unless It’s Part of Something Bigger
You mean he expects a favor from every right-wing nut.
pencilguin··on Twitter to employees: all office buildings closed, badge access suspended
Yet, Gwynne seems happy to lie about suborbital freight for him, and about colonizing Mars. I have not encountered anyone prominent at Tesla supporting his lies about self-driving (though that doesn't mean none do).
pencilguin··on Twitter to employees: all office buildings closed, badge access suspended
It would have cost him "only" a $B to weasel out, much less than expected losses. So it has value to him greater than those losses. Would be unsurprising if he used it for political leverage. I don't think he is allowed to run for the presidency, but he can probably seat his choice.
pencilguin··on Twitter to employees: all office buildings closed, badge access suspended
My bet is he bought it for the political power controlling it brings. It was cheap, if it works for that, at any loss rate.
pencilguin··on Why are U.S. transit projects so costly? This group is on the case
You are very, very, very confused.

If you have not noticed that many people find it very easy to lie to you, I hope you discover it without suffering much. Elon Musk and Trump fans, e.g., seem not to have noticed.

pencilguin··on Punctuation and other ways negotiators have resolved climate change issues
Most people think displacing CO2 production is a much more cost-effective course than building out carbon capture.

After we have deployed enough carbon-neutral energy production, we will then need to do massive carbon capture. But in the meantime, carbon capture mostly just enables polluters.

pencilguin··on Matrix v1.5 Release
They seem all-over naked pointers. I even find naked "new" expressions in Quaternion.

Anyway mtxclient looks different from the others. It wasn't listed among clients (neochat, nheko, quaternion) on the Wikipedia page.

pencilguin··on What’s the real reason you can’t go faster than the speed of light?
Nothing in physics forbids information moving backward in time, provided it has no effect on whether the event communicated will happen after it arrives.

So, information about an earthquake or asteroid strike, or even a plane crash if you don't prevent it, is fine. You can choose not to get on the plane, based on the information. But if you did stop the plane taking off, what physical event would there be to communicate?

That is not to say information does routinely go back, or does just because somebody wants for it to. The universe appears not generally to care what people want. But if any does go back, and organic systems could pick it up, it would be adaptively advantageous to be receptive to it.

Again, just because it could happen, in principle, doesn't mean it does. It would depend on some biological structure being just incidentally sensitive to the signal, and then refined by selection. It would be a Rube Goldberg sort of process, but study of parasite lifecycles will cure you of skepticism as to nature's tolerance for dodgy complexity and marginal usefulness.

pencilguin··on Matrix v1.5 Release
I am starting to think it is getting time to try out Matrix again, this time with my own homeserver that won't disappear from under me like the last three services.

Looking at the three C++ clients' source code, it seems all depressingly pre-modern. Maybe the SerenityOS crew can do better? But I wonder if Qt forces archaic practices on programs that use it.

pencilguin··on Punctuation and other ways negotiators have resolved climate change issues
They are not. Each year, more CO2 is emitted than the previous year, and the increase over the previous year is larger than last time.

So, the total CO2 in the atmosphere is larger each year: positive first derivative, slope is up. The total added to the atmosphere per unit time is also larger than last year: positive second derivative. It is possible that the amount by which it is larger than last year's is itself decreasing: negative third derivative. But that is hard to perceive.

pencilguin··on RISC-V: The Last ISA?
Let us not forget SPARC's register windows.

I don't know if you could say RISC-V was optimized, as such, for undergraduate courses, but historically that was its design target. That said, there was a lot more attention to extensibility via regularized instruction set extensions than the undergraduate target demanded.

RISC-V's permanently-zero register is akin to other RISCs' special multiplication registers.

pencilguin··on RISC-V: The Last ISA?
I pronounce it "riskive", myself. Had there been a RISC-IV it would have been pronounced the same, so it is lucky there wasn't one.
pencilguin··on Punctuation and other ways negotiators have resolved climate change issues
We usually call that "weaseling".

You could say it is why CO2 emissions continue increasing at a sharply increasing rate. But presumably any behavior within an "agreement" is better than identically the same behavior with no agreement. Somehow.

← PreviousPage 2 of 16Next →