HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

perennate

978 karma · joined November 8, 2015

submissionscomments
perennate··on Twitter deletes China embassy's Xinjiang 'emancipation' tweet
The problem with no moderation and NOT deleting obvious misinformation and fake news is that social media platforms would then be overrun by bot accounts. Because of the strong capabilities of automation on the Internet, protecting free speech on the Internet does not have a clear solution. What is clear is that deleting obvious misinformation such as this tweet is in the public interest.
perennate··on Twitter deletes China embassy's Xinjiang 'emancipation' tweet
The power of these corporations is a big issue, but the deletion of obvious misinformation and fake news such as the tweet in question here is clearly in the public interest. If anything, future regulation of social media platforms would likely include provisions that force the social media platforms to delete misleading content like this tweet.
perennate··on Twitter deletes China embassy's Xinjiang 'emancipation' tweet
Twitter has the right (and, really, an ethical obligation) to deter the spread of misinformation by malicious actors. This tweet implicitly makes the false claim that mass sterilization in Xinjiang is voluntary, and its deletion will mitigate the impact of the misinformation and fake news.
perennate··on Twitter deletes China embassy's Xinjiang 'emancipation' tweet
A ministry of information would jail and possibly harvest the organs of those sending the information. As far as I know, Twitter has not arrested and harvested the organs of anyone working in the embassy.
perennate··on Twitter deletes China embassy's Xinjiang 'emancipation' tweet
That forced sterilization is happening is fact. Twitter isn't taking a "stand" on what the truth is (it is telling that you put truth in quotes). Twitter is simply deleting tweets that spread misinformation, whether the misinformation is about US election claims or pretending that there isn't a genocide happening in Xinjiang. Actions such as this that deter the spread of fake news on social media platforms are needed because bot accounts that rapidly repeat false statements are possible on the Internet.
perennate··on Lifting Self-Imposed Restrictions on the U.S.-Taiwan Relationship
Or Biden can take no action and continue the status quo. I don't see how it boxes him in at all. The status quo would be fine if Xi Jinping weren't continuing to inflame tensions by setting a 2049 deadline for forcefully retaking Taiwan (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-46733174).
perennate··on Lifting Self-Imposed Restrictions on the U.S.-Taiwan Relationship
There is no point in provoking China into a war because it would lead to a nuclear war which would end humanity as we know it. Everyone would lose in any all-on war between two nuclear powers. China has been far more provoking than the US, with Xi Jinping continuing to maintain a 2049 deadline for taking back Taiwan, with force if needed, not to mention cracking down on the pro-democracy party in Hong Kong, which has only inflamed tensions with Taiwan and really won Tsai Ing-wen her second term.
perennate··on Lifting Self-Imposed Restrictions on the U.S.-Taiwan Relationship
You are referring to the de jure claims, which Taiwan only maintains due to pressure from the PRC. If Taiwan officially cedes these claims, the PRC would respond with economic sanctions, because the PRC wants Taiwan to continue to pretend it is another faction of the same country still fighting the civil war and not an independent country.
perennate··on Lifting Self-Imposed Restrictions on the U.S.-Taiwan Relationship
Currently PRC pressures Taiwan to maintain the status quo, which is that both the PRC and ROC are different factions of the same country. While Taiwan ending official "claims" to the mainland might be seen by the PRC as slightly less bold than declaring independence, the PRC would likely implement the same damaging economic sanctions and increased military threats, so in this case Taiwan might as well declare independence.
perennate··on Lifting Self-Imposed Restrictions on the U.S.-Taiwan Relationship
The KMT does not want to eventually re-unify the PRC. They merely want to continue pretending to want to eventually re-unify with the PRC to maintain good economic relations. Because the PRC accounts for 28% of Taiwan's exports and 19% of Taiwan's imports (https://www.wto.org/english/res_e/statis_e/daily_update_e/tr...).

Really hardly anyone in Taiwan wants to re-unify with the PRC, they have seen the genocide the fascist CCP is committing against the Uighur people in Xinjiang, if the CCP repeats this in Taiwan and exterminates or sterilizes millions of Taiwanese it would be devastating. Nobody wants to bear witness to genocide, but even more so, nobody wants to be a victim to genocide, so supporting re-unification would be senseless.

perennate··on Lifting Self-Imposed Restrictions on the U.S.-Taiwan Relationship
Parent comment discussed "democracy activists in Hong Kong being rounded up" -- Bagacrap was of course misleadingly labeling those activists as "secessionists", unless you think Bagacrap was referring to the Taiwanese people even though Taiwan is an independent country and has no need for secession beyond a legal formality. On whether these activists are secessionists: their demands focus on advancing democratic elections in Hong Kong while continuing under the "one country two systems" framework, the claim that they are asking for secession is incorrect given that the vast majority of the activists do not want Hong Kong to secede from China.

Edit: see https://www.scmp.com/yp/discover/news/hong-kong/article/3065... which is from a newspaper in China (so even if it is biased, it would be biased towards pro-CCP views). As you can see, these activists want self-determination for Hong Kong, but do not want Hong Kong to leave or secede from China.

perennate··on Lifting Self-Imposed Restrictions on the U.S.-Taiwan Relationship
Not to mention China's continued campaign of genocide against the Uighur people in Xinjiang. (And yes, when the CCP employs mass sterilization to prevent Uighurs from having children and interns millions in concentration camps without due process, it is genocide). Amazing that the world can basically ignore an ongoing modern-day Holocaust. If the US, Europe, and their allies purport to believe in universal human rights, they must put economic pressure on the PRC until the CCP ends these horrific actions.
perennate··on Lifting Self-Imposed Restrictions on the U.S.-Taiwan Relationship
> Every place has the right to self determination, but secessionists tend to be treated as criminals.

The HK democracy activists are protesting in support of self determination. Those arrested are not "secessionists", and as far as I know, Hong Kong has not left the PRC, so your comparison doesn't really make any sense.

perennate··on Von Braun Class Station
Why quote that when the Wikipedia article that it's from is titled "rotating wheel space station"? Rotating wheel is more descriptive than Von Braun or Tsiolkovsky or Potočnik.
perennate··on SolarWinds exposed FTP credentials in Public Github Repo: US Government Breach
The article title is "SolarWinds exposed FTP credentials in Public Github Repo" (in 2019) which is far less definitive than the misleading title submitted on HN.
perennate··on Biden wins White House, vowing new direction for divided U.S.
I googled it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grover_Cleveland
perennate··on Biden wins White House, vowing new direction for divided U.S.
What do you mean "all media called Gore the winner"? I can't find any evidence of that. According to Wikipedia [1], "on November 8 ... the networks declared that Bush had carried Florida and therefore been elected president. ... after all votes were counted, ... the networks retracted their declarations that Bush had won Florida and the presidency".

Also, note that Gore privately conceded the election that night, but retracted it after further counting due to the <1000 vote margin.

So in fact major networks (including CNN, ABC, FOX) initially called Bush the winner, but retracted that afterwards due to the possibility of a recount.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_United_States_presidentia...

perennate··on Biden wins White House, vowing new direction for divided U.S.
Clinton conceded the election to Trump the day after the election.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/nov/09/hillary-clin...

perennate··on Commerce Department Prohibits WeChat and TikTok Transactions
I don't know, you tell me? I didn't say anything about Trump administration banning European internet service companies.
perennate··on Commerce Department Prohibits WeChat and TikTok Transactions
The policies are harmful, and reciprocal policies are good policies. I don't think this is inconsistent. It's just like how US imposing tariffs on Canadian aluminum is harmful, but Canada reciprocating with its own tariffs is definitely good policy -- otherwise there would be no economic incentive for the US to stop its tariffs.

Canada reciprocating protects the free flow of trade by discouraging further tariffs. Similarly, here, India and the US reciprocating protects the free flow of software/information by discouraging CCP bans.

perennate··on Commerce Department Prohibits WeChat and TikTok Transactions
That (emulating CCP policies) is exactly what the US is NOT doing. Instead, the US has chosen to surgically target companies from specific countries (in this case, China) in a sensible, reciprocal reaction.

(I see many posters saying the US should pass legislation like the laws that China has, rather than respond in a surgical, targeted way. Doing so would have far more restricting effects.)

When US imposes tariffs on Canada, we expect Canada to impose reciprocal tariffs on the US; these serve to discourage the original action (US-imposed tariffs), and encourage the free flow of trade. Similarly, reciprocal reactions by India and the US serve the exact goal that you mentioned -- leading by example, discouraging other countries from imposing the same restrictions in non-reciprocal ways, and encouraging the free flow of software/information.

perennate··on Commerce Department Prohibits WeChat and TikTok Transactions
I think the US passing legislation that requires foreign companies to transfer their technology (or worse, copying brutally repressive CCP laws on media) would be far far far more damaging than surgically banning companies from specific countries under a reciprocal reaction.
perennate··on Commerce Department Prohibits WeChat and TikTok Transactions
Given the arbitrary way in which the CCP laws you mentioned are applied, I don't see any practical difference with the US action. I do agree that the CCP's way gives a better image so that its spokespeople can pretend like they are just upholding the rule of law and hide the reality.
perennate··on Commerce Department Prohibits WeChat and TikTok Transactions
When the US imposes tariffs on other countries, like Canada, we expect Canada to reciprocate.

Reciprocal countermeasures are crucial for discouraging the original activity, whether it be tariffs or bans on foreign internet service companies.

Thus, in response to the CCP's effective ban on foreign companies, we should absolutely expect India, the US, and other countries to reciprocate.

Failing to reciprocate would only serve to encourage actors to engage more in the activity (whether it be tariffs or bans on internet services), and in this case lead to a more greatly fragmented internet.

Just as reciprocal tariffs protect the free flow of trade by discouraging further tariffs, here, the US reciprocating CCP bans protects the free flow of information on the internet.

perennate··on Commerce Department Prohibits WeChat and TikTok Transactions
Exactly. When the US imposes tariffs on Canadian aluminum, we expect Canada to reciprocate. When China imposes bans on foreign internet service companies, we expect India, the US, and other affected countries to reciprocate.

Failing to reciprocate will merely serve to encourage these bans and lead to a further fragmented internet.

perennate··on Commerce Department Prohibits WeChat and TikTok Transactions
So far, the primary country that has developed its own fragmented internet is China. The response from India, the US, and others merely represents a reciprocal retaliation to the CCP's arbitrary bans on foreign internet service companies, just as Canada retaliated to US-imposed aluminum tariffs with its own tariffs.

Until countries begin imposing these types of bans in a non-reciprocal fashion (i.e., targeting countries other than China), there is no reason to believe that the internet will become further fragmented outside of China. Furthermore, the main goal of reciprocal retaliation is to discourage the original activity, so if anything, reciprocal actions by India and the US will prevent further fragmentation of the internet.

Arguing that the US should not engage in these actions is like arguing that Canada should not respond to US-imposed tariffs with its own tariffs on US goods. Failing to reciprocate would lead to more tariffs, not less.

perennate··on Commerce Department Prohibits WeChat and TikTok Transactions
After the U.S. imposed tariffs on Canadian aluminum, Canada responded with tariffs on U.S. goods [1]. A reciprocal retaliation makes sense to discourage the other side from continuing to participate in these market practices.

If reciprocal retaliation to China's arbitrary bans on US and European Internet service companies is bad, then so is reciprocal retaliation to US-imposed tariffs; but that fails to appropriately discourage the US from imposing more tariffs, and leads to greater restrictions on free trade, not less.

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2020/08/07/canada-to-impose-tariffs-on-...

perennate··on Commerce Department Prohibits WeChat and TikTok Transactions
Yes, it would be great for the American people if China bans iPhones -- Apple would have less of an economic incentive to follow arbitrary and brutally repressive takedown demands from the CCP government like this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19997188

Also, hope the US bans Xiaomi phones for the same reason, since applications like Facebook don't appear in the Mi Store.

perennate··on Home Office Projects Series: Air conditioner setup
> many countries providing supports for either split systems or, more commonly, 'window' units.

I think that's what GP was saying about the US -- while window units are very common, split systems are relatively rare. But anyway I think most of the article wasn't specific to a split system A/C unit, or even air conditioners in general.

perennate··on Home Office Projects Series: Air conditioner setup
Most of the blog post was about reverse engineering the control protocol and automating the unit. The same principles could be applied to other A/C units, like window units that are ubiquitous in many parts of the US. It is not specific to split system, they didn't even install it themselves, that was a minor part of the blog post. Also, their methodology of writing their own software is uncommon anywhere, even in Japan; but that's true of many things that get posted here, that's what makes them interesting.
← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →