HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

perennate

978 karma · joined November 8, 2015

submissionscomments
perennate··on Chinese battery expert is charged with stealing trade secrets from US employer
I agree, but keep in mind that Hongjin has merely been charged and not convicted yet. The evidence has not been presented in court yet, and it's quite likely that the evidence is going to be much much more comprehensive than the small set of facts that appeared in the SCMP article. If this is really all the evidence the FBI has, though, Hongjin will almost certainly not be convicted.
perennate··on Chinese battery expert is charged with stealing trade secrets from US employer
If all of the evidence the FBI has is what was in the SCMP article, then there is no way the jury is going to come to a guilty verdict.

But it is doubtful that the SCMP has squeezed information out of the FBI before the court case. Once the court case happens we will see all the evidence that the FBI has gathered, which probably demonstrates much more clearly that he is guilty. It doesn't make sense to discuss hypotheticals until we at least have the evidence.

It also doesn't make sense to fear getting convicted based on deleting some files unless he is actually convicted on this flimsy evidence. But again, this is unlikely -- if you would not convict someone based solely on this evidence, then why do you think anyone else would decide on a guilty verdict?

(Keep in mind that the information in the affidavit [1] "is intended to show merely that there is sufficient probable cause for the requested warrant" and doesn't include all of the evidence that they have.)

[1] https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1122851/downl...

perennate··on Chinese battery expert is charged with stealing trade secrets from US employer
The article is from SCMP, a newspaper in Hong Kong. It's unclear what the source of the information is and it's very unlikely that the SCMP has the same information that the FBI has (as stated in the affidavit [1], the evidence in the affidavit "is intended to show merely that there is sufficient probable cause for the requested warrant").

As the Department of Justice statement [2] says:

> A criminal complaint is merely an allegation, and the defendant is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt in a court of law.

There will be a court case where the FBI will lay out all the evidence they have and the jury will decide whether or not the evidence is sufficient to demonstrate that he is guilty.

The court case has not happened yet so it doesn't make sense to jump to conclusions without hearing the evidence first.

[1] https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1122851/downl... [2] https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/chinese-national-charged-comm...

perennate··on Grab is messing up OpenStreetMap data in Southeast Asia
Development Seed has a project Urchn that was trying to do something like that: https://medium.com/devseed/make-sense-of-urban-change-fabb9f...

The idea was to take satellite imagery of the same location from different timestamps and I believe use deep learning to determine if anything in the imagery changed.

I don't think they've released any code for that project yet though.

But for determining whether or not the imagery could be used in a certain region, it might make more sense to just compare the timestamps of the vector data and the imagery. For instance, if the road doesn't appear in the imagery, but the vector data timestamp is after the imagery timestamp, then keep the road. And don't add a road if it was covered by a map segment that was deleted some time between the imagery timestamp and the current time.

perennate··on Serverless Computing: One Step Forward, Two Steps Back
You're not the only one, the paper mentions this too :)

> As a result, serverless computing today is at best a simple and powerful way to run embarrassingly parallel computations or harness proprietary services. At worst, it can be viewed as a cynical effort to lock users into those services and lock out innovation

perennate··on After landing a lucrative job at a tech startup, I had made a terrible mistake
Yeah I don't disagree with you, I was just pointing out something in the article that I believe the parent comment missed, since it referenced Wikipedia while the article mentioned 2000 directly.
perennate··on After landing a lucrative job at a tech startup, I had made a terrible mistake
The article brings this up (but you can of course disagree with its conclusion):

> I was initially mystified by how a company that’s been around since 2000 could still call itself a start-up. It turns out it’s not unusual for software companies to hold on to the start-up classification long after the point when businesses in other industries would be considered established. Software companies are forever “pivoting”—changing their business plans, chasing emerging markets, pushing their platform in new directions. The day I joined, Vision Critical had some 700 staff and two main offices: most of the execs, the sales team and I were housed in Toronto, high above Yonge and Bloor, while Andrew Reid and the majority of the devs were in Vancouver, where they’d taken over part of a tower that used to house the Vancouver Sun newsroom. The company also had sales offices in the U.S., Europe, Asia and Australia. It was established, but it was also very much a start-up, and had only recently pivoted the business to cloud-based market research software.

perennate··on Canada has arrested Huawei’s global chief financial officer in Vancouver
I find your comment very misleading.

There is no indication that this arrest is related to U.S. policies to sanction foreign companies for selling to Iran.

Rather, the arrest is far more likely related to "US law [that] prohibits exports of certain US-origin technologies to certain countries" (from nytimes article). Huawei purchased certain technology from the US with the promise not to sell it to certain countries like Iran, and then proceeded to shamelessly violate the agreement.

Without laws like this, sanctions are far less powerful, because any foreign company not affected by the sanction can act as a middleman between the origin country and the sanctioned country.

What the UN International Court of Justice and European Union think about US sanctioning foreign companies that do business with Iran is completely irrelevant, since this arrest is not related to that policy.

perennate··on Backdoor in event-stream library dependency
I think part of the difference at issue is the number of distinct entities (users/organizations) you need to trust due to the acceptance of micropackaging.

With most programming languages, a small-to-medium project might pull dependencies from tens of entities, but with npm, even a small project can easily rely on hundreds or even thousands of entities.

It is easier to weed out unreputable entities when you are depending on fewer entities.

perennate··on Backdoor in event-stream library dependency
He was doing this for free and releasing it under an open source license.

In your analogy the business would be performing the chores for free and telling the users that the business is not responsible for any damage related to the access granted by the key. I don't think most people would sign up for that without a business relationship.

perennate··on I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages
Why is it morally acceptable for a landlord to be able to evict a tenant from their home if their payment was not received for a reason out of the tenant's control, like being lost by the post office or stolen from the landlord's mailbox?

The grandparent comment was responding to starting eviction process one day after rent was due. I don't see how contacting the tenant and waiting a week equates to giving lifetime free rent.

perennate··on I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages
What if the mail got lost or delayed? Why would any sane landlord immediately spend the effort to begin eviction process before contacting their tenant, when there are countless reasons that they didn't receive a check for the current month?

MA enforces what I think is a reasonable policy: the landlord must send a written notice to quit to end the tenancy, and may not file an eviction case until a 14-day notice period ends. The tenant cannot be evicted if they pay the owed rent with interest by the end of the notice period.

perennate··on Waymo CEO Says Alphabet Unit Plans to Launch Driverless Car Service
I don't see any reason for New York to permit them, especially in the city center, before they have been proven safe over at least five to ten years in less urban and crowded environments.
perennate··on M.I.T. Plans College for Artificial Intelligence, Backed by $1B
> I'd rather see existing departments and courses get updated with the technologies and techniques they are trying to integrate rather than a new "College of AI".

That seems very close to the goal of this new College of Computing (it's not "College of AI") stated in MIT's FAQ [1]:

> As MIT’s senior leaders have engaged with faculty and departments across campus, many have spoken of how their fields are being transformed by modern computational methods — specifically, by access to large data sets and the tools to learn from them. Some of the most exciting new work in fields like political science, economics, linguistics, anthropology, and urban studies — as well as in various disciplines in science and engineering — is being made possible when advanced computational capabilities are brought to these fields.

> The key connector of the College to MIT’s five schools with be the 25 “bridge” faculty: joint faculty appointments linking the College with departments across MIT. With this new structure, MIT aims to educate students who are “bilingual” — adept in computing, as well as in their primary field. The College will also connect with the rest of MIT through its work to develop shared computing resources — infrastructure, instrumentation, and technical staffing.

The FAQ says that this unit is named College instead of School (i.e., in contrast to MIT's School of Engineering, School of Science, etc.) precisely because it is meant to "work with and across all five of MIT’s existing schools".

[1] http://news.mit.edu/2018/faq-mit-stephen-schwarzman-college-...

perennate··on M.I.T. Plans College for Artificial Intelligence, Backed by $1B
MIT's news article [1] has more concrete information. The NYT article is a bit misleading.

It is a College of Computing, not College of AI. Also note that MIT has Schools (School of Engineering, School of Science, etc.), not Colleges; so this will be something different.

For example, according to MIT's FAQ [2], EECS Department will likely continue to be part of School of Engineering, even as it becomes part of College of Computing.

In particular:

> The College will reorient MIT to bring the power of computing and AI to all fields of study at MIT, allowing the future of computing and AI to be shaped by insights from all other disciplines;

> Q: Why is this a college, rather than a school? What is the difference?

> A: The MIT Schwarzman College of Computing will work with and across all five of MIT’s existing schools. Its naming as a college differentiates it from the five schools, and signals that it is an Institute-wide entity: The College is designed with cross-cutting education and research as its primary missions.

> Q: What kinds of new joint academic programs or degrees are envisioned?

> A: MIT has been making progress in this direction for some time; for example, we already offer undergraduate majors that pair computer science with economics, biology, mathematics, and urban planning. The MIT Schwarzman College of Computing will allow MIT to respond to the student demand the Institute is seeing in course and major/minor selection more effectively and creatively. It will enable MIT to pursue this vision with unprecedented depth and ambition, and will give MIT’s five schools a shared structure for collaborative education, research, and innovation in computing and AI.

[1] http://news.mit.edu/2018/mit-reshapes-itself-stephen-schwarz...

[2] http://news.mit.edu/2018/faq-mit-stephen-schwarzman-college-...

perennate··on Trump Just Signed a Law That Changes Life Aboard Airlines
To me the article's tone sounded more surprised at how little coverage there was on the bill, than outraged at the bill's contents.

In fact, I thought the article gave a quite positive view of the bill.

perennate··on Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges
The article says:

> The $40 million in penalties will be distributed to harmed investors under a court-approved process.

perennate··on Robinhood Is Making Millions Selling Out Customers to High-Frequency Traders
At https://investor.vanguard.com/investing/online-trading/order..., if you follow the "View the quarterly reports" link, it shows that Vanguard routes orders to these companies: Citadel Securities, VIRTU Americas LLC, G1 Execution Services, UBS Securities LLC, Susquehanna Capital Group, Citigroup Global Markets.

It also says "Vanguard Brokerage does not receive compensation for directing order flow in equity securities".

But the SeekingAlpha article criticizes Robinhood for routing to Citadel, calling it a "market makers that also have high frequency trading arms". So Vanguard routes to similar companies, but doesn't receive compensation? That doesn't really seem better for the customer to me. What am I missing?

perennate··on Robinhood Making Millions Selling Out Their Millennial Customers to HFTs
Is this really specific to Robinhood? If I go to https://investor.vanguard.com/investing/online-trading/order... and follow the "View the quarterly reports" link, it shows that Vanguard routes orders to these companies: Citadel Securities, VIRTU Americas LLC, G1 Execution Services, UBS Securities LLC, Susquehanna Capital Group, Citigroup Global Markets

Wikipedia says Virtu Financial is an HFT firm: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtu_Financial

Edit: yet, the same report (as well as a document that the article links to) says "Vanguard Brokerage does not receive compensation for directing order flow in equity securities". So Vanguard routes to similar companies, but doesn't get compensation from them?

perennate··on China is angered by Apple's iPhone event mentioning Taiwan
I don't think Confederacy ever cared to control all of U.S.

So this analogy might work better if Confederacy was the one who won, and Union retreated to Cuba.

Today, Cuba happens to be a highly desirable location (strategically, or for resources, or etc.). So Confederates, who now control continental U.S., want to maintain their claim on it.

Meanwhile, nowadays a majority of the people in USA (a government which controls only Cuba) consider themselves Cubans, and almost no one in USA cares about regaining control of continental U.S.

But Confederates feel that, if USA renounces control of continental U.S., it would be a step towards USA independence, which would further weaken Confederate claim over Cuba. So they pressure USA to keep referring to themselves as "USA" instead of "Cuba". Additionally, they think that the "one America" stance depends to some extent on USA retaining continental U.S. in its official borders. (But in reality, no USA citizens, aka Cubans, care about these borders continuing to include continental U.S.)

perennate··on China is angered by Apple's iPhone event mentioning Taiwan
I mostly agree with you (and upvoted your comment), but I think modern KMT doesn't really believe that either, they just say they "believe it" to maintain healthy cross-strait relations.

KMT values economy over opposing "one China". I would say DPP values eventual independence more, but they still recognize the economic ramifications and thus seek to develop economic relations with other countries to reduce reliance on China (but how successful this has been is debated).

Anyway even DPP says they support "one China" to some degree, they're just more willing than KMT to risk supporting it to a lesser degree.

perennate··on China is angered by Apple's iPhone event mentioning Taiwan
This view of the situation is one advanced by PRC.

I doubt very many Taiwanese people actually care about leading China or believe that ROC will ever become the de facto government over all of China.

The only reason that Taiwan gives the perception that it supports re-unification / "one China" (part of which includes maintaining its claims over mainland China) is to maintain good political and economic relations with China. Because opposing re-unification would piss off China.

perennate··on China is angered by Apple's iPhone event mentioning Taiwan
My understanding is that the Taiwanese government has not renounced claims over mainland China because doing so would piss off China, who would view it as a step towards independence.

Aside from escalation of tensions, pissing off PRC would likely worsen economic relations, which I think would be more damaging to Taiwan than to China (according to Wikipedia, China is Taiwan's largest import/export partner).

Absent the political/economic ramifications, I believe only a very small percentage of Taiwan's population would mind if Taiwan renounced these claims. Even "pro-reunification" KMT has stepped a bit back from its reunification stance, e.g. setting conditions like "democracy, economic development to a level near that of Taiwan, and equitable wealth distribution" for China before reunification can occur (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiwan).

So, for many, the only reason to support an "eventual reunification" stance is it'd strengthen the economy, i.e., they don't mind China playing its word games if it means peace and Taiwan prospering.

This doesn't mean "pro-independence" pan-green party ignores the economic effects. They argue for developing economic relations with other countries, to reduce economic dependence on China, and thus make independence more practical.

perennate··on Tesla issues strongest statement yet blaming driver for deadly crash
> because that's what people do; make sacrifices to improve the world we live in so that future generations don't have to know the same problem.

Whose lives are we sacrificing? In the case of the Uber crash in Tempe and this Tesla crash in California, the people who died did not volunteer to risk their lives to advance research in autonomous vehicles.

I highly respect individuals who choose to risk their lives to better the world or make progress, like doctors fighting disease in Africa and astronauts going to space, but at the same time, I think this must always be a choice. Otherwise we could justify forcing prisoners to try new drugs as the first stage of clinical trials. Or worse things. Which is why there are extensive vetting before approval for clinical trials is given.

I do think that, once the safety of autonomous vehicles have been proven on a number of testbeds, but before they are ready for deployment, it is justifiable to drive them on public roads. Maybe without safety drivers. But until then, careful consideration should be given to their testing.

Uber should not have been able to run autonomous vehicles with safety drivers where the safety driver could be allowed to look away from the road for several seconds while the car was moving at >30mph. The car should automatically shutoff if it is not clear whether the safety driver is paying attention. And there should be legislation that bans any company that fails to implement basic safeguards like this from testing again for at least a decade, with severe fines. Probably speeds should also be limited to ~30mph for the first few years of testing while the technology is still so immature, as it is today.

Similarly, Tesla should not be allowed to deploy their Autopilot software to consumers before they conduct studies to show that it is reasonably safe. Repeated accidents have shown that Level 1 and Level 2 autonomous vehicles, where the car drives autonomously but the driver must be ready to intervene, is a failed model unless the car actively monitors that the driver is paying attention.

Overall I think justifying the current state of things by saying that people must be sacrificed for this technology to work is ridiculous. Basic safeguards are not being used, and if we require them, maybe autonomous vehicles will take a few years longer to reach deployment, but that thousands of lives could become tens.

Edit: I read in another comment that the Tesla car at least "alarms at you when you take your hands off the wheel". In that case I think what Tesla is doing is much more reasonable. (Not Uber, though.) Although I still feel like it is going to be hard to react to dangerous situations when the system operates correctly almost all the time (even if you are paying attention and have your hands on the wheel). But I'm not sure what the correct policy should be here, because I don't fully understand why people use this in the first place (since it sounds like Autopilot doesn't save you any work).

perennate··on Facebook Container Extension: Take control of how you’re being tracked
I believe the parent comment is referring to multi-account-containers [1], which is a general implementation.

This Facebook extension is a reactionary Facebook-specific adaptation of that extension. But it is still useful for many users since it doesn't require any user interaction.

I think multi-account-containers is more convenient than profiles since it provides a single interface to manage the containers and browser settings are shared, but I am actually using profiles on Firefox because the extension doesn't seem to support the "Never remember history" browser option.

[1] https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers and https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account...

perennate··on Tempe Police Release Video of Uber Accident
I think the inattention is just expected now. If you have to do absolutely nothing 99.99% of the time, then it just doesn't seem possible to constantly focus on the road. At least if you are driving down an empty highway you still have to hold the wheel and press the accelerator. For this reason, I think level 0 systems ("may momentarily intervene but has no sustained vehicle control") hold much more promise for the near future (next decade or two), and I wish there was more focus on getting these systems widely deployed.
perennate··on Tempe Police Release Video of Uber Accident
I actually believe that the kind of situation shown in the video (pedestrian walking across road at night in the path of a car, where car has to brake hard to avoid a collision) happens much more frequently than most people think. And most of the time the pedestrian comes out fine because most drivers are looking ahead most of the time, and someone walking across the road is a big abnormal event that is easy for a human to notice and react to.

I don't have any data to support this, other than a vague memory of doing something similar many years ago. Although if I remember correctly, that was a more major road that was probably better lit. But I still find it hard to believe that human vision would have been as lousy as the camera's.

perennate··on Tempe Police Release Video of Uber Accident
Although a collision may still have occurred if a human slammed on the brakes immediately after seeing the pedestrian, even a 10mph slowdown may have mitigated the fatality into a minor injury. ProPublica has a graph showing the frequency of fatalities in crashes for different impact speeds, showing a more than halving in the occurrence of fatalities in crashes between 38mph and 28mph impacts: https://www.propublica.org/article/unsafe-at-many-speeds

The article says that the vehicle "doesn’t appear to slow down". If the data shows that it actually didn't slow down, it seems like there is a critical bug in Uber's software that has killed a pedestrian.

perennate··on Light Traffic
Cyclists are also not considered.

Maybe the intersection looks like this once you add pedestrians and cyclists: https://vimeo.com/106226560

Edit: also worth checking the earlier discussion from a couple years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11336009

perennate··on AWS Statement: Processor Speculative Execution Research Disclosure
They have a wiki article now, https://wiki.ubuntu.com/SecurityTeam/KnowledgeBase/SpectreAn...
← PreviousPage 8 of 9Next →