HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

perrygeo

3,195 karma · joined April 28, 2014

submissionscomments
perrygeo··on Why I ever wrote Clojure
It turns out Clojure is just a really good programming language, not a panacea. If you have to build soul-sucking software, it still sucks even in a great language. Technical cleverness isn't enough to distract you from a bullshit job forever.
perrygeo··on The language brain matters more for programming than the math brain? (2020)
What about Wernicke's area and Broca's area? If damaged they produce causal changes to our use and processing of language. I agree it's not as simple "language brain" but there are physical structures in the brain that are directly related to language.
perrygeo··on Uncle Bob Martin is anti-SQL
I agree. I've met Bob in person and he's a very nice guy and obviously very passionate about his field. But these rants feel like he's talking down to the audience, as though explaining something for the 17th time to someone who doesn't get it.
perrygeo··on Uncle Bob Martin is anti-SQL
Title is misleading. Bob doesn't say anything anti-SQL in this rant. But he's advocating for a clear separation between "business objects" and "data gunk" as he calls it. It's clear he see the business objects as more important (I respectfully disagree) but he's not anti-SQL.
perrygeo··on If you're in the market for a $1,900 color E Ink monitor, one of them exists now
Same thought, as I sit here reading the article on my Dasung Paperlike 27 eink monitor. I guess I've been living in the future all these years.
perrygeo··on Running Clojure in WASM with GraalVM
Clojure code ends up using a lot of reflection if you're doing generic Java interop. Most code destined for the GraalVM will add `(set! warn-on-reflection true)` and get repl warnings and you can set type hints accordingly.
perrygeo··on Mobygratis – Free Moby music to empower your creative projects
> somewhat eccentric 2-line license agreement

That's an understatement. Restricting content based on political activism I can sympathize, if not agree with. Restriction based on war and geopolitics, ok.

But based on promoting veganism? Come on dude, pick your battles. Any business that deals in any way with animal products (virtually every restaurant, grocery store, hospital, school, entertainment venue, etc) could get accused of promoting cruelty and violating the license; this is a nonstarter.

perrygeo··on Electric Clojure in 5 minutes – Systems Distributed 2024 (with transcript)
That is an impressive demo - code that seamlessly jumps back and forth between server and client concepts in a single function! Compiling the backend and frontend from the same codebase feels like it could eliminate all the serialization logic and network communication overhead of the API+SPA approach. Really looking forward to trying out Electric Clojure!
perrygeo··on A Grim Signal: Atmospheric CO2 Soared in 2024
We're increasing CO2 in the atmosphere with our emissions, everyone knows that. The real problem is the second derivative. Forget reducing carbon in absolute terms, we're increasing the rate of increase!
perrygeo··on Backblaze: Mounting Losses, Lawsuits, Sham Accounting, Insider Selling
I suspect it does. When I was evaluating Wasabi years ago, the sales engineers were very interested in knowing what specific kind of data we had and how compressible it was. So my guess (pure speculation) at the time was they use ZFS compression internally but charge customers for the uncompressed size.
perrygeo··on Avoiding skill atrophy in the age of AI
I agree, but it's not just AI. There's long been a push to standardize anything that requires critical thinking and human intelligence. To risk-averse rent seekers, requiring human skill is a liability. Treating human resources as replacable cogs is the gold standard. Otherwise you have to engage in thinking during meetings. Yeah, with your brain. The horror /s.
perrygeo··on Atuin Desktop: Runbooks That Run
The poor man's version of this - write your runbooks as text files in your source code. And set your editor to "Send to Terminal". I use vim-slime in nvim, vscode has similar functionality.

Document it, version control it, share it, and (semi)automate it. There's no reason to type or copy-paste important commands directly into the terminal.

perrygeo··on YAGRI: You are gonna read it
The whole model of RDBMS is based on mutable tuples; soft deletes don't make much sense as an intrinsic part of that model. If you want soft deletes, you create an application layer or use a different data model.

Most of the time if you want "soft deletes", you really want an immutable log so that you time travel to any point in the history. XTDB and Datomic are worth looking at if you want to solve the problem at the data model level.

perrygeo··on Healthy soil is the hidden ingredient
The difference is that in soil you have microbes and fungus which seek out and break down inorganic nutrients then exchange them with plants for sugar. Plant's access to nutrients is mediated by this underground ecosystem.

In hydroponics YOU provide the work to gather and process all the nutrients and provide them to the plant roots in an optimal form. In nature, that work is done by the soil ecosystem.

In the end, the plant does not seem to really care. As long as it has the right molecules available, it's happy. Possibly moreso since it doesn't need to sacrifice any of its sugars.

perrygeo··on Researcher proposes model replacing dark energy/matter to explain universe
"Measure first, discover later" can be a perfectly valid application of the scientific method. It's all about refining the resolution on reality.

The problem with dark matter/energy is that we're not guaranteed to discover anything. It might just be wrong. The neutrinos and Higgs just happened to match their initial theory, so that's a survivorship bias. We can't just assume the same will play out for dark matter. It might just be pure mathematical fiction, reflecting our ignorance and/or limitations to measurement rather than something "real" that we can zoom in on.

perrygeo··on Startup Faces Scrutiny over Sulfur Dioxide Balloons
Aside from local pollution laws, what power do governments have to prevent privately-funded geoengineering? If someone wanted to sail out to the mid-atlantic and start spewing sulfur into the atmosphere, who could stop them?
perrygeo··on (All) Databases Are Just Files. Postgres Too
I get the point of the article, but the headline is just wrong. Not all databases use files. There are a number of vendors that offer direct raw device I/O and bypass the filesystem entirely.
perrygeo··on TikTok Is Harming Children at an Industrial Scale
That's what ignorant culture warriors claimed was harming children. There was never much evidence to support those claims; they were the ravings of clowns, not statements to be taken seriously.

The damage from social media is widespread, well-studied, and unequivocally harmful to millions of people. There is no equivalence, it's a different technology with objectively worse impacts.

perrygeo··on Being a top programmer: Don't get stuck
Interesting to note that "staring at the screen confused" and "systematically working through the problem" look almost identical from the outside.
perrygeo··on Europe Wants to Ban Carbon Fiber
The 3.5 billion dollar carbon fiber bike industry comes to mind. The Tour de France riders have been using carbon fiber frames almost exclusively for decades. Going back to welded metal frames would reverse decades of technical innovation.

Boats, airplanes, weapons, wind turbines, medical equipment, sports gear. How does Europe plan to defend itself and provide renewable energy without carbon fiber, let alone compete in these other markets with such a handicap?

perrygeo··on Europe Wants to Ban Carbon Fiber
Surely they're not proposing banning all carbon fiber, just in automobiles right?
perrygeo··on Why Everything in the Universe Turns More Complex
POSIWID. Life on earth's primary "purpose" if observed from space would be to dissipate low-entropy solar radiation, using it to build temporary structures out of carbon.

It is puzzling why life isn't more common. Perhaps dissipative self-organizing structures are everywhere - stars, solar systems and galaxies themselves maintain their order by dissipating energy. They just don't look like "life" to us.

perrygeo··on Lotka–Volterra Equations
Malthus was wrong only in that he didn't anticipate the massive store of energy we were about to unleash with coil, oil, and gas. We were able to smash through Malthus' predictions because we added more solar energy (in the form of fossilized carbon) to the system. The Haber-Bosch process cranked it up to 11.

In an alternative world where we left fossil fuels in the ground, we would have hit a population ceiling in the 1800s.

In a future world where fossil fuels are no longer accessible (either through climate policy, depletion, or market forces) this means our energy budget needs to shrink - Malthusian limits to our food production will be of concern again, assuming we make it through the climate bottleneck.

perrygeo··on Apple was getting bid up like crazy yesterday, don't tell me this wasn't leaked
Pump and dumps run from the white house, blatant insider trading, no checks or balances - welcome to post-America.
perrygeo··on AI can't stop making up software dependencies and sabotaging everything
My favorite is when the LLM hallucinates some function or an entire library and you call it out for the mistake. A likely response is "Oh, I'm sorry, You're right. Here's how you would implement function_that_does_not_exist()" and proceeds to write the library it hallucinated in the first place.

It's quirks like these that prove LLMs are a long long way from AGI.

perrygeo··on Why I Program in Lisp
> parse and interpret packet headers, apply validation rules, maintain BGP routing tables, add their own headers etc.

That's a few more than zero. I don't do network programming, that was just an example to show how even the quintessential IO-heavy application requires non-trivial calculations internally.

perrygeo··on Why I Program in Lisp
> Even if you do, it's quite often a very small part of the entire project.

So your projects are only moving bits from one place to another? I've literally never seen that in 20 years of programming professionally. Even network systems that are seen as "dumb pipes" need to parse and interpret packet headers, apply validation rules, maintain BGP routing tables, add their own headers etc.

Surely the program calculates something, otherwise why would you need to run the program at all if the output is just a copy of the input?

perrygeo··on Why I Program in Lisp
Not even the most fanatical functional programming zealots would claim that programs can be 100% functional. By definition, a program requires inputs and outputs, otherwise there is literally no reason to run it.

Functional programming simply says: separate the IO from the computation.

> Pretty much anything I've written over the last 30 years, the main purpose was to do I/O, it doesn't matter whether it's disk, network, or display.

Every useful program ever written takes inputs and produces outputs. The interesting part is what you actually do in the middle to transforms inputs -> outputs. And that can be entirely functional.

perrygeo··on Cells are swapping their mitochondria. What does this mean for our health?
You sound very certain of yourself. Yet you cite no evidence at all except your gut feeling. Let's review these so-called "poorly considered claims":

(2014) https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24845118/

"Evidence suggests that alterations in mitochondrial morphology, brain energy metabolism, and mitochondrial enzyme activity may be involved in the pathophysiology of different neuropsychiatric disorders"

(2021) https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8291901/

"we provide a focused narrative review of the currently available evidence supporting the involvement of mitochondrial dysfunction in mood disorders"

(2022) https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36181925/

"Increasing experimental evidence supports a role for mitochondrial dysfunctions in neuropsychiatric disorders. "

(2024) https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01497...

"We summarize the existing literature on mitochondrial dynamics perturbations in psychiatric disorders/neuropsychiatric phenotypes"

While psychology today ain't a scientific journal, they provide an excellent summary, providing that evidence is both widespread and well known. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-therapy-center/2...

Dr. Chris Palmer's book "Brain Energy" is a good introduction to the body of research. Dozens of pages of citations, you can judge for yourself how well-considered they are. - "Mitochondrial dysfunction has been found in a wide range of diagnoses that include pretty much every symptom found in psychiatry".

"Pretty much every symptom" is not going hard enough. There has yet to be a single psychiatric symptom that isn't theoretically and empirically linked to metabolic dysfunction. The only symptoms he left out were the ones which have no published research!

And finally, just this week Forbes had a feature about it. Again, not a sci journal but there's enough interest to name it the "quiet revolution underway in psychiatry". https://www.forbes.com/sites/jessepines/2025/04/05/could-mit...

---

Do you still feel that the metabolic theory of mental illness is an unbelievable claim, poorly considered?

It may not be THE only answer. But at the very least, this theory is well supported with decades of research and deserves serious consideration.

perrygeo··on Cells are swapping their mitochondria. What does this mean for our health?
Read it earlier this year and I agree. Also, he's all over various podcasts and youtube channels if you'd rather watch.

What I got out of the book was two things:

* Mitochondria are freaking cool.

* The DSM is bollocks and metabolic dysfunction explains all mental illness.

Despite how radical the above sounds, the evidence for it is overwhelming. The book is largely an accessible tour of the evidence. It's well cited without being too academic.

And while Dr. Palmer is a prominent spokesperson for this movement, there are hundreds of other neurologists, psychiatrists and doctors on the same line.

← PreviousPage 13 of 34Next →