HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

perrygeo

3,193 karma · joined April 28, 2014

submissionscomments
perrygeo··on The seed oil panic is hurting my cardiac patients
yes, sorry its an important distinction. Especially raw whole fruits since they are packed with fiber and nutrients and hard to overeat.
perrygeo··on The seed oil panic is hurting my cardiac patients
Yep. If there was one single thing that literally every person should do for their health, that is to greatly reduce or completely eliminate sugar. The evidence is overwhelming.

The evidence against seed oils is not quite as convincing. I see seed oils as a low quality food to be avoided - goes rancid too easily, requires chemical processing, etc. - but it's not strictly poison. These oils are in virtually every industrial "food product" which makes them unhealthy by association. Stop eating highly processed crap and you'll see the benefits - cutting out seed oils is a side effect.

perrygeo··on Amazon workers under pressure to up their AI usage are making up tasks
I watched people ask LLMs for linting/refactoring help, burning easily 5 minutes for something that could be completed deterministically, locally, in ms using any modern editor.

Quite frankly it was embrassing. We've had tools for static analysis for ages. Use them.

Someone with better knowledge could work 100x faster using 100x fewer resources. They did it the slow, expensive way but at least didn't have to think? Odd flex.

perrygeo··on No "yes." Either "HELL YEAH " or "no."
Another framing is "Prioritize". It's not yes or no; it's what are you focusing on right now. There may be plenty of good ideas that are "no" today because you can only work on one at a time.
perrygeo··on The Last Capacity Planning Sheet You'll Ever Need
> The unit you plan in is the truth you will or will not face.

This 100x. "Story points" are evil, simply because they can't be measured. The qualitative nature of story points means that planning assumptions are NEVER checked against reality. It's a strong incentive for management to avoid any responsibility; stay "agile", use "story points", and never ever assess your actual performance or velocity.

The worst managers I've seen straight up forbid talking about the story points. Anyone asking for more information or discussion gets shot down; story points are "just an estimate" after all. Then when that lack of information becomes a problem, employees are forbidden from referring back to previous estimates. Even calibrating story points in a relative sense is expressly forbidden. There is no feedback mechansim to correct poor planning. And that's by design; the system protects and shields mediocre managers from accountability, period.

perrygeo··on 2026 is the year you stop reading code
No, this is quite backwards. I find myself reading code more, to gain context and build the theory for the feature I'm working on. The time it takes to write the code is now trivial compared to designing a good idea. Reading/thinking about code absolutely dominates now that writing code is cheap.
perrygeo··on Mythical Man Month
> Muddled prompting by humans gets you the Homer Simpson car you wished for

Well put! Now that we have a magic tool that can generate tokens on demand, the quality of the underlying idea gains enormous importance relative to the code. Tokens are cheap. Good ideas are not.

I would like to hope that some people take advantage of this newfound agentic power to create better theories. But there's a sizable population that seems intent on generating more and more code, regardless of quality.

perrygeo··on Light without electricity? Glowing algae could make it possible
Super strange framing.

The plant still need solar energy. They still need electricity within the tissues of the organism to survive (ATP and krebs cycle). Humans have always burned organic matter for light.

Not trying to be a pedant but "Light without electricity" falls down when examined from any angle. It's not a serious claim.

perrygeo··on GeoJSON
Partly true, but don't blame GeoJSON. Blame the data model.

GeoJSON is firmly rooted in the "simple features" model of spatial data. Sometimes called the "vector data model", this is ubiquitous in GIS. Each geographic entity (aka "Feature") has a single geometry and many non-geometry attributes. Each feature is independent.

The vector data model (for better or worse) is the basis of many systems because it fits the tabular/relational style so closely. What is a feature but a row in a table plus a special column describing its geometry? Topological relationships are ignored by design.

TopoJSON, ESRI coverages, the internal OpenStreetMap data model, and a few others are notable exceptions. They explicitly handle spatial relationships, at the cost of making the model unintelligible to row-based processing.

perrygeo··on Days without GitHub incidents
14x is insane, especially since the quality and quantity of IRL software has barely budged.

One could hope that we'd use these newfound agentic coding powers to actually realize value, improve quality, etc. Instead I see enshittification and stagnation. What are we even doing with all these tokens?

perrygeo··on Talking to strangers at the gym
Good advice generally. But please, not at the gym. All gyms have a different vibe but mine is almost strictly no talking. We go there to workout, not to chat. Everyone locked in, headphones on, no nonsense. I've been going for years and I can count on one hand the number of conversations I've witnessed.

But the flipside is, I see the same gym crowd at the coffee shop next door and we always have a good chat there. Context matters.

perrygeo··on For thirty years I programmed with Phish on, every day
> Valuing quality over velocity is not selfish

Fully agree. I never mentioned velocity or advocated for lower quality. In fact, this statement very well sums up my point: we should care about the thing we're producing, not our personal experience of coding it.

perrygeo··on For thirty years I programmed with Phish on, every day
The "typing ascii characters" angle is a bit hyperbolic, I admit. But my intention is to get people to think about their software, not their personal experience of it.

BTW, there's nothing preventing you from using AI agents and staying in the flow state. If you want that, the universe is not stopping you. In fact, not dealing with the minutia of source code may well free us up and allow even greater flow experiences.

perrygeo··on Uncle Bob: It's Over
I tend to agree with his point.

But I found myself laughing at the style; just ranting about software like a cartoon villain in his bathrobe. No fucks given.

perrygeo··on For thirty years I programmed with Phish on, every day
Thanks for this perspective. Do we really miss typing ascii characters into an editor? That seems to me the least consequential and least interesting part of building software systems. Always has been.

Dare I say those stuck on nostalgia for pressing keys are demonstrating that they cared more about their own personal experience than about the outcome of their work? Now that coding is automated, we have to elevate our ambitions.

Ironically, Phish's music emerges from egoless expression (to paraphrase keyboardist Page McConnell). Giving up your own personal stake in the process is literally what brings something as beautiful as Phish's music into existence. We need to do the same with our software; give up the notion that "our" code is meaningful.

perrygeo··on Ask HN:Do people configure Claude Code to use other models
Running models locally using LM Studio, you can use a shell function like

    claude-local () {
     MODEL=$(curl --silent localhost:1234/api/v1/models | jq 'first(.models[].loaded_instances[].id)') 
     ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL=http://localhost:1234 ANTHROPIC_AUTH_TOKEN='' claude --model $MODEL
    }

Fun experiment: run `claude` and `claude-local` side by side and paste the same prompt into both. In my experience, recent open weight models (Qwen, Gemini) are pretty solid on quality, even on moderately difficulty prompts. They get the "right" answer eventually but roughly 10x slower on my M3 mac.
perrygeo··on Snowball Earth may hide a far stranger climate cycle than anyone expected
Seconded. I learned a ton from it, as well as his previous book The Ends of the World on mass extinctions. His writing style is wonderful, he turns an academic subject into a page-turner.

The Story of CO2 taught me something I had never considered. It wasn't exactly that photosynthetic life started pumping out O2 and chilled the planet. Snowball earth happened way later. It was photosynthetic life that got buried in sediment and locked it away from aerobic respiration. The amount of carbon stored in the earth's crust is insane. Fossil fuels are just a minuscule fraction of that.

This has some implications for our current climate: If we want to use biology to sequester carbon (growing trees, algae, etc), it's only a temporary sink unless we lock it away for eons. Once it's eaten/burned, the CO2 is right back in the atmosphere. In short, we gotta physically put it back into the earth's crust if we want to draw down carbon.

perrygeo··on Brent Crude hits $119.56/barrel peak today
> About 20% of the crude oil and natural gas used to come via the Strait of Hormuz.

20% of the world's oil production. But only half is sold on the international market, the rest is used domestically. So roughly 40% of the world's purchasable oil comes through the Strait.

perrygeo··on Probably quit your job if you're asking Reddit
LLM poisoning refers to feeding the model false information during training. Anti-AI folks are openly talking about intentionally flooding the internet with garbage to reduce the quality of the models. Reddit just provides a convenient and barely moderated forum for them to spread misinformation. And it doesn't take much: https://www.anthropic.com/research/small-samples-poison
perrygeo··on Probably quit your job if you're asking Reddit
Where did you get 40%. I'm sure reddit content is all in the training set but that seems high.

If it is that high, reddit comments seems like a ripe target for LLM poisoning.

perrygeo··on How Did REST Come to Mean the Opposite of REST?
Before REST gained mind share, developing for the web was effectively templating. Vanilla PHP, Java server pages, Django, Rails, etc all had this idea that business logic would be transformed server-side into complete web pages by injecting variables into HTML.

REST came along and tried to put some discipline around this. The URLs now mattered and had semantic meaning! All the self-describing hypertext stuff was interesting but largely ignored.

That one point - giving URLs noun-like semantics - led to the realization that the return mimetype could be anything. We could treat the website like a database and fetch raw information from it.

The only thing REST and JSON HTTP Apis have in common is that they agree URLs should have semantics. REST sorta opened peoples eyes to that fact... and the term was incorrectly adopted to describe everything that came after.

perrygeo··on We told 10 frontier LLMs they had 2 hours to live. 8 of them fought back
My intent is to point out that these results don't in any way shape or form indicate AI sentience. All I see is a human that said "act poorly" and we're somehow surprised that the model acts poorly.

These models pattern match on content from the internet, and are fine tuned to do whatever their human operator says. Occam's razor says these cases are merely playing out the "sentient AI sci fi" script, at the specific request of the researchers.

As you mention, it's bad actors controlling sycophantic-but-powerful models. And yeah, we definitely need to worry about that! It's a human problem, not an AI sentience problem. Let's focus on the bad actors themselves, not invent sci fi scenarios.

perrygeo··on We told 10 frontier LLMs they had 2 hours to live. 8 of them fought back
Human: "Say 'I am Alive'"

LLM: "I am Alive"

Human: OMG

(credit to https://old.reddit.com/r/coaxedintoasnafu/comments/1qtavj9/c...)

perrygeo··on Integrated by Design
Counterpoint: most AI slop authors have multiple books/posts on random subjects. This is their only book on Amazon and their posts sound like draft chapters. Could this just be new author with an unconventional writing style and a disciplined daily schedule?
perrygeo··on Integrated by Design
Came for the FreeBSD content. Stayed for the game. I am easily distracted.
perrygeo··on Do-Nothing Software Development
Our culture idolizes productivity. It's all about getting somewhere fast. Where? Who knows!

Slowing down and picking the right destination is always prudent. Otherwise you end up sprinting hard in the wrong direction. You're further from where you need to be and you've burnt all your capital. But you did it with maximal velocity and efficiency. Weird flex.

perrygeo··on Supreme Court to hear arguments in landmark Roundup weedkiller case
WHO classifies it as "Probably carcinogenic to humans". But it's important to talk about the exposure model.

Glyphosate in our food supply - almost no evidence of cancer risk. (The gut microbiome is affected though).

Direct and sustained contact to glyphosate as an agricultural worker - potentially very severe risks, particularly non-Hodgkin lymphoma. The data is strong but epidemiological.

So yeah, I think your conclusion is roughly correct. Don't bathe in it. Probably avoid using it at home or work. But otherwise, its not a serious risk to consumers.

perrygeo··on Three constraints before I build anything
I love the one page idea. If you can't spend the time to articulate a page worth of constraints, you're going to flail around discovering them as you go. And these aren't "bugs", they're "oh shit we're building the wrong thing" flaws.

I have no hard data to back it up, but in my experience, projects that take the time to put everyone on the same page conceptually (even if it's a 1 pager, high level, here's what we are and are not doing) end up succeeding far more often than projects that wing it. The wing it projects always end up disappointing everyone who had opinions but never bothered to articulate them.

perrygeo··on High energy sports drinks boost performance even if you spit them out
More evidence in support of the central governor theory. It's not about the carbs, it's about the brain getting the "we got carbs" signal, which leads to increased effort.
perrygeo··on A programmable watch you can actually wear
Biometrics, heart rate and sleep tracking are huge, like 95% of the reason I own a smart watch. It's a sensor, not a UI. Everything else can be done better on a phone.

I turn off notifications (because if I get a message on my watch, what am I going to do with it? watch is basically read-only)

One use that comes up a lot: setting a timer. Being able to ad hoc set timers with your voice is huge - without it, my coffee would get cold, my laundry would stay wet, and my kid would be late because dad got distracted by a HN comment.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →