ART is a ground-up rewrite of Dalvik. The AOT thing seemed to take root as some sort of differentiating talking point.
2,015 karma · joined April 2, 2014
ART is a ground-up rewrite of Dalvik. The AOT thing seemed to take root as some sort of differentiating talking point.
Wage your religious battle and set up the caricatures of anyone who might disagree, but you sway no one.
Isolating the key for security/control purposes is a well known technique. It's what ssh-agent/putty paegent does, where you can even forward key usage over the network to different machines. It's what PKCS11 does to SSL/TLS, where generally the key is a hardware security module (CAs and banks don't have keys sitting on their public facing machines, but instead generally have dedicated hardware for it -- they are generally doing, at a different scale, what is described), though there have been various implementations and proposals over the years to do it over the network (e.g. https://svn.opendnssec.org/docs/p11proxy.png and pkcs11-proxy).
Why isn't it commonly done as Rackspace proposes? Well it's kind of an odd need for limited gain, but is effectively PKCS11 used in a different context. If they are solving a specific need for some of their clients then fantastic, but it's the narrative of the innovation that makes it a bit weird, and yielded a lot of the purportedly negative commentary.
It is obvious, and they effectively implemented a custom approach for PKCS11/ssh-agent. Yet the narrative implies some brilliant period of insight and innovation, when really it kind of isn't.
Which is where the "silly" notion that they must have did something novel came from -- their narrative claims it.
Generally the key you would give them is for, and limited to, the resources that they cache/reverse proxy, so the same "read all traffic" concern exists.
What Cloudflare did is essentially, as others have mentioned, PKCS11 over the internet. PKCS11 is an existing, very well proven technique of sequestering the key in a hardware device, that hardware device doing what Cloudflare is moving to the client location here. It's neat enough, but they seem to kind of exaggerating the innovation a bit.
Instead they separate the actual key signing, delegating it to the customer's device. That's nice and useful, but isn't quite what I was expecting.
Though the iPhone 6 and other devices still feature contrast detection (which is generally a function of the image processor) in addition to phase detection. They each have strengths and applications.
That was the first on-plane phase detection, and it is the technique used by the iPhone 6 and GS5.
This is of relevance given the phase detection offered on the iPhone 6 (and previously released on the Galaxy S5).
Make lots of pieces claiming sources and reasons for why Apple is going to do something big and new and innovative. Endless pageviews, speculation, etc.
Apple releases a very nice, but completely traditional and incremental upgrade.
Make lots of pieces explaining why Apple not doing those things you previously said they would do is actually best, because of contrived justifications and reasons. Tonnes of pageviews and links.
Rinse repeat. This has happened with every Apple release this decade.
EDIT: I don't normally care much about a "downvote", but when it must be backed by ignorance I have to comment. Excel has always, and to this day, uses doubles. There is not a whit of decimal math to be found in the product. I kind of know this given that my industry is finance, and the calculation quirks of Excel (which is simply a quirk of floating point math) are something that the industry is aware of and works around.
Now it by default rounds the number for presentation, but surely no one on HN would be so confused that they fail to understand the difference.
Did they actually scoff or did you, essentially, "scoff" yourself.
There is often a subtext to this sort of observation, and it comes through in the blog entry as well -- it isn't enough to say "I don't do that. Too bad.", but instead has to take it further to saying "I don't do it, and neither do you, damn dirty liar. And if you do, you're doing it wrong anyways."
It's kind of ridiculous.
Some people really live this 16/7. And good for them. Others live it 8/5, and if it works for them then good for them as well. But it is obnoxious for the 8/5 crew to tell the 16/7 crew that they're wrong.
HN is a finicky, short-attention span beast, by design. A front page of HN, and tens of thousands of uniques, often yields zero residual "value" (seriously, zero. The most lauded piece on here with endless upvotes and you're lucky if a single reader reposts it anywhere else or mentions it, beyond the karma seekers who stick it on /r/programming). I don't get this post. 6000 unique visitors in no universe yields thousands of emails (again, due to the short attention span probably 5000 clicked back ten seconds in), unless the game itself generates enormous amounts of operator notifications and mechanical turk type behavior, in which case the game is unsustainable for anyone.
The model of getting a project to some level of success and then offloading it is an entirely reasonable one (though really the tough luck story I think undermines the pitch), though at the current level of success this project is, sadly, currently close to worthless. Having a very temporary spike of a niche user base is not at all sustainable.
Hardware virtualized I/O is a thing now as well, and in that case as well the overhead has shrunk to marginal. Add external storage (iSCSI), and things get much more complex.
Much of the argument about virtualization is about ten years+ old. It once represented a significant additional overhead, but that simply isn't true at all now.
https://major.io/2014/06/22/performance-benchmarks-kvm-vs-xe...
-but with de-duplication of a solution like vmware, approaches 0.
Containerization seems like a massive win when you're trying to fit a bunch of stuff in a single Digital Ocean VM, etc. When you're running many machines in a data center, though, it becomes dramatically less valuable.
Containers are interesting and the technology is emerging, but for 1-2% overhead it just isn't as critical as its often held.
However your point is comically specious in the context -- Android Play Store sales went from $0.9B, to $2.0B, to $5.0B over successive years (these numbers are in Google's yearlies, despite your repeated claims that they're mysteriously shrouded. They're as transparent as Apple's numbers). Android Play Store sales right now are where App Store sales were last year. Where were the people talking about the dire results of the App Store last year? In fact, quite contrary it was held as an incredible, unparamounted success, by people like you. And not only is the Play Store already there, it is seeing extraordinary growth.
I'm not sure why that should be an absurd observation
Your own points are contradictory, holding the dichotomy of the rich Android users (who all apparently were just waiting for a larger iPhone) versus the poor Android user, but then mashing them together into one universally "poorer" Android user.
Android is the platform of all demographics. We know that from the famous city analysis of Android/iOS usage of twitter, where Android was dominant in the poorer areas of town, and similar to iOS in the rich areas of town. That is a great thing about the platform -- it is inclusive and lifts all boats -- and it is utterly reprehensible when some people hold this as a bizarre negative, as if platform association with the less wealthy brings it down.
It seems probable that the people in the richer areas are spending in the store. The people in the poorer areas aren't. That's life of consumable items and varying spending money. There is no great mystery to it. And your contention is that since all of those Android users with money are going to race to iPhone (the same story we've heard with every iOS release for years), there goes the store.
So how does a per capita basis make any sense? Oh because all facts need to be contrived into the message of Ben Evans?
I apologize for resorting to "insults", but it seems that reality has an insult-based bias in the case of analyzing your various creations. You are selling to the converted.
Did the grocer get more commission selling you chicken? (sidenote: That commission bit appears in every conspiracy laden story about Android's rise, despite having zero empirical evidence. Indeed, many carriers do more to market and pitch the iPhone than any other brand, implying something very different).
For most people now, smartphones are largely interchangeable. They really are. You have a browser, can make calls, can access Netflix and your fantasy football app and Facebook and Twitter, etc. An iPhone 6x versus a GS 5, for instance, to many users it is simply a wash. Apple has tried hard to lock people into an ecosystem (Facetime me? No, Skype or Hangouts me please), but those efforts have fallen by the wayside and are becoming more of a hindrance than a benefit.
So it comes down to marketing (you know, like having U2 and giving out albums to gain more attention for your keynote) and differentiating features. Apple tried with the "true tone" flash or whatever. HTC is trying the dual-lens camera. Others make their devices waterproof. And so on. It isn't so clear.
Further, Ben Evans isn't just a bit of an Apple fan boy -- he is a huge Apple fan boy, with compromised credibility outside of that circle. He got a taste of the Apple aficionado love so now he panders to it fullstop. And given that Evans loves pointing out the payout to developers (then, absurdly calculating per capita metrics because it sells his point), note that the Play Store payout is growing more quickly than the App Store is -- YoY growth in the most recent yearly period was 150%. At current rates the Play Store will payout more than Apple within a year. But of course they're both very lucrative targets, and it would be folly to ignore either, and it's bizarre that this metric even appears in a piece contemplating consumer choices.
The reception to the iPad was overwhelmingly positive (if we really need to go to archived press and reviews, we can do that, but this revisionist nonsense about the iPad's reception needs to stop). And I don't remember anyone doubting that it would sell, just as I have no doubt that Apple will sell tens of millions of this watch regardless of any defects.
What people criticized was the notion that the iPad killed laptops -- that it was the new vehicle of productivity. And the terrible name which, while it stuck, remains terrible.
And those critics were by and large right. I know people can point to the fringe "productivity" use of an iPad, but overwhelming we use it for casual browsing, watching videos, and playing casual games. Exactly the same sort of stuff that we did on PMPs before. Because the iPad is a biggie-sized PMP, and it was hardly the first to idealize the notion that PMPs were cool, but would be cooler bigger (the "CrunchPad", for instance, was proposed two years before the iPad. The concept was obvious, albeit within a narrow band).
Defense? Why do I have to defend or explain anything? Are we waving flags? Why do I have to defend the things other people say?
I was specifically replying to the defensive notion that criticisms of Apple have been proven wrong (though they weren't wrong, and this is zero revisionism: The first iPod was a general market failure, and took off two years later), thus they will always be wrong, which is a bit of logical nonsense. The other bit was the "Apple is doing what no one else is doing", but other people are doing it and have been doing it. Here in Canada we've enjoyed extremely prolific NFC use without Apple's involvement.
Apple makes a lot of great products. They yield a lot of success. That does not mean that they are not prone to making mistakes, for proclaiming truths that are self-serving nonsense, and for getting the market wrong. It's worth noting that at the height of Microsoft's success the same "can do no wrong" arguments appeared everywhere.
Outside of that, some people seem to identify their personality with Apple, and they truly seem to project a persecution complex (yes, this is seen on /r/technology. I marvel that you hold it as an example, as it is one place where any criticism of Apple, however deserved and accurate, brings out droves and droves of defenders. It is a cesspool of a sub for that reason). Apple is an enormous company, and is enormously successful, so this "woe are us" bit just grows tiring.
Nonetheless, the iTunes empire is currently doing almost $20B of business a year, with a $6B cut. The NFL, in contrast -- for all its seeming enormity and influence -- is about a $8B business, gross.
Somehow this has taken off as a talking point, yet all NFC secure element payment solutions qualify as "card present". Google Wallet, for example, is card present. The NFC on my card is card present.
It isn't about negotiations, but indicates the security of the presentation. NFC secure elements are considered card equivalent.
I would say it is entirely in Apple's DNA. Apple has aggressively tried to inject themselves between sellers and buyers in multiple markets, even where their value add is unwanted and unnecessary.
And I don't fault them at all for that. They're a business and they're doing what businesses do, growing revenue. Trying to get a pound of flesh from the payment industry process is something many players are aggressively trying to do right now, and Apple is no exception.
And of course in the end all fees end up being borne by consumers.
One fallacy that many make in such discussions is the argument that Apple makes so much from hardware they really don't care about the smaller parts of their business, yet they have shown that they care very much about it. Don't think of Apple (or Google, or Microsoft, or any other growth company) as a $N billion dollar company -- every day they are, to the people fighting for more market, a $0 company, because all that matters to the tiers and people involved is $(M-N) tomorrow.
Very few bought the iPod in the first two years, and it was a commercial failure. It was iTunes on Windows that brought it mainstream.
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Total_ipod_sales.svg
We know that it took off, but that was wholly on the back of iTunes - 0.99 tracks and much easier use than competitors sold the iPod, not some fundamental excellence of the device.
People forget now but while we revile iTunes generally now, at the time it was the killer feature of the iPod, and the initial iPhone success.
You mean exactly like Android.
Pretty remarkable having clueless people telling me that I don't know what I'm talking about: I develop in both Android and iOS. But please, inform me.
Of extraordinary social and technological importance. I work in technology, and shifts in mobile technology have significant impacts on my life.
I can understand if this were a knitting board and someone made a comment like yours. In technology, however, it is extremely pertinent to what we do.
You've soundly beaten down notions that I certainly didn't state. Nor have I seen everyone else. However the narrative among the Apple camp was that competitors were desperately rushing to deliver vapour, and that their stodgy square mega watches were non-starters.
Yes, Android had dynamic layout before iOS. And? Qt had it before everyone.
Again, you've firmly argued against something not being discussed. No one ever claimed that Android was first, however Android was quite specifically criticized by Apple (as were, tellingly, larger smartphones, and smaller tablets, and people eat it up). Because it turns out that Apple just says today whatever benefits their contemporary product line, much like just about every other company. And that's fine, but somehow it turns into higher meaning.
Aside from CSS-type "responsive" design, Android layouts have always had resource tags, which means that you can set different layouts for screen sizes, orientations, pixel densities, cultures, text direction, and so on.
Apps that didn't demonstrate this on tablets were as they were because the developers were lazy or simply didn't care, not because of a limitation of the platform.