HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

personZ

2,015 karma · joined April 2, 2014

submissionscomments
personZ··on The Apple Watch
it's hard for me not to recall Commander Taco's (in)famous dismissal of the original iPod when I browse these comments

You should also remember that he was hardly in the majority with those comments. Further he was technically correct, and the iPod succeeded because of a synergy with other parts of Apple's empire (notably iTunes).

But what's really interesting to me is that Apple has clearly put a lot more thought into how interactions on a device like this should work than anybody else.

How so? Google put, it seems, enormous thought and effort into Android Wear. It is a whole interaction and ecosystem built specifically for smart watches. Because Tim Cook gives some trite speech about not using a smartphone OS on a watch (this was, it is worth noting, not long after celebrating how xcode now supports dynamic layouts...you know, the thing that Android did a half a decade ago, and was widely deridden as "running smartphone apps on a tablet")?

You've tried to cover every possible Apple defense, so you seem pretty committed, but you have to understand that a lot of people are derisive because we've been hearing the Apple faithful railing about these same attributes of competitor devices for months. Announcing before availability, large and bulky, needs to be tethered to a device, square, and so on...I have to imagine all of those once liabilities will suddenly turn into strengths.

I love my Apple products, but there is absolutely no doubt that there is a distortion field, and it really is hard to stomach.

personZ··on The Apple Watch
Without context and metadata, I cannot fathom how finger-drawn pictures could convey data clearly, much less those done on a 1" screen. If someone got a picture of a fish, as demonstrated, for instance -- presuming they actually recognize it as a fish -- are they really going to think of sushi? That seems like a bit of a reach, a tonne of narrative adding context that the picture most certainly doesn't add.

I've done the drawn picture thing. It isn't new, and many messaging clients have supported it for literally years (ICQ supported it in the 90s). And when it was added everyone sent pictures around, and quickly (very quickly) it was completely forgotten.

It's a gimmick through and through.

personZ··on The Apple Watch
Perhaps, but it is a five minute app. For Apple to spend minutes on the concept of communicating via finger drawings on a tiny screen borders on bizarre. I will say that if Samsung or LG demoed something like this, they would be widely and rightfully mocked. I'm not saying that in a polarizing "camps" perspective, but that people are often surprisingly uncritical of Apple.
personZ··on The Apple Watch
As much ink was spilled about competitors' failures, it's interesting that this won't be available some until vague window next year, and needs to be tethered to an iPhone.

The interface looks interesting. The ridiculous draw pictures to each other bit, though -- what a gimmick.

personZ··on Why Google is Hurrying the Web to Kill SHA-1
If going SHA-2 only requires a request flag, why so long for a transition? Is there some downside (e.g. old clients that don't support it) that holds Google off?
personZ··on Moto 360 review – Beautiful outside, ugly inside
Exactly the case, and it really undermines the whole article. The general floating point performance (non GPU) is entirely irrelevant for the general uses of this device. Other subsystems might be faulty, or it could be a faulty device, but it certainly isn't floating point performance.

One line in the article that gave me a chuckle was We can say that Android Wear looks much better on a round screen. The OS was clearly designed with circular displays in mind—every button is round, producing a cool circle-within-a-circle look on the 360. Contrast this with the Verge who said that Android Wear was designed and looks better on a square screen, and is forced onto a round screen.

personZ··on Pricenoia shuts down
I know Google does the same, but it's not an example to follow.

When Google decides that clicks were invalid, they remove the commission and also remove the charges from the advertiser. The fact that they do this, and aggressively fight click fraud, is one of the major reasons they have so little real competition.

In the case of Amazon I'm not sure how they could do that...do they cancel all of the orders under the old agreement? Give customers their money back and ask for stuff to be shipped back?

As an aside, Amazon's Affiliate program is one of the big vehicles of noise on the net. When authors suddenly decide to write a big blog entry about the best headphones, or the best coffee grinders, etc, invariably you find that it was 100% affiliate fee driven. That might seem like a "well they might as well capitalize", but the corrupting influence of peddling commission goods is unavoidable.

personZ··on Lessons I learned from the failure of my first startup, Dinnr
Their observation isn't remotely an ad hominem: They are specifically criticizing the message, not the speaker.

And their point is valid: There is a wide "startup" belief that you needn't know the market or domain, the customers, etc. You just need to find a domain name and make a web page and customers will come and somehow a business will fall together. Only the overwhelming odds are that it will face likely failure.

Another trait of many of these types of posts is what idlewords points out: The tendency for people to generalize lessons. This is the risk of the dirty sushi restaurant with poor service that inevitably fails, but then writes a broad treatise about how the area won't support sushi restaurants. We see this constantly among such "lessons learned", where macro inputs are often substituted for micro failures.

personZ··on Apple Says It Will Add New iCloud Security Measures After Celebrity Hack
The item they are fixing is not the password, which already has complexity requirements, and through most systems is rate limited. They are fixing the security questions system.

And I think they're understating the changes they're going to make. Simply sending a "BTW someone just took over your account" message is obviously not enough -- take it over at 2am and enjoy a night of malfeasance. Instead I imagine they are going to put in some thoughtful patterns like-

-emailing the password change notice to the email address on record on the successful completion of the security questions.

-having a window before any new password/grants come into effect from such a system.

Or the like. As is their proposed improvements don't do much more than what currently exists, where you (apparently) do at least get an email after someone reset your password by exploiting this system weakness.

personZ··on Apple Says It Will Add New iCloud Security Measures After Celebrity Hack
This sort of comment appears a lot and it makes for an easy trip to victim blaming.

Apple created these questions for you to enter real answers. They fully intend for you to put in real answers. That is what the system's purpose is.

That we look at it and say "well that is grossly insecure, so I'm going to put in the SHA512 hash of the question with a fixed secret salt" might assuage our risk, but it does nothing to relieve Apple of the failure of this security system.

personZ··on Standard Markdown Is Now Common Markdown
Yes, I do think it's appropriate. Further, this discussion is among the participants of HN -- it isn't for the edification or entertainment of any subjects.

There's a name and namespace collision that is causing enormous ill will. Further, as much as it's a "standard" it's a half-baked standard on most sites, many simply utilizing what people already traditionally did for ASCII decoration.

personZ··on Standard Markdown Is Now Common Markdown
Why not just do something completely original and get away from this mess?

And by original, I include the concept of using traditional ASCII markups. For instance, doing this (asterisks) for emphasis long preceded Markdown. As did _this_. As did -this- and various other ASCII markings. None of those are innovations of markdown, or are they inventions of John Gruber, and their intention is directly paralleled in HTML.

Beyond that...the link mechanism of Markdown is and always has been pretty weak, and outside of that it's pretty marginal grounds.

personZ··on Go Execution Modes
The current state of the CGO interface is that you can't safely pass Go pointers to C code. That's all this document is repeating.

Where is this stated? Where is it said that it's technically incorrect?

Just to be clear, I'm not passing it and then running a thread in C that just runs with the pointer to an object that no longer exists in Go. Instead I'm calling a C function synchronously -- there is no possible way the element is going to be collected during that run. It could be compacted (though Go up until now has explicitly had a non-compacting GC, so not a current risk), of course, which is what brought up this issue, but that's the reason such interop languages have pinning (flagging that something shouldn't be moved).

It wasn't by chance -- it was by design, and it was purposefully understanding the lifetime of objects.

personZ··on Go Execution Modes
This is the type of issues that nicely lead to security bugs

It's also the type of functionality that enables the efficient use of high performance C libraries and existing code (I use it to great effect with the Intel compiler for extremely high performance SIMD code).

The "someone might not use it right, therefore it's anathema" notion is misguided, and is orthogonal with the philosophy of Go. Even C# and Java -- the pinnacle of "enterprise" languages -- understand and respect the notion of pointer sharing, and early on built in mechanisms to support it. Go is a league above, though, given that it follows C struct layout rules.

But I see where the person proposing banning it got their notion from -- it's a classic hubris of "if it isn't important to me, it isn't important to anyone". A compacting GC has benefits, but the lazy notion of wholesale blocking broad and powerful uses because one doesn't personally benefit from them is how languages die.

personZ··on Go Execution Modes
The dogma about preventing the sharing of pointers with C is a bit concerning. I've made use of that mechanism, to fantastic effect, albeit understanding the risks and consequences. The notion that it must be prevented because bad things can happen if you aren't careful isn't a starter, as there are essentially zero people doing that who've had problems. Instead a lot of people have enjoyed fantastic productivity because of the similarities of the implementations, and the synergy that allows.

But the team wants move to a compacting GC. Fine, add pin/unpin idioms. This ground has been well covered by other languages. Don't completely destroy a very productive mechanism because in some oddball cases it might not work.

personZ··on Failing the startup game at Unbabel
the claims about my platform and the competence of my team would be my focus and I'd address them head on

Why? A former employee criticizes the company they were fired from -- that carries essentially zero weight to pretty much anyone, and you seem to be among very, very few who took it at face value. Heck, even if they weren't fired and didn't have the axe to grind, people complain about "spaghetti" code with such vigor and frequency in this industry that it has become essentially meaningless: It's the standard fall-back when someone is in over their head -- attack others, malign their code and technology, and try to pull up yourself by tearing down others.

Further, how in the world can you complain about them commenting on a "personal" matter, when they are responding to a guy who posted a highly-critical extortion rant. I call it an extortion rant because he even claims that if he warned them that they need to pay up or face his public flailing.

That's incredibly lame.

personZ··on Update to Celebrity Photo Investigation
It seems significantly more likely that the "hack" was in the account recovery system which allows -- via a couple of often easily discovered personal details -- a complete, immediate account takeover.
personZ··on Failing the startup game at Unbabel
This is why I never take these sorts of stories at face value. I'm not casting aspersions on the author, but at the same time I'm not willing to blindly accept the same against others. In these sorts of situation, invariable both sides feel they were wronged in some way.

I've hired, and directed, people who just didn't work out, and many of them could write something very similar to what the author submitted.

Because what I was hiring were people to help propel us forward in short-order, and did everything possible to filter and convey expectations of the same, but some hires needed so much direction, so much hand-holding, and so much oversight that they ended up literally being a net negative on velocity of the whole. So it just wasn't a fit and we had to split ways.

There are different companies, at different stages and sizes, where that sort of thing is perfectly okay. But at anything where the word "startup" might be applied, it just isn't the case.

personZ··on Anger mounts over Barclays ban on rooted Android phones
it's the direct equivalent of UAC on Windows or sudo access on Linux

Indeed, it is. Do most corporate users run with admin accounts? Home users? In both cases, while the answer is unfortunately sometimes yet, it should always be no -- they are one confirmation away from significant peril.

personZ··on Anger mounts over Barclays ban on rooted Android phones
The type of person who roots their phone is almost always going to be technologically experienced

Unfortunately, it seems, the opposite is true: Rooting is often one of the "checklist" kind of things that you see on many misled Android forums, and it seems that many users do it...just because.

And now they have a platform that is often significantly more vulnerable.

I completely understand why services would block this -- it fundamentally breaks the protections of the device. Many widely referenced vulnerabilities of Android only apply to rooted devices.

personZ··on Apple Working with American Express on iPhone 6 Mobile Payments
Not only do you hold up things that Apple hasn't released, gloating about their grand innovation of vapour, you apparently don't realize that credit cards have NFC. There is nothing "impossible" about fitting NFC in just about anything, and your strawman simply makes no sense at all.

Fingerprint authenticated NFC? That would be solving a complete non-problem, misunderstanding the whole role of NFC.

You can get business cards with NFC. Every Skylander action figure has NFC in it. Credit and payment cards have NFC. But here you're comically holding that putting it in a wearable will be a grand innovation.

This sort of bubble and ignorance is extraordinary. But yes, I fully expect that after Apple releases something, years after so many others embraced NFC, you'll go forth telling all how innovative they were.

personZ··on Apple Working with American Express on iPhone 6 Mobile Payments
>Apple will be the first company to convince the rest of my technophobic family to actually use the technology.

You seem pretty certain of that. Apple has a long list of initiative failures.

Are you overloading the technology side of this? I'm not saying "Apple versus Google Wallet", for instance -- pretty much every Canadian Mastercard, and now many debit card, has NFC on it. I pay at the gas station and the grocery store by moving my card in proximity to a reader. This is ubiquitous. Putting an Apple middleman in the solution seems unnecessary and backwards.

The interesting thing about that insight is that it does seem as though people are trying to copy Apple before they have even entered the arena.

I find this line of thought simply incredible. Wearables have been around for years, and are a simple manifestation of technological refinement in processors, displays, batteries, and wireless technology. It is happening because the technology is there and making it both possible and compelling. Yes, Apple will eventually get in the market, but the notion that everyone else is copying Apple in advance is simply incredible.

I probably give them too much credit and you give them too little - seems like a reasonable balance.

Again, the entire payment industry is moving to NFC. Wearables are becoming technologically possible and powerful. In neither case does Apple deserve any credit at all -- this isn't a case where the middle ground must be right -- and it is rather incredible when they are given any.

personZ··on Apple Working with American Express on iPhone 6 Mobile Payments
The reason they get credit is that people actually use the solutions they provide.

The entire payment industry is moving to chip / NFC, and the parent offers up that maybe Whole Foods is prepping for Apple.

No, they aren't. They're prepping for, again, the entire payment industry. Hundreds of products across all major payment vendors. You haven't used it because the US payment space in particular is very slow, but soon enough every card you carry will feature it, and the technology will be ubiquitous, with or without Apple getting involved.

This happens repeatedly: Apple is very good at choosing the right time to enter a market -- hitting it when it hits primetime -- and then they get credit for creating the market. Incidental, but I saw an incredible conversation the other day where multiple participants were vilifying Apple's competitors for copying Apple on wearables.

personZ··on Apple Working with American Express on iPhone 6 Mobile Payments
It is a coincidence, and it is odd that Apple seems to get attribution for emerging technology trends.

All of the payment vendors are or have already embraced NFC. Here in Canada, NFC is ubiquitous, and I'd be surprised if it wasn't in the US. MasterCard's PayPass, for instance, is NFC.

personZ··on Detroit Is America’s Emerging Market
Aside from the Detroit car industry doing quite well, I have to comment on -

"Also, according to protonfish, Detroit has terrible infrastructure and sounds like a shitty place to live."

Just to contrast here, protonfish questions the motives of a billionaire who has moved thousands of his own employees, and made significant investments, in downtown Detroit. A man who, despite the financial capacity to live anywhere in the world, lives in Detroit. Invests in Detroit. Believes in Detroit.

Isn't that an incredible contrast? On the one hand you have someone taking strong actions, and on the other you have someone posting a comment on a message board. And you believe the guy posting on a message board?

I doubt protonfish knows anything about Detroit beyond some ruin porn they saw on a Reddit post.

personZ··on Detroit Is America’s Emerging Market
>Nearly 70,000 residential accounts are going to have their water cut off through the end of September.

No they won't. Detroit faced an endemic issue where people simply felt that they didn't have to pay their water bills because there was no consequence. Now that they've instituted this plan, lots of people have found the ability to pay their bill, or to make arrangements to pay it eventually, or to credibly make a case for why they can't.

Pretty much every city charges for water, and pretty much every city cuts you off if you don't pay your bill.

personZ··on Detroit Is America’s Emerging Market
Manufacturing has since left, and it's very unlikely that an equally lucrative industry is going to be able to fill the gap.

By this measure, just about every American city is doomed. Except, I suppose, San Francisco, if we accept that every city is "winner takes all" (which it isn't and has never been).

Detroit is a metro area about 4 million strong. It is the gateway for millions of Canadians, and to the Toronto area. It is midway between a number of great cities. It has abundant energy, geological and political stability, limited pests, and so on. It has a very large workforce, and despite the reputation, a very large educated workforce.

I mean some of the commentary in here is just...weird. Someone else commented as if all industry is going to move South, as if winter is a significant economic factor (it isn't) to industry (aside from data centers and cooling, for that matter).

personZ··on Detroit Is America’s Emerging Market
Most of the stories you read about Detroit are deeply negative. We've seen "ruin porn" on here, the whole water issue (where having a service turned off for lack of payment somehow got cast into something greater). It gives a baseline for a story like this -- and the contrast -- to appear.
personZ··on Detroit Is America’s Emerging Market
Isn't it possible that such a comeback is reflected in small areas at first? That the city isn't going to wake up one morning restored to its former glory?

Comments such as yours (and the parent above it) seem to believe that Detroit is down and must stay down. That any negative in the town anywhere invalidates any positive elsewhere. But that is, of course, nonsense. Indeed, we heard exactly the same sort of noise about New York City in the 80s which, while clearly never hitting anywhere near the bottoms of Detroit, many wrote off as beyond repair, settled into a cesspool of crime and decay.

The "real" Detroit includes an invigorating downtown, growing investments, and an actual tech community. That, too, counts as Detroit, and it doesn't not count simply because you can point to negatives elsewhere.

personZ··on Mozilla Unveils $33 Intex Cloud FX Smartphone
Using HTML5 enables the operating system to be very lean and it requires less memory consumption.

This claim is deeply suspect.

← PreviousPage 8 of 18Next →