348 karma · joined November 30, 2017
Tldr: it has EVERYTHING to do with hacking
You can definitely recreate the feeling of exclusivity today on the internet.
Just poking fun.
You really shouldn't have voted leave my friend.
I don’t know too much about this particular aspect, but I imagine that even the risk management part of paying for insurance gets tricky once you’re projecting out 10+ years.
All this being said, it’s the best argument in my view, but still not prohibitive. I still find myself believing in nuclear power, especially more research into advanced tech.
Educated and physically capable men with some wealth typically became warriors in the past. They certainly didn’t become blacksmiths/builders/engineers/whatever. Maybe there’s something to be said for an entire industry and culture around letting this type of person act out their aggression in a less violent way. Probably serves a huge good to a stable society in general, so that the builders can build in relative peace. If you believe that prices reflect value, then definitely more good to pay these dudes to tackle each other than it is to pay for doctors and teachers - Can’t care for the raped and pillaged.
Funny though that now we get the less-fortunate rungs of society to fight the wars now.
>our fundamental constitution as multicellular organisms, our limited lifespan, the epidemiology of the aging population, socioeconomics and the future of society.
Like, hey man, you do realize that the killing or reprogramming of cancer cells goes far beyond the molecular technicalities of actually doing it?
Yup. It’s a pretty vacuous critism.
I think what we're both touching on here, and what the article touches on as well, is the question of what happens when the accumulation of wealth becomes so great, that it's utility becomes almost incomprehensible. We know the sun consumes matter, but to speak of the markets 5 billion years from now is so incomprehensible, that the energy produced today might as well be 'free'. The discussion stops being an economic one and turns into a religious one.
To bring it back to the article, what I understand you to be saying is, what if the Congolese Trading Window had opened into the living room of someone who could throw off good things for 'free'. They won't purchase goods that deprive someone else of having them. So basically, a never-ending flow of rice comes out of this window. This person, or even just the window if there's no person attached, literally becomes a god. It's why the sun has been worshiped. It's why feudal lords had the honorific 'lord'. The disparity in wealth between a parent and child is so great that religions have used the terms 'mother' and 'father' to describe nature and deities. A King's Divine Right. The Emperor's Mandate of Heaven. We could find others I think.
In all of these cases, there is still consumption of resources to produce something, just that the scale at which this happens is beyond the realm of understanding for the end-user. We have a decent idea that the sun will be burning in however many billion years, but will markets exist? No clue, so yeah, it's 'free'. Before we knew these facts, it was grounds for worship, but now, we just know it as physics.
You asked if I thought if to produce without consuming was the worst possible thing, and then mentioned that the need to consume was missing the core insight. What is your answer to your question?
If your statement had been 'produces X amount', and not 'works X amount', then my answer definitely changes. Less consumption for the same amount of production is always better, because in aggregate it means more resources for consumption, and production goes up. Or maybe not? I'd be interested to think about a good counterpoint.
Even the sun consumes - it consumes hydrogen, helium, lots of stuff. And that stuff is localized to the sun. Perhaps we'll figure out a way to add fuel from somewhere else to the sun one day, but as of right now, the sun consumes an ultimately limited amount of stuff. We have a pretty decent understanding now of the relationship between the sun's consumption and production of resources.
If someone were like the sun, and charged for sunlight, then they would HAVE to spend the money on acquiring more hydrogen. If they left the money in the bank, then they wouldn't be able to produce the sunlight that earns them money.
In other words, you have to produce in order to consume in order to produce in order to consume, and so on. The worst possible thing would be consumption sans production - that's cancer.
Can you think of examples where you would produce without consumption? I can't think of any. Even intellectual discoveries consume information. My answer to your question would be that it would be the most impossible thing someone could do to produce but never consume.
You can't eat cake that's gone bad because you've kept it in your cupboard too long. Even though we're using a metaphor here, literally - in the very definition of literal - if you don't eat your cake, it actually does become toxic, defeating the purpose of having it in the first place.
edit: btw, I think we're in agreement. I'm advocating for thoughtful consumption.
We are social animals, and our standing within the tribe is most certainly a resource to be extracted and utilized. How you utilize it is a different discussion, but influence and respect are undeniably parts of our software as human beings. Money is not a token we trade for things that have intrinsic value. We would have traded for these things before money was a thing, under a system of social credit. Everyone knows who's dependable and who sucks in the tribe, since you see and work with them everyday. Now that we're bigger than 200 tribe members, we need an abstraction to determine this: money.
The author comes to this conclusion about 4/5 of the way down:
>The money you've earned represents value you've contributed to society.
I agree with the author throughout most of the article until this thought:
>The point is, money spent on consumption is toxic — value-destroying.
It's like, yeah, if I eat my cake then of course I can't have it too, but I needed the calories, and the tribe is better off that I had the energy and means to be productive. The whole of section V is just weird to me. It would be like saying 'metabolism is toxic'. I mean, I guess it can be? There are waste products, and there's also energy. It's just a nonsensical conclusion that we get to in an otherwise well-written article.
>But as long as we're soul-searching, let's not forget to examine our spending habits as well.
Yeah, 100% agree. Thought-provoking read overall.
Your status in the tribe is highly dependent on your utility to the tribe, and that utility is highly-dependent on how well you work with other members of the tribe to achieve common goals. If you are more effective than your neighbor at advancing community goals, then you will have a higher social value than your neighbor.
When we were just tribes of 150-200 humans, our minds were able to store all of this social value tallying. You can intimately know everyone in your tribe. You know their credits and debits to the communal good. We have imaginations though, and can abstract some of this into stories and myths and other sorts of value systems, and so, maybe you don’t know Urgk personally, but he has a lot of cows, and you know how useful those are, so you immediately assign him some qualities in your mind.
This breaks down if you also don’t know how Urgk got these cows. Did he murder their owners and take them for his own? Did he execute some brilliant trades with tanned leather than eventually became a self-perpetuating cow-wealth machine and left the whole tribe better off? Hopefully, in your abstraction machine you’ve also codified some of the qualities of one type of Urgk and qualities of the other type of Urgk. He’s wearing a cross, and he treats his children well, so, even though you still don’t know him intimately, you at least can make some assumptions, and communicate with him directly to fill in the rest.
If you wanted people to respect you in your tribe (a VERY natural and good desire to have), then you might start trying to figure out how to build a cow-wealth feedback system too. You don’t know shit about tanning, but your weird son enjoys playing with sticks and has an idea to make everyone’s domicile a little more resilient to the weather with his weird hobby. People don’t really understand it, until they see it.
Or maybe you just decide to gain wealth by doing something that is not respectable, and yeah, you’ve got the money now, but it’s negated by the negative social value you’ve incurred, so you’re never truly respected and you never get the girl, ala Gatsby.
You’re comment is close to the mark. I’d go even further than you have and just say outright, ‘money is a store of social value’.
It becomes not so much an issue of never having to pay the debt back because we owe ourselves and can ultimately write it off, but an issue of, at a certain level of easy credit, is it possible that it becomes impossible to keep making good investments. There’s definitely a balancing act in how much world debt is too much.
We’re for sure in a multi-ethnic society. There’s no question about this. But when a ‘black’ man is elected to the highest office, when ‘black’ people continue to hold institutional power, both in government and universities, the actual practice of racism becomes hard to prove. It becomes ethnocentrism.
The irony of this fact is how so many ‘whites’ (mostly uneducated) know it to be true, and so many ‘blacks’ refuse to believe it, instead calling on the European-American burgousie to feel guilt and dole out pity. There’s this belief that to be ‘black’ means to be cursed. Fuck that, African-Americans have reason to be proud of their accomplishments in this country.
If anything, white guilt is racism. You can’t look someone in the eye when you’re looking down on them.
Trump is the harbinger of a return to patrimonialism. Family offices, a return to patrimonialism. You get a bunch of people who never really understood civics or finance and you try to govern them technocratically, and you’re going to struggle. But everyone in this demographic understands families. They see this dude being passed down wealth, and ‘making something’ of it, and setting his kids up. People understand that, especially the type of person who doesn’t necessarily understand how the neoliberal world works, in ways that are both in their favor and against it.
Family offices are another data point in this trend towards capital accumulation, stark income inequality, and a retreat from public exposure.
Long position.
I think we’re officially in bear market territory, but they’ll be alright. Lots of companies will be fine. We’re going to see a correction next year, and the beginning of a shift from growth stocks to value stocks.
These articles do get tired. Yeah, we’re gonna see a correction, and it’s not gonna be the end of the world.