HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

petegrif

406 karma · joined January 4, 2011

submissionscomments
petegrif··on $4.5 B. Nortel Bid Shows the Disastrous State of Software Patents
Lame poorly written piece without clear argument or even any remotely convincing substantiation for its disconnected assertions.
petegrif··on Warning To All Entrepreneurs About Bad Investor Behavior
great post - thanks Brad Feld = respect
petegrif··on Google Reveals Its Stealth Social Project, Google+
I agree. It is somewhat ironic that Paul Adams who promoted this idea so forcibly whilst at google now works for...facebook.
petegrif··on Even for Cashiers, College Pays Off
My faith in some of the research underlying this article took a fatal hit when I read that the researchers discovered that whereas a dishwasher with no degree earned $19K, a college graduate earned $34K for the same menial task. It may just be me but that rings so untrue that it bears investigation. To me it is unfathomable why an employer would pay a dishwasher 15K a year more because he/she has a degree. I don't buy it.
petegrif··on Restoration of 1st Edition Unix kernel sources
Fabulous!
petegrif··on You don't understand something until you think it's obvious.
This is why so many people think patents are unfair - because they are so obvious. :)
petegrif··on Supreme Court rules against Microsoft in major patent case
data structures?
petegrif··on Supreme Court rules against Microsoft in major patent case
No. Because the law is perfectly clear on this point. Algorithms cannot be patented.
petegrif··on Supreme Court rules against Microsoft in major patent case
IMHO you are missing an absolutely critical point and are therefore falling prey to the hindsight effect. Let's imagine that you have a brilliant idea right now, one that NOW is not at all obvious. What does that mean? It means that NOW (a) there is no prior art (b) there may well be teaching away from the art, in other words, even though the field is a familiar one and you would think it obvious once pointed out, nonetheless there is no evidence that anyone has thought of it before (c) there is no public domain publication or record of a talk etc .... Such evidence is taken as evidence that it is not obvious. Now let's assume that you take your idea further and turn it from an idea - an insight if you will - into an invention. That may involve a great deal of time and money. In some cases it certainly does. Now let us assume that you release a product and it achieves great success. The very success of your product means that it will become a part of popular culture and there have been several studies that show that within a remarkably short period of time people take what was your innovation for granted and consider it obvious. Bear in mind however that it wasn't obvious when you thought of it and when its obviousness was considered, for example, by the patent office. Failure to recognize this and the associated hindsight effect leads to people making statements about how obvious something is when that is completely irrelevant. The question is not how obvious it is but how obvious it was. If a patent is granted it can always be challenged and invalidated if someone is able to demonstrate that there was indeed prior art. The patent is assumed to have validity but that does not mean that evidence of prior art will just be disregarded, it just means that the evidence has to be clear.
petegrif··on Supreme Court rules against Microsoft in major patent case
I honestly don't understand the point you are making. Would you mind elaborating? Thanks.
petegrif··on Supreme Court rules against Microsoft in major patent case
@romp please see my post above about 'the obviousness test' IMHO this relationship between patents and what is obvious is the source of a huge amount of misunderstanding about and opposition to patents. I have no problem with serious discussions about patent reform, but surely such a serious discussion should be based on a substantive understanding of reality not popular misconceptions? Let's all get clear on what is meant by 'obvious' in the context of patents and that will help us move things along.
petegrif··on Supreme Court rules against Microsoft in major patent case
@rwmj - the question is not whether it is obvious now but rather was their invention obvious then. Do you have any reason to believe it was obvious then? Remember that this very question has been litigated with MS doing everything in their power to demonstrate it was indeed obvious then, that there was prior art, and they failed! So it is easy to allege something like this now but I suspect that you are suffering from the hindsight effect and don't actually have any evidence supporting your claim of obviousness. I don't doubt your sincerity and I don't mean to be rude, I just don't think you are likely to have done the research (as MS and their attorneys did!) to prove it was obvious THEN.
petegrif··on Supreme Court rules against Microsoft in major patent case
i4i is exactly such a small company.
petegrif··on Supreme Court rules against Microsoft in major patent case
I am in favor of software patents and I am in favor of shortening the duration. (In this context we somehow have to reform USPTO so that they can get a patent out in less than 3-5 years! remember this time comes off the term of the patent) :)
petegrif··on US Supreme Court won't weaken presumptive strength of patents
Not really. In fact it makes a large swathe of speculative litigation to invalidate patents rather less likely so you can rest easy. :)
petegrif··on Supreme Court rules against Microsoft in major patent case
"It's so ridiculous theyre essentially patenting generic syntaxes for representing documents that anybody "skilled in the art" would come up with in 5 minutes." now - sure but then? - apparently not as extensive litigation demonstrated. And that 'non-obvious' nature back then - that's kinda the point, hindsight effect is a powerful thing
petegrif··on Supreme Court rules against Microsoft in major patent case
@aroberge - that is absolutely correct. Part of the reason that MS were hit so hard is precisely because they knowingly and willfully infringed.
petegrif··on Interview with Ken Thompson - on writing Unix, Go language and Dennis Ritchie
A giant amongst men.
petegrif··on The Bobby Fischer Defense, by Garry Kasparov
Great article. I am always amazed by how well K writes.
petegrif··on Poll: Do you support software patents?
That is clearly not a reasonable test. In fact it is almost certainly a great test for someone having innovated in a valuable way. If you file a worthless patent then no-one will be interested in your innovation and there will be no-one to sue. If however you file something valuable you would expect to potentially have lots of people to sue. In your example the question arises, why have so many people trespassed on this patent? We know they have an incentive - it is valuable. But why in this hypothetical case did they trespass? Did they think the patent was breakable? the patent holder weak? the market opportunity so great that they would build now pay later? Perhaps they didn't find the patent? So many questions. But as a cursory study of hindsight bias will make plain it is extremely common for something that is not at all obvious at the time of its invention of appear so later.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindsight_bias

petegrif··on Poll: Do you support software patents?
That is precisely what they don't do. All they do is stop someone else from claiming it as an innovation with the associated IP rights. There is nothing to stop someone innovating like a fiend. But surely it is blindingly obvious that copying something someone has already patented is not innovating. Everything else however is fair game. Knock yourself out and innovate.
petegrif··on Poll: Do you support software patents?
" In fact, the very fact that we have patent trolls that can run around and sue business after business after business for the same patent, while the businesses have no evidence that shows they have communicated with each other about the patented subject, ought to be proof positive that the patent is obvious and shouldn't be patentable."

Whether the person suing is or isn't a patent troll is irrelevant to your argument. You are basically arguing that if lots of people have done something without colluding it must be obvious. Not so.

I recommend this piece on hindsight bias. It is an extremely well documented fact that things rapidly become obvious after the fact.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindsight_bias

petegrif··on Poll: Do you support software patents?
There are many ideas that I can't stand. Fortunately I weigh them against their likelihood and find that reassuring. I suggest you do likewise. The probability that in your noodling you will develop something non-obvious and worthy of intellectual protection and will nonetheless continue obliviously developing it, without the slightest idea there may be protected prior art is vanishingly small. Consequently your paranoid intuition that we should abolish all software patents may be laid to rest. There may well be good reasons to investigate the patent system. IMHO this is not one of them. Hope this helps.
petegrif··on Poll: Do you support software patents?
I have read the piece in question. I don't understand how it answers Notjim's question. What is the alternative?
petegrif··on Poll: Do you support software patents?
One well documented problem here is 'hindsight effect.' After something has been invented and has been used for even a short while it becomes 'obvious.' This effect is so powerful that it is in fact difficult for attorneys representing patent holders where patents are being challenged for being 'obvious' to defend the case because juries now find what was non-obvious at the time to now be obvious. Studies show that this is not only potent but pervasive - being smart and well educated does not mean one can rewind time any better than the next person. It is hard to recapture that innocent state before the innovation.
petegrif··on Poll: Do you support software patents?
I have seen quite a few people who have filed patents state that they don't understand their own patents and (as a general statement) I find this puzzling. A patent has 3 main sections (a) background and prior art (b) description of the invention and (c) the claims.

The claims in particular are indeed technical and difficult for a lay person to readily understand. But the background, the prior art and the description of the implementation are not. Background and prior art are a summary of the technical context and I have never had any difficulty reading or understanding this section. The description may be rather long winded as it has to detail how to implement the invention so that it may be implemented from the description by someone skilled in the art, but it isn't legalese and should certainly be understood by the inventor! The lawyer can't write this by him/herself.

I can certainly sympathize with those who can't follow the claims (although I have found it to be perfectly possible with determined effort), but I simply fail to understand how a lawyer turns it into something "I can't understand any more." Find alien and unfamiliar - yes. But incomprehensible?

petegrif··on Poll: Do you support software patents?
http://www.betanews.com/joewilco... I would recommend this piece for those who wish to see the problems that a small innovative company can have even with patent protection. Without such protection they would have been left with nothing - copied wilfully by Microsoft and competitively dominated, all their investments down the rain. At least this way they prevailed in the courts and will have some recompense for the damage done to their innovative business.
petegrif··on Poll: Do you support software patents?
I'm sorry but I truly don't understand the relevance to my argument.
petegrif··on Poll: Do you support software patents?
Thanks for the vote - it was indeed an attempt to make a serious point.

I didn't actually forget 'first mover advantage' I simply didn't list it there because it isn't considered a form of IP protection. The problem I think with your position is that there is a historical record of innovative software companies being seriously or fatally damaged by unfair competition form big companies, some of whom are quite happy to copy your work despite the patent then challenge you to sue them with their vast legal resources. I think it is very hard to justify a general statement to justify your confidence that 'innovators would come up with clever ways of capitalizing...' And when you say it wouldn't be a perfect system but it would be a better one, the question arises - better for who? Not better for the small innovators who would be left with nothing, surely?

I am not suggesting this is easy, but I don't think a one sided abolition frenzy is the answer. IMHO this position is often motivated by (a) an ideology of freedom on the internet which whilst generally a good thing runs into problems in some cases in this context (b) a real ignorance about how the patent system actually works as opposed to caricatures and edge cases.

petegrif··on Poll: Do you support software patents?
I think the problem here stems from the fact that people talk as if "software" were one homogenous entity. But as we all know - it isn't. Some software is trivial and some isn't. Some represents a trifling investment and some a huge investment of time and dollars. Some is very easy to copy and some much harder. It is only when we start thinking about such categories that we can make real progress thinking about where and when patents may be appropriate when they are not.

Let's stipulate that the USPTO is not perfect. They do make mistakes. Patents are issued that should not be. But the existence of such patents should not be taken to be an inditement of the entire system. Few systems are perfect, but recognizing this let's further stipulate that advocating tossing the baby out with the bath water on this basis alone is impulsive.

The difficulty is in drawing a line - defining innovations which deserve protection and those which don't.

Let's try a thought experiment. Imagine you have an idea which you believe to be novel. You research the field and it does indeed look novel. You look into the problem. It's non-trivial. It is going to take man-years of work to put together an implementation. But there's a problem. The technology you have to use to implement it is such that it is extremely easy to copy your work. You don't want to have to patent your work. You don't want the time and expense. Perhaps you have principled reasons why you don't want to patent it? But let's consider your options. If you don't get patent protection you are left with (a) trade secret (b) copyright. We already know that a trade secret won't work because your work will be in a form that is easily copied. Does copyright protect you? No. Why not? Because copyright only protects the expression of the work, not the underlying ideas, no matter how novel and valuable they may be. It is easy for a determined competitor to take your work and re-engineer it such that copyright is worthless.

So what are you going to do? That depends on who you are. If you are a huge company and you still don't want to patent it you can go ahead and develop and publish your progress so that it is in the public domain and a competitor can't patent in the area. You are relying on your market strength to carry the day. But what if you are a small company? Are you prepared to risk everything with no protection? It is risky enough anyway starting a company, as we are constantly reminded, but if you can so easily be ripped off, isn't it wise to think twice?

It's your decision. You may have philosophical objections to patents so strong that you just don't proceed. That is your right. But if someone else decides to proceed it seems to me that it is perfectly rational for him/her to seek patent protection. It would be crazy not to. There is plenty of recent precedent of large companies ripping off small innovators even when they have patent protection!

IMHO to evaluate 'software patents' as a class is dangerous. Our industry is too big and the use cases are too various for such generalizations to be helpful. It is only by considering categories of innovation that we can hope to make progress on patent reform is such reform is needed. A knee jerk 'all software patents are the work of satan and should be trashed' doesn't help any more than a strident declaration of IP rights by well financed patent trolls.

← PreviousPage 11 of 12Next →