HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

petegrif

406 karma · joined January 4, 2011

submissionscomments
petegrif··on SourceMaps in Chrome allow debug of any source language compiled to JS
Very interesting. The reason we didn't want to use GWT was precisely because of the difficulty of debugging. This is a big step in the right direction.

The talk emphasizes debugging js as output of another language. But did I understand correctly that it can be used to debug js programs directly? Makes sense and would be awesome.

Great job - again.

petegrif··on Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There Himself
How is he going to get there and back without his bones disintegrating? I don't believe the science is there yet.
petegrif··on Posterous acquired by Twitter
good question - I don't get it either.
petegrif··on Pinterest, We Have a Problem
I think the point is well made about Youtube. There was indeed a huge amount of 'pirated' content on Youtube in the early days. Pinterest may be even worse because (a) the UI is specifically designed to make it incredibly easy to copy content. The overwhelming majority of Pinterest's content appears to be copied in this way. With Youtube at least people could and did upload a huge amount of their own content. And this is directly relevant to (b) Whereas Youtube was about hosting video content which may or may not have been copied Pinterest is so dominantly about copying content that it is much more like the case of the P2P sites whose whole modus operandi was to enable copying. It wasn't an unexpected or relatively minor aspect of their business - it was their business. And IMHO copying is Pinterest's business. The courts took a dim view of the P2P sites claiming that they were just the innocent service providers because of the overwhelming dominance of the use of the service and the fact that the site was designed to facilitate it. My suspicion is that Pinterest's moves to provide facilities to block pinning are legally motivated to fend off suits to the effect that they are unashamedly a copying engine.
petegrif··on Pinterest, We Have a Problem
I think this is extremely common. Most people don't read Terms of Service Agreements. And an even higher percentage of people don't read Updates to such agreements.
petegrif··on A Lawyer/Photographer Just Deleted All Her Pinterest Boards Out Of Fear
I don't think your position would be very compelling in court. By analogy you could argue that adding a movie to your hard drive is 'commenting on it' because its inclusion represents an implicit comment of liking it. And the courts have already ruled on that. Basically I find it hard to believe that you will get away with copying something by arguing you like it and that's a comment. If you could anyone could copy anything.
petegrif··on A Lawyer/Photographer Just Deleted All Her Pinterest Boards Out Of Fear
In what way are they different in law? Because surely that's the point, isn't it?
petegrif··on A Lawyer/Photographer Just Deleted All Her Pinterest Boards Out Of Fear
They don't necessarily make them 'public' in the sense you suggest. They may make them available for viewing on a site (distribution channel) that they have approved for whatever commercial reasons they see fit. They have chosen the channel and do rights to control that channel because they may well believe that the channel affects the value of the product.
petegrif··on A Lawyer/Photographer Just Deleted All Her Pinterest Boards Out Of Fear
I am pretty sure that foot massage clause is in Apple's ToU. Everything else is.
petegrif··on A Lawyer/Photographer Just Deleted All Her Pinterest Boards Out Of Fear
I am not sure this will work for them if courts decide that their very modus operandi is to encourage widespread copying. Peer to peer companies argued that they weren't copying, just providing a platform and that others were 'abusing' that platform, not them. But I believe the reason they were wiped out was that the whole way they conducted their business effectively promoted such abuse. I suspect it wouldn't be hard to argue that against Pinterest.
petegrif··on When She Codes, The Revolution’s Coming
Good for you guys. Awesome!
petegrif··on Amit Gupta has found a 10/10 matched donor
wonderful news I know 2 people who have had this procedure. Both are well!
petegrif··on Elm: a functional reactive programming language that compiles to JavaScript
very cool - good job
petegrif··on What I suspect Google is up to with Native Client
May I suggest a rather more innocent possibility wrt Google's intentions? They want us to be able to run high performance apps in the browser. And guess what - most of us would like that.
petegrif··on What I suspect Google is up to with Native Client
Agreed. And I still don't understand Mozilla's problem with NaCl. They argue that js is now nearly as fast as native. Well...even if that were true it ignores the fact that as you point out there is huge investment in legacy code that NaCl unlocks AND it ignores the fact that js makes it easy to copy what may be valuable IP.
petegrif··on What I suspect Google is up to with Native Client
tldr(all) this is a paranoid rambling piece that may just have some sense in it somewhere but it's so incoherently written it's tough to find it.
petegrif··on Security researcher responds to CarrierIQ with video proof
Horrific.
petegrif··on Programming languages cannot be copyrighted, says senior EU court adviser
No surprise. But thank god they got it right.
petegrif··on EU: Copyright Doesn't Cover Functionality, Programming Language
This should be no surprise. The case was weak. Copyright offers no practical intellectual protection for software. And in this case the software in question was reverse engineered!
petegrif··on HTML5 2D gaming performance analysis: Canvas 2D vs. WebGL vs. C++
It would be interesting to see a NaCl implementation.
petegrif··on If you want to get rich, stop being a fucking joker
What a douchebag.
petegrif··on Linus Torvalds: Software and Process Patents Don't Make Sense
You are absolutely correct. There are differences between the two industries. The two key ones would seem to be that (a) the investment required in time and money to create the software and its likely lifetime value are low compared with a drug, and (b) the ease of difficulty with which the software may be copied can vary a great deal. Compiled source code is harder to reengineer than a drug. Server side code that is held as a trade secret, such as google's search algorithms, is hard to recreate. So in these cases it is quite true that there has been innotation (ignoring the fact google did have some IP protection). But there are cases I can think of where it would be downright foolish for a software company, particularly a small one, to invest substantially without protection. The key characteristic is that the code cannot be held secret and can be readily read and thereby copied. The key point is that it really isn't very helpful to generalize to broadly about the software industry.
petegrif··on Patently Absurd - Copyright Law Can Meet the Needs of Software Developers
That doesn't make any sense. It is the same as writing the software from scratch. The only difference is that the behavior of the original software which is being copied is effectively the spec.
petegrif··on Patently Absurd - Copyright Law Can Meet the Needs of Software Developers
I am afraid that it is you who evidently does not understand my point. I am not suggesting that some imbecile may transcribe in a manner to blindingly obvious that they may run into trouble. What I am suggesting is that access to the code for anyone with an IQ over 50 is a HUGE help in building your own version and that this assistance is not inhibited by copyright.

I am extremely familiar with clean room reverse engineering. You are absolutely mistaken if you believe that 'That's what you have to do to copy software without infringing its copyright.' Reverse engineering actually has a rather different history. Given a device, say a chip, take the inputs and outputs of said device which defines the machine's behavior. Now design and build a machine which reproduces such a mapping. This practice was frequently associated with 'clean room' protocols. The key point is that the team had absolutely NO access to the source code. And because such a clean room team would never hire anyone who had previously had such access they could be confidently said to have reverse engineered the behavior from the APIs alone. This is a VERY different situation.

petegrif··on In defense of the Google chef
If the Zynga story is as reported it is beyond despicable.
petegrif··on In defense of the Google chef
+1
petegrif··on Linus Torvalds: Software and Process Patents Don't Make Sense
Bear in mind that a patent consists of several sections and these sections vary a great deal in how intuitive the use of language is.

The section which Linus is almost certainly referring to is the claims. These are indeed expressed in a technical vocabulary which is tricky for a lay person to penetrate.

But the section which is supposed to enable a person ordinarily skilled in the art to be able to make the invention is not written in such vocabulary. On the contrary, it typically written in language which is perfectly comprehensible. The difficulty if any is in having the patience to read a tediously long description with endless references to diagrams.

petegrif··on Patently Absurd - Copyright Law Can Meet the Needs of Software Developers
This is a frighteningly naive article. Consider the following extract: "There are at least three reasons to exclude software from patentability. First, software development is an individual, creative activity, more akin to writing a novel than designing a jet engine...Second, software patents are especially prone to litigation...Finally, software patents are unnecessary because software is already eligible for copyright protection...As long as programmers write their own code from scratch, they can be confident they aren't infringing others' copyrights."

The idea that software development is the sole province of the lone inventor is both wrong and irrelevant. The reason that our constitution facilitated patents was nothing to do with how many people invented something but rather with encouraging disclosure of the result.

If we stipulate that software patents are frequently violated...so what? Without further analysis of why or whether specific improvements to the system would be helpful this is a dangling factoid - no more.

Finally, the idea that copyright provides any kind of protection for software is so ludicrous the writer's naivety is laid bare. Copyright protects only the expression of an idea. In the case of a work of art such as a novel or painting the expression is critical to the work and copyright is a valuable protection. But if a programmer sits with original source code before him and rewrites it in another language thereby benefiting enormously from the original work but changing the expression completely they may indeed be programmers writing "their own code" but it certainly isn't "from scratch", and whilst he is right that "they can be confident they aren't infringing others" it is blindingly obvious that they have copied. Copyright is worthless if the expression doesn't matter and all that matters is functional equivalence. And guess what, users don't give a rat's ass how a program is expressed so long as it works.

petegrif··on Linus Torvalds: Software and Process Patents Don't Make Sense
Wouldn't that be nice. Now consider the case of a pharmaceutical company that has to spend hundreds of millions of dollars to develop a new drug and get it past FDA. If there is no IP protection would you as the CEO of this company spend that kind of money on innovating when the resultant drug could be copied a week after it appears on the shelves? In this case you would be competing on product alright - exactly the same product. But the copier has had no R&D cost and can undercut you and put your offering out of business.

The issue is often framed in terms of all patents being bad, or all software patents being bad but to anyone to gives the matter more than the kind of superficial thought stemming from ideology the reality is rather more complicated.

petegrif··on Linus Torvalds: Software and Process Patents Don't Make Sense
"... and that's the reason you have to have a patent lawyer because the language makes no sense. In US it’s technically English but it’s not really English. It’s like using English words but there are different meanings to them. There is a whole different set of rules about what things mean when they do a patent application."

Well guess what - that is not unusual when everyday words migrate into a technical area and the law is such an area. To complain about words having specialist meanings in a specific subject area strikes me as naive.

← PreviousPage 8 of 12Next →