HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

petegrif

406 karma · joined January 4, 2011

submissionscomments
petegrif··on Intellectual Ventures on This American Life
Great piece.
petegrif··on The Brilliance of Dwarf Fortress
Cool piece.
petegrif··on The Trouble with Nathan Myhrvold’s Pro-Patent Arguments
I don't understand what, if any, point you are really making here.
petegrif··on The Trouble with Nathan Myhrvold’s Pro-Patent Arguments
Not quite that simple. They also work with leading scientists to innovate.
petegrif··on The Trouble with Nathan Myhrvold’s Pro-Patent Arguments
This is an incredibly lame piece. The best I can find to say for it is that he spelt Myhrvold's name right. Otherwise it is crummy rant. He couldn't even do research a 4th grader would find simple - look up his target in Wikipedia and take the trouble to read enough to find out that M is indeed smart so he doesn't have to take the word of others for it.

The first para in Wikipedia would give him a clue. "Myhrvold attended Mirman School,[6] and began college at age 14.[7] He studied mathematics, geophysics, and space physics at UCLA (BSc, Masters). He was awarded a Hertz Foundation Fellowship for graduate study and he chose to study at Princeton University, where he earned a master's degree in mathematical economics and completed a PhD in theoretical and mathematical physics by age 23. He also attended Santa Monica College. For one year, he held a postdoctoral fellowship at the University of Cambridge working under Stephen Hawking, studying cosmology, quantum field theory in curved space time and quantum theories of gravitation."

So if this is his level of research why on earth would anyone in their right minds who is not already a patent hater take this chump seriously?

petegrif··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
I have looked into this further to confirm my belief. You don't have to license your patented IP. This is well treated in: http://fosspatents.blogspot.com/2011/07/what-does-5-buy-htc-...
petegrif··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
Much clearer - thank you.
petegrif··on Ask HN: Software Patent Best Practices
Against what? Is your concern that you will (hopefully inadvertently) infringe on someone else's patent or that someone will rip off your invention?
petegrif··on Why can't Facebook sue Google when most of UI ideas in G+ seems to be copied?
No - it has to be an invention. In other words, whether someone chooses to implement it or not the description section of the patent has to describe the invention in such detail that it can be implemented by someone with ordinary skill in the art.
petegrif··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
I think you have posted this in the wrong place. It has nothing to do with the point of this thread.
petegrif··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
You may or may not be correct about the fact that there was prior art in the case of the Apple suit. That however does not refute my key point which is that time and time again discussions include endless statements about how obvious something is, not a discussion about how obvious it was then.

As for your statements about the USPTO that is just a rant. It doesn't contribute anything to a real discussion.

petegrif··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
Highly unlikely. There are many suppliers of phones and even of smartphones.
petegrif··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
You are 50% right. The title isn't the patent - true. But the description isn't the patent either. The description serves to demonstrate how the claims may be implemented and hence underwrites their validity. It is the claims that have the teeth. (Respecting the fact that in cases of ambiguity the description will indeed be referenced)
petegrif··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
Yeah - Apple really has a crummy record on innovation compared with... ... oh yeah... now that I actually engage my brain for a millisecond... they have been pretty innovative haven't they?
petegrif··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
It isn't. The overwhelming majority of competition is about innovation.
petegrif··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
I don't understand the question - please rephrase.
petegrif··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
I don't believe you do have license your patented IP unless you choose to do so and I would be interested to see evidence to the contrary.
petegrif··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
A language which the overwhelming majority of people are (understandably) completely unfamiliar.
petegrif··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
Of course - it's so easy that only someone of high moral character wouldn't do it.
petegrif··on Apple deals massive patent blow to HTC, Android in serious trouble
The technical term is not 'a general practitioner' but 'one ordinarily skilled in the art.' And that ordinary skill is in the directly relevant art. So the proper question is 'was the invention novel and non-obvious to one ordinarily skilled in the art?' And here we run into endless problems because one of the best tested psychological phenomena is the 'hindsight effect.' Once things are invented and become part of popular culture or of the culture and lore of a technical sub-group they are (remarkably quickly) considered to be 'obvious.' Hordes of people who have never invented anything in their lives moan about how 'obvious' this or that patent is. If it is so easy, they should just stop moaning and go make those billions you so mistakenly believe are so easily to be earned by inventing things that are blindingly obvious. This is an absurd argument. It really is time to put it to bed. If something is blindingly obvious at the time, it probably won't get a patent. The USPTO and other such agencies are not perfect but they are not total imbeciles. Will some bad patents get through - yes. But if you want to spend your whole life focusing on edge cases why spend it on patents? Why not do something useful and campaign for prisoners' rights? After all, we know that some prisoners are innocent? So the whole penal system must be abolished, right? If we are going to have sensible discussions about patent reform we have to get some of the basic facts straight. And one of those basic facts is that what is 'obvious' now wasn't necessarily 'obvious' then and no amount of whinging from today will make that act any different. It has been 'obvious' now for some time that if you have HIV you should take antiretrovirals but it wasn't in 1982 when we started to identify AIDS. That's just 28 years ago. 'Obvious' is a slippery term - get used to it. There are no useful discussions about patents without getting over it.
petegrif··on Thomas Jefferson on Patents
excellent summation
petegrif··on To defend Android, Google must attack software patents
For major players I think it is likely to scale precisely because of the pervasiveness of patents in the area. Those companies with substantial patent portfolios (many of them as you pointed out) gain nothing by suing each other and so most of the time they don't. The case that would indeed be a concern would be if there were a company with no patent portfolio that the others could all pile onto and freeze out. This is possible but it does raise the question of how Apple was able to enter a market with such heavy existing IP holdings. A point worth remembering is that patents don't have to stop you innovating but rather oblige you to redirect your innovation. So if you want to build another 'me too' product there may well be IP issues to navigate but if you do want to truly innovate it is unlikely to be a major concern of the kind you describe with everyone else holding patents in the area.
petegrif··on How “Patent Trolling” Taxes Innovation
This strategy may work for those cases where the troll has a claim of questionable value but what about the cases where the troll holds a meaningful patent and has a valid claim?
petegrif··on To defend Android, Google must attack software patents
?? I'm sorry. I don't understand your point. Could you explain it for me.
petegrif··on To defend Android, Google must attack software patents
hysterical :)
petegrif··on To defend Android, Google must attack software patents
No it wouldn't. Patents are deeply enshrined in US law and a patent holder is perfectly within their rights to pursue those infringing on their rights. In fact that is the only right they have!!
petegrif··on To defend Android, Google must attack software patents
The really big unaddressed question in this post is whether Google actually does have to defend Android. After all, $10 per handset is nothing like as much as the cost of developing, maintaining and supporting your own smartphone OS. We're not talking feature phone here, this is a sizeable piece of sophisticated software that is in competition (primarily) with iOS. (Bear in mind that Apple can amortize its enormous development expense over a very large number of handsets!) I suppose you could argue that it gives MS some kind of an advantage with their OS but that rather ignores the investment MS had to make developing their OS.

I am certainly prepared to be persuaded that somehow fighting the patents in question is a life or death matter for Android but so far I haven't seen a convincing evidence that it's true.

petegrif··on To defend Android, Google must attack software patents
So if I understand you correctly, even if someone has a meaningful valid patent and infringers on reviewing the patent agree that it is a valid patent, and even if the licensing terms are agreed to be reasonable by both parties, even in such a case you would still consider this to be in some sense wrong because the $10 handset license (which incidentally is still ridiculously cheaper than developing your own smartphone OS) is a competitive disadvantage to smaller would be handset manufacturers or network operators, even though that wouldn't seem to be the case because everyone else supplying android phones is paying the same fee? In fact, ironically having Android available for $10 a phone is a great deal for small suppliers. You are, however, quite happy to accept trashing someone's intellectual property rights, even if they are valid, because of some imagined competitive disadvantage? That doesn't seem to me to be a coherent position or a meaningful conclusion.
petegrif··on To defend Android, Google must attack software patents
The writer, who has indeed attacked software patents on previous occasions, omits a key step in his argument.

para 3 "Of course, that doesn't necessarily mean that Android infringes on anyone's patents.:" This is absolutely correct. But it doesn't mean that it doesn't either. And without examining the facts (a matter requiring a significant effort of time and effort and no small familiarity with patent law) it is impossible to know a priori whether the patents have been infringed upon.

"It simply indicates that the companies in question have done the sums and decided that it is probably cheaper in the long run to pay licensing fees now rather than risk losing a long and expensive patent infringement suit and end up paying much more later. " True. But without evidence and argument we still don't know if they settled because they (a) although they sincerely believed they were not infringing they didn't want to risk the legal process, or (b) they did believe they were infringing and whilst they would much rather not pay it was pointless to resist. All we can be confident of therefore is that (a) in either case their assessment of the risk has certainly been expertly evaluated by the best IP attorneys money can buy, and (b) those attorneys advised them to settle so they are unlikely to have been crystal clear it was blindingly obvious there was no infringement.

"In other words, these deals are mostly about the skewed incentives of the US patent system" This is a false conclusion. This statement is not a reasonable consequence of anything that proceeded it. It is rather a statement of the writer's opinion of the patent system. He has twisted the argument, with no supporting evidence, to support his cause.

The fact is that from the material he presents (practically nothing) we cannot draw any meaningful conclusions about the state of the patent system. He and/or we may have prior opinions about the subject but this paragraph is just another opinion masquerading as an argument.

petegrif··on How “Patent Trolling” Taxes Innovation
It would help if they characterized 'patent trolls' accurately. Their alleged behavior is after all the subject of the piece.
← PreviousPage 10 of 12Next →