HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pfraze

7,223 karma · joined November 6, 2011

bluesky dev bsky.app/profile/pfrazee.com github.com/pfrazee pfrazee.com
submissionscomments
pfraze··on There are no instances in ATProto
I’d also call out that activitypub has the same threat model in the form of ICANN, as it’s also heavily dependent on DNS for identity. I believe these are reasonable trades to make; realistically the alternative is to use a blockchain, which few people are keen to do.
pfraze··on There are no instances in ATProto
It doesn’t fully resolve your concerns, but I do want to highlight that atproto now has an IETF working group to home its spec development
pfraze··on There are no instances in ATProto
Honestly that’s just as much because atproto is a raw data protocol. Putting an http frontend on an atproto account is something we encourage and a lot of folks do. I do that on pfrazee.com for instance, and my leaflet blogposts (which are canonically on atproto) render on my blog.
pfraze··on There are no instances in ATProto
Relays are actually quite cheap now! They used to be a bit more expensive when they archived all the traffic, but in sync 1.1 that was dropped and they can be run on $20/mo VMs pretty trivially now
pfraze··on W Social, public institutions and the theater of European digital sovereignty
Bluesky is the opposite of locked down
pfraze··on W Social, public institutions and the theater of European digital sovereignty
Wcyd? It was the name that Dorsey chose before the PBC was even formed. It's from the technical term of art, like greenfield.
pfraze··on W Social, public institutions and the theater of European digital sovereignty
Fyi it’s actually called bluesky, not bluewhatever
pfraze··on The (real) dead economy theory
“Losing” is a loaded word choice. If I buy something I’m really happy to have, I probably don’t describe it as losing the money.

Obviously the investment expense has been extremely high, which is what the replies are quibbling about.

pfraze··on Age verification for social media, the beginning of the end for a free internet?
OS-level is so much better than app-level. App-level means redoing the work for each app and increasing the odds of issues.
pfraze··on At Protocol for Agents
No disagreement there. If you want to keep updated on the permissioned data protocol you can follow daniel's leaflets https://dholms.leaflet.pub/ (https://dholms.leaflet.pub/rss)

The public side is extremely important for agents though. Agents need up to date public information to do their job. Every other service is going closed. Public information and activity should be a commons.

pfraze··on We need a federation of forges
Yeah I’ve met the Radicle people a couple times. I’ve never given it a thorough review but, for their goals, their designs have always seemed strong, and they’re pleasant people to chat with.

The main difference was atproto wanted to tackle scale, so we went with a servers & aggregation model. Radicle is going for device-to-device networking as a primary goal.

pfraze··on We need a federation of forges
The most valuable thing Tangled will ever do is establish the protocol of Tangled. Once that’s done, it lives as long as people are willing to run it.
pfraze··on We need a federation of forges
Yeah the problems they seemed to have were over collaborative data structures with permissions. You’re right about how atproto solves that, which means you’re using CRDTs if you need to collaborate. If that’s a fit mismatch, I’d tell people to just appoint api servers which wrap a repo and provide the needed semantics.
pfraze··on Top Programmers Return to Hand-Coding Amid AI Tool Doubts
Absolutely none of this matches my experience.
pfraze··on Bluesky April 2026 Outage Post-Mortem
Technically you can still view the posts directly from the PDS. It’s just uninteresting compared to web pages
pfraze··on Bluesky April 2026 Outage Post-Mortem
This writeup is useful for backend engineers: https://atproto.com/articles/atproto-for-distsys-engineers

The simple answer is that atproto works like the web & search engines, where the apps aggregate from the distributed accounts. So the proper analogy here would be like yahoo going down in 1999.

pfraze··on Bluesky April 2026 Outage Post-Mortem
All support to other decentralizers but nothing never goes down.
pfraze··on About the Atmosphere
Just want to add that the AT Protocol IETF working group has been formed, and the PLC directory independent organization and board has officially been established. I’m at the closing talk for this years Atmosphere Conference as I write this and it’s really an incredible community of devs.
pfraze··on Apple Just Lost Me
I’ve never felt so motivated to fight on your behalf
pfraze··on Apple Just Lost Me
Indeed. There has been zero political opposition to these laws. Apple isn’t going to pay the fines on our behalf, so we need to get organizing if we don’t like this.
pfraze··on Apple Just Lost Me
Pretty sure it’s California that’s got the OS law
pfraze··on Apple Just Lost Me
How long till that’s illegal?

This situation is being treated like a bad business decision. It’s not. It’s a new set of laws. It’s bigger than just Apple.

pfraze··on Apple Just Lost Me
They actually have very few choices, and they had only a few months to get it done. Just like the rest of us.
pfraze··on Apple Just Lost Me
You are aware that the law applies to Linux desktops and will likely be included in a system update soon?
pfraze··on Apple Just Lost Me
I was sure I’d hate it. But I actually think it’s pretty good
pfraze··on Apple Just Lost Me
Age verification has been put into law across the world over the last year. Apple doesn’t have a choice.
pfraze··on No-build, no-NPM, SSR-first JavaScript framework if you hate React, love HTML
Dont get me wrong, I'm a pretty big believer in interop, but in practice I've rarely run into a situation where I need to mix components from multiple frameworks. Especially because React is so dominant.
pfraze··on No-build, no-NPM, SSR-first JavaScript framework if you hate React, love HTML
Wasn’t that the Lit framework? It was okay. Like a slightly more irritating version of React.

I recall the property passing model being a nasty abstraction breaker. HTML attributes are all strings, so if you wanted to pass objects or functions to children you had to do that via “props” instead of “attributes.”

I also recall the tag names of web components being a pain. Always need a dash, always need to be registered.

None of these problems broke it; they just made it irritating by comparison. There wasn’t really much upside either. No real performance gain or superior feature, and you got fewer features and a smaller ecosystem.

pfraze··on Qite.js – Frontend framework for people who hate React and love HTML
Reactivity isn’t the problem. Reactivity is one of the few things that helps reduce the complexity of state management. GUI state is just a complex thing. Frontend development doesn’t get enough cred for how deeply difficult it is.
pfraze··on Show HN: s@: decentralized social networking over static sites
Ah, that's right. Forgot about that one.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →